Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodturning (rec.crafts.woodturning) To discuss tools, techniques, styles, materials, shows and competitions, education and educational materials related to woodturning. All skill levels are welcome, from art turners to production turners, beginners to masters. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked.
After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don |
#2
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Can't give you a personal comparison but I have 2 Talons and they are
fantastic. The Oneway jaws really hold well and there is good selection of other jaws for it. Very well made and capable of holding much larger pieces than your Jet Mini can turn. Has an adapter system so you can upgrade it to fit a large spindle if necessary just by getting a different adapter. Oneway chucks aren't the only ones that offer this. billh "Don Sforza" wrote in message ... Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don |
#3
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Don Sforza said:
So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. I use a SuperNova II. It took me a while to pry nearly as much from my wallet for a chuck as for the lathe itself. But it holds very well, and like the Talon, is upgradable for new lathe acquisitions. It comes with a chuck mountable woodworm screw, and I like the improved, quicker acting jaw mech which uses a single T-handled ball head hex wrench. Teknitool has an extremely broad selection of jaws available. The number of available jaw-sets and their slight price advantage were factors that finally sold me on the SuperNova II. I understand that it will also allow use of many Oneway jaws with a slight modification. FWIW, Greg G. |
#4
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
The Oneway Stronghold are the best it has a 5 to 1 clamping ratio. For
smaller lathes the Talon is next. The Stronghold is pricey but you get what you pay for. It can't be beat. Tim "Don Sforza" wrote in message ... Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don |
#5
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
You might check the Grizzly site too. They have a couple that are
reasonably priced and work well. Brian |
#6
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
The Talon also has a 5:1 ratio as well and I wouldn't be surprised if most
key driven chucks are around the same. However, I do have a lot of faith in the Oneway jaws for holding. I also have a Stronghold and you are right, it is fantastic but somewhat big for his lathe. What I like about the Talon is its small size which makes it easier to do more complete shapes of bowl bottoms while chucked. To the original poster, any quality chuck will serve you well be it a Oneway, Vicmarc, SuperNova. billh "tdup2" wrote in message ... The Oneway Stronghold are the best it has a 5 to 1 clamping ratio. For smaller lathes the Talon is next. The Stronghold is pricey but you get what you pay for. It can't be beat. Tim "Don Sforza" wrote in message ... Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don |
#7
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
the advantage of the oneway jaws over the vicmarc and supernova is that
they work well for more than one diameter because of oneway's special profiled jaws. but if you can get a less expensive chuck body from another company that the oneway jaws would fit onto that would be the best. ~BHB |
#8
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
"tdup2" wrote in message ... The Oneway Stronghold are the best it has a 5 to 1 clamping ratio. For smaller lathes the Talon is next. The Stronghold is pricey but you get what you pay for. It can't be beat. I have both the Stronghold and the Talon. I use the Talon more often, simply because the majority of my things are either bettter off with a recess of 52mm (Talon) instead of 62 mm recess (the Stronghold). For turning between centers I also seem to prefer the Talon, simply because it has less mass, and is easier to stop. But, for the heavier work, the Stronghold can probably not be beat. Bjarte |
#9
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Based on comments in other forums, it seems they are a bit of gamble. Some
people have been very happy some haven't but you can't expect the same level of QA for something that much cheaper. I used a $65 cheapie with my first lathe and to be honest, it worked reasonably well. Having used the Oneway chucks now, I wouldn't want to go back. billh "Brian" wrote in message ... You might check the Grizzly site too. They have a couple that are reasonably priced and work well. Brian |
#10
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
On Thu, 22 Dec 2005 17:24:00 GMT, "Don Sforza" wrote:
Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don OK.. biases opinion from someone that has only used the Talon: Buy it, you won't regret it! I bought the Talon for my shopsmith, bought the 1-8 adapter for the Jet Mini when it came along and use it on the Jet 1442 with the same adapter... I recently bought a 2nd Talon so that each lathe had it's own chuck... Easy to use (it was my first chuck) and well made... very versatile, etc... A really good tim that was passed on to me by Jim Pugh was to NOT buy the smaller ( #1? ) jaws... Get the "spigot" jaws and you'll do more things with them and be happier... They're like the smaller jaw set, but have longer jaws... more holding in a small size... I've turned a few hundred things on my Talon and have had only have one problem... I somehow managed to force the jaws open too wide and broke the pin out of #1 jaw that prevents you from opening the jaws too wide... (not recommended by me or Oneway, it makes the jaws fall out on the lathe bed and puts a nasty scratch on the chuck face) I smoothed out the face and replaced the pin and went back to turning... IMO, this chuck is the "honda gold wing" of chucks... it just keeps going and going even if you forget to maintain it.. YMWV mac Please remove splinters before emailing |
#11
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Chucks are over priced and not needed to turn a bowl. I turn up 24" bowls
with no chuck and no tailstock. The bottoms of my bowls are conclave and nicely finished. cm "Don Sforza" wrote in message ... Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don |
#12
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
I quite agree that a chuck is not essential. IMO, though, it makes a lot of
tasks more convenient and it is useful for holding small spindles such as icicles for ornaments as well as face work. A chuck is just a somewhat universal jig and there is nothing to stop you from making your own purpose-built jig to do any task - I would just sooner use a chuck. billh "cm" wrote in message ... Chucks are over priced and not needed to turn a bowl. I turn up 24" bowls with no chuck and no tailstock. The bottoms of my bowls are conclave and nicely finished. cm "Don Sforza" wrote in message ... Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don |
#13
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
"billh" wrote in message .. . I quite agree that a chuck is not essential. IMO, though, it makes a lot of tasks more convenient and it is useful for holding small spindles such as icicles for ornaments as well as face work. A chuck is just a somewhat universal jig and there is nothing to stop you from making your own purpose-built jig to do any task - I would just sooner use a chuck. billh "cm" wrote in message ... Chucks are over priced and not needed to turn a bowl. I turn up 24" bowls with no chuck and no tailstock. The bottoms of my bowls are conclave and nicely finished. A chuck is a tool. You can fiddle and fuss and get the job done, but it sure is nice to have the proper tool. I'm Novas, standard and Super. The most-used jaws on mine are the pin jaws, followed by the 50mm. I also keep the power grip jaws mounted for those times I want to cut something hanging way out. What you need is a good mate on the jaws when closed, smooth symmetrical operation on opening. "Grip" and how fast they open or close are so unimportant as to be inconsequential. |
#14
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
You will probably find that most of the people in this group prefer the
Oneways, for your Jet Mini, a Talon would be appropriate. I have a Jet Mini and have no problems at all with the SuperNova. This chuck also has interchangeable adapters, so when I bought my Stubby, all I had to do was buy a $24.95 adapter. I think you will find that Nova has a more expansive range of jaws than Oneway. As for whether the Oneway grips tighter........I really can't say. I'm thinking about try a SuperNova II, which replaced the SuperNova. Reviews have bee good on this chuck. Barry "Don Sforza" wrote in message ... Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don |
#15
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
There are alot of good chucks out there. Truth be told, you will
