Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Metalworking (rec.crafts.metalworking) Discuss various aspects of working with metal, such as machining, welding, metal joining, screwing, casting, hardening/tempering, blacksmithing/forging, spinning and hammer work, sheet metal work. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Advice requested - make or buy? Or?
"ldg" wrote in message ... I've been lurking this group for a few weeks in hope of answering my own questions from your experience, but I'm a little to dense to solve this apparently. I need patio brackets. I hired a guy to make plans for several additions to the house, one being a tile covered patio. This patio looks simple enough on paper. it has 6 posts, with 4 being at 45 degree angles. The framing is 6x6 lumber, and there are 2 large trusses made with these large beams that span the 20 foot width. The problem is no one seems to make 45 degree brackets to hold the wood up. My carpenter found a local blacksmith who can make the brackets, but his schedule is such that I'm probably not going to get the thing done this year. My wife is upset and that, believe me, is not a good thing. Anyone have any suggestions? I did some welding about 30 years ago. I suppose I could buy an arc welder and plasma cutter, then just do the job myself. (To tell the truth this is appealing.) The problem is I'm not in the least artistic. How can I make a simple, yet decorative set of brackets? I looks at though a fairly simple jig could be made of the decorative cuts in some sort of (ceramic?) guide, then the shape could be cut out with a plasma cutter. This would leave straight welds, which I could probably handle. Am I way off base? Thanks for any help. It's ok to make fun. I deserve it by now. Anyone that would pour concrete in 45 degree corners and not research the entire patio parts list ahead of time should be made fun of. :-) From this group, I've sort of settled on the Miller 625 plasma cutter and the Miller 210 welder. The cost is still considerable less than having the brackets made. What do ya think? Regards. Larry Larry Here is another idea that you may not have thought of. That is to post your location and ask if there is anyone on this NG who would be interested in building them for you. I've also posted this on the rec.crafts.metalworking newsgroup which is another very helpful NG. Both of these NG's have some very capable people. Good luck. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"Lane" lane (no spam) at copperaccents dot com wrote in message ... "ldg" wrote in message ... I've been lurking this group for a few weeks in hope of answering my own questions from your experience, but I'm a little to dense to solve this apparently. I need patio brackets. I hired a guy to make plans for several additions to the house, one being a tile covered patio. This patio looks simple enough on paper. it has 6 posts, with 4 being at 45 degree angles. The framing is 6x6 lumber, and there are 2 large trusses made with these large beams that span the 20 foot width. The problem is no one seems to make 45 degree brackets to hold the wood up. My carpenter found a local blacksmith who can make the brackets, but his schedule is such that I'm probably not going to get the thing done this year. My wife is upset and that, believe me, is not a good thing. Anyone have any suggestions? I did some welding about 30 years ago. I suppose I could buy an arc welder and plasma cutter, then just do the job myself. (To tell the truth this is appealing.) The problem is I'm not in the least artistic. How can I make a simple, yet decorative set of brackets? I looks at though a fairly simple jig could be made of the decorative cuts in some sort of (ceramic?) guide, then the shape could be cut out with a plasma cutter. This would leave straight welds, which I could probably handle. Am I way off base? Thanks for any help. It's ok to make fun. I deserve it by now. Anyone that would pour concrete in 45 degree corners and not research the entire patio parts list ahead of time should be made fun of. :-) From this group, I've sort of settled on the Miller 625 plasma cutter and the Miller 210 welder. The cost is still considerable less than having the brackets made. What do ya think? Regards. Larry Larry Here is another idea that you may not have thought of. That is to post your location and ask if there is anyone on this NG who would be interested in building them for you. I've also posted this on the rec.crafts.metalworking newsgroup which is another very helpful NG. Both of these NG's have some very capable people. Good luck. This was originally posted to the sci.engr.joining.welding newsgroup.\ I posted it here for the original poster. Lane |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
