Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located
in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
On Jan 27, 11:29 am, "Mike" wrote: Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike I imagine you are probably going to end up with an electric furnace with a heat pump. As far as I know this is about as efficient as you can get using electric. But bear in mind the cost of this is going to be thousands of dollars It could be a while before you hit break even on your energy bills. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Hi Mike,
Since you currently have electric baseboard heat and therefore I take it no existing ductwork, I would highly recommend a ductless heat pump (a multi-zone model most likely). A ductless heat pump can be installed very easily and without any disruption to your living space -- no cutting of walls and floors, no loss of interior or closet space, no re-drywalling, no repainting and no construction dust. A high efficiency ductless heat pump can cut your space heating costs by 70 per cent and your cooling costs in half. It will improve the outward appearance and security of your home; i.e., no unsightly window air conditioners that can leave you venerable to break-ins. They're also incredibly quiet. I've been speaking with someone in another newsgroup who lives in Montréal, a city much colder than your own. He tells me that even at -1F, his ductless heat pump can still heat his entire home and at half the cost of resistance heat. He has a Fujitsu model 24RL. You can obtain more information on this product he http://www.fujitsugeneral.com/PDF_06...6_brochure.pdf I have oil-fired hot water baseboard heating and a year and a half ago I installed a small Friedrich ductless heat pump (it's a rebranded Fujitsu). It has cut my heating costs by more than half. This is a picture of the inside air handler, which is located in my living room: http://server4.pictiger.com/img/2640.../heat-pump.php You can view the Friedrich line he http://www.friedrich.com/pdf/Ductles...s_Brochure.pdf The Mitsubishi "Mr. Slim" is another popular choice and you can learn more about their offerings he http://www.mrslim.com/UploadedFiles/..._final_9-8.pdf I had read BGE will be increasing their residential utility rates by a whopping 72 per cent! With that in mind, I would recommend a heat pump with a high SEER and HSPF rating -- preferably a SEER in the range of 16 to 20 and a HSPF of at least 8.0 and, better yet, 9 or 10. You'll pay a little more upfront, but a heat pump with a high HSPF produces far more heat in sub-freezing weather and at a much lower operating cost. Cheers, Paul On Sat, 27 Jan 2007 16:29:44 GMT, "Mike" wrote: Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike |
#4
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Mike" wrote in message news:Y5Luh.315$Hb6.2@trndny02... Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike Depending on your local utility rates, you might want to install Heat Pumps. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
wrote in message ups.com... On Jan 27, 11:29 am, "Mike" wrote: Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike I imagine you are probably going to end up with an electric furnace with a heat pump. As far as I know this is about as efficient as you can get using electric. But bear in mind the cost of this is going to be thousands of dollars It could be a while before you hit break even on your energy bills. I've got a gas stove and water heater. How can I convert BTU/therms to kw so I can compare costs? |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Paul M. Eldridge" wrote in message ... Hi Mike, Since you currently have electric baseboard heat and therefore I take it no existing ductwork, I would highly recommend a ductless heat pump (a multi-zone model most likely). A ductless heat pump can be installed very easily and without any disruption to your living space -- no cutting of walls and floors, no loss of interior or closet space, no re-drywalling, no repainting and no construction dust. A high efficiency ductless heat pump can cut your space heating costs by 70 per cent and your cooling costs in half. It will improve the outward appearance and security of your home; i.e., no unsightly window air conditioners that can leave you venerable to break-ins. They're also incredibly quiet. I've been speaking with someone in another newsgroup who lives in Montréal, a city much colder than your own. He tells me that even at -1F, his ductless heat pump can still heat his entire home and at half the cost of resistance heat. He has a Fujitsu model 24RL. You can obtain more information on this product he http://www.fujitsugeneral.com/PDF_06...6_brochure.pdf I have oil-fired hot water baseboard heating and a year and a half ago I installed a small Friedrich ductless heat pump (it's a rebranded Fujitsu). It has cut my heating costs by more than half. This is a picture of the inside air handler, which is located in my living room: http://server4.pictiger.com/img/2640.../heat-pump.php You can view the Friedrich line he http://www.friedrich.com/pdf/Ductles...s_Brochure.pdf The Mitsubishi "Mr. Slim" is another popular choice and you can learn more about their offerings he http://www.mrslim.com/UploadedFiles/..._final_9-8.pdf I had read BGE will be increasing their residential utility rates by a whopping 72 per cent! With that in mind, I would recommend a heat pump with a high SEER and HSPF rating -- preferably a SEER in the range of 16 to 20 and a HSPF of at least 8.0 and, better yet, 9 or 10. You'll pay a little more upfront, but a heat pump with a high HSPF produces far more heat in sub-freezing weather and at a much lower operating cost. Cheers, Paul On Sat, 27 Jan 2007 16:29:44 GMT, "Mike" wrote: Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike Hi Paul, thanks for the useful information. I'll check out each link. BGE rates going up - I suspect the "delivery charge" will be going up too. Nobody has ever saved money using deregulated gas or electric. What a major rip off. Mike |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Hi Mike,