probably be happy with any of them. I have never used a multistar, but I have herd they are the best (they are the most expensive, so that makes sense). I have a pair of vicmarc 120's that I reach for first ( the 120 may be a little big, the 100 may fit you better). I have the oneway talon and stronghold. They are both great checks, and hold rough pieces well. The vicmarcs seem to be better machined, then the oneways, but are more expensive today (I bought mine several years ago when the Aussie exchange rate was very favorable). I like the extra jaw designs on the vicmarc, but any of them would do the job. I have not used the supernova, others could give you good feedback. I would: - pick the type of turning you do - determine if specialized jaws would help you with this style of turning - find a good dealer, see what they sell Make sure the conveyance of the chuck is worth to cost, if yes, buy it and start turning with it:-) Happy turning, and Merry Christmas to all. Back to the shop to finish working on those presents :-) Mike Barry N. Turner wrote: You will probably find that most of the people in this group prefer the Oneways, for your Jet Mini, a Talon would be appropriate. I have a Jet Mini and have no problems at all with the SuperNova. This chuck also has interchangeable adapters, so when I bought my Stubby, all I had to do was buy a $24.95 adapter. I think you will find that Nova has a more expansive range of jaws than Oneway. As for whether the Oneway grips tighter........I really can't say. I'm thinking about try a SuperNova II, which replaced the SuperNova. Reviews have bee good on this chuck. Barry "Don Sforza" wrote in message ... Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don -- The greatest performance improvement occurs on the transition of from the non-working state to the working state. |
#16
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
On Fri, 23 Dec 2005 18:52:43 GMT, "cm" wrote:
Chucks are over priced and not needed to turn a bowl. I turn up 24" bowls with no chuck and no tailstock. The bottoms of my bowls are conclave and nicely finished. / cm well, we don't all have a set of shirts with a big "S" on 'em, cm... Some of us wimps need help holding stuff.. mac Please remove splinters before emailing |
#17
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
On Fri, 23 Dec 2005 14:23:58 -0500, "billh" wrote:
I quite agree that a chuck is not essential. IMO, though, it makes a lot of tasks more convenient and it is useful for holding small spindles such as icicles for ornaments as well as face work. A chuck is just a somewhat universal jig and there is nothing to stop you from making your own purpose-built jig to do any task - I would just sooner use a chuck. billh yep.. lathe chucks are just another tool... lathe chisels are an option, also... hell, why use a lathe? Just spin the wood real fast and hold an ax out... *g* and who the hell needs a drill or screwdriver that's powered??? (umm... that'd be me) "cm" wrote in message ... Chucks are over priced and not needed to turn a bowl. I turn up 24" bowls with no chuck and no tailstock. The bottoms of my bowls are conclave and nicely finished. cm "Don Sforza" wrote in message ... Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. After about a year of turning pens and other "between center" things, I'm ready to make the jump into other turning... bowls and the like. I began a search for a chuck and I've narrowed my choices down. BTW, I bought a Penn Industries Barracuda (not the B2), and it's going back today. I was really diappointed in the fit of the jaws and the overall finish. I woudl have jumped at a B2, but none are in stock. From the looks of the Barracuda, I would have been buying another one in short order. I like to buy tools ONCE, but I'm not opposed to saving a buck if the functionality is not compromised. So I'm thinking either a Oneway Talon with the extra set of small jaws or the SuperNova. I currently have a Jet Mini, but will be looking to upgrade in the next year. Prices seem comparable, but I'm looking for some of that peer to peer banter of the relative merits of each. Don mac Please remove splinters before emailing |
#18
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Well it does take a little creativity to easily hold your work on the lathe
without a chuck. I never imagined there would be any of that lacking here! GRIN I'm just a poor boy gettin by...... Craig www.vintagetrailersforsale.com "mac davis" wrote in message ... On Fri, 23 Dec 2005 18:52:43 GMT, "cm" wrote: Chucks are over priced and not needed to turn a bowl. I turn up 24" bowls with no chuck and no tailstock. The bottoms of my bowls are conclave and nicely finished. / cm well, we don't all have a set of shirts with a big "S" on 'em, cm... Some of us wimps need help holding stuff.. mac Please remove splinters before emailing |
#19
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
You can read everything I know about chucks at the following address:
http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/russ7.shtml There have been some new and less exopensive offerings on the market since this article was written. So far may opinion hasn't changed. If there are some prejudices showing in the article, so be it. |
#20
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
On 26 Dec 2005 06:58:17 -0800, "Russ Fairfield"
