Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Anyone have plans or photos of an acoustic enclosure for a desktop computer?
Best, Christopher |
#2
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On Thu, 1 Oct 2009 09:51:42 -0700, "Christopher Glaeser"
wrote: Anyone have plans or photos of an acoustic enclosure for a desktop computer? What is an acoustic enclosure for a computer? Never heard of one before. |
#3
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
What is an acoustic enclosure for a computer? Never heard of one before.
Acoustic enclosures are used to reduce computer noise. One of my desktop computers has six hard drives and six fans. Kell Systems is one company that sells enclosures in this market. See http://www.kellsystems.com/ Features typically include noise reduction, air flow to extract heat, cable paths for power and peripherals, and doors for easy access. Best, Christopher |
#4
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
"Christopher Glaeser" wrote in message ... What is an acoustic enclosure for a computer? Never heard of one before. Acoustic enclosures are used to reduce computer noise. One of my desktop computers has six hard drives and six fans. Kell Systems is one company that sells enclosures in this market. See http://www.kellsystems.com/ Features typically include noise reduction, air flow to extract heat, cable paths for power and peripherals, and doors for easy access. Best, Christopher For a second I thought he meant an acoustic computer. (grin) If you are recording with a microphone on the computer, you find out just how loud the things are. Ed |
#5
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On Thu, 1 Oct 2009 10:31:23 -0700, "Christopher Glaeser"
wrote: Acoustic enclosures are used to reduce computer noise. One of my desktop computers has six hard drives and six fans. Kell Systems is one company that sells enclosures in this market. See http://www.kellsystems.com/ Ok, that sounds reasonable. In retrospect, I have heard of an acoustic enclosure before, just for printers, not computers. Noise from older computer systems of mine was something I used to just accept, having multiple SCSI drives and the fans to keep them cool. Then I upgraded a little while ago with fewer drives, forgoing SCSI for SATA drives and when I bought fans for it, I choose the ones with a smaller noise rating. The only problem I have now is that I bought an i7-650 extreme processor and a Cooler Master V10 cpu cooler to go with it. The cpu cooler is damned near the size of a football and I'm dreading trying to fit it in the case I've got even though it is a monster tower case. And no, I'm not going to try water cooling. |
#6
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Every other house in Nashville has a studio in the basement, so you see
all kind of crazy stuff. A fridge in the studio is a great thing to have for keeping water and juice and snacks and whatnot. One guy had a fridge, built into the wall. You couldn't hear this refrigerator when the compressor kicked on because it was behind the wall and he did a great job of sealing up around the fridge. This one was the kind with the cooler on top and the freezer on the bottom. He had disabled the freezer section and used it for the acoustic computer enclosure, with a fan and access in the back, from the other room. It was brilliant and worked like a charm. -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#7
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On Thu, 01 Oct 2009 13:13:42 -0500, -MIKE-
wrote: Every other house in Nashville has a studio in the basement, so you see all kind of crazy stuff. Makes me wonder about Nashville power requirements. What kind of power generation does Nashville use? Have they got their own nuclear power reactor? |
#9
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On Thu, 1 Oct 2009 09:51:42 -0700, "Christopher Glaeser"
wrote: Anyone have plans or photos of an acoustic enclosure for a desktop computer? Best, Christopher Start with a quiet tower PC case with 120mm slow-running fans. Put the computer on a carpeted floor. Replace many hard drives with a 1T HD. The only thing I built is a wheeled base, made from some scrap pine, painted black with a front pull. |
#10
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Replace many hard drives with a 1T HD.
Or, I could use an HP calculator; those are pretty quiet. FWIW, I have 10 terrabyes of storage that includes a system drive, data drive and raid array. Squeezing into a single 1TB HD is not an option. I was thinking more of a woodworking solution. Best, Christopher |
#11
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Christopher Glaeser wrote:
Replace many hard drives with a 1T HD. Or, I could use an HP calculator; those are pretty quiet. FWIW, I have 10 terrabyes of storage that includes a system drive, data drive and raid array. Squeezing into a single 1TB HD is not an option. I was thinking more of a woodworking solution. That isn't a desktop computer, it is a server, or should be. Why not just network into it, then you could move the machine far away from your desk? i.e. got a garage, closet etc. where the noise would not be an issue. -- Froz... |
#12
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
That isn't a desktop computer, it is a server, or should be.