"ldg" wrote in message
... On Sun, 22 May 2005 20:04:09 -0700, "Lane" lane (no spam) at copperaccents dot com wrote: "ldg" wrote in message . .. I've been lurking this group for a few weeks in hope of answering my own questions from your experience, but I'm a little to dense to solve this apparently. I need patio brackets. I hired a guy to make plans for several additions to the house, one being a tile covered patio. This patio looks simple enough on paper. it has 6 posts, with 4 being at 45 degree angles. The framing is 6x6 lumber, and there are 2 large trusses made with these large beams that span the 20 foot width. The problem is no one seems to make 45 degree brackets to hold the wood up. My carpenter found a local blacksmith who can make the brackets, but his schedule is such that I'm probably not going to get the thing done this year. My wife is upset and that, believe me, is not a good thing. Anyone have any suggestions? I did some welding about 30 years ago. I suppose I could buy an arc welder and plasma cutter, then just do the job myself. (To tell the truth this is appealing.) The problem is I'm not in the least artistic. How can I make a simple, yet decorative set of brackets? I looks at though a fairly simple jig could be made of the decorative cuts in some sort of (ceramic?) guide, then the shape could be cut out with a plasma cutter. This would leave straight welds, which I could probably handle. Am I way off base? Thanks for any help. It's ok to make fun. I deserve it by now. Anyone that would pour concrete in 45 degree corners and not research the entire patio parts list ahead of time should be made fun of. :-) From this group, I've sort of settled on the Miller 625 plasma cutter and the Miller 210 welder. The cost is still considerable less than having the brackets made. What do ya think? Regards. Larry Larry Here is another idea that you may not have thought of. That is to post your location and ask if there is anyone on this NG who would be interested in building them for you. I've also posted this on the rec.crafts.metalworking newsgroup which is another very helpful NG. Both of these NG's have some very capable people. Good luck. Thanks for the help! This is great! Regards, Larry Where are you located Larry? |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"ldg" wrote in message ... I've been lurking this group for a few weeks in hope of answering my own questions from your experience, but I'm a little to dense to solve this apparently. I need patio brackets. I hired a guy to make plans for several additions to the house, one being a tile covered patio. This patio looks simple enough on paper. it has 6 posts, with 4 being at 45 degree angles. The framing is 6x6 lumber, and there are 2 large trusses made with these large beams that span the 20 foot width. The problem is no one seems to make 45 degree brackets to hold the wood up. My carpenter found a local blacksmith who can make the brackets, but his schedule is such that I'm probably not going to get the thing done this year. My wife is upset and that, believe me, is not a good thing. Anyone have any suggestions? I did some welding about 30 years ago. I suppose I could buy an arc welder and plasma cutter, then just do the job myself. (To tell the truth this is appealing.) The problem is I'm not in the least artistic. How can I make a simple, yet decorative set of brackets? I looks at though a fairly simple jig could be made of the decorative cuts in some sort of (ceramic?) guide, then the shape could be cut out with a plasma cutter. This would leave straight welds, which I could probably handle. Am I way off base? Thanks for any help. It's ok to make fun. I deserve it by now. Anyone that would pour concrete in 45 degree corners and not research the entire patio parts list ahead of time should be made fun of. :-) From this group, I've sort of settled on the Miller 625 plasma cutter and the Miller 210 welder. The cost is still considerable less than having the brackets made. What do ya think? Regards. Larry From 1980 to 1993, I did ornamental metal and then progressed into steel erection. I sold my business in 1993, and went and did some stints in the Gulf of Mexico and overseas. Fast forward to 2003. New wife. New situation. Wife says she wants to get some security doors made for our new add on. 96" wide and 79" high. Two doors. Some decorative castings. She said she paid $1600 each for the other two already on the house. I said, hell, I could buy a welder, and do them, and then own the welder for all sorts of other ornamental metal projects, and just do them for material costs. So, I now have another shop with welding equipment, and I have made two double security doors, one 28' wide