Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
![]() |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings
and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC |
#2
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Mar 16, 9:39 pm, "MiamiCuse" wrote:
I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Your electrician is an idiot. If he is licensed, he should take a refresher course on the code. Unless you have something that has a plug like this - | then you don't need any 20 amp outlets, let alone any 20 amp switches. We just covered this in a lengthy discussion on a yahoo group. If anyone has a sound reason to disagree, get out your code book and quote chapter and verse. I bow to the greater wisdom and would love to hear logic from a licensed master electrician, which I am not. BTW, are you talking about can lights when you say "high hats"? JK |
#3
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Mar 16, 9:47 pm, "Big_Jake" wrote:
On Mar 16, 9:39 pm, "MiamiCuse" wrote: I had an electrician inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Your electrician is an idiot. If he is licensed, he should take a refresher course on the code. Unless you have something that has a plug like this - | then you don't need any 20 amp outlets, let alone any 20 amp switches. We just covered this in a lengthy discussion on a yahoo group. If anyone has a sound reason to disagree, get out your code book and quote chapter and verse. I bow to the greater wisdom and would love to hear logic from a licensed master electrician, which I am not. BTW, are you talking about can lights when you say "high hats"? I would like to add that the electrician might not be an idiot. He might just be trying to drum up some unnecessary work. If your switches are failing often enough, and you feel replacing them would end the headaches then go for it. You might consider using 20A receptacles in the kitchen. That is about the only place I can think of. As many here have already pointed out, 20A in the kitchen most likely won't necessary as it is rare that you actually find an appliance with a 20A plug. Hooking up switches and receptacles yourself is very simple. With the power off you unscrew one wire at a time and put it on the new device and you are good to go. You should never have to unscrew a wire-nut. |
#4
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
20 amp outlets and switches don't make them better, just higher capacity. If
you want better than residential grade devices, get something like spec grade. It is a code violation to install 20 amp receptacles on a 15 amp circuit. It is however legal to install 15 amp receptacles on 20 amp circuits "MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC |
#5
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Just get the contractor packs. 10 for $4.89 or something like that.
-- Steve Barker YOU should be the one controlling YOUR car. Check out: www.lightsout.org "MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC |
#6
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
As everyone said, the electrician is an idiot. It is actually wrong to put
20a outlets on 15a circuits; that is why they are different. That said, I wouldn't use $0.89 devices. They are likely to wear out faster and be less dependable. Spend a couple bucks on it and do it right the first time. Unless of course you like doing it all again next year. |
#7
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
MiamiCuse wrote:
I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Buy the better 15A outlets for about $2 each. You don't need any 20A switches unless you are switching motors. The 79¢ switches are fine. The 35¢ outlets are good enough for bedrooms, washing machine, behind the refrigerator, etc. You need good outlets at the kitchen counters, bathroom, garage, the one in the hall where you plug in the vacuum cleaner all the time, etc. Bob |
#8
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Big_Jake" wrote in message ups.com... BTW, are you talking about can lights when you say "high hats"? JK Yes that is what I mean, recessed can lights. Thanks, MC |
#9
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Fri, 16 Mar 2007 22:39:09 -0400, "MiamiCuse"
wrote: I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC You're being robbed...... If you have a few outlets where the plugs seem loose and fall out, replace THOSE. If you have swithces that make the light flicker and pop internally when turned on, replace them. Leave the others until they are needed. You only need 20A ones on 20A circuits for large appliances, such as the kitchen. |
#11
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
MiamiCuse wrote:
I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Note: the price difference is not 15 vs 20, the price difference there is far less. but rather you are not looking at the same grade switch and outlet. Chances are the reason you now have flaky switches and outlets is the originals are cheap contractor grade like the $0.89 ones you are seeing. I would never bother buying one of those. Considering the difference I would go for the better quality. Follow code about the 15 vs 20 issue. You don't need to replace them all at the same time. I would not. I would tend to replace any that I had problems with and then any critical ones and then as time and money moved me the rest of them. -- Joseph Meehan Dia 's Muire duit |
#12
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
There's likely to be a few sockets where things get plugged in
once every five years. The lamp behind the sofa. The garage door opener socket, on the ceiling of the garage. Those don't need premium quality sockets. Other things get plugged every day. Razor shaver, blender and toaster socket in the kitchen, etc. Those could use premium sockets. And there are exceptions like me, who leaves his shaver plugged in all the time. -- Christopher A. Young You can't shout down a troll. You have to starve them. .. "Toller" wrote in message ... : As everyone said, the electrician is an idiot. It is actually wrong to put : 20a outlets on 15a circuits; that is why they are different. : : That said, I wouldn't use $0.89 devices. They are likely to wear out faster : and be less dependable. Spend a couple bucks on it and do it right the : first time. Unless of course you like doing it all again next year. : : |
#13
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Terry wrote:
On Mar 16, 9:47 pm, "Big_Jake" wrote: On Mar 16, 9:39 pm, "MiamiCuse" wrote: I had an electrician inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Your electrician is an idiot. If he is licensed, he should take a refresher course on the code. Unless you have something that has a plug like this - | then you don't need any 20 amp outlets, let alone any 20 amp switches. We just covered this in a lengthy discussion on a yahoo group. If anyone has a sound reason to disagree, get out your code book and quote chapter and verse. I bow to the greater wisdom and would love to hear logic from a licensed master electrician, which I am not. BTW, are you talking about can lights when you say "high hats"? I would like to add that the electrician might not be an idiot. He might just be trying to drum up some unnecessary work. If your switches are failing often enough, and you feel replacing them would end the headaches then go for it. You might consider using 20A receptacles in the kitchen. That is about the only place I can think of. As many here have already pointed out, 20A in the kitchen most likely won't necessary as it is rare that you actually find an appliance with a 20A plug. Hooking up switches and receptacles yourself is very simple. With the power off you unscrew one wire at a time and put it on the new device and you are good to go. You should never have to unscrew a wire-nut. It is simple but the wire is pretty heavy duty and the outlet boxes are tight so it may take time. Also, as mentioned, TURN OFF THE POWER at the breaker box - and be sure you turned off the right breaker. If you have any 3 way switches go very slowly or the three ways will not work. Lou |
#14
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Mar 17, 5:54 am, "Joseph Meehan"
wrote: MiamiCuse wrote: I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Note: the price difference is not 15 vs 20, the price difference there is far less. but rather you are not looking at the same grade switch and outlet. Chances are the reason you now have flaky switches and outlets is the originals are cheap contractor grade like the $0.89 ones you are seeing. I would never bother buying one of those. Considering the difference I would go for the better quality. Follow code about the 15 vs 20 issue. You don't need to replace them all at the same time. I would not. I would tend to replace any that I had problems with and then any critical ones and then as time and money moved me the rest of them. -- Joseph Meehan Dia 's Muire duit- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - If you want, you can get heavy duty 15 amp receptacles. I'd use those in any location where you may frequently plug and unplug things, as opposed to say a location behind the couch that you may only plug a lamp cord in and leave it. You can also use them everywhere, as they aren't anywhere near as expensive as the prices you are seeing for 20 amp. Also, as others have pointed out, if you elect to go with 20 amp outlets, which I would not, unless you have a load that requires it, the wire and breaker must be rated for 20amps. It is a code violation to put a 20 amp outlet on a 15 amp breaker or with wire that is less than 12 gauge. If it's an old house, it is likely the wiring is not 12. First thing I would do is find another electrician. |
