Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's
not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 3, 10:03 pm, "jeffc" wrote:
It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? You should clean the trim to be painted before sanding to make sure there's no grease or oils that will cause problems with the finish. Wrap sandpaper around a suitably sized dowel or pencil to sand the rounded parts, and fold the paper to sand into the sharp corners. Other than that it's business as usual. You're just scuffing up the surface to give the paint primer something to bite onto. Use a primer with high adherence like Benjamin Moore's Fresh start. You could use a liquid deglosser (aka liquid sandpaper) that is a really nasty chemical cocktail that will soften the poly and give it some tooth for the primer. It will also take care of the cleaning step at the same time. It's nasty stuff so wear a respirator. http://www.cornerhardware.com/index....dex&cPath=7632 R |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"jeffc" wrote in message ... It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? Just use your fingers to wrap it against the surface as you sand. Bob |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"Bob F" wrote in message ... "jeffc" wrote in message ... It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? Just use your fingers to wrap it against the surface as you sand. You guys don't seem to understand the type of trim I'm talking about. It's not this, but it should give an idea http://www.bmcwest.com/products/default.asp?cat=11 There's no possible way to sand hundreds of feet of that and getinto the crevices. That's the way trim usually is nowadays. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
jeffc wrote:
"Bob F" wrote in message ... "jeffc" wrote in message ... It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? Just use your fingers to wrap it against the surface as you sand. You guys don't seem to understand the type of trim I'm talking about. It's not this, but it should give an idea http://www.bmcwest.com/products/default.asp?cat=11 There's no possible way to sand hundreds of feet of that and getinto the crevices. That's the way trim usually is nowadays. Make patterns and fold -- I've done thousands of feet of similar mouldings over my lifetime... -- |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
In article ,
"jeffc" wrote: "Bob F" wrote in message ... "jeffc" wrote in message ... It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? Just use your fingers to wrap it against the surface as you sand. You guys don't seem to understand the type of trim I'm talking about. It's not this, but it should give an idea http://www.bmcwest.com/products/default.asp?cat=11 There's no possible way to sand hundreds of feet of that and getinto the crevices. That's the way trim usually is nowadays. You could sandblast it. That's what I'd do. About 200 times faster than hand sanding. |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
RicodJour wrote:
On Jul 3, 10:03 pm, "jeffc" wrote: It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? You should clean the trim to be painted before sanding to make sure there's no grease or oils that will cause problems with the finish. Wrap sandpaper around a suitably sized dowel or pencil to sand the rounded parts, and fold the paper to sand into the sharp corners. Other than that it's business as usual. You're just scuffing up the surface to give the paint primer something to bite onto. Use a primer with high adherence like Benjamin Moore's Fresh start. You could use a liquid deglosser (aka liquid sandpaper) that is a really nasty chemical cocktail that will soften the poly and give it some tooth for the primer. It will also take care of the cleaning step at the same time. It's nasty stuff so wear a respirator. http://www.cornerhardware.com/index....dex&cPath=7632 R Good advice. I've repainted after bad paint jobs done by other people and find that issue #1 is absolute cleanliness. Gloss is less of a problem than greasy dirt and fingerprints. Clean it well with your favorite household cleaner, wipe with denatured alcohol. I use only alkyd semi for trim, but it has issues with yellowing nowadays. Latex is crap for trim, especially when time to repaint. It may not yellow as quickly as alkyd but stains more easily. |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 3, 11:54 pm, "jeffc" wrote:
"Bob F" wrote in message ... "jeffc" wrote in message .. . It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? Just use your fingers to wrap it against the surface as you sand. You guys don't seem to understand the type of trim I'm talking about. It's not this, but it should give an ideahttp://www.bmcwest.com/products/default.asp?cat=11 There's no possible way to sand hundreds of feet of that and getinto the crevices. That's the way trim usually is nowadays. Since there were only two posters when you wrote "You guys don't seem to understand...", I assume you meant me, which makes me wonder why you didn't read the second part of my post. There are two parts that must be mastered when asking for advice. The asking part you have down pat, the reading part needs a little bit of work. Go back and have another go at it. Thanks. R |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"jeffc" wrote in message ... "Bob F" wrote in message ... "jeffc" wrote in message ... It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? Just use your fingers to wrap it against the surface as you sand. You guys don't seem to understand the type of trim I'm talking about. It's not this, but it should give an idea http://www.bmcwest.com/products/default.asp?cat=11 There's no possible way to sand hundreds of feet of that and getinto the crevices. That's the way trim usually is nowadays. There is a way, but it requires patience. Bob |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
Norminn wrote:
.... alkyd semi for trim, but it has issues with yellowing nowadays. Latex is crap for trim, especially when time to repaint. It may not yellow as quickly as alkyd but stains more easily. I disagree w/ both points, personally. Colors are more stable than ever imo, and a good latex enamel in semi- or gloss finish won't stain badly at all. A flat will because of the rougher texture, but flat shouldn't be used for trim, anyway. imo, etc., etc., ... -- |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"RicodJour" wrote in message ps.com... Since there were only two posters when you wrote "You guys don't seem to understand...", I assume you meant me, which makes me wonder why you didn't read the second part of my post. There are two parts that must be mastered when asking for advice. The asking part you have down pat, the reading part needs a little bit of work. Go back and have another go at it. Thanks. I don't need to, I read it right the first time. The second part of your post had to do with using a deglosser, so obiously I'm not talking about that. In the second part of your post, you didn't say "disregard the first part of my post", so I'm not. I'm responding to the advice there. To wit: "fold the paper to sand into the sharp corners", which is just crazy. That would take 10,000 years for all the cracks and crevices in the trim. There has to be something like - what? - 5 or 10 thousand feet of trim in a good sized house? |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"jeffc" wrote in message ... You guys don't seem to understand the type of trim I'm talking about. It's not this, but it should give an idea http://www.bmcwest.com/products/default.asp?cat=11 There's no possible way to sand hundreds of feet of that and getinto the crevices. That's the way trim usually is nowadays. A better example http://www.burtonmoldings.com/images...esText/139.jpg |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 4, 1:04 pm, "jeffc" wrote:
"RicodJour" wrote in message Since there were only two posters when you wrote "You guys don't seem to understand...", I assume you meant me, which makes me wonder why you didn't read the second part of my post. There are two parts that must be mastered when asking for advice. The asking part you have down pat, the reading part needs a little bit of work. Go back and have another go at it. Thanks. I don't need to, I read it right the first time. The second part of your post had to do with using a deglosser, so obiously I'm not talking about that. In the second part of your post, you didn't say "disregard the first part of my post", so I'm not. I'm responding to the advice there. To wit: "fold the paper to sand into the sharp corners", which is just crazy. That would take 10,000 years for all the cracks and crevices in the trim. There has to be something like - what? - 5 or 10 thousand feet of trim in a good sized house? Let me see if I understand your position. You read the full post, ignore the advice that works for you, and then criticize the other part. That about sum it up? Equally obviously, you could say thanks for the advice. R |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
In article ,
"jeffc" wrote: "RicodJour" wrote in message ps.com... Since there were only two posters when you wrote "You guys don't seem to understand...", I assume you meant me, which makes me wonder why you didn't read the second part of my post. There are two parts that must be mastered when asking for advice. The asking part you have down pat, the reading part needs a little bit of work. Go back and have another go at it. Thanks. I don't need to, I read it right the first time. The second part of your post had to do with using a deglosser, so obiously I'm not talking about that. In the second part of your post, you didn't say "disregard the first part of my post", so I'm not. I'm responding to the advice there. To wit: "fold the paper to sand into the sharp corners", which is just crazy. That would take 10,000 years for all the cracks and crevices in the trim. There has to be something like - what? - 5 or 10 thousand feet of trim in a good sized house? Yeah, you're right, it's an impossibly large job. Never been done by any mortal. 10,000 feet, 10,000 years. That's one year per foot. I don't think you need to be quite so meticulous with it. Just break the sheen and slap that paint on there. You coulda sanded two rooms in the time you spent sniveling about how hard it is. Anyway, if you can afford a house with *two miles* of trim, you can afford to hire a professional painter. (imagine smiley emoticon here) |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
