Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
Moved into the house 11 years ago.
Back exterior doors looked to be part of a fairly new remodel. They are solid wood, framing a large glass panels, with what appears to be a simple poly top coat that has been beaten by sun and rain and almost completely gone near the bottom. Yes, I've neglected. Something about a shoemaker's sons. :-) I want something that will last the longest and withstand the sun and rain. I'm toying around with an epoxy product similar to this... http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2004140/9248/Mirror-Coat-112-Quart-Kit.aspx http://xrl.us/bijwr4 I've seen several applications of this and similar products and they seem to be like virtually dipping the object in plastic. The stuff seems to be impervious to anything, including sun and water. I wouldn't mind spending a hundred bucks on this stuff it it's going to protect like I think it will. Has anyone used it in an exterior application? -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#2
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On 2/25/2011 12:00 AM, -MIKE- wrote:
Moved into the house 11 years ago. Back exterior doors looked to be part of a fairly new remodel. They are solid wood, framing a large glass panels, with what appears to be a simple poly top coat that has been beaten by sun and rain and almost completely gone near the bottom. Yes, I've neglected. Something about a shoemaker's sons. :-) I want something that will last the longest and withstand the sun and rain. I'm toying around with an epoxy product similar to this... http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2004140/9248/Mirror-Coat-112-Quart-Kit.aspx http://xrl.us/bijwr4 I've seen several applications of this and similar products and they seem to be like virtually dipping the object in plastic. The stuff seems to be impervious to anything, including sun and water. I wouldn't mind spending a hundred bucks on this stuff it it's going to protect like I think it will. Has anyone used it in an exterior application? Check the instructions on it if you can get them. I use a lot of this stuff for bars, tabletops, etc. and most of them say not for exterior use. The stuff tends to yellow with age when used outside and I don't know what else it may do. I have a few projects that I did for outdoors and they are ok, but that was West Marine stuff and it is for outdoor use. Just saying it can be done, but make sure you use the right stuff. -- Robert Allison New Braunfels, TX |
#3
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
-MIKE- wrote:
Moved into the house 11 years ago. Back exterior doors looked to be part of a fairly new remodel. They are solid wood, framing a large glass panels, with what appears to be a simple poly top coat that has been beaten by sun and rain and almost completely gone near the bottom. Yes, I've neglected. Something about a shoemaker's sons. :-) I want something that will last the longest and withstand the sun and rain. I'm toying around with an epoxy product similar to this... http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2004140/9248/Mirror-Coat-112-Quart-Kit.aspx http://xrl.us/bijwr4 I've seen several applications of this and similar products and they seem to be like virtually dipping the object in plastic. The stuff seems to be impervious to anything, including sun and water. I wouldn't mind spending a hundred bucks on this stuff it it's going to protect like I think it will. Has anyone used it in an exterior application? Two things might influence your choice: The color of the wood and whether it is exposed to direct sunlight. If the wood is fairly dark and in the shade, you can't go wrong with multiple coats of spar varnish. |
#5
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
J. Clarke wrote:
Take a look at http://www.jamestowndistributors.com...uct.do?pid=869 &familyName=AwlBrite+Clear+Gloss+Base, which is specifically intended for exterior use under harsh conditions. I was going to suggest urethane coatings like those used in automotive refinishing. About as good a UV resistant coating as one can find. Several years ago I got tired of the brass handles on two of our exterior doors looking all tired and worn out, so I took them into the garage, buffed them up with rubbing compound until I had them at a like-new shine, and then shot them with clear coat. Years later, they look like the day I shot them. -- -Mike- |
#6
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