It's a desktop computer for video editing. Silly me, I thought if I posted to the woodworking forum, someone would suggest a solution that would use one of those tools with a round wheel with sharp teeth, um, I think they are called table saws. My apologies for the technical jargon. Perhaps if I post this question to a computer forum they will provide plans for a 3/4" birch plywood enclosure. I'll let you guys get back to whatever it is you discuss on this forum. Certainly can't be woodworking. Best, Christopher |
#13
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Christopher Glaeser wrote:
That isn't a desktop computer, it is a server, or should be. It's a desktop computer for video editing. Silly me, I thought if I posted to the woodworking forum, someone would suggest a solution that would use one of those tools with a round wheel with sharp teeth, um, I think they are called table saws. My apologies for the technical jargon. Perhaps if I post this question to a computer forum they will provide plans for a 3/4" birch plywood enclosure. I'll let you guys get back to whatever it is you discuss on this forum. Certainly can't be woodworking. Best, Christopher HAHAHHAHA, now you know. Took the words right out of my mouth. :-) -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#14
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On Oct 1, 4:00*pm, "Christopher Glaeser" wrote:
Replace many hard drives with a 1T HD. Or, I could use an HP calculator; those are pretty quiet. FWIW, I have 10 terrabyes of storage that includes a system drive, data drive and raid array. *Squeezing into a single 1TB HD is not an option. *I was thinking more of a woodworking solution. Best, Christopher Is most of this noise transmitted via vibration or is it airborne? IOW.. can you feel the case vibrate? |
#15
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Robatoy wrote:
Is most of this noise transmitted via vibration or is it airborne? IOW.. can you feel the case vibrate? I don't know if we're still referring to studio use, but it's mostly the fan and drive noise, not vibration, that bug people. -- -MIKE- "Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life" --Elvin Jones (1927-2004) -- http://mikedrums.com ---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply |
#16
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Is most of this noise transmitted via vibration or is it airborne?
IOW.. can you feel the case vibrate? Vibration is relatively low. There is some noise due to the six drives, but most of the noise is due to all the fans (fans for dual cpu chips, fan for hign-end graphics card, and multiple fans for power and enclosure). A Kell System enclosure would be ideal, but they are pricey (though I'm sure they are worth it). I expect a reasonable design would use 1/2" or 3/4" birch plywood lined with carpeting and/or sound proofing material. One key feature is the air flow. Needs to cool 600-800 watts, yet baffle the noise inside the enclosure. Several superquiete 120mm fans could be used to exchange the air. Another feature is the door. Needs to provide easy access, but also a seal to minimize noise. I've seen plans on the net to build the computer case out of wood. I have no desire to do that. I want the ability to swap in a new computer every couple of years, but keep the acoustic enclosure. Best, Christopher |
#17
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
I don't know if we're still referring to studio use, but it's mostly the
fan and drive noise, not vibration, that bug people. Correct. The problem is also cumulative. The 24 port gigabit switch is noticable but not really annoying, the NAS is noticable but not annoying, the video editing station is somewhat loud but tolerable, etc, etc, but with everything running, it's an annoying wind tunnel. My goal is to tackle the loudest PC first, and then perhaps add more acoustic enclosures as needed. Best, Christopher |
#18
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On 10/01/2009 11:31 AM, Christopher Glaeser wrote:
What is an acoustic enclosure for a computer? Never heard of one before. Acoustic enclosures are used to reduce computer noise. One of my desktop computers has six hard drives and six fans. My first suggestion would be to get rid of some of the fans if possible, or at least slow them down. I cut my system noise way down by using only one case fan. Chris |
#19
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On 10/01/2009 02:53 PM, Christopher Glaeser wrote:
That isn't a desktop computer, it is a server, or should be. It's a desktop computer for video editing. Silly me, I thought if I posted to the woodworking forum, someone would suggest a solution that would use one of those tools with a round wheel with sharp teeth, um, I think they are called table saws. Actually, from an overall perspective his post is a good one. A sound absorbing enclosure would kill the sound somewhat, but it's going to be big and bulky. Better to move the noise elsewhere to start with. Here's what I'd do, starting with free and moving progressively more expensive. 1) Move as much noise as possible out of the room completely. This includes things like your NAS and your gigabit switch. 2) Reduce the power requirements on the computer as much as possible. Without changing the hardware this basically means move stuff from your 10TB of local disks to the NAS. Ideally you want to get rid of entire drives from your desktop machine. Reduce the number of case fans and/or run them as slowly as possible without causing too much heat buildup. 3) Enclose the tower in a sound absorbing enclosure. I'd go with a large box made of MDF or particleboard (solid wood resonates more), with sound absorbing panels on the inside and mass-loaded acoustic barrier sheets on the outside, with baffled air intake and exit. You want the air to have to travel in a zigzag pattern so that there is no direct path for sound to escape. 4) Reduce the noise on the remaining components. This starts to cost money. Use quieter/fewer fans, more efficient cpus, quieter heatsinks, quieter video cards, quieter power supplies, cases designed for cooling and sound absorption, quieter/cooler hard drives, etc. Basically go and read www.silentpcreview.com. Chris |
#20
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Since this is taking the course it is, I will throw this out. It's a friggen