by 7' high double gate for our motorhome, about 30' of 7' high fencing with backing, and countless other small projects that would have cost quite a bit. If you are going to do much work, get the equipment, and do it yourself. You get it when you want it. You get it how you want it. If you don't like it, you buy some more material and do it again. The price is always right. Many benefits from doing it yourself, price being the biggest. I have not spent as much on tooling up as I would have spent on getting those things built, and I still own all that equipment. If I wanted to, I could sell it, and that would be another plus. Don't overthink the thing. Most metalwork is Gawd awful strong compared to what is needed, and if you have any engineering smarts at all, there is no problem in building things that will hold the weight and last. Problem is, when people find out you do it, they bug you to do work for them. Practice your welding, and take some refresher courses to build up your skill level. People bitch about the price of steel, but compared to what a contractor wants for a project, that steel cost starts looking REALLY cheap. But, then, I think you are already seeing that. Plus, if you can build this stuff and save lots of money, your wife treats you better, and the dogs even like you more. Steve |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Lane wrote:
"ldg" wrote in message ... I've been lurking this group for a few weeks in hope of answering my own questions from your experience, but I'm a little to dense to solve this apparently. I need patio brackets. I hired a guy to make plans for several additions to the house, one being a tile covered patio. This patio looks simple enough on paper. it has 6 posts, with 4 being at 45 degree angles. The framing is 6x6 lumber, and there are 2 large trusses made with these large beams that span the 20 foot width. The problem is no one seems to make 45 degree brackets to hold the wood up. My carpenter found a local blacksmith who can make the brackets, but his schedule is such that I'm probably not going to get the thing done this year. My wife is upset and that, believe me, is not a good thing. Anyone have any suggestions? I did some welding about 30 years ago. I suppose I could buy an arc welder and plasma cutter, then just do the job myself. (To tell the truth this is appealing.) The problem is I'm not in the least artistic. How can I make a simple, yet decorative set of brackets? I looks at though a fairly simple jig could be made of the decorative cuts in some sort of (ceramic?) guide, then the shape could be cut out with a plasma cutter. This would leave straight welds, which I could probably handle. Am I way off base? Thanks for any help. It's ok to make fun. I deserve it by now. Anyone that would pour concrete in 45 degree corners and not research the entire patio parts list ahead of time should be made fun of. :-) From this group, I've sort of settled on the Miller 625 plasma cutter and the Miller 210 welder. The cost is still considerable less than having the brackets made. What do ya think? Regards. Larry Take a look at this website http://www.strongtie.com/ Simpson makes many types of beam hangers, some set at 45deg and some adjustable. You can probably find what you want here. Gary Brady Austin, Tx |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Start with the Simpson catalog. If they don't have one, then you're looking
at custom steel fabrication. If you can do it, do it. Else you're going to wind up asking contractors who they use, and farming it out. It isn't so much the cost as the delay, those guys can have delays of several weeks. I live in the Seattle area and do this kind of work for some builders, owning an ironworker and welder and having the requisite skills. I find that my work is well valued. The commercial vendor in this area is Allied Steel Fabricators in Redmond, Washington. But you probably don't live here. - GWE Gary Brady wrote: Lane wrote: "ldg" wrote in message ... I've been lurking this group for a few weeks in hope of answering my own questions from your experience, but I'm a little to dense to solve this apparently. I need patio brackets. I hired a guy to make plans for several additions to the house, one being a tile covered patio. This patio looks simple enough on paper. it has 6 posts, with 4 being at 45 degree angles. The framing is 6x6 lumber, and there are 2 large trusses made with these large beams that span the 20 foot width. The problem is no one seems to make 45 degree brackets to hold the wood up. My carpenter found a local blacksmith who can make the brackets, but his schedule is such that I'm probably not going to get the thing done this year. My wife is upset and that, believe me, is