There are 100,000 BTUs per therm of natural gas, or the equivalent of 29.3 kWh of electric heat. A mid efficiency furnace operating at 80 per cent efficiency will provide you with 23.4 kWh of heat per therm (the other 5.9 kWh being lost up the chimney). A high efficiency furnace with a 90 per cent efficiency rating would give you 26.4 kWh/therm and at the very top end of the scale you might achieve upwards of 28 kWh/therm. It looks like BGE is currently charging residential customers $1.30 per therm (commodity and delivery prices combined). At 80 per cent conversion efficiency, each kWh of gas heat costs you roughly 5.5 cents and at 90 per cent efficiency, that cost falls to 4.9 cents per kWh(e). I believe BGE's winter electric rate now stands at 12.73 cents per kWh. A high efficiency heat pump with a seasonal COP of between 2.5 and 3.0 (not an unreasonable number given your relatively moderate winters), would produce heat in the range of 4.2 to 5.1 cents per kWh(e). One of the Fujitsu ductless heat pumps has a HSPF of 11.0, which puts its seasonal COP at just over 3.2. That effectively reduces the cost of electric heat to just 3.9 cents per kWh(e), or some twenty per cent below that of a high efficiency gas furnace operating at 90 per cent efficiency. One of the nice things about a ductless heat pump is that you can simply leave your electric baseboard heaters in place, so there's no need to rip them out, re-plaster your walls and repaint your rooms. This also provides you with backup emergency heat should your heat pump require servicing. Cheers, Paul On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 01:22:31 GMT, "Mike" wrote: I've got a gas stove and water heater. How can I convert BTU/therms to kw so I can compare costs? |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Hi Mike,
You're welcome. Domestic natural gas production peaked back in 1973. I believe current U.S. demand is somewhere around 22 trillion cubic feet per year, twenty per cent of which is imported from outside sources. As domestic production continues to fall and as demand continues to rise, this ever-widening gap will be made up through additional imports. That puts the U.S. in an unenviable position both economically and politically speaking, and in terms of its national security. See where I'm going here? Your best course of action is to aggressively reduce your home's energy demands through generous insulation and careful air sealing. That should be your number one priority. Once you've done everything you can on that front, investigate your heating options and choose the one likely to offer the lowest long-term operating costs and the greatest security of supply. I don't know much about BGE's fuel mix but I seem to recall it's heavily weighted towards nuclear and coal, both domestic sources. As it stands now, a high efficiency heat pump can provide heat at less than one-third the cost of your current heating system and even below that of a high efficiency gas furnace. Over the long term, I tend to believe it's one of your best choices. Cheers, Paul On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 01:26:42 GMT, "Mike" wrote: Hi Paul, thanks for the useful information. I'll check out each link. BGE rates going up - I suspect the "delivery charge" will be going up too. Nobody has ever saved money using deregulated gas or electric. What a major rip off. Mike |
#9
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Mike" wrote in message news:Y5Luh.315$Hb6.2@trndny02... Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike Depending on your local utility rates, you might want to install Heat Pumps. He's in Baltimore. http://www.usepropane.com/esc/ -- |
#10
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Mike" wrote in message news:Y5Luh.315$Hb6.2@trndny02... Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike Depending on your local utility rates, you might want to install Heat Pumps. He's in Baltimore. http://www.usepropane.com/esc/ But the real question is, what is his utility rates? |
#11
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Mike" wrote in message news:Y5Luh.315$Hb6.2@trndny02... Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike Depending on your local utility rates, you might want to install Heat Pumps. He's in Baltimore. http://www.usepropane.com/esc/ But the real question is, what is his utility rates? He has to enter that ( kwh ) for himself....varies considerably depending on your location...pretty sure IM at $.058/ kwh last I checked--"cheap hydro"... Anyways, run the program twice, first using baseboard heat then run through it a second time using heat pump.... Actual value entered for propane isnt important, ( unless someone is using, or considereing converting to it)...but suggest just use same cost / gal value both times... === IIRC my brother is getting nailed at 3 ~bux /gallon--Seattle,Wa area.--understandably, I've disabled the gas portion of his furnace just recently... Still need to log further info, but appears after a couple weeks worth of "intelligent adaptive recovery" and what with his night temps being ~ 25 and with 45 daytime told me yesterday he might occasionally fall short by a couple degrees tops at the morning recovery period--so guessing at least someone actually did an accurate heat load analysis upon initial install. Like I say, outdoors reset stat is to be permanently installed soon--which brings out the big guns only on as-needed basis. === FWIW, still think the Taystat 103 is a sucky system--esp where total lockout occurs--but still is absolutely needed where you have HP coils downstream in the airflow from the gas HX. Not rocket science, still will probly eventually put up a link to the schemtic with crossed out connections etc. Meanwhile, Joseph and Pat can also more than likely assist if you happen to find yourself with a customer that's wanting to ramp down on gas usage, perhaps with the attendant addition / installation of of larger capacity heat pump system. IIRC, your in the corn belt--then if so pay close attention to a/c mode...dehumidifican problems and short cycling definately can be a problem where yuo have oversized a heat pump for to deal primarily with the heating load. -- |