"-MIKE-" wrote in message ... Moved into the house 11 years ago. Back exterior doors looked to be part of a fairly new remodel. They are solid wood, framing a large glass panels, with what appears to be a simple poly top coat that has been beaten by sun and rain and almost completely gone near the bottom. Yes, I've neglected. Something about a shoemaker's sons. :-) I want something that will last the longest and withstand the sun and rain. I'm toying around with an epoxy product similar to this... http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2004140/9248/Mirror-Coat-112-Quart-Kit.aspx http://xrl.us/bijwr4 I've seen several applications of this and similar products and they seem to be like virtually dipping the object in plastic. The stuff seems to be impervious to anything, including sun and water. I wouldn't mind spending a hundred bucks on this stuff it it's going to protect like I think it will. Has anyone used it in an exterior application? I have not heard of any finish, except paint, that lasts much more than a few years when direct sun light is involved. It will probably be a constant problem that you will have to deal with every few years. |
#7
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
"-MIKE-" wrote in message
... Moved into the house 11 years ago. Back exterior doors looked to be part of a fairly new remodel. They are solid wood, framing a large glass panels, with what appears to be a simple poly top coat that has been beaten by sun and rain and almost completely gone near the bottom. Yes, I've neglected. Something about a shoemaker's sons. :-) I want something that will last the longest and withstand the sun and rain. I'm toying around with an epoxy product similar to this... http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2004140/9248/Mirror-Coat-112-Quart-Kit.aspx http://xrl.us/bijwr4 I've seen several applications of this and similar products and they seem to be like virtually dipping the object in plastic. The stuff seems to be impervious to anything, including sun and water. I wouldn't mind spending a hundred bucks on this stuff it it's going to protect like I think it will. Has anyone used it in an exterior application? Its been my experience that most epoxy resins are not UV resistant including marine grade epoxy. I had a discussion once with a fellow at a gun show who claimed he had an epoxy resin with a good UV inhibitor when I queried him about some carbon fiber transport luggage he was using. He said they made their own carry luggage as a counterpoint to the carbon fiber bolt on fixtures (stocks, grips, etc) they made for various more popular firearms. He declined my invitation to set one of his bags in my backyard for a summer to see how it held up to the Arizona sun. |
#8
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On 2/25/11 7:39 AM, J. Clarke wrote:
Has anyone used it in an exterior application? Epoxy has no more innate immunity to UV than any other coating--the manufacturer says specifically that it will yellow in exterior exposure which implies that it doesn't have the heavy dose of UV barrier that a coating intended for exterior use would have. Take a look at http://www.jamestowndistributors.com...uct.do?pid=869 &familyName=AwlBrite+Clear+Gloss+Base, which is specifically intended for exterior use under harsh conditions. Thank you for actually reading my post and replying with relevant, helpful info. :-) -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#9
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On 2/25/11 8:59 AM, dadiOH wrote:
-MIKE- wrote: Moved into the house 11 years ago. Back exterior doors looked to be part of a fairly new remodel. They are solid wood, framing a large glass panels, with what appears to be a simple poly top coat that has been beaten by sun and rain and almost completely gone near the bottom. Yes, I've neglected. Something about a shoemaker's sons. :-) I want something that will last the longest and withstand the sun and rain. I'm toying around with an epoxy product similar to this... http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2004140/9248/Mirror-Coat-112-Quart-Kit.aspx http://xrl.us/bijwr4 I've seen several applications of this and similar products and they seem to be like virtually dipping the object in plastic. The stuff seems to be impervious to anything, including sun and water. I wouldn't mind spending a hundred bucks on this stuff it it's going to protect like I think it will. Has anyone used it in an exterior application? I've never used it but I wouldn't touch it with a 10' pole (for your potential use). If it *is* epoxy - as opposed to polyester - then it will deteriorate rapidly from UV unless protected. The best protection is paint. If it is polyester, that isn't great either for what you want. I once did all the bright work on a 42' sailboat with polyester resin thinned with styrene; brushed on several coats, wet sanded smooth, polished with rubbing compound, looked great. Two years later I sanded (and sanded...and sanded...and sanded) it all off and went back to varnish. There is NO clear coat that will last as long as paint. If you want the wood to show, use oil or a NON-poly varnish with UV filter. Both will need periodic maintenance, oil is the easiest, just wipe on, varnish will need sanding first. Thanks. I guess the general consensus is, "sorry, you're outta luck." I don't think I want to paint... the wood still looks too nice. -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#10