not a good thing. Anyone have any suggestions? I did some welding about 30 years ago. I suppose I could buy an arc welder and plasma cutter, then just do the job myself. (To tell the truth this is appealing.) The problem is I'm not in the least artistic. How can I make a simple, yet decorative set of brackets? I looks at though a fairly simple jig could be made of the decorative cuts in some sort of (ceramic?) guide, then the shape could be cut out with a plasma cutter. This would leave straight welds, which I could probably handle. Am I way off base? Thanks for any help. It's ok to make fun. I deserve it by now. Anyone that would pour concrete in 45 degree corners and not research the entire patio parts list ahead of time should be made fun of. :-) From this group, I've sort of settled on the Miller 625 plasma cutter and the Miller 210 welder. The cost is still considerable less than having the brackets made. What do ya think? Regards. Larry Take a look at this website http://www.strongtie.com/ Simpson makes many types of beam hangers, some set at 45deg and some adjustable. You can probably find what you want here. Gary Brady Austin, Tx |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Take a look at this website http://www.strongtie.com/ Simpson makes many types of beam hangers, some set at 45deg and some adjustable. You can probably find what you want here. Gary Brady Austin, Tx Thanks Gary, We've already talked to a commercial shop like this that makes most of the brackets sold in this area (San Diego). Their bid for 6 simple brackets was about $2500. I need 40. The truss brackets will look something like this: http://www.strongtie.com/products/co...USTOM_APG.html but I'd imagine a blacksmith would cut a simple design on the ends. These brackets will be way up high and no one will notice them, so it's not all that necessary. These are custom brackets on the strongtie web site, so they'll be expensive. The most difficult area are the 45 degree angles: http://www.strongtie.com/products/connectors/A-Z.html If you look at the AA45 brackets in the picture, then imagine the top cross beam being spit into two beams coming in at an angle (22.5) so the total is 45 degrees. You could build a bracket on an angle similar to the AA45 with a top plate at 45 with vertical bolts holding things together. The bottom angle could have wrought iron or something decorative since it will be a little above eye level. Another approach would be to do something like this: http://www.strongtie.com/products/co.../CCPC_APG.html with a 45 degree channel on the top. Wouldn't be pretty, but it would hold the wood in place. Another consideration is that I live on a hill that gets really high winds occasionally. Some years the wind gets so strong it pulls trees out of the ground by the roots. This is the reason for the 6x6 framing. The tile roof will also add weight. These brackets need to do their part as well. Regards, Larry |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
That bid isn't ridiculous. It simply needs to be interpreted correctly.
It says very clearly "I DON'T WANT THIS WORK UNLESS YOU ARE ****ING DESPERATE". I can make these for you and ship them to San Diego if you want. Email me off list if you're interested. To do so, please note that my 'reply-to' address is completely bogus in every way and it is not possible to infer my actual address from it. Please visit http://www.tinyisland.com/email.html to email me. Grant Erwin Kirkland, Washington ldg wrote: We've already talked to a commercial shop like this that makes most of the brackets sold in this area (San Diego). Their bid for 6 simple brackets was about $2500. I need 40. The truss brackets will look something like this: http://www.strongtie.com/products/co...USTOM_APG.html but I'd imagine a blacksmith would cut a simple design on the ends. These brackets will be way up high and no one will notice them, so it's not all that necessary. These are custom brackets on the strongtie web site, so they'll be expensive. The most difficult area are the 45 degree angles: http://www.strongtie.com/products/connectors/A-Z.html If you look at the AA45 brackets in the picture, then imagine the top cross beam being spit into two beams coming in at an angle (22.5) so the total is 45 degrees. You could build a bracket on an angle similar to the AA45 with a top plate at 45 with vertical bolts holding things together. The bottom angle could have wrought iron or something decorative since it will be a little above eye level. Another approach would be to do something like this: http://www.strongtie.com/products/co.../CCPC_APG.html with a 45 degree channel on the top. Wouldn't be pretty, but it would hold the wood in place. Another consideration is that I live on a hill that gets really high winds occasionally. Some years the wind gets so strong it pulls trees out of the ground by the roots. This is the reason for the 6x6 framing. The tile roof will also add weight. These brackets need to do their part as well. Regards, Larry |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