box. How hard is it to make a box? "Christopher Glaeser" wrote in message ... That isn't a desktop computer, it is a server, or should be. It's a desktop computer for video editing. Silly me, I thought if I posted to the woodworking forum, someone would suggest a solution that would use one of those tools with a round wheel with sharp teeth, um, I think they are called table saws. My apologies for the technical jargon. Perhaps if I post this question to a computer forum they will provide plans for a 3/4" birch plywood enclosure. I'll let you guys get back to whatever it is you discuss on this forum. Certainly can't be woodworking. Since this is taking the course it is, I will throw this out. It's a friggen box. How hard is it to make a box? |
#21
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
"CW" wrote in message m... Since this is taking the course it is, I will throw this out. It's a friggen box. How hard is it to make a box? -- It is easy to make a box. But to make it so it absorbs sound and still allow sufficient cooling/air flow at the same time is a bit more difficult. I have installed those anechoic wedge foam blocks in recording studios before. It is expensive but works well. You would have to make sure the air still got through though. |
#22
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
2) Reduce the power requirements on the computer as much as possible.
Without changing the hardware this basically means move stuff from your 10TB of local disks to the NAS. The local RAID is required for uncompressed HD video editing. You want the air to have to travel in a zigzag pattern so that there is no direct path for sound to escape. I was thinking along the same lines, but check out the 3D Model Tour at http://www.kellsystems.com/3d.asp#tab9 It appears the air intake is at the bottom back of the unit, and the air exhausts are a relatively simple modular package at attach to the back of the unit. Each exhaust module has three fans at an angle that force the air down and out through side ports. Is that how you imterpret this model? In other words, all of the Kell air flow is at the back from bottom to top. They make no attempt to force air to the front of the rack, so each rack unit is responsible for pulling air into the front and out the back, and then the air exchange happens at the back where the Kell vertical air flow exchanges with the rack unit exhaust. Is that the way you see it? Best, Christopher PS: Pause the video as necessary to examine the exhausts. |
#23
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Since this is taking the course it is, I will throw this out. It's a
friggen box. How hard is it to make a box? If the only requirement was a box, sure, the project would be trivial with not much planning needed. However, a major design objective is to significantly reduce noise while providing adequate air flow, which requires a bit more thought and planning. Best, Christopher |
#24
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Christopher Glaeser wrote:
That isn't a desktop computer, it is a server, or should be. It's a desktop computer for video editing. Silly me, I thought if I posted to the woodworking forum, someone would suggest a solution that would use one of those tools with a round wheel with sharp teeth, um, I think they are called table saws. My apologies for the technical jargon. Perhaps if I post this question to a computer forum they will provide plans for a 3/4" birch plywood enclosure. I'll let you guys get back to whatever it is you discuss on this forum. Certainly can't be woodworking. You didn't specify the usage of the machine before, now I know why you need all that local. But the box can still be located elsewhere, there are IP based remote solutions, have you researched the option? Even extending the keyboard, video and mouse cables may allow you to get it around a corner or something to cut the noise. Building a box that will absorb sound and provide the cooling requirements for a computer like that is non-trivial. -- Froz... |
#25
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Find an old Printer enclosure. It is a lid opening box and it has thick
foam on the inside area. The issue you will come in with is air. Cooling a working computer in an box isn't easy. Not silent. Perhaps in stead of asking for what you did - you might tell us why or for what reason. Might be just a different computer to solve the problem. Might be exotic water cooled... Martin Christopher Glaeser wrote: Anyone have plans or photos of an acoustic enclosure for a desktop computer? Best, Christopher |
#26
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On Oct 1, 6:49*pm, "Martin H. Eastburn"
wrote: Find an old Printer enclosure. *It is a lid opening box and it has thick foam on the inside area. *The issue you will come in with is air. *Cooling a working computer in an box isn't easy. * Might be just a different computer to solve the problem. *Might be exotic water cooled... Most desktop computers cool by turbulent circulation of air, which generates high-frequency 'ssss' sound, in addition to a few low- frequency components from disk rotation and fan bearings. Soundproofing, like in a studio, relies on baffling and putting high density barriers in low density mediums (lead sheet will stop a LOT of sound from air, less of conducted sound in wood). So, one approach is to use heavy panels (like, liquid nails assemblies of two or three thicknesses of sheetrock/drywall/gypsum board) and supporting the computer inside the box with soft foam pads. There has to be an air inlet and outlet, so either use a labyrinth box-with-baffles as an air channel, or close the thing comletely and put an air/water heat exchanger (ask at an auto radiator shop, they can build up a small core easily enough) and remove heat through water circulation. Sound-deadening carpentry includes sand-filled panels (Wharfedale speakers, I think, used this) and humble MDF-glue construction (also a favorite of speaker designers). Best, though, is to remove the disks and power-hungry parts to another room. Sound studios can keep laptops in the quiet room, and used 'em to remote-control the real mix computers elsewhere... rubber-chicklet keyboards and trackpads can be quieter than standard keyboard/mouse. |
#27
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Might be just a different computer to solve the problem.
