Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
I have to get a new washer. Don't want fancy bells & whistles, just a
washer that does its job; won't crash tomorrow. I don't need extra capcity. I looked at a Whirlpool at Sears that I liked, but it's not on special any more. Salesperson said Kenmore is made by Whirlpool and is on special. Questions: 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? Tx Aspasia |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
That is who makes Sears applicances. 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? The same, unless some special version in some model is made just for the Sears account. Unlikely. 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? Seems reasonable. 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. We have a Kenmore front-load washer. More $$$, but my wife loves it. We had a Maytag last time around for 20+ years, but the word on the street is that the quality has dropped. I think Whirlpool now owns Maytag, for their upper-end stuff. Not sure about that. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. My service on Kenmore appliances has been fine. No complaints. Your milage will vary... Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? I did the routing stuff -- belts, pumps, hoses on the Maytag. I think servicing the side-load Kenmore may be a bit much myself. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
aspasia wrote in message ... 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? I don't claim to understand maketing, but each appliance vendor has lots of different names. Maytag also does JenAir and Magic Chef. GE does Hotpoint and Monogram. Whirlpool does KitchenAid. Electrolux does Fridgidaire, Kelvinator, and White Westinghouse. At one point in their life, Sears only sold stuff branded as Sears. In the last few decades, they now sell most brands, but some of their brands remain, including Kenmore appliances, which have gained a reputation for being a good value and reliable. (sort of like their Craftsman hand tools). 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? Maybe, but like I said above, Kenmore is considered to be very reliable (as is Whirlpool, who makes most their stuff). Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? I'm generally not a Sears fan, but do like Kenmore. I've owned quite a few different ones and they've given me no trouble. -Tim |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
aspasia wrote: I have to get a new washer. Don't want fancy bells & whistles, just a washer that does its job; won't crash tomorrow. I don't need extra capcity. I looked at a Whirlpool at Sears that I liked, but it's not on special any more. Salesperson said Kenmore is made by Whirlpool and is on special. Questions: 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? This is a common thing to do in the trade. Companies either buy out each other or sell units in order to hit a wider maket. If you had bought a Whirlpool previously and not liked it, you may not realise and buy the same thing under a different brand. Its a bit like buying a VW car and a Skoda. 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? Sometimes the alternative company saves on the casing. This doesn't always mean it is worse, but facias & switches can make a difference to the production costs. 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. The web is a top place for info, but sometimes not as accurate as we would like, so best off not to rely on it. I know dealers who state 'its exactly the same model, but different codes'. This can end up a totally different spec as they do produce some models slightly different to comply with being exclusive for a large wholesaler. Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? I agree with the prof on the servicing and I would try to barter a deal on an extended warranty by quoting a net price and getting from a proper dealer. Sounds mad from me as I sell on line, but truth is if you buy from a shop you are more likely to get better after service. Oh yeah, Whirpool domestic kit has got a lot better over the years and there are only about 6 pump types for about 90% of all brand types. A lot of internals are not even made by the brand name and are made in factories in Italy. Best of luck Stu http://www.cateringappliancesltd.co.uk |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
Compare prices at Lowes. If considering an extended warratny Lowes is much
cheaper on the service agreements. aspasia wrote in message ... I have to get a new washer. Don't want fancy bells & whistles, just a washer that does its job; won't crash tomorrow. I don't need extra capcity. I looked at a Whirlpool at Sears that I liked, but it's not on special any more. Salesperson said Kenmore is made by Whirlpool and is on special. Questions: 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? Tx Aspasia |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
Whirlpool does now own Maytag and all it lines.