#15
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
well I once replaced every outlet and switch here and bought the
premium pricey ones. The old ones were 50 years old and going bad. The under a buck ones often with backstab connections are a bad deal, they are pure junk. I bought the premium 15 amp ones, that looked like the originals for 4 bucks a piece but that was over 10 years ago. I did all the work myself, replaced all the light fixtures too. after a shower of sparks in the middle of the night when I turned on my bedroom lighjt ![]() A basic rule the cheapest ANYTHING is probably designed for a low price point, a mid price item is usually better. high fashion priced stuff is a rip off. |
#16
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article .com, "Terry" wrote:
I would like to add that the electrician might not be an idiot. He might just be trying to drum up some unnecessary work. If your switches are failing often enough, and you feel replacing them would end the headaches then go for it. No, he *is* an idiot. Putting 20A receptacles on a 15A circuit is a fire hazard, because it enables plugging in a device that may draw more current than the circuit conductors can safely carry. You might consider using 20A receptacles in the kitchen. That is about the only place I can think of. As many here have already pointed out, 20A in the kitchen most likely won't necessary as it is rare that you actually find an appliance with a 20A plug. NOT UNLESS he has 20A circuits feeding the kitchen. -- Regards, Doug Miller (alphageek at milmac dot com) It's time to throw all their damned tea in the harbor again. |
#17
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC In addition to what everyone else said, I suggest that you consider installing Decora style switches and receptacles as an upgrade. They have a nice modern look to them. Sometimes you can buy these devices on sale at Home Depot, but check at an electrical supply for box quantities (Ten to a box). They may give you a great price like that. |
#18
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() Walmart sells these and I recommend them. Never had one that wasn't perfect. On Fri, 16 Mar 2007 22:39:09 -0400, "MiamiCuse" wrote: I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC |
#19
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
how many household 20 amp things are there?
honestly cant ever remember seeing one. |
#20
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Terry wrote:
For switches, stick with the 15A also, but ... use brand name switches. If you're trying to switch on/off a load of say an air conditioner, even a 20A switch won't take that punishment for long. There just isn't much need for a 20 amp switch, really. .... Your electrician is an idiot. If he is licensed, he should take a refresher course on the code. Unless you have something that has Or he's looking for work that doesn't need to be done. Such a statement is not called for unless you know WHY he made the recommendation. a plug like this - | then you don't need any 20 amp outlets, let alone any 20 amp switches. Agreed. .... You might consider using 20A receptacles in the kitchen. That is about the only place I can think of. As many here have already pointed out, 20A in the kitchen most likely won't necessary as it is rare that you actually find an appliance with a 20A plug. Uhh, especially in a residential kitchen! Forget about 20A receptacles unless you have a known specific need, which is very, very unlikely IME. Just an edumacated diy'er wit lotsa sperience. Pop` |
#21
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Toller wrote:
As everyone said, the electrician is an idiot. It is actually wrong to put 20a outlets on 15a circuits; that is why they are different. "Everyone" did not say that. And you can not know that without knowing WHY it was said. You're guessing and jumping to conclusions as are others. That said, I wouldn't use $0.89 devices. They are likely to wear out faster and be less dependable. Spend a couple bucks on it and do it right the first time. Unless of course you like doing it all again next year. |
#22
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
John Grabowski wrote:
"MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC In addition to what everyone else said, I suggest that you consider installing Decora style switches and receptacles as an upgrade. They have a nice modern look to them. Sometimes you can buy these devices on sale at Home Depot, but check at an electrical supply for box quantities (Ten to a box). They may give you a great price like that. I have been unable to find the "spec grade" Decora receps in a contractor pack, only the cheap ones. You can get them individually at Lowe's however. HD does not seem to carry them at all. nate -- replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply. http://members.cox.net/njnagel |