dpb wrote:
Norminn wrote: ... alkyd semi for trim, but it has issues with yellowing nowadays. Latex is crap for trim, especially when time to repaint. It may not yellow as quickly as alkyd but stains more easily. I disagree w/ both points, personally. Colors are more stable than ever imo, and a good latex enamel in semi- or gloss finish won't stain badly at all. A flat will because of the rougher texture, but flat shouldn't be used for trim, anyway. imo, etc., etc., ... -- Flat paint holds dirt more because of the texture. I was referring to latex semi, which is smoothe. In my experience, it stains (permanently) from ink, lipstick, and other oily stuff. It is also lousy to sand when one wants to repaint, and trim around busy doorways usually has dings to sand out. |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 4, 9:32 pm, Norminn wrote:
Flat paint holds dirt more because of the texture. I was referring to latex semi, which is smooth. In my experience, it stains (permanently) from ink, lipstick, and other oily stuff. Pretty much all paint will stain with that stuff. It is also lousy to sand when one wants to repaint, and trim around busy doorways usually has dings to sand out. That's true enough. Wonder when they'll get around to developing sandable latex... R |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
jeffc wrote:
"Bob F" wrote in message ... "jeffc" wrote in message . .. It was recommended I sand poly interior trim before painting white. If it's not flat (i.e. it's typical nook-and-cranny cross section, like most trim nowadays), how do you go about sanding it? Just use your fingers to wrap it against the surface as you sand. You guys don't seem to understand the type of trim I'm talking about. It's not this, but it should give an idea http://www.bmcwest.com/products/default.asp?cat=11 There's no possible way to sand hundreds of feet of that and getinto the crevices. That's the way trim usually is nowadays. Well, actually, that's not the way my trim is nowadays or ever ) If you didn't want advice about sanding trim, why did you ask for it????? When complex moldings are painted, the paint tends to be a little heavier in the carvings/crevices than on the raised portion. It also sticks better to the raised or flatter portions....the paint film actually "bridges" the grooves and as long as it is bonded will on both sides, it will stick. You could probably get by without any sanding if you clean it very well, degrease with denatured alcohol, and use good quality primer and paint. I've done a good deal of painting and paint removal. Unless your "poly" is high gloss, I'd forget sanding at all. As was suggested to you, a liquid sander can also be used - it is highly volatile, so need good vent. and care about flammability. It softens the finish enough to remove the gloss, and will get gummy and smeary if you use too much. With "thousands of feet" of shaped or carved molding, I would be hesitant to paint it at all.....clear finish doesn't show blemishes as easily as paint, IMO. |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"Norminn" wrote in message ink.net... Well, actually, that's not the way my trim is nowadays or ever ) It's the way plenty of trim is in plenty of houses. If you didn't want advice about sanding trim, why did you ask for it????? I do want advice. If the advice is impractical or doesn't make sense, I point it out. I've done a good deal of painting and paint removal. Unless your "poly" is high gloss, I'd forget sanding at all. Well that's fine advice. With "thousands of feet" of shaped or carved molding, I would be hesitant to paint it at all.....clear finish doesn't show blemishes as easily as paint, IMO. It's not a question of showing blemishes. Houses with natural wood trim look very dated and are hard to sell around here. White semi-gloss is the norm. (I'll be painting the doors too, which are natural too, but that's easy.) |
#19
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"jeffc" wrote in message ... It's not a question of showing blemishes. Houses with natural wood trim look very dated and are hard to sell around here. White semi-gloss is the norm. (I'll be painting the doors too, which are natural too, but that's easy.) Boring!! I sure wish I could have stopped the people that painted all the trim in my old house. The little remaining stained wood is way more attractive than the painted wood. Bob |
#20
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 5, 2:05 pm, "Bob F" wrote:
"jeffc" wrote in message ... It's not a question of showing blemishes. Houses with natural wood trim look very dated and are hard to sell around here. White semi-gloss is the norm. (I'll be painting the doors too, which are natural too, but that's easy.) Boring!! I sure wish I could have stopped the people that painted all the trim in my old house. The little remaining stained wood is way more attractive than the painted wood. Me, too! Who gives a crap about "hard to sell"? I'm planning on leaving my house feet first. I'm pretty sure it's oak under that paint--the baseboards are stained and varnished oak, whereas the door and window casings are painted. Cindy Hamilton |
