Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 126
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector

I've recently come to the conclusion that my shop-vac just wasn't
doing a good enough job at dust collection. When a Harbor Freight
flyer arrived in the mail recently, I noticed that HF was putting
their 13 Gallon Industrial Portable Dust Collector[1] on sale for
about $90. So I picked up one today to use with my planer, jointer,
and anything else I could connect up.

At the store, I looked around for some 4" hose, as the ad and the
web page for the DC state "Hose sold separately". I couldn't find
any. I asked one sales person and they claimed they didn't sell any
hose of that sort. Given the wording about the hose being sold
separetly, it implied to me that it was something HF sells, but maybe
not all the sells people know about it. So I decided to ask a
different sales person--this time I got a better answer. It turns out
they don't sell just the hose, but they do sell a Dust Collector
Accessory Kit[2] for $43. This kit wasn't out on the floor, so they
had to get it from the back. If you should decide to get one of these
things, make a note of the model number (93601) and then ask someone
to get one of them for you.

The DC kit includes two 10' lengths of 4" hose that seem quite
sturdy, along with a collection of wire clamps, blast gates, etc.
I was really only interested in the hose and clamps, but figured I'd
find a use for the other goodies later on.

When I got the DC and DC Kit home, there wasn't much to put together
except the casters on the DC. I was impressed with the size of the
motor on it (1HP) and it looked to be a pretty beefy little unit. The
DC bag is made out of canvas, but it is very thick and sturdy. One
thing I immediately noticed though was the casters. In the ad/web
page it describes them as "heavy duty ball bearing casters." Not even
close--these are just those plastic sort of things you find on cheap
office chairs. No biggy there though, if they break, I'll just
replace them with some better casters.

The first thing I decided to try was using the DC with my jointer. I
fired up the DC and was pleasently surprised at how much less noise it
makes than my shop vac. I then fired up the jointer and ran a board
through a couple of times and then shut everything down. Checking the
bag of the DC there were indeed some dust in there--so it must be
working.

Next I decided to try the DC with my planer. This is where I'd really
been wanting better dust collection, because even with my shop vac
hooked to the planer, it would still spit chips all over the place.
After getting the DC connected, I ran a board through and immediately
noticed that the planer was still spitting chips. I decided to check
the DC and see if there was something wrong. At the end of the hose,
it seemed the suction wasn't very strong. I shut down the DC and then
removed the hose on the input side and immediately I noticed what the
problem was--it was clogged with chips. On the inside of the DC's
input was a plastic mesh/screen that was clogging things up, so I
decided to see if I could remove it. The input is held on with four
machine screws. After removing those, I was able to easily remove the
screen. I put the input connector back on along with the hose and
then fired up the planer again. Again, it was spitting chips at me.
This time, it turns out the output side of the DC was clogged--again
with a screen. The screen on the output was also easily removed.

With both input and output screens removed, I was now getting some
decent suction from the DC. This time, when I ran some wood through
the planer there were no chips to be seen at all. This little DC
really does a good job at getting the dust and chips away from the
cutter head on the planer.

So, with the HF DC on sale for about $90 and the added DC Kit it all
comes to about $133 (with out tax). Normally the DC goes for about
$120. If you've been wanting a small dust collector, this one seems
to do a pretty good job.


[1]: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=31810
[2]: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=93601


--

If you want to reply via email, change the obvious words to numbers and
remove ".invalid".
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,185
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector

Michael Faurot wrote:
I've recently come to the conclusion that my shop-vac just wasn't
doing a good enough job at dust collection. When a Harbor Freight
flyer arrived in the mail recently, I noticed that HF was putting
their 13 Gallon Industrial Portable Dust Collector[1] on sale for
about $90. So I picked up one today to use with my planer, jointer,
and anything else I could connect up.


Just a minor note. This thing is more properly called a "chip collector". It doesn't have enough
airflow to collect finer dust, and any that it does collect will go right through the bag.

It will likely work just fine to collect planer/jointer chips, but it won't protect your lungs at
all. You should still wear a respirator for that.

Chris
  #3   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 75
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector

Best of all would be to exhaust it outside!
Wilson
"Chris Friesen" wrote in message
...
Michael Faurot wrote:
I've recently come to the conclusion that my shop-vac just wasn't
doing a good enough job at dust collection. When a Harbor Freight
flyer arrived in the mail recently, I noticed that HF was putting
their 13 Gallon Industrial Portable Dust Collector[1] on sale for
about $90. So I picked up one today to use with my planer, jointer,
and anything else I could connect up.