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
|
#11
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
-MIKE- wrote:
On 2/25/11 8:59 AM, dadiOH wrote: There is NO clear coat that will last as long as paint. If you want the wood to show, use oil or a NON-poly varnish with UV filter. Both will need periodic maintenance, oil is the easiest, just wipe on, varnish will need sanding first. Thanks. I guess the general consensus is, "sorry, you're outta luck." I don't think I want to paint... the wood still looks too nice. Sorry Mike but I had not seen dadiOH's repsonse earlier. I have to disagree with the broad brush he paints with. There are indeed clear coats that are superior to paints. Just do look at your car... -- -Mike- |
#12
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
"Mike Marlow" wrote in message ... Leon wrote: I have not heard of any finish, except paint, that lasts much more than a few years when direct sun light is involved. It will probably be a constant problem that you will have to deal with every few years. Pssst... Leon - go look at your car... Yeah paint, right? |
#13
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On Sat, 26 Feb 2011 19:53:28 -0600, "Leon"
wrote: "Mike Marlow" wrote in message .. . Leon wrote: I have not heard of any finish, except paint, that lasts much more than a few years when direct sun light is involved. It will probably be a constant problem that you will have to deal with every few years. Pssst... Leon - go look at your car... Yeah paint, right? That shiny stuff over the paint is a clearcoat with extremely high UV resistance. -- You can't wait for inspiration. You have to go after it with a club. --Jack London |
#14
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
"Larry Jaques" wrote in message ... On Sat, 26 Feb 2011 19:53:28 -0600, "Leon" wrote: "Mike Marlow" wrote in message . .. Leon wrote: I have not heard of any finish, except paint, that lasts much more than a few years when direct sun light is involved. It will probably be a constant problem that you will have to deal with every few years. Pssst... Leon - go look at your car... Yeah paint, right? That shiny stuff over the paint is a clearcoat with extremely high UV resistance. Which works very well over automotive paint, not wood and even with flex agents added don't work real well as it will eventually crack. Wood moves all the time and automotive color coat and clear coats do best on surfaces that don't expand and contract as much as wood does. Color coated rubber painted bumpers tend to crack in a few years if flexed. |
#15
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On Sun, 27 Feb 2011 08:51:02 -0600, "Leon"
wrote: "Larry Jaques" wrote in message .. . On Sat, 26 Feb 2011 19:53:28 -0600, "Leon" wrote: "Mike Marlow" wrote in message .. . Leon wrote: I have not heard of any finish, except paint, that lasts much more than a few years when direct sun light is involved. It will probably be a constant problem that you will have to deal with every few years. Pssst... Leon - go look at your car... Yeah paint, right? That shiny stuff over the paint is a clearcoat with extremely high UV resistance. Which works very well over automotive paint, not wood and even with flex agents added don't work real well as it will eventually crack. Wood moves all the time and automotive color coat and clear coats do best on surfaces that don't expand and contract as much as wood does. Color coated rubber painted bumpers tend to crack in a few years if flexed. Didn't Mike have good experiences with it, though? Someone just stated that. shrug -- You can't wait for inspiration. You have to go after it with a club. --Jack London |
#16
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
"Larry Jaques" wrote in message ... On Sun, 27 Feb 2011 08:51:02 -0600, "Leon" wrote: "Larry Jaques" wrote in message . .. On Sat, 26 Feb 2011 19:53:28 -0600, "Leon" wrote: "Mike Marlow" wrote in message . .. Leon wrote: I have not heard of any finish, except paint, that lasts much more than a few years when direct sun light is involved. It will probably be a constant problem that you will have to deal with every few years. Pssst... Leon - go look at your car... Yeah paint, right? That shiny stuff over the paint is a clearcoat with extremely high UV resistance. Which works very well over automotive paint, not wood and even with flex agents added don't work real well as it will eventually crack. Wood moves all the time and automotive color coat and clear coats do best on surfaces that don't expand and contract as much as wood does. Color coated rubber painted bumpers tend to crack in a few years if flexed. Didn't Mike have good experiences with it, though? Someone just stated that. shrug I could not say, perhaps he is satisfied with an automotive paint finish on his wood products. |