A tip on the front load Whirlpool and Kenmore (HE type). If you remove the lower front panel there is a screw out/clean out strainer just before the pump. I found it the hard way after the kids left something in their pockets and clogged it up. This strainer isn't listed in the book anywhere I could find. professorpaul wrote: That is who makes Sears applicances. 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? The same, unless some special version in some model is made just for the Sears account. Unlikely. 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? Seems reasonable. 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. We have a Kenmore front-load washer. More $$$, but my wife loves it. We had a Maytag last time around for 20+ years, but the word on the street is that the quality has dropped. I think Whirlpool now owns Maytag, for their upper-end stuff. Not sure about that. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. My service on Kenmore appliances has been fine. No complaints. Your milage will vary... Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? I did the routing stuff -- belts, pumps, hoses on the Maytag. I think servicing the side-load Kenmore may be a bit much myself. |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
my serviceman told me whirlpool makes sears top loaders. differences
include rubber mounts on the kenmore to run more quiet, and the knobs on the control panel. lucas http://www.minibite.com/america/malone.htm |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
There is no difference in quality between a company's products marketed
under its own brands and those that are brand-engineered for other retailers. Sometimes there are minor differences, such as the functionality of a feature, or the availability of a particular feature. For example, Whirlpool might have two switches with two options each that give you four options total (2X2), while Kenmore might bundle the same functionality into one switch giving you four options total. One important note, though, is that part prices can differ between pure-branded and brand-engineered products. Let me give you an example. If your Frigidaire front load washer that appears as Kenmore at Sears, and GE at Home Depot needs repairs, you will pay a higher price for the part if it has a GE part number as compared to it having a Frigidaire part number. It is the same part, but the part number that appears on the box depends on the channel of distribution that it takes on the way to you. Most people don't know this, and are unable to do the math before making a purchase, but I would personally stay away from products made by other companies that are brand-engineered to the GE nameplate. When it comes down to it, nobody will ever know how clean your clothes really are, just by looking at your or your machine, and you probably won't be able to tell either. Most people buy way too many bells and whistles, when all you probably need is perhaps 2 speeds and 2 water temp options. Otherwise, most machines do pretty much the same thing. |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
|
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
On Sat, 30 Sep 2006 03:09:51 GMT, "Art"
wrote: Compare prices at Lowes. If considering an extended warratny Lowes is much cheaper on the service agreements. Thanks. There's no Lowe's near me, but it might be worth checking out. However, Sears offers free delivery and installation. Does Lowe's? ****What does the group think of extended warranties? Worth it?*** Aspasia aspasia wrote in message m... I have to get a new washer. Don't want fancy bells & whistles, just a washer that does its job; won't crash tomorrow. I don't need extra capcity. I looked at a Whirlpool at Sears that I liked, but it's not on special any more. Salesperson said Kenmore is made by Whirlpool and is on special. Questions: 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? Tx Aspasia |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
On Fri, 29 Sep 2006 17:12:28 -0700, aspasia wrote:
I have to get a new washer. Don't want fancy bells & whistles, just a washer that does its job; won't crash tomorrow. I don't need extra capcity. I looked at a Whirlpool at Sears that I liked, but it's not on special any more. Salesperson said Kenmore is made by Whirlpool and is on special. Questions: 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? Tx Aspasia There are so many companies that bought others it is hard to tell anymore. I suggest looking at Consumer Reports. Get the largest capacity, I think it's "Super Capacity." The fewer gadgets, the better. I like "scratch and dent" and keep the $100. My Whirlpool is over 16 years old and still kicking, but I'm not sure if Whirlpool has the same quality today in washers. Kenmore is a good brand. I found that generally Sears won't haggle over price, but a Mom-and-Pop usually will. |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
I find that the advice on laundry machines that one can find in
Consumer Reports is extrememly dubious, as if they never consult appliance experts at all. I was surprised that they rated the Calypso washers so highly, all the way to the bitter end. And with model numbers changing as fast as fashion (maybe 10 times a year, in seasons), the information you can find there is already outdated when you crack open the magazine. I've never figured out how a model that is available for only 6 weeks can rate an entry in Consumer Reports. And I've never figured out how a pure-branded item and a brand engineered item can have different ratings in the magazine, despite being the exact same machine. Another dubious value is buying at "scratch and dent" stores. You will never know the history of any one machine, despite the salesman's insistance that it has never been used and just came out of the box. If you buy there, you will, in essence, be assuming someone else's nightmare. The best way to buy a machine is by selecting a platform, and then buying the cheapest model with the capacity you need. All manufacturers build their models on basic platforms. For the most part, all Kenmore and Whirlpool top load washers are built on the direct drive platform. All Maytag models are built on just one platform, and same for GE and Frigidaire. Choose the platform with the best durability, and then choose within that platform for the best value. |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