"Grant Erwin" wrote in message ... That bid isn't ridiculous. It simply needs to be interpreted correctly. It says very clearly "I DON'T WANT THIS WORK UNLESS YOU ARE ****ING DESPERATE". I can make these for you and ship them to San Diego if you want. Email me off list if you're interested. To do so, please note that my 'reply-to' address is completely bogus in every way and it is not possible to infer my actual address from it. Please visit http://www.tinyisland.com/email.html to email me. Grant Erwin Kirkland, Washington Larry, Just in case you need it, I can verify that Grant does this, as I've helped him load some custom made brackets into a contractors van one day when he hosted a local groups meeting. Grant is the real deal, and he'll treat you right. Lane |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
ldg wrote:
Take a look at this website http://www.strongtie.com/ Simpson makes many types of beam hangers, some set at 45deg and some adjustable. You can probably find what you want here. Gary Brady Austin, Tx Thanks Gary, We've already talked to a commercial shop like this that makes most of the brackets sold in this area (San Diego). Their bid for 6 simple brackets was about $2500. I need 40. Geez, maybe I need to move back out to San Diego.. John |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
If they are just flat steel plate cut to a shape similar to the one shown
at http://www.strongtie.com/products/co...USTOM_APG.html then just draw up what you want on a CAD program and find a local laser cutter to cut them from flat mild steel. If you supply them a DXF drawing, they don't have to do much except tut it on the machine and invoice you. This keeps costs down quite well. Laser cutting is fast and cheap and has more than enough accuracy for your application. If you can't draw it your self, or get it done locally, draw it on paper with dimensions,scan it, and email it to me and I'll email you a DXF format drawing at no charge. Tom "Lane" lane (no spam) at copperaccents dot com wrote in message ... "ldg" wrote in message ... I've been lurking this group for a few weeks in hope of answering my own questions from your experience, but I'm a little to dense to solve this apparently. I need patio brackets. I hired a guy to make plans for several additions to the house, one being a tile covered patio. This patio looks simple enough on paper. it has 6 posts, with 4 being at 45 degree angles. The framing is 6x6 lumber, and there are 2 large trusses made with these large beams that span the 20 foot width. The problem is no one seems to make 45 degree brackets to hold the wood up. My carpenter found a local blacksmith who can make the brackets, but his schedule is such that I'm probably not going to get the thing done this year. My wife is upset and that, believe me, is not a good thing. Anyone have any suggestions? I did some welding about 30 years ago. I suppose I could buy an arc welder and plasma cutter, then just do the job myself. (To tell the truth this is appealing.) The problem is I'm not in the least artistic. How can I make a simple, yet decorative set of brackets? I looks at though a fairly simple jig could be made of the decorative cuts in some sort of (ceramic?) guide, then the shape could be cut out with a plasma cutter. This would leave straight welds, which I could probably handle. Am I way off base? Thanks for any help. It's ok to make fun. I deserve it by now. Anyone that would pour concrete in 45 degree corners and not research the entire patio parts list ahead of time should be made fun of. :-) From this group, I've sort of settled on the Miller 625 plasma cutter and the Miller 210 welder. The cost is still considerable less than having the brackets made. What do ya think? Regards. Larry Larry Here is another idea that you may not have thought of. That is to post your location and ask if there is anyone on this NG who would be interested in building them for you. I've also posted this on the rec.crafts.metalworking newsgroup which is another very helpful NG. Both of these NG's have some very capable people. Good luck. |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
ldg wrote:
Their bid for 6 simple brackets was about $2500. I need 40. The truss brackets will look something like this: http://www.strongtie.com/products/co...USTOM_APG.html Oh my Good! I will make all 40 for that price and even send them to you free (from Germany that is). Are they nuts? Nick -- WDR Fernsehen: "Ein Computer arbeitet so lange Befehle ab, bis keine mehr vorhanden sind." Muss ich die dann irgendwie nachfüllen? |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
