Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Tom Dacon
 
Posts: n/a
Default A good small bandsaw

I'm looking around for a good small woodworking bandsaw for my garage shop.
The one I've got right now is one of those little 8" Delta saws. I think
it's never seen a piece of wood that didn't scare its little heart to death,
even with cool blocks, a 3/8" blade, and all the tension I could screw into
the blade tensioner. About the only good experience I've ever had with it
was cutting rigid foam, and I've concluded that it's useful only for taking
up space that might be better occupied by a better tool.

This would be just a light-duty casual-use saw, rather than a workhorse
tool. I have the use of a friend's woodshop nearby, and if I have any
serious sawing to do I can use his 18" Grizzly, but I'd like this one to be
a competent tool even so.

A bandsaw in that general size range that I've heard good reports about,
long ago, is the Inca 340 10 1/2" saw, which Garrett Valley, or was it Lee
Wade -just kidding, folks! :-) - used to sell some years ago. I've been all
over google and google groups, and even ebay, looking for someone who sells
that line or has one they'd like to sell, and I can't turn up any recent
information on Inca tools at all, let alone on that saw. So maybe they're
out of business nowadays or have no American distributor, and everyone who
has one of those saws wouldn't dream of parting with it - who knows?

Anyone know of a Inca 340 for sale in good condition, and know where to get
parts? Failing that, what would the collective wisdom of the wreck recommend
in this situation? Delta used to have a 10" saw, but I've never seen any
chatter on the wreck about it, and I fear that it wouldn't actually be any
better than the 8". Three-wheel saws are out, in my opinion, because of
blade flexing around the tiny wheels and because the ones I've seen looked
pretty cheesy. Delta's BS220LS 12" saw is a little bigger than I'd like, and
comes with a metal stand I'd have no use for (the saw needs to go on an
existing work table, due to limited space in the garage). Jet's smallest is
a 12", and doesn't look much different from the Delta 12" in either features
or disadvantages. Grizzly's G1052 9" saw looks attractive, at least to judge
from the marketing info on the web site - anyone have any experience with
this model?

Thanks for any comments,
Tom Dacon


  #2   Report Post  
Chris Hornberger
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"Tom Dacon" wrote in message
...
I'm looking around for a good small woodworking bandsaw for my garage

shop.
The one I've got right now is one of those little 8" Delta saws. I think
it's never seen a piece of wood that didn't scare its little heart to

death,
even with cool blocks, a 3/8" blade, and all the tension I could screw

into
the blade tensioner. About the only good experience I've ever had with it
was cutting rigid foam, and I've concluded that it's useful only for

taking
up space that might be better occupied by a better tool.


Husky (A private label at Home Despot) makes what seems to be a pretty
decent unit. I haven't used it myself but the demo the guy at one of the
stores was doing seemed to do ok. I'm going to be getting one too... same
idea as you... casual use, midrange product, affordable, so it's one I'll be
looking at pretty closely.


  #3   Report Post  
Robert Galloway
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I don't know about a light duty casual saw. I have a 14" Delta with the
riser block. I've resawed a lot with it, cut contours, done a few
tenons. I feel like I've gotten more than my money's worth out of this
saw. I haven't used Lagunas and some of the other "premium" saws. I
have no doubt they're worth the money. For what I spent, I have no
quarrel with the little Delta. It's fairly heavy and solid (compared to
what?) I'd consider it to be a "competent tool".

bob g.

p.s. Looking for a used tool, have you checked e-bay?

Tom Dacon wrote:

I'm looking around for a good small woodworking bandsaw for my garage shop.
The one I've got right now is one of those little 8" Delta saws. I think
it's never seen a piece of wood that didn't scare its little heart to death,
even with cool blocks, a 3/8" blade, and all the tension I could screw into
the blade tensioner. About the only good experience I've ever had with it
was cutting rigid foam, and I've concluded that it's useful only for taking
up space that might be better occupied by a better tool.

This would be just a light-duty casual-use saw, rather than a workhorse
tool. I have the use of a friend's woodshop nearby, and if I have any
serious sawing to do I can use his 18" Grizzly, but I'd like this one to be
a competent tool even so.

A bandsaw in that general size range that I've heard good reports about,
long ago, is the Inca 340 10 1/2" saw, which Garrett Valley, or was it Lee
Wade -just kidding, folks! :-) - used to sell some years ago. I've been all
over google and google groups, and even ebay, looking for someone who sells
that line or has one they'd like to sell, and I can't turn up any recent
information on Inca tools at all, let alone on that saw. So maybe they're
out of business nowadays or have no American distributor, and everyone who
has one of those saws wouldn't dream of parting with it - who knows?