#21
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"Cindy Hamilton" wrote in message oups.com... I sure wish I could have stopped the people that painted all the trim in my old house. The little remaining stained wood is way more attractive than the painted wood. Me, too! Who gives a crap about "hard to sell"? I'm planning on leaving my house feet first. Um, younger people making wise use of their home as an investment as well? People who are flipping houses? People who will only be in the house for a few years? What's going on with you people, are you all 80 years old? |
#22
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 5, 11:47 pm, "jeffc" wrote:
"Cindy Hamilton" wrote in message "Bob F" wrote: I sure wish I could have stopped the people that painted all the trim in my old house. The little remaining stained wood is way more attractive than the painted wood. Me, too! Who gives a crap about "hard to sell"? I'm planning on leaving my house feet first. Um, younger people making wise use of their home as an investment as well? People who are flipping houses? People who will only be in the house for a few years? What's going on with you people, are you all 80 years old? People that disagree with your taste, or more accurately, lack of it, are necessarily old? Interesting concept - dimwitted, but interesting. Your estimate of 5 or 10 thousand feet of trim in a good sized house is way on the high side, as is your obviously gross exaggeration of the amount of time it would take to scuff sand trim. You also seem to be projecting your tastes onto other people, which is a common occurrence in people new to real estate sales. It's not about you and your ego. It's about the buyer. Making a statement that stained/ natural wood trim and doors is hindering the sale of a house is absurd. Badly done anything is what hinders the sale of a house. Your reasoning regarding semi gloss white being the norm in your area dictating what you should do is faulty. If you ask anyone with real estate experience - watching flipping shows on TV doesn't count - making your house stand out in a good way is what sells a house - wherever you are. Stained/natural finishing costs more than painting. It's tougher to get it right. If it's badly done, that's another animal entirely, but you didn't mention the quality being poor. If the quality is reasonable, you are downgrading the house by painting. You will _never_ see a house listing indicate "painted trim", but you will certainly see "natural wood" and "stained {insert wood species here} trim" in listings. These are selling points. That's why they put them in the listings. You should really learn this stuff before you start mucking up buildings. It has nothing to do with young/old. It's more of a question of dumb/smart - and you've already weighed in. R |
#23
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 5, 11:47 pm, "jeffc" wrote:
"Cindy Hamilton" wrote in message oups.com... I sure wish I could have stopped the people that painted all the trim in my old house. The little remaining stained wood is way more attractive than the painted wood. Me, too! Who gives a crap about "hard to sell"? I'm planning on leaving my house feet first. Um, younger people making wise use of their home as an investment as well? People who are flipping houses? People who will only be in the house for a few years? What's going on with you people, are you all 80 years old? I've always bought houses to live in, not as vehicles for financial speculation. Three houses, and the three questions I ask myself a Can I afford it comfortably? Is it a good house (structurally sound, etc.)? Do I find it attractive? I've never calculated whether I've made money on either of the sales. I've bought when I needed a house, and sold when I no longer needed it. I bought my first house when I was 32, and I'm now 50. I'm sure that 50 seems like 80 to you. (It seems like 20 to me.) Cindy Hamilton |
#24
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
jeffc wrote:
.... Um, younger people making wise use of their home as an investment as well? People who are flipping houses? ... Ummm....let's see. These "wise" younger people going into foreclosure and bankruptcy over their attempted speculation when bubbles burst... -- |
#25
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"dpb" wrote in message ... jeffc wrote: ... Um, younger people making wise use of their home as an investment as well? People who are flipping houses? ... Ummm....let's see. These "wise" younger people going into foreclosure and bankruptcy over their attempted speculation when bubbles burst... Don't make me laugh. |
#26
