Has anyone had problems with their house insurance because they bought a
piece of machinery? Specifically mills/lathes? Is there a size limit of any
kind where the insurance company may begin to take interest as to what you
are running in your garage/basement?

--
Michael Koblic,
Campbell River, BC

This is a huge problem. Insurance companies (at least the ones I have asked) will not insure these or the tools that go with them
as a part of home insurance. They will gladly sell you a separate policy that will insure, but these polices are designed for
businesses, not the hobbyist. Consequently you end up paying for risks that do not exist and the policies are way too expensive. I
haven't given up yet though. What I now must do is a complete accurate inventory complete with photos, new costs, estimated
current value and your loss value if different. Have that certified by an adjuster. Then state the risks you wish to be covered
for and then ask for a quote. We may very well find that the risk may have to be assumed yourself, because of cost. Anything less
will open the door for subjective loss analysis by an adjuster after loss. This is exactly what you must avoid..
Steve

"Michael Koblic" wrote in message ...
Has anyone had problems with their house insurance because they bought a piece of machinery? Specifically mills/lathes? Is there
a size limit of any kind where the insurance company may begin to take interest as to what you are running in your
garage/basement?

--
Michael Koblic,
Campbell River, BC

In article ,
"Steve Lusardi" wrote:

This is a huge problem. Insurance companies (at least the ones I have asked)
will not insure these or the tools that go with them
as a part of home insurance. They will gladly sell you a separate policy that
will insure, but these polices are designed for
businesses, not the hobbyist. Consequently you end up paying for risks that
do not exist and the policies are way too expensive. I
haven't given up yet though. What I now must do is a complete accurate
inventory complete with photos, new costs, estimated
current value and your loss value if different. Have that certified by an
adjuster. Then state the risks you wish to be covered
for and then ask for a quote. We may very well find that the risk may have to
be assumed yourself, because of cost. Anything less
will open the door for subjective loss analysis by an adjuster after loss.
This is exactly what you must avoid..
Steve

Is the OP trying to insure the machine tools, or is he worrying that the
insurance company might take exception to their presence if too large?

Joe Gwinn


"Michael Koblic" wrote in message
...
Has anyone had problems with their house insurance because they bought a
piece of machinery? Specifically mills/lathes? Is there
a size limit of any kind where the insurance company may begin to take
interest as to what you are running in your
garage/basement?

--
Michael Koblic,
Campbell River, BC

Michael Koblic wrote:

Has anyone had problems with their house insurance because they bought a
piece of machinery? Specifically mills/lathes? Is there a size limit of any
kind where the insurance company may begin to take interest as to what you
are running in your garage/basement?

In the US, I'm pretty sure this will vary quite a bit between companies,
between states and even in different areas within states. Folks in rural
areas will probably be more likely to have large tools covered by
default as they would be considered normal for the area.

Beyond that, homeowner's policies cover "personal property", so unless
you are operating a business, your tools no matter how large are
"personal property". You may have to argue that a metalworking hobby
isn't any different than a woodworking hobby or a ceramics hobby, but
you should ultimately prevail since your tax records will show your
tools aren't part of a business. Insurance companies wouldn't likely
argue about covering the loss of a $2,500 table saw, so a $2,500 mill
shouldn't be any different.

My policy lists some $120k coverage for "personal property", plus
additional coverages for computer equipment and "teleworker" coverage.
If we don't count vehicles since they have separate policies, the
coverage should be adequate to replace my stuff if it were all destroyed
by a tornado or the like. Since the shop is 80' from the house, the
chances of a loss on both at the same time is fairly low. The shop
building itself should fall under the "dwelling extension" coverage and
the $16k there should be enough to replace the 20'x32' building.

All policies have exclusions for "hazardous materials", but the fine
print in the exclusions excludes small quantities of such materials that
would be considered "normal", which should include the gas can for the
mower, paint thinner and the like.

"Michael Koblic" wrote:

Has anyone had problems with their house insurance because they bought a
piece of machinery? Specifically mills/lathes? Is there a size limit of any
kind where the insurance company may begin to take interest as to what you
are running in your garage/basement?

If you are doing work for hire or work to sell with your machines, I suspect your
insurance company isn't going to cover your machines from fire or theft if they can find
evidence of such.

The exclusions pages are what you need to read. You can also ask your insurance dealer
about this and demand your question be answered in writing. If your insurance dealer
refuses, time to look for another policy.

Wes

"Joseph Gwinn" wrote in message
...

Is the OP trying to insure the machine tools, or is he worrying that the
insurance company might take exception to their presence if too large?


Both, really. I cannot see them worrying about a X2 mill (they don't, I
discussed it with them). I can see raised eyebrows at a 20x60 lathe in the
spare bedroom. I wondered what the general experience was and if there was
any sense of a cut-off in these matters. At what point will the machine
becomes uninsurable under the ordinary household policy and at what point it
might be construed as a hazard to the rest of the dwelling.

Asking the insurance company is not always the best policy.

I know that I am not allowed to weld within 25 feet of the buildings. OTOH I
am allowed to solder.

I am not allowed to have a web site - this would make me into a *business*.

--
Michael Koblic,
Campbell River, BC

Michael Koblic wrote:

"Joseph Gwinn" wrote in message
...

