Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
siding vs painting
We're moving into a wood home we bought. I'm considering having some kind
of metal or vinyl siding put on it, and need some thoughts as to how that compares with painting. What's a good range for how many years a house can go between paintings? I've got an estimate of cost of painting, and an estimate of siding cost. What's missing is how often we'd need to paint in order to do a long term cost comparison. |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
siding vs painting
RB wrote: We're moving into a wood home we bought. I'm considering having some kind of metal or vinyl siding put on it, and need some thoughts as to how that compares with painting. What's a good range for how many years a house can go between paintings? I've got an estimate of cost of painting, and an estimate of siding cost. What's missing is how often we'd need to paint in order to do a long term cost comparison. That depends on many things which we have no way of knowing. Is the house in Arizona or on the coast of Maine? What condition is the wood in? How many layers of existing paint is on there, what kind was it, and what shape is it in? What kind of paint are you planning to use? In my experience, quality paint correctly applied to a good base in an average environment will generally last 7 to 9 years. And IMO, if you have good quality wood siding, that looks superior and adds value to a house compared to vinyl siding, so I would not cover it up. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
siding vs painting
In article , RB says...
We're moving into a wood home we bought. I'm considering having some kind of metal or vinyl siding put on it, and need some thoughts as to how that compares with painting. What's a good range for how many years a house can go between paintings? I've got an estimate of cost of painting, and an estimate of siding cost. What's missing is how often we'd need to paint in order to do a long term cost comparison. A job done well, at least here in the northeast, can last up to ten years. That's with not scrimping on prep or paint quality. You can found out what neighbors' experiences were, and maybe get some estimates, taking the middle of the estimates and only believing the ones that will include a lot of prep. Then make your comparison with what a siding cost would be. But it's not just cost. Think about what you want/like as far as esthetics, and how important low maintenance is to you. Banty (will side it this year) |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
siding vs painting
Metal siding definetly interferes with cell phone reception vinyl is
a better choice Honestly your better off with siding, your existing wood probably has lead based paint Repaining is a never ending job, and when it comes time to sell low maintence is a advantage. unless your home is in a historic district!............... Expect siding to cost about 4 times the cost of repainting. figure painting abut every 7 years to keep house looking good. every 10 is pushing it. the longer between repaints the more the wood repair. that adds costs too. |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
siding vs painting
"RB" wrote in message . .. We're moving into a wood home we bought. I'm considering having some kind of metal or vinyl siding put on it, and need some thoughts as to how that compares with painting. What's a good range for how many years a house can go between paintings? I've got an estimate of cost of painting, and an estimate of siding cost. What's missing is how often we'd need to paint in order to do a long term cost comparison. Without knowing where you are, the condition of the siding and the quality of the prep work that will go into the job I agree with all the other posters. 5 - 10 years if you want to protect the siding and keep the house looking good. This presumes a quality paint and prep job over siding in average condition. Colbyt |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Patching Hardboard Siding | Home Repair | |||
Painting 8" channel wood siding | Home Repair | |||
Painting siding vs. New siding | Home Repair | |||
Painting vs. replacing vinyl siding ... ? | Home Repair | |||
painting siding | Home Repair |