#12
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Mike" wrote in message news:Y5Luh.315$Hb6.2@trndny02... Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike Depending on your local utility rates, you might want to install Heat Pumps. He's in Baltimore. http://www.usepropane.com/esc/ But the real question is, what is his utility rates? He has to enter that ( kwh ) for himself....varies considerably depending on your location...pretty sure IM at $.058/ kwh last I checked--"cheap hydro"... True... 6 cents/kwh is pretty darn cheap! IIRC my brother is getting nailed at 3 ~bux /gallon--Seattle,Wa OooooOoooooOooooooUCH!!!!!!!! IIRC, your in the corn belt--then if so pay close attention to a/c mode...dehumidifican problems and short cycling definately can be a problem where yuo have oversized a heat pump for to deal primarily with the heating load. That's why one should size for the cooling system. :-) |
#13
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Mike" wrote in message news:Y5Luh.315$Hb6.2@trndny02... Hi, I live in a 70 y/o EOG rowhouse with southern & western exposure located in Baltimore, MD. The house has electric baseboard heating and window air conditioners. Utilities were recently deregulated and I believe I need to install a more efficient heating unit. Might as well install central air at the same time. I understand there are new high efficiency units that can save a bundle in utility costs but they need to installed by a crew that's trained to install them otherwise the are less effcient than the other systems. Recommendations for HVAC companies are also needed. Any recommendations for highly effcient replacement windows at a resonalble cost? (will chck consumers union website) Thanks, Mike Depending on your local utility rates, you might want to install Heat Pumps. He's in Baltimore. http://www.usepropane.com/esc/ But the real question is, what is his utility rates? He has to enter that ( kwh ) for himself....varies considerably depending on your location...pretty sure IM at $.058/ kwh last I checked--"cheap hydro"... True... 6 cents/kwh is pretty darn cheap! IIRC my brother is getting nailed at 3 ~bux /gallon--Seattle,Wa OooooOoooooOooooooUCH!!!!!!!! IIRC, your in the corn belt--then if so pay close attention to a/c mode...dehumidifican problems and short cycling definately can be a problem where yuo have oversized a heat pump for to deal primarily with the heating load. That's why one should size for the cooling system. :-) Apparently, cost structure was more favorable towards propane near to a decade ago--when the sys was initially installed....main benefit to having the heat pump being the luxury of having cooling... Still makes no sense--if the gas is cheaper then just kill the HP on heating altogheter. Diferent situation in the machine shop here though, I have tools that actually produce a significant heat load--nice during winter but becomes a burden during summertime. --- |
#14
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... Apparently, cost structure was more favorable towards propane near to a decade ago--when the sys was initially installed....main benefit to having the heat pump being the luxury of having cooling... Still makes no sense--if the gas is cheaper then just kill the HP on heating altogheter. LP and Nat used to be cheap fuels. But as time goes by, they continue to rise dramatically while the electric costs have had slight increases. With new product designs and affiances, today a heat pump can often save you a significantly large amount of money in operational costs. I have designed a spreadsheet to show my clients how much they can save (or spend) with varying heat sources. They don't understand it, till they see the actual numbers. Many people are switching to corn burners. But with the evolution of ethanol being used for automotive purposes, the costs of corn is increasing. So this only raises their heating bills. Making the heat pump look better once again. One thing is constant, and that is, that things are always changing. Something that is effective today may not be tomorrow. |
#15
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... Apparently, cost structure was more favorable towards propane near to a decade ago--when the sys was initially installed....main benefit to having the heat pump being the luxury of having cooling... Still makes no sense--if the gas is cheaper then just kill the HP on heating altogheter. LP and Nat used to be cheap fuels. But as time goes by, they continue to rise dramatically while the electric costs have had slight increases. With new product designs and affiances, today a heat pump can often save you a significantly large amount of money in operational costs. I woud kil the crossposteing but im too drunkat present....besides, the topic at least fits. Ya want cheep then go geothermal, closed or even open loop--here we have well-water-a- plenty- Cmes outa the ground at ~51 deg F--I just pump and dump.....over onto the freeway right-of-way it goes. I have designed a spreadsheet to show my clients how much they can save (or spend) with varying heat sources. They don't understand it, till they see the actual numbers. Then if it sells, great....so long as it saves long-term. Many people are switching to corn burners. But with the evolution of ethanol being used for automotive purposes, the costs of corn is increasing. So this only raises their heating bills. Making the heat pump look better once again. Yes, esp here where electric rates have remained fairly stable. One thing is constant, and that is, that things are always changing. Something that is effective today may not be tomorrow. Well the one thing that is constant--if you burning any hydrocarbon fuel then it depletes fossil reserves, as well as contributing to escalation of co co2 into the atmosphere. Suggest then plant some trees--it's the only thing available to Joe Sixpak that effectively re-sequesters the carbon by-products back into the soil. -- |