Just a minor note. This thing is more properly called a "chip collector".
It doesn't have enough airflow to collect finer dust, and any that it does
collect will go right through the bag.

It will likely work just fine to collect planer/jointer chips, but it
won't protect your lungs at all. You should still wear a respirator for
that.

Chris



  #4   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 175
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector


"Michael Faurot" wrote in message
...

Snippage

So, with the HF DC on sale for about $90 and the added DC Kit it all
comes to about $133 (with out tax). Normally the DC goes for about
$120. If you've been wanting a small dust collector, this one seems
to do a pretty good job.


[1]:
http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=31810
[2]:
http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=93601


I bought a similar King unit here in Canada a few years ago, although it
wasn't close to $90.

I originally bought it for blowing dust from a renovation job outside
without the crappy little bag. I was impressed with the blow power of this
little unit. But when I put the bag on, the suction dropped to nothing. So I
replaced the bag with one of the huge 5 micron bags from Lee Valley strapped
to the top of a G Can with a gate. I also neutured my blower (took the
stand off) and strapped it to a wooden lid on the top of another G can to
act as a chip collector. The performance increase was astounding and I
rarely have to empty the dust bucket, just the chip bucket.


  #5   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
Sam Sam is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector

Wilson wrote:
Best of all would be to exhaust it outside!
Wilson


I bought one of these little vacs about a year ago, and that is EXACTLY
what I did! That bag that comes with it is for the birds. It DEFINITELY
does NOT stop dust. I routed the hoses from the aforementioned hose kit
in such a way that the discharge goes directly out my window into my
basement window well. I used the 12" table saw hood on the output hose
at the window. A piece of cardboard and a couple pieces of duct tape
keep it pretty tight. The input and output screens were left in place.
I pull off the input hose and clean it out when clogged. I keep a
plastic bowl handy for the cleanout. When I use the jointer, the hose
clogs quickly. Perhaps I will try removing the screens as mentioned
above. Without the screens in place, what do you think about the
possibility of damage to the vac from stray nails or large chips?

Best Regards,
Sam



  #6   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 126
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector

Sam wrote:

When I use the jointer, the hose clogs quickly. Perhaps I will try
removing the screens as mentioned above. Without the screens in place,
what do you think about the possibility of damage to the vac from
stray nails or large chips?


I'm not worried about any stray metal like nails getting into the
DC as I'm pretty careful about the salvaged wood I mess with. As
for larger chips of wood, that did cross my mind. I may wind up
putting a chip separator of some type in front of the DC such as
these from Grizzly[1][2] or this one from Harbor Freight[3].


[1]: http://www.grizzly.com/products/G3376
[2]: http://www.grizzly.com/products/G6102
[3]: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...temnumber=9586


--

If you want to reply via email, change the obvious words to numbers and
remove ".invalid".
  #7   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 175
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector

On Fri, 6 Oct 2006 17:03:17 -0500, "Michael Faurot"
wrote:

I've recently come to the conclusion that my shop-vac just wasn't
doing a good enough job at dust collection. When a Harbor Freight
flyer arrived in the mail recently, I noticed that HF was putting
their 13 Gallon Industrial Portable Dust Collector[1] on sale for
about $90. So I picked up one today to use with my planer, jointer,
and anything else I could connect up.

At the store, I looked around for some 4" hose, as the ad and the
web page for the DC state "Hose sold separately". I couldn't find
any. I asked one sales person and they claimed they didn't sell any
hose of that sort. Given the wording about the hose being sold
separetly, it implied to me that it was something HF sells, but maybe
not all the sells people know about it. So I decided to ask a
different sales person--this time I got a better answer. It turns out
they don't sell just the hose, but they do sell a Dust Collector
Accessory Kit[2] for $43. This kit wasn't out on the floor, so they
had to get it from the back. If you should decide to get one of these
things, make a note of the model number (93601) and then ask someone
to get one of them for you.

The DC kit includes two 10' lengths of 4" hose that seem quite
sturdy, along with a collection of wire clamps, blast gates, etc.
I was really only interested in the hose and clamps, but figured I'd
find a use for the other goodies later on.