Anyone know of a Inca 340 for sale in good condition, and know where to get
parts? Failing that, what would the collective wisdom of the wreck recommend
in this situation? Delta used to have a 10" saw, but I've never seen any
chatter on the wreck about it, and I fear that it wouldn't actually be any
better than the 8". Three-wheel saws are out, in my opinion, because of
blade flexing around the tiny wheels and because the ones I've seen looked
pretty cheesy. Delta's BS220LS 12" saw is a little bigger than I'd like, and
comes with a metal stand I'd have no use for (the saw needs to go on an
existing work table, due to limited space in the garage). Jet's smallest is
a 12", and doesn't look much different from the Delta 12" in either features
or disadvantages. Grizzly's G1052 9" saw looks attractive, at least to judge
from the marketing info on the web site - anyone have any experience with
this model?

Thanks for any comments,
Tom Dacon


  #4   Report Post  
Prometheus
 
Posts: n/a
Default


Anyone know of a Inca 340 for sale in good condition, and know where to get
parts? Failing that, what would the collective wisdom of the wreck recommend
in this situation? Delta used to have a 10" saw, but I've never seen any
chatter on the wreck about it, and I fear that it wouldn't actually be any
better than the 8".


I've got the Delta 9", and no, I don't think it's any better than what
you're describing. I doubt the 10" is much of a step up in quality
either. Good for very little stuff, but not much else.
  #5   Report Post  
Dave in Fairfax
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Prometheus wrote:
I've got the Delta 9", and no, I don't think it's any better than what
you're describing. I doubt the 10" is much of a step up in quality
either. Good for very little stuff, but not much else.


I'm giving my Delta 9" to my BIL who'lll use it for trim and stuff
around the house. I picked up the 12" Delta at Lowe's during
their clearance sale. It does what I need it to and despite the
number, seems to be the same size throat as the Grizzly 14". It
also has a 6" under guide size. Not the most powerful saw on the
block, but if you're only doing little stuff it'll do.

Dave in Fairfax
--
Dave Leader
reply-to doesn't work
use:
daveldr at att dot net
American Association of Woodturners
http://www.woodturner.org
Capital Area Woodturners
http://www.capwoodturners.org/
PATINA
http://www.Patinatools.org/


  #6   Report Post  
Joe Woody Woodpecker
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I have a Delta 28-195 10" band saw and I find it works great. When I
first sat it up, I mounted it to the stand that comes with it. This put
the table at eye level when sitting in my wheelchair cutting wood.
Later, I decided to make the band saw turn on my DC automatically and so
I removed the saw from the stand and sat it on a 20" HTC tool stand and
it became the right height for cutting wood while in my wheelchair. I
bolted the band saw to the tool stand and added a couple drawers and a
remote switch. Now when I turn on the saw, it in turn, turns on the DC
and my work light.

I have found that the three wheel units are more a hobbist unit for very
light duty work. The Delta 28-195 10" may have been discontinued with
the number change that Delta did on all of their products.

I would like to add that I also installed a stabilizer and a low tension
blade. The low tension blade & stabilizer allow no fuss with tension to
have a saw cut like a scroll saw. When I put the blade on after
installing the stabilizer, all I did was snap it onto the two wheels and
adjust the stabilizer.

--
Woody


Check out my Web Page at:

http://community-1.webtv.net/Woodwor...workerJoesInfo

Where you will find:

******** How My Shop Works ******** 5-21-03

* * * Build a $20 DC Separator Can Lid. 1-14-03
* * * DC Relay Box Building Plans. 1-14-03
* * * The Bad Air Your Breath Everyday.1-14-03
* * * What is a Real Woodworker? 2-8-03
* * * Murphy's Woodworking Definitions. 2-8-03
* * * Murphy's Woodworking Laws. 4-6-03
* * * What is the true meaning of life? 1-14-03
* * * Woodworker Shop Signs. 2-8-03

  #7   Report Post  
Tom Dacon
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Thanks for your comments, everyone -

Since I started this thread, I actually found a couple of Inca 340 bandsaws
for sale. I made an inquiry of Garrett Wade, and they connected me with a
company in Los Angeles named Eagle Tools (www.eagle-tools.com). Eagle has
some used Inca power tools for sale, and a couple of them are 340's. Their
technician has worked on Inca for many years, and presumably knows how to
get them in good shape. Garrett Wade, who stopped selling the Inca line a
couple of years ago when the company went out of business, still sells parts
for the line out of the spare parts inventory they bought from Lee Valley
some years before, and a lot of parts like bearings, belts, and blades can
be US-sourced.