#16
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
kjpro @ usenet.com wrote in message ... "Jeffrey Lebowski" wrote in message ... Apparently, cost structure was more favorable towards propane near to a decade ago--when the sys was initially installed....main benefit to having the heat pump being the luxury of having cooling... Still makes no sense--if the gas is cheaper then just kill the HP on heating altogheter. LP and Nat used to be cheap fuels. But as time goes by, they continue to rise dramatically while the electric costs have had slight increases. With new product designs and affiances, today a heat pump can often save you a significantly large amount of money in operational costs. I have designed a spreadsheet to show my clients how much they can save (or spend) with varying heat sources. They don't understand it, till they see the actual numbers. Many people are switching to corn burners. But with the evolution of ethanol being used for automotive purposes, the costs of corn is increasing. So this only raises their heating bills. Making the heat pump look better once again. One thing is constant, and that is, that things are always changing. Something that is effective today may not be tomorrow. You bring up good ponts. Can I get a copy of your spreadsheet? |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Paul M. Eldridge" wrote in message ... Hi Mike, You're welcome. Domestic natural gas production peaked back in 1973. I believe current U.S. demand is somewhere around 22 trillion cubic feet per year, twenty per cent of which is imported from outside sources. As domestic production continues to fall and as demand continues to rise, this ever-widening gap will be made up through additional imports. That puts the U.S. in an unenviable position both economically and politically speaking, and in terms of its national security. See where I'm going here? Your best course of action is to aggressively reduce your home's energy demands through generous insulation and careful air sealing. That should be your number one priority. Once you've done everything you can on that front, investigate your heating options and choose the one likely to offer the lowest long-term operating costs and the greatest security of supply. I don't know much about BGE's fuel mix but I seem to recall it's heavily weighted towards nuclear and coal, both domestic sources. As it stands now, a high efficiency heat pump can provide heat at less than one-third the cost of your current heating system and even below that of a high efficiency gas furnace. Over the long term, I tend to believe it's one of your best choices. Cheers, Paul Paul, BGE energy production comes from nuclear and coal and just enough natural gas so the can use the cost of natural gas for ALL of the cost to produce energy. All energy produces do this and it's legal. Insulating and HP seems to be the way to go. Tomorrow I'll print out the descriptions of the heat pumps. It is appealing to leave the baseboard electric heaters in place and add the heat pump. Mike |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
As you probably know, LP is derived from either oil or natural gas and
its price thus closely follows these other two fuels. And since the U.S. is a net importer of oil and gas and since the gap between supply and demand continues to grow wider day by day, its price is likely to become increasingly volatile over time, with the long-term trend pointing upward. Also worth noting you'll be competing (should I say fighting?) with the rest of the world for these resources as they become increasingly more scarce. Electricity prices are likely to remain more stable over the long term, as a good portion is generated by way of coal and nuclear (both domestic resources) and therefore not subject to the same external market forces. Plus electricity can capitalize on a growing portfolio of renewable resources such as wind, small hydro, geothermal, solar, etc., that generally have very low operating costs and, thankfully, much more modest environmental impact. This will further add to the diversity in supply and perhaps help dampen price pressures on other competing fuels. I don't want to suggest everyone race out to their local home improvement store and buy armfuls of electric baseboard heaters; that would be insane. However, when it comes time to evaluate your heating options, I hope a geothermal or air source heat pump will be added to the list. As previously noted, a high efficiency heat pump can produce three times more heat, per kWh, than an electric baseboard heater, even in cold, northern climates. I can buy a ductless heat pump today with a 21 SEER rating and a HSPF of 11.0 -- that's double the efficiency of many heat pumps now in service. And the good news is that the Japanese are working hard to advance that bar even higher, which begs the question: where's America's leadership in this area? Looking at it another way, if I were to switch from electric baseboard heat to a high