Is the OP trying to insure the machine tools, or is he worrying that the
insurance company might take exception to their presence if too large?


Both, really. I cannot see them worrying about a X2 mill (they don't, I
discussed it with them). I can see raised eyebrows at a 20x60 lathe in
the spare bedroom. I wondered what the general experience was and if
there was any sense of a cut-off in these matters. At what point will
the machine becomes uninsurable under the ordinary household policy and
at what point it might be construed as a hazard to the rest of the
dwelling.

Asking the insurance company is not always the best policy.

I know that I am not allowed to weld within 25 feet of the buildings.
OTOH I am allowed to solder.

I am not allowed to have a web site - this would make me into a *business*.

Wow, this is funny! I asked about getting just
casualty insurance on my machines some years ago.
For $25,000 in machine tools, tooling, etc. they
wanted fully as much as the entire house and
contents for all sorts of casualty situations,
including the umbrella policy for persons injured
on my property. Needless to say, I didn't buy
this insurance. So, would having your own web
site on a computer in your home invalidate your
homeowner's insurance?

Jon

"Jon Elson" wrote in message
...
Michael Koblic wrote:

"Joseph Gwinn" wrote in message
...

Is the OP trying to insure the machine tools, or is he worrying that the
insurance company might take exception to their presence if too large?


Both, really. I cannot see them worrying about a X2 mill (they don't, I
discussed it with them). I can see raised eyebrows at a 20x60 lathe in
the spare bedroom. I wondered what the general experience was and if
there was any sense of a cut-off in these matters. At what point will the
machine becomes uninsurable under the ordinary household policy and at
what point it might be construed as a hazard to the rest of the dwelling.

Asking the insurance company is not always the best policy.

I know that I am not allowed to weld within 25 feet of the buildings.
OTOH I am allowed to solder.

I am not allowed to have a web site - this would make me into a
*business*.

Wow, this is funny! I asked about getting just casualty insurance on my
machines some years ago. For $25,000 in machine tools, tooling, etc. they
wanted fully as much as the entire house and contents for all sorts of
casualty situations, including the umbrella policy for persons injured on
my property. Needless to say, I didn't buy this insurance. So, would
having your own web site on a computer in your home invalidate your
homeowner's insurance?

That is the way it was interpreted to me by the broker. Whether it would
have invalidated the *whole* policy or just the parts related to the
"business" is not clear and I did not pursue it as it was somewhat
irrelevant - I wanted all my tools etc. insured which they are now. I was
not going to pay an exorbitant price for a business policy to cover what
generates a pitiful income if any.

--
Michael Koblic,
Campbell River, BC

Michael Koblic wrote:

"Joseph Gwinn" wrote in message
...

Is the OP trying to insure the machine tools, or is he worrying that the
insurance company might take exception to their presence if too large?


Both, really. I cannot see them worrying about a X2 mill (they don't, I
discussed it with them). I can see raised eyebrows at a 20x60 lathe in
the spare bedroom. I wondered what the general experience was and if
there was any sense of a cut-off in these matters. At what point will
the machine becomes uninsurable under the ordinary household policy and
at what point it might be construed as a hazard to the rest of the
dwelling.

Asking the insurance company is not always the best policy.

I know that I am not allowed to weld within 25 feet of the buildings.
OTOH I am allowed to solder.

I am not allowed to have a web site - this would make me into a *business*.

OK, well, I have a web STORE on a web server located in my house,
manufacture motion control hardware using the machines in my shop and
sell them through the web store. I have a fictitious name registration
through the state. So, it is clearly a business, in every way. I even
had a part time employee for a while, but moving over to surface mount
electronics and getting a pick and place machine got me to where I
didn't need him anymore.

I will have to look at my latest policy, and make sure that I don't have
a problem. Last time I read through it, it seemed that having a
business was not a problem, but the business equipment was not covered
above a very small amount that might cover a laptop and a printer.

I have a HUGE TIG welder, but use it so RARELY for the business that it
might be considered a hobby machine on that accord.

I have a Bridgeport converted to CNC and a Sheldon 15" lathe, those are
the big machines. I also have a 1600 Lb pick and place machine that I
was INCREDIBLY lucky to pick up at a very low price, I'd like to get
that insured for what it is worth, not what I paid for it. (Humpf, fat
chance!)

Well, my insurance is coming up for renewal, I can inquire again and see
what is available.

Jon

In article ,
Jon Elson wrote:

I also have a 1600 Lb pick and place machine that I
was INCREDIBLY lucky to pick up at a very low price, I'd like to get
that insured for what it is worth, not what I paid for it. (Humpf, fat
chance!)

Most of the time you'd do better to put the equivalent of the premiums
for said insurance into the "buy the next one" fund, as they are often
rather steep, especially for replacement cost (and then they weasel out
of replacement cost anyway when you need to file a claim.)

For all the things you can control, do so - ie, fireproofing, alarms,
what is stored where (such as flammable liquids, etc) while it "should"
save you money on premiums, more importantly it can save you ever having
to hire a lawyer to beat what's owed to you out of your insurance
company in the first place. Prevention is cheaper than replacement.

--
Cats, coffee, chocolate...vices to live by