Unfortunately, the price is way out of my budget for a small saw like that.
They quoted me a price of $696 more or less, depending on condition, and I
couldn't possibly justify spending that much, no matter how good the saw is
and how well it fits my needs. But if anyone is looking for what's said to
be a real fine small bandsaw, and can afford the price, give Jesse at Eagle
Tools a call. Phone number (323) 999-2909.

Tom Dacon

"Tom Dacon" wrote in message
...
I'm looking around for a good small woodworking bandsaw for my garage
shop. The one I've got right now is one of those little 8" Delta saws. I
think it's never seen a piece of wood that didn't scare its little heart
to death, even with cool blocks, a 3/8" blade, and all the tension I could
screw into the blade tensioner. About the only good experience I've ever
had with it was cutting rigid foam, and I've concluded that it's useful
only for taking up space that might be better occupied by a better tool.

This would be just a light-duty casual-use saw, rather than a workhorse
tool. I have the use of a friend's woodshop nearby, and if I have any
serious sawing to do I can use his 18" Grizzly, but I'd like this one to
be a competent tool even so.

A bandsaw in that general size range that I've heard good reports about,
long ago, is the Inca 340 10 1/2" saw, which Garrett Valley, or was it Lee
Wade -just kidding, folks! :-) - used to sell some years ago. I've been
all over google and google groups, and even ebay, looking for someone who
sells that line or has one they'd like to sell, and I can't turn up any
recent information on Inca tools at all, let alone on that saw. So maybe
they're out of business nowadays or have no American distributor, and
everyone who has one of those saws wouldn't dream of parting with it - who
knows?

Anyone know of a Inca 340 for sale in good condition, and know where to
get parts? Failing that, what would the collective wisdom of the wreck
recommend in this situation? Delta used to have a 10" saw, but I've never
seen any chatter on the wreck about it, and I fear that it wouldn't
actually be any better than the 8". Three-wheel saws are out, in my
opinion, because of blade flexing around the tiny wheels and because the
ones I've seen looked pretty cheesy. Delta's BS220LS 12" saw is a little
bigger than I'd like, and comes with a metal stand I'd have no use for
(the saw needs to go on an existing work table, due to limited space in
the garage). Jet's smallest is a 12", and doesn't look much different from
the Delta 12" in either features or disadvantages. Grizzly's G1052 9" saw
looks attractive, at least to judge from the marketing info on the web
site - anyone have any experience with this model?

Thanks for any comments,
Tom Dacon




  #8   Report Post  
Leuf
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On Sun, 31 Oct 2004 10:34:17 -0800, "Tom Dacon"
wrote:

I'm looking around for a good small woodworking bandsaw for my garage shop.
The one I've got right now is one of those little 8" Delta saws. I think
it's never seen a piece of wood that didn't scare its little heart to death,
even with cool blocks, a 3/8" blade, and all the tension I could screw into
the blade tensioner. About the only good experience I've ever had with it
was cutting rigid foam, and I've concluded that it's useful only for taking
up space that might be better occupied by a better tool.

This would be just a light-duty casual-use saw, rather than a workhorse
tool. I have the use of a friend's woodshop nearby, and if I have any
serious sawing to do I can use his 18" Grizzly, but I'd like this one to be
a competent tool even so.


I have the Ryobi 9", which I'm not sure they still make but it's
probably about in the same league as what you have already. It
vibrates like crazy, but it does well enough in softer hardwoods and
up to 3/4" oak if I ask it nicely, which is all I really got it for
anyway. I believe Sears has a 9" model, as I buy my replacement
blades for the Ryobi there, it's the only local place that has any
that small, but I would guess it's the same quality. Grizzly has a 9"
G1052 that's twice what we paid for the Ryobi so I would hope it's
leaps and bounds better, but for the money it's not that much more for
the 14" if you can find room for it.


-Leuf
Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Small bandsaw John UK diy 3 August 31st 04 09:25 PM
drive pin on R8 collets Charles A. Sherwood Metalworking 50 July 9th 04 05:41 AM
Good low-cost small sander? James Nipper Home Repair 8 February 25th 04 06:35 AM
Good place to buy a GOOD saw in Central FL???? (Tampa) Elmar Woodworking 8 December 17th 03 02:49 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:11 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"