efficiency heat pump, electricity prices could double or triple and I would still pay less per month than what I do now. That's precisely the long-term price protection a high efficiency heat pump can offer me today. As always, do whatever you can to lower your heating and cooling requirements through generous insulation and careful air sealing. Then, and only then, take a look at some of the alternative heating systems that have the potential to dramatically lower your monthly energy costs. Cheers, Paul On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 03:19:08 -0600, kjpro @ usenet.com wrote: LP and Nat used to be cheap fuels. But as time goes by, they continue to rise dramatically while the electric costs have had slight increases. With new product designs and affiances, today a heat pump can often save you a significantly large amount of money in operational costs... |
#19
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Hi Mike,
At this stage you've already taken the big hit in terms of your rate adjustment. Unfortunately, this is what happens when regulators lock prices at artificially low levels for, what was it? Ten years? When you don't pay the true cost, consumers will use far more electricity than they would otherwise and will logically forego investments in energy conservation and more efficient end-use technologies such as heat pumps. And who can blame them? It's the perfectly rational thing to do. But now the ride has come to an end and consumers are faced with the new reality. Hopefully most have prepared for this day, but for those who haven't, the pain has only begun. Please keep us informed of your progress and, by all means, let me know if I can help you in any way. Cheers, Pau; On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 15:39:59 GMT, "Mike" wrote: Paul, BGE energy production comes from nuclear and coal and just enough natural gas so the can use the cost of natural gas for ALL of the cost to produce energy. All energy produces do this and it's legal. Insulating and HP seems to be the way to go. Tomorrow I'll print out the descriptions of the heat pumps. It is appealing to leave the baseboard electric heaters in place and add the heat pump. Mike |
#20
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
As an addendum to my previous note, I came across this on the
Bloomberg,com website earlier today: http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?p...0&refer=energy Tony Blair, speaking of the U.K.'s own declining North Sea oil and gas reserves and the subsequent future of nuclear power in that country spelled it out in rather blunt terms.... ``We are going to move from self sufficiency in gas to importing 90 percent of it'. North Sea production peaked in 1999 and has been steadily falling ever since. Cheers, Paul |
#21
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
On Sun, Steve Cothran wrote:
One thing is constant, and that is, that things are always changing. Something that is effective today may not be tomorrow. For years the fuel of choice in a rural setting was propane. It was 70-90 cents/gal. Now it is 2.10/gal and btu for btu yielded you can heat with low-tech electric resistance heat for less money. 1 Million BTU Electricity = $24.90 (TN) $24.90 would be about 400 KWH here, and that could produce more than 1.2 million BTU. 1 Million BTU Propane (80% Furnace)=$28.46 Out of curiosity I checked the price for propane 17 pound bottle refills at Lowes, and it was $18, that is a lot more than $2.10 a gallon, isn't it. But maybe in bulk it is cheaper. The temperature here fell through -10 C during daylight here today, and that could mean life threatening temperatures without backup heat, regardless of what the fuel is, furnaces and anything else can fail even if there is plenty of fuel. The high tech furnaces are a threat, even if they are supposed to be more efficient, fuel cost is not as important as avoiding unsafe temperatures. Joe Fischer |
#22
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Joe Fischer" wrote in message ... On Sun, Steve Cothran wrote: One thing is constant, and that is, that things are always changing. Something that is effective today may not be tomorrow. For years the fuel of choice in a rural setting was propane. It was 70-90 cents/gal. Now it is 2.10/gal and btu for btu yielded you can heat with low-tech electric resistance heat for less money. 1 Million BTU Electricity = $24.90 (TN) $24.90 would be about 400 KWH here, and that could produce more than 1.2 million BTU. 1 Million BTU Propane (80% Furnace)=$28.46 Out of curiosity I checked the price for propane 17 pound bottle refills at Lowes, and it was $18, that is a lot more than $2.10 a gallon, isn't it. But maybe in bulk it is cheaper. Bulk is definately cheaper than having a 20 lb tank filled. The temperature here fell through -10 C during daylight here today, and that could mean life threatening temperatures without backup heat, regardless of what the fuel is, furnaces and anything else can fail even if there is plenty of fuel. The high tech furnaces are a threat, even if they are supposed to be more efficient, fuel cost is not as important as avoiding unsafe temperatures. Joe Fischer "high tech furnaces are a threat"??????????? How do you come up with that horse****? |
#23
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
One thing is constant, and that is, that things are always changing. Something that is effective today may not be tomorrow. For years the fuel of choice in a rural setting was propane. It was 70-90 cents/gal. Now it is 2.10/gal and btu for btu yielded you can heat with low-tech electric resistance heat for less money. 1 Million BTU Electricity = $24.90 (TN) 1 Million BTU Propane (80% Furnace)=$28.46 |
#24
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & ReplacementWindows
Steve Cothran wrote:
One thing is constant, and that is, that things are always changing. Something that is effective today may not be tomorrow. For years the fuel of choice in a rural setting was propane. It was 70-90 cents/gal. Now it is 2.10/gal and btu for btu yielded you can heat with low-tech electric resistance heat for less money. 1 Million BTU Electricity = $24.90 (TN) 1 Million BTU Propane (80% Furnace)=$28.46 1 Million BTU = 293 kWh * $0.15 (NY) = $43.95 Propane wins. Plus, when the power goes out, propane still runs, if I had electric, I freeze to death. -- Steve Spence Dir., Green Trust http://www.green-trust.org |
#25
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Steve Spence" wrote in message ... Steve Cothran wrote: One thing is constant, and that is, that things are always changing. Something that is effective today may not be tomorrow. For years the fuel of choice in a rural setting was propane. It was 70-90 cents/gal. Now it is 2.10/gal and btu for btu yielded you can heat with low-tech electric resistance heat for less money. 1 Million BTU Electricity = $24.90 (TN) 1 Million BTU Propane (80% Furnace)=$28.46 1 Million BTU = 293 kWh * $0.15 (NY) = $43.95 Propane wins. Plus, when the power goes out, propane still runs, if I had electric, I freeze to death. What's the cost on a gal of LP up there? |
#26
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & ReplacementWindows
kjpro @ usenet.com wrote:
What's the cost on a gal of LP up there? Last fill up was $2.20/gallon. 100 gallon minimum. -- Steve Spence Dir., Green Trust http://www.green-trust.org |
#27
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Paul M. Eldridge" wrote in message ... Hi Mike, There are 100,000 BTUs per therm of natural gas, or the equivalent of 29.3 kWh of electric heat. A mid efficiency furnace operating at 80 per cent efficiency will provide you with 23.4 kWh of heat per therm (the other 5.9 kWh being lost up the chimney). A high efficiency furnace with a 90 per cent efficiency rating would give you 26.4 kWh/therm and at the very top end of the scale you might achieve upwards of 28 kWh/therm. It looks like BGE is currently charging residential customers $1.30 per therm (commodity and delivery prices combined). At 80 per cent conversion efficiency, each kWh of gas heat costs you roughly 5.5 cents and at 90 per cent efficiency, that cost falls to 4.9 cents per kWh(e). I believe BGE's winter electric rate now stands at 12.73 cents per kWh. A high efficiency heat pump with a seasonal COP of between 2.5 and 3.0 (not an unreasonable number given your relatively moderate winters), would produce heat in the range of 4.2 to 5.1 cents per kWh(e). One of the Fujitsu ductless heat pumps has a HSPF of 11.0, which puts its seasonal COP at just over 3.2. That effectively reduces the cost of electric heat to just 3.9 cents per kWh(e), or some twenty per cent below that of a high efficiency gas furnace operating at 90 per cent efficiency. One of the nice things about a ductless heat pump is that you can simply leave your electric baseboard heaters in place, so there's no need to rip them out, re-plaster your walls and repaint your rooms. This also provides you with backup emergency heat should your heat pump require servicing. Cheers, Paul On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 01:22:31 GMT, "Mike" wrote: I've got a gas stove and water heater. How can I convert BTU/therms to kw so I can compare costs? Paul, another poster stated the cost on NG is going up, and I assume, might even surpass electricso the HP is evenn more appealing. How does it cool in the rooms in the summer? |
#28
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Mike posted for all of us...
EOG rowhouse What is EOG rowhouse? End of Grid? Huh? -- Tekkie Don't bother to thank me, I do this as a public service. |
#29
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Hi Mike,
I don't think anyone can accurately predict the long-term cost of natural gas, but I tend to believe it will only go up... most likely, way up. Canada now supplies 90 per cent of U.S. imports and most of that gas originates in Alberta. The bad news is that Alberta's fields are rapidly maturing and production will soon begin its inevitable decline. But that's just part of the story. It takes 1,000 cubic feet of natural gas to process each barrel of oil made from Alberta's tar sands (add four barrels of fresh water to the mix while you're at it). By 2015, these oil sands are expected to produce two million barrels of oil per day. Now do the math.... multiple two million barrels by 1,000 cubic feet, then multiple by 365 days in a year. Anyone want to guess where a good chunk of that Canadian gas will soon be going? I don't know about you, but I get that queasy feeling in the pit of my stomach. Oh, while we're at it, can anyone tell me where those eight million barrels of water (per day) will go once they finish processing all that oily, sticky tar? ... Someone? ... Anyone? In regards to cooling, they work great. A heat pump with a SEER rating of 20 or 21 is likely to be two to two-and-a-half times more energy efficient than your current window units. I'm happy to say they cool just as well as they heat. Cheers, Paul Paul, another poster stated the cost on NG is going up, and I assume, might even surpass electricso the HP is evenn more appealing. How does it cool in the rooms in the summer? |
#30
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 19:39:55 -0500, Steve Spence
wrote: 1 Million BTU = 293 kWh * $0.15 (NY) = $43.95 Propane wins. Plus, when the power goes out, propane still runs, if I had electric, I freeze to death. Ouch. Our electic rate here is ~0.085/kwh depending on usage. Don't know how long that will last, though. |
#31
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
With most recent statement in hand....