wrote: You can read everything I know about chucks at the following address: EVERYthing??? Chuck - Who wondered who that was following me around. -- Chuck *#:^) chaz3913(AT)yahoo(DOT)com Anti-spam sig: please remove "NO SPAM" from e-mail address to reply. September 11, 2001 - Never Forget ----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Unrestricted-Secure Usenet News==---- http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! 120,000+ Newsgroups ----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption =---- |
#21
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
|
#22
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Bertie Pittman said:
On Thu, 22 Dec 2005 17:24:00 GMT, "Don Sforza" wrote: Go easy on me... I'm new to turning, but getting hooked. Hi Don, I've used a SuperNova for a few years now and it has worked well. Yeahbut, they don't make the SuperNova anymore. The replacement SuperNova2 is a new animal that addresses your complaints. I would not have bought the SN, but I DID pick the SN2 over the Talon, which is certainly no slouch in the chucking department. No affiliation with Teknitool or Oneway or anyone else but myself. FWIW, Greg G. |
#23
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Note that the Supernova is righty-tighty if you're using it as a spigot (expanding) chuck. The manual makes it seem like this is the preferred mode for this chuck. |
#24
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Bertie Pittman said:
On Wed, 28 Dec 2005 16:36:43 -0500, Greg wrote: Yeahbut, they don't make the SuperNova anymore. The replacement SuperNova2 is a new animal that addresses your complaints. I would not have bought the SN, but I DID pick the SN2 over the Talon, which is certainly no slouch in the chucking department. Greg, Yes, they have addressed some of the problems with the newer model SuperNova2, but not my main difficulty with the chuck, - which is, you need to turn the handle counter-clockwise to tighten the chuck when in the compression mode. Well, it does operate differently than the Talon, but whether you consider that backwards or not depends on whether you are used to "tightening" around a spigot or into a dovetail recess... I use a recess more often than a spigot/tenon. Maybe I don't notice it as much due to the fact that I'm a lefty and am also used to left-hand threads. It does have an arrow stamped into the pinion for those who just can't remember. :-\ I'm not trying to sell anyone on either, but there has been far wider acceptance of the SN2 than the original SN. The ball headed chuck key is a nice touch that eliminates the need to be "straight-on" to the chuck. Some might appreciate the indexing holes, but I haven't had any use for them yet. The captive woodworm screw is also clamped by the jaws, and prohibited from rotating. Perhaps I have a subconscious desire to own Australian products. ;-) I am simply reporting that it works fine for me and is well machined. FWIW, Greg G. |
#25
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Bertie Pittman wrote in message news On Wed, 28 Dec 2005 16:36:43 -0500, Greg wrote: Yeahbut, they don't make the SuperNova anymore. The replacement SuperNova2 is a new animal that addresses your complaints. I would not have bought the SN, but I DID pick the SN2 over the Talon, which is certainly no slouch in the chucking department. Greg, Yes, they have addressed some of the problems with the newer model SuperNova2, but not my main difficulty with the chuck, - which is, you need to turn the handle counter-clockwise to tighten the chuck when in the compression mode. I suppose you have a problem with the left end of your grinder and the arbor of your tablesaw, too? It's a left-hand-thread. No mystery. It's that way because the folks who designed the chuck figured the thing would be used predominantly in the expansion mode, where Lefty Lucy still works. In case you'd like a new mnemonic, remember that Lefty Lucy doesn't spread 'em with Chuck. |
#26
Posted to rec.crafts.woodturning
|
|||
|
|||
A question about chucks
Bertie Pittman wrote in message ... On Thu, 29 Dec 2005 07:30:04 -0500, "George" George@least wrote: I don't have any problem with left handed threads on tools or whatever - at least not where they make sense anyway. You'd love the 3000, where the tailstock is secured leftie tightie for reasons known only to Teknatool. As I said, the reason for the apparent other-handedness is that the designers anticipated that regular usage would be in the recess mode. Means start-up inertia tightens it, too. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Morse Taper Question | Woodturning | |||
Yet another tub caulking question (sorry!) -this time about color | Home Repair | |||
Simple question regarding Ceiling tiles and sound? | Home Ownership | |||
Plumbing Question | UK diy | |||
Question????? | Woodworking |