ldg wrote:
Thanks Gary, We've already talked to a commercial shop like this that makes most of the brackets sold in this area (San Diego). Their bid for 6 simple brackets was about $2500. I need 40. The truss brackets will look something like this: http://www.strongtie.com/products/co...USTOM_APG.html You know, there is an outfit here called Trueform Metalservice that made some brackets similar to this for a friend of mine a few years ago, and I was shocked at how cheap they were. This business has some sort of CNC cutting and forming equipment that apparently requires no hands on labor. I believe a CAD drawing is required, though. Surely there's a shop around San Diego that has similar equipment. Or if you want to shop cross country, I could find you their phone number. Gary Brady Austin, TX |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 23 May 2005 02:45:28 -0400, the inscrutable JohnM
spake: ldg wrote: Take a look at this website http://www.strongtie.com/ Simpson makes many types of beam hangers, some set at 45deg and some adjustable. You can probably find what you want here. Gary Brady Austin, Tx Thanks Gary, We've already talked to a commercial shop like this that makes most of the brackets sold in this area (San Diego). Their bid for 6 simple brackets was about $2500. I need 40. Geez, maybe I need to move back out to San Diego.. A friend of mine lives in Olivenhain. He sent a flyer for lots (bare, untouched land) in Rancho Santa Fe. They're going for a cool $2.5 million. Check your email for a copy, then reconsider. - The only reason I would take up exercising is || http://diversify.com so that I could hear heavy breathing again. || Programmed Websites |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 23 May 2005 12:06:52 GMT, Gary Brady
wrote: ldg wrote: Thanks Gary, We've already talked to a commercial shop like this that makes most of the brackets sold in this area (San Diego). Their bid for 6 simple brackets was about $2500. I need 40. The truss brackets will look something like this: http://www.strongtie.com/products/co...USTOM_APG.html You know, there is an outfit here called Trueform Metalservice that made some brackets similar to this for a friend of mine a few years ago, and I was shocked at how cheap they were. This business has some sort of CNC cutting and forming equipment that apparently requires no hands on labor. I believe a CAD drawing is required, though. Surely there's a shop around San Diego that has similar equipment. Or if you want to shop cross country, I could find you their phone number. Gary Brady Austin, TX Ive got a waterjet cutting company that might give you a Gunner Discount if need be. California. Gunner "Considering the events of recent years, the world has a long way to go to regain its credibility and reputation with the US." unknown |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
"JohnM" wrote Geez, maybe I need to move back out to San Diego.. John Consider that for a moment ............. HIGH Property taxes HIGH Sales taxes HIGH Corporate taxes HIGH Employee taxes HIGH Industrial insurance rates HIGH EVERYTHING. This poor schmuck was probably making a buck fifty after paying all the overhead. You say, "back" to San Diego. Remember how it was? It's far worse now. A friend of mine is a roofing contractor. He pays $1.93 industrial insurance for every $1 of wages. Steve |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 23 May 2005 17:35:34 +1000, "Tom Miller"
wrote: If they are just flat steel plate cut to a shape similar to the one shown at http://www.strongtie.com/products/co...USTOM_APG.html then just draw up what you want on a CAD program and find a local laser cutter to cut them from flat mild steel. If you supply them a DXF drawing, they don't have to do much except tut it on the machine and invoice you. This keeps costs down quite well. Laser cutting is fast and cheap and has more than enough accuracy for your application. If you can't draw it your self, or get it done locally, draw it on paper with dimensions,scan it, and email it to me and I'll email you a DXF format drawing at no charge. This is a great idea. If I could find a source for Corel or Autocad compatible metal decoration, I could draw decorative tails on the brackets - the laser could care less. Just thinking out loud. Regards, Larry |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
MAKE YOUR OWN MONEY | Home Ownership | |||
how to make big money fast | Home Ownership | |||
OT Guns more Guns | Metalworking | |||
make millions from home | Home Ownership |