I pay Superior Propane $1.008 per litre. My bill includes a $6.00 "transportation fee" and an additional $3.95 "hazardous mat handling fee". My consumption during this billing period was 94.5 litres and my total bill, including tax, comes to $119.93. There are approximately 24,200 BTUs per litre of propane (7.1 kWh). If I multiple 94.5 litres by 24,200 BTUs, the result is 2,286,900 BTUs. That means one million BTUs cost me $52.44. That's the equivalent of buying electricity at $0.18 per kWh. Assuming an 80 per cent conversion efficiency, my actual cost per kWh(e) is just over $0.22. The net result is that I pay more than twice as much for propane as I do electricty. Cheers, Paul On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 19:03:07 -0800, Steve Cothran wrote: Ouch. Our electic rate here is ~0.085/kwh depending on usage. Don't know how long that will last, though. |
#32
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
On Sun, kjpro @ usenet.com wrote:
"high tech furnaces are a threat"??????????? How do you come up with that Ask the, about a million, people who lost power for a week or more in the plains and west coast. It would help if each one were installed with a big warning sign "Be sure to have a backup heating system if the power goes off". I seriously doubt if one out of a thousand homes have an emergency generator, and even some that do could not isolate the furnace circuit and run it. But I am prejudiced, I don't like the noise of the small duct forced air. Joe Fischer |
#33
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Tekkie®" wrote in message . .. Mike posted for all of us... EOG rowhouse What is EOG rowhouse? End of Grid? Huh? -- Tekkie Don't bother to thank me, I do this as a public service. eeerrrr.... aahhhhh.. . . . end of group. |
#34
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Paul M. Eldridge" wrote in message ... Hi Mike, At this stage you've already taken the big hit in terms of your rate adjustment. Unfortunately, this is what happens when regulators lock prices at artificially low levels for, what was it? Ten years? When you don't pay the true cost, consumers will use far more electricity than they would otherwise and will logically forego investments in energy conservation and more efficient end-use technologies such as heat pumps. And who can blame them? It's the perfectly rational thing to do. But now the ride has come to an end and consumers are faced with the new reality. Hopefully most have prepared for this day, but for those who haven't, the pain has only begun. Please keep us informed of your progress and, by all means, let me know if I can help you in any way. Paul, Thank you much for you useful comments. I will keep the group informed. Also, I've learned alot. Today I was talking some buddies about HPs. Apparently, they have improved quite a bit over the last few years. Electric - BGE and Constellation Energy made very substanial profits even though the rates were frozen since 1999. BGE, when regulated produced reliable power and always paid dividends to its stock holders. It was a stock many conservative investors owned. Then Enron and others lobbied (bought) the local polictioans in Annapolis and after power producers were decoupled from the power transmitters and the rates were deregulated resulting in the maintenance of the grid going to pot and the rates are in a continuous upward spiral. The local power grids were not designed to import power from other areas thus they are overstressed and are facing premature failure. Of course there is no method to store electric so it is not a commodity that be stored 'til it's needed. In some areas transmissions costs are approaching electric rates in some deregulated markets. I don't know of anybody who has saved a nickel in rates when switching to deregulated electric power. Sorry I digress. It just really ****es me off. I'm a free market guy when it serves a purpose. BTW, A large energy intensive business just left Maryland and moved to state w/ regulated electric because it was no longer profitable using overpriced deregulated energy. Most states who had been moving to deregualtion no longer are because they're a seeing the profound impact it has. Mike |
#35
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Steve Spence" wrote in message ... kjpro @ usenet.com wrote: What's the cost on a gal of LP up there? Last fill up was $2.20/gallon. 100 gallon minimum. Not to bad then, I figured with your electric cost that it would have been higher than that. |
#36
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Hi Mike,