#17
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
Leon wrote:
Which works very well over automotive paint, not wood and even with flex agents added don't work real well as it will eventually crack. Wood moves all the time and automotive color coat and clear coats do best on surfaces that don't expand and contract as much as wood does. Color coated rubber painted bumpers tend to crack in a few years if flexed. I have never had a bumper cover crack on me Leon, and I've painted a lot of them. I don't use flex agents at all - not worth the time with today's paints. They served a better purpose back in the days of lacquer. A couple of weeks ago I hit a deer and wasted the front end of my car. The bumper cover was torn in many places. The hood folded up just like it is designed to do. The bumper cover paint never even cracked where it went through the extreme flexing it underwent. The hood - well pretty good sized chunks of clear, base and primer came free where the crinkles were - but they were big crinkles. I've never tried clear coat on wood, so I don't know how it would stand up over time, but I'm not so sure I'd expect it to crack from normal movement. It would be interesting to see. Maybe I'll shoot a stick next time I'm shooting a car. My bigger point was that there are indeed very UV resistant urethanes out there. My personal familiarity is with the automotive stuff, but it would not surprise me if there weren't a similar product formulated for wood. -- -Mike- |
#18
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
|
#19
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
"Mike Marlow" wrote in message ... Leon wrote: I could not say, perhaps he is satisfied with an automotive paint finish on his wood products. What better way to get that craftsman-like plastic coated look? ;~) Actually - I had posted an experience with re-clearing a brass door handle - a different thing. |
#20
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
"Mike Marlow" wrote in message ... Leon wrote: Which works very well over automotive paint, not wood and even with flex agents added don't work real well as it will eventually crack. Wood moves all the time and automotive color coat and clear coats do best on surfaces that don't expand and contract as much as wood does. Color coated rubber painted bumpers tend to crack in a few years if flexed. I have never had a bumper cover crack on me Leon, and I've painted a lot of them. I don't use flex agents at all - not worth the time with today's paints. They served a better purpose back in the days of lacquer. A couple of weeks ago I hit a deer and wasted the front end of my car. The bumper cover was torn in many places. The hood folded up just like it is designed to do. The bumper cover paint never even cracked where it went through the extreme flexing it underwent. The hood - well pretty good sized chunks of clear, base and primer came free where the crinkles were - but they were big crinkles. How old is /was the vehicle? I've never tried clear coat on wood, so I don't know how it would stand up over time, but I'm not so sure I'd expect it to crack from normal movement. It would be interesting to see. Maybe I'll shoot a stick next time I'm shooting a car. My bigger point was that there are indeed very UV resistant urethanes out there. My personal familiarity is with the automotive stuff, but it would not surprise me if there weren't a similar product formulated for wood. Perhaps... ;~) |
#21
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
Leon wrote:
"Mike Marlow" wrote in message ... I have never had a bumper cover crack on me Leon, and I've painted a lot of them. I don't use flex agents at all - not worth the time with today's paints. They served a better purpose back in the days of lacquer. A couple of weeks ago I hit a deer and wasted the front end of my car. The bumper cover was torn in many places. The hood folded up just like it is designed to do. The bumper cover paint never even cracked where it went through the extreme flexing it underwent. The hood - well pretty good sized chunks of clear, base and primer came free where the crinkles were - but they were big crinkles. How old is /was the vehicle? This particular vehicle is a 2006 Sonata. All fixed like new now. -- -Mike- |
#22