I know you're just giving an example, but Frigidare and GE are different
manufactures and (as far as I know) never used as different monikers on the same machine. See my other post in this thread for some actual "same machine/different name" twins... -Tim |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
Tim Fischer wrote: I know you're just giving an example, but Frigidare and GE are different manufactures and (as far as I know) never used as different monikers on the same machine. See my other post in this thread for some actual "same machine/different name" twins... GE buys a lot of rebranded models from Frigidaire. The basic GE front load washer at Home Depot, not the newer one with the black control panel, is a Frigidaire product rebranded as GE. GE also buys certain laundry systems from Frigidaire and rebrands them with their own name. IIRC, there was a time in Maytag's history, pre-Whirlpool, when they were on strike and their Maytag branded laundry equipment was actually from GE. |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
On 1 Oct 2006 18:56:55 -0700, "larry moe 'n curly"
wrote: wrote: There is no difference in quality between a company's products marketed under its own brands and those that are brand-engineered for other retailers. One important note, though, is that part prices can differ between pure-branded and brand-engineered products. Let me give you an example. If your Frigidaire front load washer that appears as Kenmore at Sears, and GE at Home Depot needs repairs, you will pay a higher price for the part if it has a GE part number as compared to it having a Frigidaire part number. It is the same part, but the part number that appears on the box depends on the channel of distribution that it takes on the way to you. Most people don't know this, and are unable to do the math before making a purchase, but I would personally stay away from products made by other companies that are brand-engineered to the GE nameplate. I found that even GE-made appliances have expensive parts. The range burner temperature control for our GE electric oven was $75 from GE and hard to find for less than $50, while a Whirlpool equivalent was about $40 list and could be bought for $27. . As I wrote in companion thread "extended warranties - worth it?" Sears price for lid switch assembly for old Maytag washer was $44. Same part available on-line through part supplier for $27. Aspasia |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
aspasia wrote in message ... On 1 Oct 2006 18:56:55 -0700, "larry moe 'n curly" As I wrote in companion thread "extended warranties - worth it?" Sears price for lid switch assembly for old Maytag washer was $44. Same part available on-line through part supplier for $27. I always thought Sears parts were overpriced, but I checked around for some parts for our circa-ten-year-old Frigidare dishwasher last month, and Sears was pretty much the same as most other places I called, actually a little cheaper than one or two of them. One of the other places had the items in stock, though, and Sears needed to order, so I didn't buy from them. -Tim |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
In article , "Tim Fischer" wrote:
One of the other places had the items in stock, though, and Sears needed to order, so I didn't buy from them. Well, at least they were honest enough to tell you they had to order it. In my experience, Sears will tell you they have the part "in stock" regardless of whether they do or not -- because, to them, "in stock" means "the computer says we can get it". It most definitely does *not* mean that they actually have the part. -- Regards, Doug Miller (alphageek at milmac dot com) It's time to throw all their damned tea in the harbor again. |
#19
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
Yes last time I bought an appliance there. Delivery guy also dropped door
of refrigeratior on hardwood floor. Lowes paid for repair no quibbles about it. aspasia wrote in message ... On Sat, 30 Sep 2006 03:09:51 GMT, "Art" wrote: Compare prices at Lowes. If considering an extended warratny Lowes is much cheaper on the service agreements. Thanks. There's no Lowe's near me, but it might be worth checking out. However, Sears offers free delivery and installation. Does Lowe's? ****What does the group think of extended warranties? Worth it?*** Aspasia aspasia wrote in message om... I have to get a new washer. Don't want fancy bells & whistles, just a washer that does its job; won't crash tomorrow. I don't need extra capcity. I looked at a Whirlpool at Sears that I liked, but it's not on special any more. Salesperson said Kenmore is made by Whirlpool and is on special. Questions: 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? Tx Aspasia |
#20
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
Phisherman wrote: On Fri, 29 Sep 2006 17:12:28 -0700, aspasia wrote: I looked at a Whirlpool at Sears that I liked, but it's not on special any more. Salesperson said Kenmore is made by Whirlpool and is on special. There are so many companies that bought others it is hard to tell anymore. I suggest looking at Consumer Reports. Get the largest capacity, I think it's "Super Capacity." The fewer gadgets, the better. I like "scratch and dent" and keep the $100. My Whirlpool is over 16 years old and still kicking, but I'm not sure if Whirlpool has the same quality today in washers. Kenmore is a good brand. I found that generally Sears won't haggle over price, but a Mom-and-Pop usually will. I think that a lot of items are scratched or dented simply because Sears stores use hand carts that scrape bare metal against the products. So if you plan on buyng an open box item, bring along some cardboard or a towel, and insist that Sears cover the product with it before they haul it. |
#21
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
Most items at outlets are returns from other customers, not scratched
or dented as most people think. If you compare prices, though, you will find that they are pretty much the same as brand new items. |
#22
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
|
#23
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
maytag does ammana also.
