Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Li tool warning - a really long rant Part 2
There's more to this.... I thought I would post a follow up to the Li
battery scheme. After talking to two reps and th HD guy their marketing schtick goes like this: + You will get almost double the duty cycles from our Li batteries than you did with NiCad batteries. Double!! That means a savings to you as a "pro" over the long haul! - But wait, if I have to charge them 3 - 4 times as much when in actual use, how did I come out ahead on that? I'll be underwater since the batteries won't "work" as long between charges... + Our new batteries only take 15 minutes to charge! - In the field: yeah, but they only last about 15% of the time as the 3 Ah batteries. + But we give you TWO batteries, so you can always be on the ready! - In the field: OK, so now I have NEED two batteries that I have to fiddle with to get to 30% performance of a real battery? If I drill a bunch of holes, then need the second battery and it isn't finished charging, then what? (See broken record response above) + Well, you could always buy a 3 Ah off the rack over there.... another $100 and you would be in business! - So let me get this right; I can buy a new tool that doesn't do what I want it to do, then back it up with an accessory that will let it perform as it should. And this accessory is almost 50% of the cost of the tool in question? + Well sir, if you buy Ridgid under this promotion and register properly, you will get lifetime coverage on batteries as well as the drill under normal use. (Note: Not all batteries on all cordless tools put out by Ridgid have this warranty; buy carefully) - Well sir, if I was working in a tight place and had to recharge my F'in drill every 5 - 6th hole, I would take a hammer and beat it to pieces. + Oh.... well, that wouldn't be covered under warranty, sir. OK.. seriously guys. What do you do with these pieces of crap? Is a Li $200 to $275 drill a homeowner drill? They had a few old DeWalt NiCads left on the shelf. With the XT batteries, they were pretty hard to beat. There is some talk that with the unpopularity of the Li (there are some temp problems with some) that DeWalt will continue on with the NiCad lines. They seem abundant on Amazon, and even new NiCad models are available. I guess the reason this ****es me off so much is that I got stung with the whole NiCad to NiMh battery switch. I still have a Makita that works well when charged, but I was disappointed that I spent $300 to upgrade from my favorite old DeWalt, only to find that I didn't get the performance of my $239 DeWalt compact drill driver. I felt like Makita burned me good, and since there wasn't anything technically wrong with the drill, after more than 90 days of wrestling with it, my vendor wouldn't take it back. So I have a $300 "shop only" drill. Verrrry practical. And it ****es me off any time I see it. It is a horse when charged, but will easily discharge (almost completely) itself in the truck when not used in about 2 weeks. It forced me to carry a corded drill for backup, which I never did when I had the DeWalt. DW seemed like it was always ready to go, and it would hold a good charge in the truck for a month. I don't want to get to a house to install new hardware and hinges and have to wait on the drill to charge every time. And I don't want to start carrying a backup drill for my front line drill again. OK, rant off. Buy these new "slim lines" or "compacts" at your own risk. I thought some here might be interested to see just what you would be getting when these things are on sale, or up at a good price for the holiday season. And if you think I was ****y, google around a bit and find posts from people that have spent their hard earned bucks on these. Robert |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Li tool warning - a really long rant Part 1 | Woodworking | |||
Tool ReReview - Refurb Delta Unisaw - Part Two (Long) | Woodworking | |||
Tool ReReview - Refurb Delta Unisaw - Part One (Long-what else?) | Woodworking | |||
BT, phones and more. Long rant. | UK diy | |||
Long Rant - Tool Addiction | Woodworking |