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On Feb 25, 1:40*pm, -MIKE- wrote:
On 2/25/11 7:39 AM, J. Clarke wrote: Has anyone used it in an exterior application? Epoxy has no more innate immunity to UV than any other coating--the manufacturer says specifically that it will yellow in exterior exposure which implies that it doesn't have the heavy dose of UV barrier that a coating intended for exterior use would have. Take a look at http://www.jamestowndistributors.com...uct.do?pid=869 &familyName=AwlBrite+Clear+Gloss+Base, which is specifically intended for exterior use under harsh conditions. Thank you for actually reading my post and replying with relevant, helpful info. * :-) I noticed this part from that link: "Ten coats are recommended." Now don't skimp and try to squeak by with only eight or nine coats. R |
#23
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On 2/28/11 5:21 PM, Larry Kraus wrote:
My understanding and experience is that any clear finish on wood has a relatively short exterior life span. UV rays (direct or reflected) degrade the wood surface through the finish, and the finish has nothing to cling to. Additives for UV resistance may slow the damage but it still occurs. If you can see the wood, the light is breaking down the surface. Personally, if it is outside, I feel wood should be painted. Life is too short to spend it refinishing doors every few years. FWIW, I've never seen a painted house that didn't need repainted every 5 or so years. -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#24
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
|
#25
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On 3/1/11 6:50 AM, dadiOH wrote:
-MIKE- wrote: On 2/28/11 5:21 PM, Larry Kraus wrote: My understanding and experience is that any clear finish on wood has a relatively short exterior life span. UV rays (direct or reflected) degrade the wood surface through the finish, and the finish has nothing to cling to. Additives for UV resistance may slow the damage but it still occurs. If you can see the wood, the light is breaking down the surface. Personally, if it is outside, I feel wood should be painted. Life is too short to spend it refinishing doors every few years. FWIW, I've never seen a painted house that didn't need repainted every 5 or so years. I just had mine painted last summer. The old paint was mostly good but had faded. It had been there 15 years. Hmmmm.... maybe I'll paint. -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#26
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On Mar 1, 10:47*am, -MIKE- wrote:
Hmmmm.... maybe I'll paint. Mike - you seem pretty opened minded, and a pretty sincere craftsman. This is my opinion, so take it for what it is worth. I had a contract with a company here in town, and probably removed and replaced about 250 doors for them before we got tired of each other. But finishing is something I have done for years, doors included before my contract with the door supplier I hooked up with, and I can tell you what I have observed. Poor finishing, clear, semi transparent or anything else, yields just that; a poor finish. Paint, ditto. 90% of finishing is in the prep, not in the application. Nor in my opinion is it in the finishing material. Most quality finishes you buy these days are quite good, and people mistakenly blame crappy results on a product instead of themselves. In a pinch, I have used Minwax OIL (no water based ANYTHING except paint for me!) with excellent results. Same with other brands that make others here spit with disgust when their names are mentioned. Clear finishes will not protect wood (tip of hat to you, Mike!) as well as paint. Mike refers to a system of finishing where the top coat of urethane is an integral component of the paint job. Today's auto paints are formulated and need that top coat. Auto finishes are not abrasive resistant as most oil based wood finishes, nor are they as easily applied by the average guy, but for their purpose they are excellent. (Remember, you can't put on auto urethane with a foam brush!) NOTHING protects wood as well as a completely opaque finish. UV modified clear finishes with all manner of voodoo in them are great for a few years, but don't last as well as an alkyd finish. I have refinished a few hundred doors, and and found that to be true. The old oil based stuff used to last for years, but has been replaced by latex. Most people are just too lazy to put on oil, and are afraid of its application. If you have the type of doors I am envisioning, you can brush or spray alkyd on them easily. With a 2 hour layout time, not too much to worry about with brush strokes if you brush, and today's alkyds spray very easily. You know I will give my usual opinion; if the current surface is damage, strip the wood, clean it and sand it before