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"Cindy Hamilton" wrote in message oups.com... I sure wish I could have stopped the people that painted all the trim in my old house. The little remaining stained wood is way more attractive than the painted wood. Me, too! Who gives a crap about "hard to sell"? I'm planning on leaving my house feet first. Um, younger people making wise use of their home as an investment as well? People who are flipping houses? People who will only be in the house for a few years? What's going on with you people, are you all 80 years old? I've always bought houses to live in, not as vehicles for financial speculation. Three houses... 'nuff said. |
#27
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"jeffc" wrote in message ... "Norminn" wrote in message ink.net... Well, actually, that's not the way my trim is nowadays or ever ) It's the way plenty of trim is in plenty of houses. If you didn't want advice about sanding trim, why did you ask for it????? I do want advice. If the advice is impractical or doesn't make sense, I point it out. I've done a good deal of painting and paint removal. Unless your "poly" is high gloss, I'd forget sanding at all. Well that's fine advice. With "thousands of feet" of shaped or carved molding, I would be hesitant to paint it at all.....clear finish doesn't show blemishes as easily as paint, IMO. It's not a question of showing blemishes. Houses with natural wood trim look very dated and are hard to sell around here. White semi-gloss is the norm. (I'll be painting the doors too, which are natural too, but that's easy.) Some things are just wrong. Painting over good hardwood is one of them. I think the trend toward painted trim was probably a plot by the design magazines done at the behest of the mills selling crap finger-jointed pine trim. aem sends.... |
#28
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 7, 7:00 pm, "aemeijers" wrote:
"jeffc" wrote in message "Norminn" wrote in message Well, actually, that's not the way my trim is nowadays or ever ) It's the way plenty of trim is in plenty of houses. If you didn't want advice about sanding trim, why did you ask for it????? I do want advice. If the advice is impractical or doesn't make sense, I point it out. I've done a good deal of painting and paint removal. Unless your "poly" is high gloss, I'd forget sanding at all. Well that's fine advice. With "thousands of feet" of shaped or carved molding, I would be hesitant to paint it at all.....clear finish doesn't show blemishes as easily as paint, IMO. It's not a question of showing blemishes. Houses with natural wood trim look very dated and are hard to sell around here. White semi-gloss is the norm. (I'll be painting the doors too, which are natural too, but that's easy.) Some things are just wrong. Painting over good hardwood is one of them. I think the trend toward painted trim was probably a plot by the design magazines done at the behest of the mills selling crap finger-jointed pine trim. I lived in Back Bay Boston many moons ago. Spent a _lot_ of time stripping paint off of beautiful mahogany railings and quarter sawn oak paneling. The whole time, every scrape and stink of the way, I was thinking, why would someone do this to nice wood?! R |
#29
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"jeffc" wrote in message It's not a question of showing blemishes. Houses with natural wood trim look very dated and are hard to sell around here. White semi-gloss is the norm. (I'll be painting the doors too, which are natural too, but that's easy.) In 10 or 15 years, some poor ******* will be scraping that paint off to get the natural wood again once it is back in style. It may be easier to take out the trim, store it in the attic, and put up some cheap pine or plastic molding that is painted. |
#31
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
On Jul 7, 1:19 am, "jeffc" wrote:
"Cindy Hamilton" wrote in message oups.com... I sure wish I could have stopped the people that painted all the trim in my old house. The little remaining stained wood is way more attractive than the painted wood. Me, too! Who gives a crap about "hard to sell"? I'm planning on leaving my house feet first. Um, younger people making wise use of their home as an investment as well? People who are flipping houses? People who will only be in the house for a few years? What's going on with you people, are you all 80 years old? I've always bought houses to live in, not as vehicles for financial speculation. Three houses... 'nuff said What's your issue with three houses? Too many? Not enough? We've relocated twice for job changes. Cindy Hamilton |
#32
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Sanding trim
"dpb" wrote in message ... jeffc wrote: ... Um, younger people making wise use of their home as an investment as well? People who are flipping houses? ... Ummm....let's see. These "wise" younger people going into foreclosure and bankruptcy over their attempted speculation when bubbles burst... LMAO -- |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
What do I really need to cut trim? | Woodworking | |||
Looking for trim | UK diy | |||
Using a trim router bit on 1x2x8 oak trim? | Woodworking | |||
Will a flush trim bit plow thru or trim one edge only? | Woodworking | |||
How well do the powerless sanding tools work on sanding the inside of bowls? | Woodturning |