I can appreciate your frustration. What I find funny is how major power consumers vigorously fought for deregulation, fully expecting electricity rates to go down. In most cases, that didn't happen (quite the opposite) and some of those same voices were screaming to have things put back as they once were. We can bemoan high energy prices but at the end of the day we're no further ahead. What we need to do is look for intelligent ways to use less. For example, all of us might consider replacing the five incandescent bulbs we use most frequently with CFLs; at $2.00 to $3.00 each, there's really no reason why any of us should be using a bulb that consumes four times more energy than necessary. When it comes time to replace that old refrigerator or dishwasher, select an Energy Star model. A twenty-five or thirty year old refrigerator could easily consume 2,000 or more kWhs per year; my current refrigerator uses less than one-quarter of that. How many old refrigerators sit in hot garages keeping one or two cases of beer cold? If you put your mind to it, you'll find a dozen different ways to reduce your bill. This Channel 4 presentation might help start the ball running. And who knows? You too might save a "packet of money". #1 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1PVGEk5Wlxk #2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fxfyiOtfD88 #3 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQGtHpxvmLg #4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8S8DPfICQiM #5 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXqHrsTFv2Y #6 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAub4yoRZkc Cheers, Paul |
#37
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
Propane wins. Plus, when the power goes out, propane still runs, if I had
electric, I freeze to death. Steve Spence So how do you run the fan in the furnace when the power is out? Donald |
#38
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Joe Fischer" wrote in message news On Sun, kjpro @ usenet.com wrote: "high tech furnaces are a threat"??????????? How do you come up with that Ask the, about a million, people who lost power for a week or more in the plains and west coast. It would help if each one were installed with a big warning sign "Be sure to have a backup heating system if the power goes off". I seriously doubt if one out of a thousand homes have an emergency generator, and even some that do could not isolate the furnace circuit and run it. But I am prejudiced, I don't like the noise of the small duct forced air. Ok then, With most modern every day piece of heating equipment... which one do you recommend, that doesn't require ELECTRIC to operate? Or are we to go back to the days of Gas Fired SPACE heaters??? |
#39
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 23:58:18 -0600, kjpro @ usenet.com wrote:
Ok then, With most modern every day piece of heating equipment... which one do you recommend, that doesn't require ELECTRIC to operate? Or are we to go back to the days of Gas Fired SPACE heaters??? Electric or electric controlled is fine for primary heat, but I keep two Gas Fired SPACE heaters just for when the electric is out. :-) Actually, I have been lucky, power has not been off more than 8 hours at a time. My baseboard heat isn't working as well as I hoped, even at 6 cents, it is expensive to heat just one room, small kitchen and bath. There really isn't much choice, it seems to be either heat pump or modern furnace, depending on electric rates and natural gas ups and downs. My utility company offers free truck loads of mulch when they are trimming trees in the area, but I would need to build an incinerator type heating system for that. The convenience of a modern heating system of any kind really spoils people, the thought of chopping wood seems like too much work, and it is too much for me to think about. Gas SPACE heaters can be built to be just as efficient as the modern furnace, and I suppose I could put ductwork for flame air and a heat exchanger in the vent pipe, so I may need to do that next summer. Joe Fischer |
#40
Posted to alt.energy.homepower,alt.energy.renewable,alt.home.repair,alt.hvac
|
|||
|
|||
Need to replace Electric Baseboard Heating Units & Replacement Windows
"Joe Fischer" wrote in message ... On Sun, 28 Jan 2007 23:58:18 -0600, kjpro @ usenet.com wrote: Ok then, With most modern every day piece of heating equipment... which one do you recommend, that doesn't require ELECTRIC to operate? Or are we to go back to the days of Gas Fired SPACE heaters??? Electric or electric controlled is fine for primary heat, but I keep two Gas Fired SPACE heaters just for when the electric is out. :-) If you are going to have a back-up source for heat... and even if you don't... Then don't say "high tech furnace's are a threat". The fact is, the newer, high tech, modern day furnace's are safer than the old units. My baseboard heat isn't working as well as I hoped, even at 6 cents, it is expensive to heat just one room, small kitchen and bath. Expensive at 6 cents... something isn't right. Of coarse a heat pump would be more economical than your straight electric heat. Gas SPACE heaters can be built to be just as efficient as the modern furnace, Going backwards in technology again are we? and I suppose I could put ductwork for flame air and a heat exchanger in the vent pipe, so I may need to do that next summer. Joe Fischer You're starting to sound like an engineer that is wanting to spend $1000 to save $5. Good luck with that. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Hydronic elecric baseboard heater vs standard electric baseboard heater | Home Repair | |||
Electric baseboard heating problem | Home Repair | |||
DG units for Crittall windows | UK diy | |||
Replace radiator with baseboard?? | Home Repair | |||
Help with replacing radiators with baseboard units | Home Repair |