application of anything. If you spray, prime first with BIN. I use that on doors and cabinets as it is ready to coat in an hour with paint. Three coats of alkyd will last for years. Sherwin Williams makes some great stuff, as does Benjamin Moore. FWIW, I have never seen any type of epoxy resin finish hold up in EXTERIOR use. Interior, fine. But on an exterior application, the theory among my finishing buddies is that the wood and resin move at different temperatures, and at different amounts. It seems to work OK in the shade, but not in direct sunlight. But remember, if just a small percent of the light gets through (UV resistant, not UV impermeable!) the clear coat, the problem starts with degrading the wood. I like clear finishes, though. My solution from time to time where the bottom of the door is the only thing facing direct sunlight is to clear coat the door with UV resistant finish, then cover the bottom of the door with a big brass or nickel kick plate to cover previous damage and to help protect from future. It isn't a fix, but it stops the cracking and hides the discoloration of the damaged wood. It also covers any repairs I might need to make to save the door. As always, just my 0.02. Robert |
#27
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On 3/1/11 1:50 PM, wrote:
On Mar 1, 10:47 am, wrote: Hmmmm.... maybe I'll paint. Mike - you seem pretty opened minded, and a pretty sincere craftsman. This is my opinion, so take it for what it is worth. Thank you. My above comment was sincere, not sarcastic. I had a contract with a company here in town, and probably removed and replaced about 250 doors for them before we got tired of each other. But finishing is something I have done for years, doors included before my contract with the door supplier I hooked up with, and I can tell you what I have observed. Poor finishing, clear, semi transparent or anything else, yields just that; a poor finish. Paint, ditto. 90% of finishing is in the prep, not in the application. Nor in my opinion is it in the finishing material. Most quality finishes you buy these days are quite good, and people mistakenly blame crappy results on a product instead of themselves. I hate painting, but people always ask me about it because I'm "that guy" who always does everything. I tell them all the time that the paint is the cheapest part of painting, and the painting is the easiest part. So I know where you're coming from. In a pinch, I have used Minwax OIL (no water based ANYTHING except paint for me!) with excellent results. Same with other brands that make others here spit with disgust when their names are mentioned. Clear finishes will not protect wood (tip of hat to you, Mike!) as well as paint. Mike refers to a system of finishing where the top coat of urethane is an integral component of the paint job. Today's auto paints are formulated and need that top coat. Auto finishes are not abrasive resistant as most oil based wood finishes, nor are they as easily applied by the average guy, but for their purpose they are excellent. (Remember, you can't put on auto urethane with a foam brush!) NOTHING protects wood as well as a completely opaque finish. UV modified clear finishes with all manner of voodoo in them are great for a few years, but don't last as well as an alkyd finish. I have refinished a few hundred doors, and and found that to be true. The old oil based stuff used to last for years, but has been replaced by latex. Most people are just too lazy to put on oil, and are afraid of its application. If you have the type of doors I am envisioning, you can brush or spray alkyd on them easily. With a 2 hour layout time, not too much to worry about with brush strokes if you brush, and today's alkyds spray very easily. You know I will give my usual opinion; if the current surface is damage, strip the wood, clean it and sand it before application of anything. If you spray, prime first with BIN. I use that on doors and cabinets as it is ready to coat in an hour with paint. This? http://www.rustoleum.com/CBGProduct.asp?pid=216 Three coats of alkyd will last for years. Sherwin Williams makes some great stuff, as does Benjamin Moore. FWIW, I have never seen any type of epoxy resin finish hold up in EXTERIOR use. Interior, fine. But on an exterior application, the theory among my finishing buddies is that the wood and resin move at different temperatures, and at different amounts. It seems to work OK in the shade, but not in direct sunlight. But remember, if just a small percent of the light gets through (UV resistant, not UV impermeable!) the clear coat, the problem starts with degrading the wood. I like clear finishes, though. My solution from time to time where the bottom of the door is the only thing facing direct sunlight is to clear coat the door with UV resistant finish, then cover the bottom of the door with a big brass or nickel kick plate to cover previous damage and to help protect from future. It isn't a fix, but it stops the cracking and hides the discoloration of the damaged wood. It also covers any repairs I might need to make to save the door. As always, just my 0.02. Robert Thanks for such a thought out and well presented reply. Great info. -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#28