#23
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#24
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Thanks for all the replies it was very helpful. I think may be I will attempt to do it myself. Part of the reasons I agreed to change them all is that some are toggles, some are old buttons, some are ivory, some black and some whites, some rounded outlets and some rectangulars. Even the phone outlets there are some with two screws on and some with a "rotating cover"...some of the switches I have to flip up and down twice or three times to get the light to come on etc... The electrician did say my circuits (I have two main panels in the garage) are all 20 amp circuits and he opened select outlets and switch boxes and my wirings are all 12 gauge. So the consensus is I only need 15amps but may be I am better of getting spec grade or pro grade ones except for those rarely used behind the couch plugs, correct? Again thanks for all the comments. MC |
#25
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Correct
"MiamiCuse" wrote in message news ![]() "MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Thanks for all the replies it was very helpful. I think may be I will attempt to do it myself. Part of the reasons I agreed to change them all is that some are toggles, some are old buttons, some are ivory, some black and some whites, some rounded outlets and some rectangulars. Even the phone outlets there are some with two screws on and some with a "rotating cover"...some of the switches I have to flip up and down twice or three times to get the light to come on etc... The electrician did say my circuits (I have two main panels in the garage) are all 20 amp circuits and he opened select outlets and switch boxes and my wirings are all 12 gauge. So the consensus is I only need 15amps but may be I am better of getting spec grade or pro grade ones except for those rarely used behind the couch plugs, correct? Again thanks for all the comments. MC |
#26
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() Your electrician is an idiot. If he is licensed, he should take a refresher course on the code. Unless you have something that has Or he's looking for work that doesn't need to be done. Such a statement is not called for unless you know WHY he made the recommendation. 20A circuits are better than 15A circuits. But you don't necessarily "need" them unless they are required (such as in your kitchen). The advantages might not be readily apparent, and you may not get an instant economic pay off by using the higher amperage circuit, but here is my experience with this. I have a room with several computers, monitors, printers, etc. where my home office is located. It is served by just one 15A circuit. Does it work? Yes... 99.5% of the time there is no problem, but I've got enough load on this particular circuit where it just reaches the tripping point and overloads the breaker. Every once in a while it overloads and causes me grief. I have to reset clocks, fix the computer, etc. I can't plug the 12A vacuum cleaner into the same circuit, for example. I really wish a 20A circuit had been installed from the beginning. If I had control of the house during construction, I would have done it that way. In fact, I would have run at least two 20A circuits just for this room. Right now, I live with the single 15A circuit because it would not be economical feasible to tear up the walls and replace the wiring. I suspect a lot of readers may have situations like this. In addition to the higher capacity, 20A circuits have less voltage drop than 15A circuits and perform better at longer distances from the breaker box. They make sense for workshops, outdoor garden power tools, computer rooms, and the larger 120V air-conditioners. Less voltage drop also means less energy wasted in the form of heating the wires. Some would consider this a luxury, but if you are doing new construction, or you have the walls open and the opportunity to run new wiring, you might want to consider running 20A circuits instead of 15A. I believe the code allows 15A devices on a 20A circuit so there is no point in buying the more expensive switches and outlets unless there is an individual device needing them. The upgraded (higher gauge) wire and the higher capacity breaker are the key factors to a better quality electrical installation. Beachcomber |
#27
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Mar 17, 11:45�am, "MiamiCuse" wrote:
"MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. *But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. *We decided to replace all outlets and switches. *He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. *Big difference. *I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. *Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC Thanks for all the replies it was very helpful. *I think may be I will attempt to do it myself. *Part of the reasons I agreed to change them all is that some are toggles, some are old buttons, some are ivory, some black and some whites, some rounded outlets and some rectangulars. *Even the phone outlets there are some with two screws on and some with a "rotating cover"...some of the switches I have to flip up and down twice or three times to get the light to come on etc... The electrician did say my circuits (I have two main panels in the garage) are all 20 amp circuits and he opened select outlets and switch boxes and my wirings are all 12 gauge. So the consensus is I only need 15amps but may be I am better of getting spec grade or pro grade ones except for those rarely used behind the couch plugs, correct? Again thanks for all the comments. MC- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Yeah all 12 gauge go with all the same outlets. Although I seriouslyu doubt your need for 20 amp with the extra bar on plug. what consumer product uses 20 amp? its a big job, read up in advance like wiring simplified. are all your outlets grounded? you should do ONE outlet at a time, then if wires come and go in box check every outlet and lamp on that circuit eveywhere in building assume troubles will come up they always do. Like wires too short to be polarized properly. so if something quits working you know where the problem occured if you have a knowledgable friend better to get some initial help test EVERY OUTLETS as you finish it for proper polarity and good grounding |
#28
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Nate Nagel" wrote in message ... John Grabowski wrote: "MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC In addition to what everyone else said, I suggest that you consider installing Decora style switches and receptacles as an upgrade. They have a nice modern look to them. Sometimes you can buy these devices on sale at Home Depot, but check at an electrical supply for box quantities (Ten to a box). They may give you a great price like that. I have been unable to find the "spec grade" Decora receps in a contractor pack, only the cheap ones. You can get them individually at Lowe's however. HD does not seem to carry them at all. nate Perhaps an electrical supply company would have the spec grade in quantity. I'm not sure that they are necessary for a residence though. The standard Decora devices are pretty good |
#29
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#30
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Doug Miller wrote:
snipped No, he *is* an idiot. Putting 20A receptacles on a 15A circuit is a fire hazard, because it enables plugging in a device that may draw more current than the circuit conductors can safely carry. I certainly agree with you that putting a 20 amp receptical on a 15A circuit is NOT a smart thing to do because the shape of the receptical slots makes it APPEAR that it's a 20 amp circuit. But, if it IS a 15 amp circuit I'd expect the breaker (or fuse) to open if the load exceeded 15 amps, so where does the fire hazard come from? You could create an overload just by plugging two 10 amp loads into a duplex 15 amp receptical on a 15 amp circuit, couldn't you? snipped Jeff -- Jeffry Wisnia (W1BSV + Brass Rat '57 EE) The speed of light is 1.98*10^14 fathoms per fortnight. |
#31
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
mm wrote:
On Sat, 17 Mar 2007 16:52:33 GMT, (Beachcomber) wrote: 20A circuits are better than 15A circuits. You may have come in in the middle, but in this particular example, he wasn't going to put in a 20A circuit. Just a 20A outlet on what was most likely a 15A circuit. If it had been a 20A circuit, it would likely have had 20A outlets already, but it doesn't. None of them do. But you don't necessarily "need" them unless they are required (such as in your kitchen). ..... OP has since said that all of the circuits are 20A and wired with 12 gauge wire (as I would have expected, my old house is like that too) The only place where you'd likely see a 20A outlet is by a window for an air conditioner. AFAIK, that's the only residential appliance that uses a 20A plug. You also might have a 20A plug on a 3 or 4 HP (bogus rating) air compressor. It is normal to put 15A duplex receptacles on 20A circuits in the USA. I think it's different in Canada. Best regards, Bob |
#32
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Me neither. This 20A appliance discussion has been beat into the ground and
there doesn't seem to be any basis for it. -- Steve Barker YOU should be the one controlling YOUR car. Check out: www.lightsout.org wrote in message oups.com... how many household 20 amp things are there? honestly cant ever remember seeing one. |
#33
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
not normally plugged in, in the kitchen.