When I got the DC and DC Kit home, there wasn't much to put together
except the casters on the DC. I was impressed with the size of the
motor on it (1HP) and it looked to be a pretty beefy little unit. The
DC bag is made out of canvas, but it is very thick and sturdy. One
thing I immediately noticed though was the casters. In the ad/web
page it describes them as "heavy duty ball bearing casters." Not even
close--these are just those plastic sort of things you find on cheap
office chairs. No biggy there though, if they break, I'll just
replace them with some better casters.

The first thing I decided to try was using the DC with my jointer. I
fired up the DC and was pleasently surprised at how much less noise it
makes than my shop vac. I then fired up the jointer and ran a board
through a couple of times and then shut everything down. Checking the
bag of the DC there were indeed some dust in there--so it must be
working.

Next I decided to try the DC with my planer. This is where I'd really
been wanting better dust collection, because even with my shop vac
hooked to the planer, it would still spit chips all over the place.
After getting the DC connected, I ran a board through and immediately
noticed that the planer was still spitting chips. I decided to check
the DC and see if there was something wrong. At the end of the hose,
it seemed the suction wasn't very strong. I shut down the DC and then
removed the hose on the input side and immediately I noticed what the
problem was--it was clogged with chips. On the inside of the DC's
input was a plastic mesh/screen that was clogging things up, so I
decided to see if I could remove it. The input is held on with four
machine screws. After removing those, I was able to easily remove the
screen. I put the input connector back on along with the hose and
then fired up the planer again. Again, it was spitting chips at me.
This time, it turns out the output side of the DC was clogged--again
with a screen. The screen on the output was also easily removed.

With both input and output screens removed, I was now getting some
decent suction from the DC. This time, when I ran some wood through
the planer there were no chips to be seen at all. This little DC
really does a good job at getting the dust and chips away from the
cutter head on the planer.

So, with the HF DC on sale for about $90 and the added DC Kit it all
comes to about $133 (with out tax). Normally the DC goes for about
$120. If you've been wanting a small dust collector, this one seems
to do a pretty good job.


[1]: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=31810
[2]: http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...emnumber=93601


If you have room, I'd suggest making a cyclone type chip collector...
This is a picture of my monster.. lol

https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis/images/shop-dc.jpg

It will not only collect the chips and larger dust in the can, but my main
concern in your case is that if I understand correctly, you've removed the
screen that would protect your impeller from a screw or knot that the DC sucked
up...
After hearing a few things "ping" on the impeller, I made my trash can collector
quick! *g*

Mac

https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis
https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis/wood_stuff.htm
  #8   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
Han Han is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 4,297
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector

I think you need 2 things:
A cyclone in front of the dust collector to collect the big stuff.
I bought something like the Lee Valley garbage can top cyclone adapter -
works beautifully.

The other thing is the Wynn canister filter to replace the bags on th HF
machine.

I found it a pain to install the plastic bag in place of the bottom canvas
bag, but finally got it in place. With the "cyclone" adapter there is
hardly any need to change the bottom plastic bag.

This should take care of almost all collectable dust. You'll still have
stuff kicked away from the table saw and so, si I finally dispensed with
the paper masks and got a Triton Darth-Vader-type filter. Now my glasses
don't fog, and I can breathe!

--
Best regards
Han
email address is invalid
  #9   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 126
Default Review: Harbor Freight Dust Collector

mac davis wrote:

This is a picture of my monster.. lol
https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis/images/shop-dc.jpg


That is a monster.

If you have room, I'd suggest making a cyclone type chip collector...


I think that's what I'll ultimately do. I was thinking I'd just
get the garbage can cyclone lid from Grizzly[1] and a suitable sized
garbage can from the local hardware store. But maybe I'll take
another look at fabricating one myself, now that I've seen yours.

Thanks!

[1]: http://www.grizzly.com/products/G3376

--

If you want to reply via email, change the obvious words to numbers and
remove ".invalid".
Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
What is a fair price for this dust collector (used)? John Woodworking 3 September 28th 06 01:38 PM
New Dust Collector Questions Leon Woodworking 14 June 16th 06 11:05 PM
Dust collector prank... lex Woodworking 6 November 8th 05 09:06 PM
220 saw & dust collector wiring question Tom Home Repair 8 October 23rd 04 06:00 PM
How to Put 6" Duct to 1.5 HP Dust Collector? Jay Chan Woodworking 17 March 16th 04 04:11 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:35 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"