Empresser #124457 The best Games a href=http://www.gamestotal.com/Multiplayer Online Games/a a href=http://www.gamestotal.com/Strategy Games/abra href=http://uc.gamestotal.com/Unification Wars/a - a href=http://uc.gamestotal.com/Massive Multiplayer Online Games/abra href=http://gc.gamestotal.com/Galactic Conquest/a - a href=http://gc.gamestotal.com/Strategy Games/abra href=http://www.stephenyong.com/runescape.htmRunescape/abra href=http://www.stephenyong.com/kingsofchaos.htmKings of chaos/abr Tim Fischer wrote: aspasia wrote in message ... 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? I don't claim to understand maketing, but each appliance vendor has lots of different names. Maytag also does JenAir and Magic Chef. GE does Hotpoint and Monogram. Whirlpool does KitchenAid. Electrolux does Fridgidaire, Kelvinator, and White Westinghouse. At one point in their life, Sears only sold stuff branded as Sears. In the last few decades, they now sell most brands, but some of their brands remain, including Kenmore appliances, which have gained a reputation for being a good value and reliable. (sort of like their Craftsman hand tools). 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? Maybe, but like I said above, Kenmore is considered to be very reliable (as is Whirlpool, who makes most their stuff). Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? I'm generally not a Sears fan, but do like Kenmore. I've owned quite a few different ones and they've given me no trouble. -Tim |
#24
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
aspasia wrote: I have to get a new washer. Don't want fancy bells & whistles, just a washer that does its job; won't crash tomorrow. I don't need extra capcity. I looked at a Whirlpool at Sears that I liked, but it's not on special any more. Salesperson said Kenmore is made by Whirlpool and is on special. Questions: 1. If it's made by Whirlpool, why sell it under Sears Kenmore name? 2. Is there a difference in quality between W. and K.? Whirlpool ranks a tad better according to CR...but it depends on the model. 3. Sorry I don't have a model number, but the Whirlpool I was looking at is about $395. After spending ages on-line trying to get comparative info, I'm more confused than ever. Any voice-of-experience/repair professional advice out there? Tx Aspasia |
#25
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
wrote in message
oups.com... Most items at outlets are returns from other customers, not scratched or dented as most people think. If you compare prices, though, you will find that they are pretty much the same as brand new items. I just bought an LG Dishwasher ($799 at Home Depot) at an ApplianceSmart outlet for $599 as a "scratch and dent". The "dents" were so subtle that you have to be standing in specific light looking from a specific angle or you'd never see them. You can be right in front of the unit and feel up and down and you'd never notice. I'm kind of picky, but for $200 off that was fine by me. The thing cleans like a dream, by the way, and it's stainless in and out... -Tim |
#26
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Washer - Whirlpool vs Kenmore
replying to Tim Fischer, Donna East wrote:
Purchased a Whirlpool Washer today & I was praying that the Kenmore which was $50.00 less wasn't the better one & the salesman just wanted me to pay higher for him better commission. I worry because first I can't afford wasting $$$ & 2- me females normally suffer bigger loss. Thanks Tim now I don't feel salesman got 1- in on me. -- for full context, visit https://www.homeownershub.com/mainte...re-150829-.htm |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Whirlpool washer - lid switch malfunction | Home Ownership | |||
Kenmore (Whirlpool) HE3-T Front load washer | Home Repair | |||
Any maintenance to do on 5yr old Kenmore (Whirlpool) washer? | Home Repair | |||
Kenmore washer acting strange | Home Repair | |||
Whirlpool Duet Washer Problems? | Home Repair |