-- Steve Barker YOU should be the one controlling YOUR car. Check out: www.lightsout.org "Nate Nagel" wrote in message ... wrote: how many household 20 amp things are there? honestly cant ever remember seeing one. Air compressor wired for 120V? nate -- replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply. http://members.cox.net/njnagel |
#34
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Sat, 17 Mar 2007 12:06:33 -0400, Nate Nagel
wrote: John Grabowski wrote: "MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC In addition to what everyone else said, I suggest that you consider installing Decora style switches and receptacles as an upgrade. They have a nice modern look to them. Sometimes you can buy these devices on sale at Home Depot, but check at an electrical supply for box quantities (Ten to a box). They may give you a great price like that. I have been unable to find the "spec grade" Decora receps in a contractor pack, only the cheap ones. You can get them individually at Lowe's however. HD does not seem to carry them at all. Go to a true electrical supply co. |
#35
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
I suspect you are asking the wrong question, the question is not so much the
amp rating on the switches and outlets but rather the grade of the switches and outlets. If you look there should be several grades listed something like spec, industrial and pro. the cheapies are usually less than a buck, the pro are something around 2 bucks each and the industrial are the $6+ plugs. The low grade is usually selected by track home builders because most people buying houses don't care about plugs. The mid grade is fine for most service probably outlast you, and the industrial is big overkill unless you have a shop and are doing heavy work or you have some special needs. Try a different store if the borg doesn't have the mid grade. -- Roger Shoaf If you are not part of the solution, you are not dissolved in the solvent. "MiamiCuse" wrote in message ... I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC |
#36
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Sat, 17 Mar 2007 05:37:53 -0400, Nate Nagel
wrote: wrote: On Fri, 16 Mar 2007 22:39:09 -0400, "MiamiCuse" wrote: I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC You're being robbed...... If you have a few outlets where the plugs seem loose and fall out, replace THOSE. If you have swithces that make the light flicker and pop internally when turned on, replace them. Leave the others until they are needed. You only need 20A ones on 20A circuits for large appliances, such as the kitchen. It might be possible that ALL old outlets and switches are due for replacement. that is the case in my house. How do you know they ALL need replacement? If you are talking about visual appearance, they might need replacement for cosmetic reasons. If you are talking wear and tear, there is no way they all need replacement, because there are outlets in every home that never or seldom get used. Why replace what is not broke? If for some reason the outlets are all bad, possibly because they were installed 100 years ago, then the wiring also needs to be replaced. The only time I can see where it would be needed to replace ALL outlets is when a home is completely rewired, or when it's done for cosmetic reasons such as during a complete house remodel job. Otherwise, replace the ones that are used regularly, such as the kitchen counter, bathroom outlet where the shaver, hair dryer, etc are always plugged and unplugged, and maybe a few others where things are regularly plugged and unplugged such as the ones used for the vacuum cleaner, and those used for a workshop. Outlets dont wear out just because a lamp is plugged in a couple times a year when cleaning the house. Switches on the other hand take more abuse and wear out more than outlets. But there too, they wear at different rates. The bathroom, bedrooms, and kitchen lights are likely used often, but the switch for the seldom used walkin closet or attic are probably fine. I think this electrician is just trying to generate work for himself. The OP would be better off having the kitchen and bathroom outlets changed ONLY, or to really save some money, change them himself, one room at a time, starting with the kitchen and bathroom. Personally I dont understand why anyone would do any of this. Change them one at a time when they get bad. In other words, dont fix what isn't broke. He should replace all those that are worn now, and deal with the others as needed in the future. I'd use "spec grade" devices wherever I could. Yes, it will be several times more expensive than standard. nate |
#37
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
wrote:
On Sat, 17 Mar 2007 05:37:53 -0400, Nate Nagel wrote: wrote: On Fri, 16 Mar 2007 22:39:09 -0400, "MiamiCuse" wrote: I had an electrican inspect an old house I bought and he said the wirings and everything are fine and great. But many of the outlets and switches are getting flaky and sometimes the switches don't work. We decided to replace all outlets and switches. He told me to be on the safe side I should get 20 amps switches and outlets. I went to Home Depot and found the normal 15 amp switches are $0.89 a piece, the 20 amp switches are $5.89 a piece. Big difference. I counted that I need about 70 outlets and 45 switches so this adds up. Plus 3 way 20 amp switches are even more expensive! I called him and he said if I have outlets I might plug in a saw or vaccum cleaner than I should get 20 amps if it's a desk lamp 15 amp is enough. So what is the basis for determining this if I have these switches: For activating garage door openers. For plugging in a central vac system. For high hat lights (10 of them with one switch) For high hat lights (a single one) For outdoor dusk light For a series of 5 florescent tube lights For ceiling fan that has a light attachment For a hallway a set of two high hat light Can I use some 15 amps and some 20 amps, would really like to avoid the expensive one if not really necessary. Thanks, MC You're being robbed...... If you have a few outlets where the plugs seem loose and fall out, replace THOSE. If you have swithces that make the light flicker and pop internally when turned on, replace them. Leave the others until they are needed. You only need 20A ones on 20A circuits for large appliances, such as the kitchen. It might be possible that ALL old outlets and switches are due for replacement. that is the case in my house. How do you know they ALL need replacement? If you are talking about visual appearance, they might need replacement for cosmetic reasons. If you are talking wear and tear, there is no way they all need replacement, because there are outlets in every home that never or seldom get used. Why replace what is not broke? If for some reason the outlets are all bad, possibly because they were installed 100 years ago, then the wiring also needs to be replaced. The only time I can see where it would be needed to replace ALL outlets is when a home is completely rewired, or when it's done for cosmetic reasons such as during a complete house remodel job. Otherwise, replace the ones that are used regularly, such as the kitchen counter, bathroom outlet where the shaver, hair dryer, etc are always plugged and unplugged, and maybe a few others where things are regularly plugged and unplugged such as the ones used for the vacuum cleaner, and those used for a workshop. Outlets dont wear out just because a lamp is plugged in a couple times a year when cleaning the house. Switches on the other hand take more abuse and wear out more than outlets. But there too, they wear at different rates. The bathroom, bedrooms, and kitchen lights are likely used often, but the switch for the seldom used walkin closet or attic are probably fine. I think this electrician is just trying to generate work for himself. The OP would be better off having the kitchen and bathroom outlets changed ONLY, or to really save some money, change them himself, one room at a time, starting with the kitchen and bathroom. Personally I dont understand why anyone would do any of this. Change them one at a time when they get bad. In other words, dont fix what isn't broke. He should replace all those that are worn now, and deal with the others as needed in the future. *none* of mine feel like they hold a plug securely. It appears that they were all replaced sometime around 1980. I'm systematically going through and replacing them all; I'd be done by now except I found a mess of bootlegged grounds as well, which I've posted about before - I'm waiting for a warm weekend to go up in the attic and rewire the 2nd floor. nate -- replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply. http://members.cox.net/njnagel |
#38
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Jeff Wisnia wrote:
Doug Miller wrote: snipped No, he *is* an idiot. Putting 20A receptacles on a 15A circuit is a fire hazard, because it enables plugging in a device that may draw more current than the circuit conductors can safely carry. I certainly agree with you that putting a 20 amp receptical on a 15A circuit is NOT a smart thing to do because the shape of the receptical slots makes it APPEAR that it's a 20 amp circuit. But, if it IS a 15 amp circuit I'd expect the breaker (or fuse) to open if the load exceeded 15 amps, so where does the fire hazard come from? The breaker could be defective. You could create an overload just by plugging two 10 amp loads into a duplex 15 amp receptical on a 15 amp circuit, couldn't you? The breaker would flip. |
#39
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Beachcomber wrote:
I have a room with several computers, monitors, printers, etc. where my home office is located. It is served by just one 15A circuit. Does it work? I really wish a 20A circuit had been installed from the beginning. If I had control of the house during construction, I would have done it that way. In fact, I would have run at least two 20A circuits just for this room. Right now, I live with the single 15A circuit because it would not be economical feasible to tear up the walls and replace the wiring. I suspect a lot of readers may have situations like this. Consider running conduit under the eaves from your breaker to the room (assuming the room has an outside wall). |
#40
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
gfci amps. | Home Repair | |||
How many amps? | Home Repair | |||
Battery Amps | Electronics Repair | |||
Motor HP/Amps ? | Woodworking | |||
car amps | Electronics Repair |