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On Mar 1, 2:24*pm, -MIKE- wrote:
I hate painting, but people always ask me about it because I'm "that guy" who always does everything. *I tell them all the time that the paint is the cheapest part of painting, and the painting is the easiest part. *So I know where you're coming from. Absolutely true. The paint is nothing, nor is any finish that you apply if you prep right. The last kitchen I did, I refinished all the cabinets in the kitchen, as well as the island. It took me almost two weeks of prep, and the client was getting very impatient. However, they were astonished that I got one coat of primer (BIN) on everything in one day, as well as one coat of finish. I put two more coats on everything the next day and was easily finished in 8 hours. That is cabinets inside and out, 24 or so doors, and I think 12 drawers, a wall mounted display rack, and an island with bead board sprayed white to match the cabinets. Most folks don't understand that the application (good or bad!) is the quickest part of the project. The super hot finishes like I use take a lot of practice, but most of the finishes out there today yield very good results by just following the instructions. This? http://www.rustoleum.com/CBGProduct.asp?pid=216 That's the juice! Since it is a pigmented shellac, don't plan on brushing it unless you are comfortable brushing shellac. That stuff sprays like a dream; on a 65 degree day, you won't need to thin, mix in thinner (anhydrous alcohol) or do anything else but stir it and put it in your paint cup. I would suggest a 1.4mm tip if you are spraying, as I have had great results in my guns with that size. BIN can be a strangely high build finish, too. I have used it as an "almost" pore filler, and built up 2-3 heavy coats on oak, and it will partially fill the tubules. It will certainly close them off, so you can paint without the all the pin holes. Real oak retains that woodgrain texture and looks like that plastic trim we used to buy that had the woodgrain cast into it. Clients like it as they can still see some of their woodgrain so it doesn't look like particle board or colored melamine. As far as coatings go, I have used this stuff before, but am a fan of Coronado (a regional manufacturer) products. However, most of my painting buddies use this with great results out of their spray setup. They also claim it brushes very well, too. http://preview.tinyurl.com/4jpzeqa Sherwin Williams makes an equivalent, and it is quite good as well. Thanks for such a thought out and well presented reply. Great info. Anytime, just glad to help. I enjoy reading a few of the posters that frequent here, and you are certainly one of them. Robert |
#29
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On Mar 2, 5:40*am, "dadiOH" wrote:
Good stuff but it is meant for interior use; however, Zinsser makes a slew of others. *I've pretty much settled on 1-2-3 for everything...applies/flows/covers well, drys quickly and sands well.http://www.rustoleum.com/CBGProduct.asp?pid=419 I just don't care for water based stain killers/blockers or primers. They don't dry fast enough or hard enough for me. Since I use oil based enamels, I don't like to put a hard resin over a soft latex product. I only use water borne on sheetrock prep for repaints because I will be putting latex on over it. If I have heavy staining, knot bleeding, or other issues besides a simple priming on fairly clean wood, this is my preference: http://www.rustoleum.com/CBGProduct.asp?pid=222 Another excellent product, it works as advertised. It doesn't spray out as smoothly as the first one I recommended due to its higher solid content, but it is close. While it says it is for "spot exterior use", it works fine for ext. doors, trims, cabinetry, etc. The best thing about the BIN for me is that when it all works correctly, you don't have to sand before applying your top coats. Spray your BIN on a large cabinet and drawers, clean the gun, go have lunch. Come back, start finish coat applications. Not spray your primer, wait until it is hard enough to sand, sand the project all over again to scuff it up, wipe out with a damp rag, blow it/vacuum it, let it dry 100% (since water based finishes are inherently more porous), then start to apply the topcoats. Think of the time you save with no sanding. Add on the fact you don't have to clean the cabinet thoroughly to get any dust you will kick up when spraying. Think of maintaining your clean finishing environment because you didn't raise any dust in the air from sanding or cleaning. Even if you shuttle cabinets, doors, or whatever you are finishing around from place to place to keep the dust down, that still requires the processes required from sanding, but now with added project handling. There is nothing like moving cabinets around in the different stages of finish only to drop one... or an entry door.... yikes! Drop it and it is toast. Everyone has their favorite processes, and I think as long as the end product is satisfactory, it is important to use the ones you are comfortable in using. For me personally, I try to use the best technology that yields the best finish at the fastest pace. As comment on that, I still have a colleague (read: another beer drinking contractor) that used the BM product I referenced above to repaint kitchen cabinets. He doesn't spray... he hand brushes! He has one guy that does the most beautiful job on doors you have ever seen. They look sprayed; my brush work isn't that good, nor is my buddy's. We can't figure out what he does, but his flatwork turns out like glass. (In the cruel revenge of Karma, he can't cut a straight line to save his ass!) My buddy won't spray as he doesn't have a good spray guy, he won't invest in the equipment, tried it himself and can't get the hang of mixing and gun adjustment, and is convinced that the time it takes to isolate and tape off a room is more time than it is worth. On occasion he has paid me to spray metal exterior doors with enamels, cabinet doors and drawer fronts for him, but he still brushes the rest of a kitchen job. It all works out... he is an older fella with a lot of older clients. Since he peddles that hand brushed business as "things done the old way, the right way" he does indeed get his price. Routinely, he gets about 15% or more than I do for the same job. No reason for him to change, right? Just a little additional commentary on the subject. Robert |
#30
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Best Wood Exterior Door Finish
On Mar 2, 4:03*pm, "dadiOH" wrote:
They look sprayed; my brush work isn't that good, nor is my buddy's. We can't figure out what he does, but his flatwork turns out like glass. While you and his boss are out drinking beer he hauls in a sprayer * Damnit... I laughed so hard when I read that I almost spewed out my iced tea! I will be sure and pass that on to my "colleague", Bill. He'll get a bang out of it too! Seriously; you know how it look like you are doing the exact same thing someone else is doing and yet you get different results? That's me with oils. I am OK on small pieces, crown and trims, and flat panels when using a brush. But this guy can give me a complex. Raised six panel wood doors in a house? No problem. One Marlboro and a 1/2 cup of coffee a door. Worse, (or at least more frustrating to me) this guy is fast. So one day when visiting my buddy's job site a while back, I ran into this guy and he was cleaning brushes at around 2:00 pm. We chatted a bit as I thought he was just changing colors or needed a quick clean. Nope, he was going home. I was pretty dumbstruck, and thought something was wrong at the home front. Nope, again. The rest of the job needed to be sprayed, and that wasn't his job. He did the cab interiors along with the rails and stiles in the kitchen and bath and that was it. Aren't you going to spray the doors and drawers, I asked? No he wasn't. That wasn't his job. He told me he never "learned" the spray rig (except for an airless) and didn't understand all the knobs and stuff on the gun. And no clue at all about thinning, patterns, tips or anything else. He thinks being a spray man is a subset of being a painter, but not the same thing. Apparently he and his pals decided to spray a truck, and it was a disaster, and an expensive one at that. After that happened, no more sprayer. Ever. I told him I could walk him through the basics and even had a old gun he could use to practice his skills. He wasn't even remotely interested. I actually think he really enjoys being the king of handwork, and if everyone knew he couldn't spray it would be too embarrassing. So he stays the king of what he knows. I was REALLY looking forward to ragging on him for his lack of spray skills, but I won't ever get to see them. Thanks... I am *still* chuckling over here.... Robert |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Exterior Wood Door | Woodworking | |||
What kind of wood for exterior door? | Woodworking | |||
exterior wood door stain | Woodworking | |||
Exterior Wood Door | Home Repair | |||
Exterior door finish | Woodworking |