The computer I'm using was $8,200. I can see I'm pushing a string here. Thank you everyone for all the computer suggestions; I know the intent was in the right place. Best, Christopher |
#28
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
"Christopher Glaeser" wrote in
: Anyone have plans or photos of an acoustic enclosure for a desktop computer? Best, Christopher Model railroaders often complain of noise from their trains, and go through several lengths building the benchwork to minimize the noise. The track base consists of plywood and homasote, a pressed paper like material. There are no nails from the track in to the plywood, and in most cases the homasote is glued to the plywood. This helps quiet the vibration noise. (Some of us simply use thicker plywood that doesn't transmit sound like the thinner stuff.) What about pictures and plans for a shop vac enclosure? They'd seem to have the same problems of heat and noise. Puckdropper -- "The potential difference between the top and bottom of a tree is the reason why all trees have to be grounded..." -- Bored Borg on rec.woodworking To email me directly, send a message to puckdropper (at) fastmail.fm |
#29
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
IF the machine doesn't need 3d accelerated graphics or full motion video,
then a thin client might be a possibility--there are several ways to set that up--a netbook or a mini-itx system does fine as a thin client and they can be made as quiet as a lamp, while you can put the main machine in another room. If you haven't checked out http://www.silentpcreview.com you might want to. Search that site with keyword "wood" and you'll find some discussion of wooden cases and some articles by people who have tried them. If your objective is to do a woodworking project by all means have at it, but if the objective is to have a quiet machine in a reasonable time then I think that buying one is going to be a better plan. |
#30
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
|
#31
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
"J. Clarke" wrote in message ... IF the machine doesn't need 3d accelerated graphics or full motion video, then a thin client might be a possibility--there are several ways to set that up--a netbook or a mini-itx system does fine as a thin client and they can be made as quiet as a lamp, while you can put the main machine in another room. If you haven't checked out http://www.silentpcreview.com you might want to. Search that site with keyword "wood" and you'll find some discussion of wooden cases and some articles by people who have tried them. If your objective is to do a woodworking project by all means have at it, but if the objective is to have a quiet machine in a reasonable time then I think that buying one is going to be a better plan. I have not read all of the posts in this thread. But, if one's objective is to have a quiet machine, then building one with a graphics cards having ambient cooling is a good start. Giga-byte makes some. I think their URL is giga-byte.com I like mine. If you want a quiet machine, you will probably need to build it yourself. The specifications of most components will list their sound level in db. As may have been pointed out, "water cooling" may offer the quietest system--but I'm not willing to bother with that yet. Bill |
#32
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
"Christopher Glaeser" wrote in message FWIW, I have 10 terrabyes of storage that includes a system drive, data drive and raid array. Squeezing into a single 1TB HD is not an option. I was thinking more of a woodworking solution. Perhaps there's other options. I'm not too far removed from your 10 terabytes with a total of more than 7 TB, but 6 TB (4x1.5 TB drives) are located in a USB connected satellite case, which is extremely small and quiet. And with that I plan on increasing transfer speed soon by replacing the USB connection with a Firewire 800 connection, which the satellite case has. |
#33
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
"Christopher Glaeser" wrote in message If the only requirement was a box, sure, the project would be trivial with not much planning needed. However, a major design objective is to significantly reduce noise while providing adequate air flow, which requires a bit more thought and planning. If it helps you any, I built a padded box around my portable compress to stifle the noise when I use it in my apartment. It's a simple 3/4" plywood box, four rubber wheeled casters and lined with furnace air intake filters. It reduces the noise over 50%. Air intake is sufficient by the use of an interior 120v fan and the air to it is supplied through several layers of speaker grill cloth. If it does that well on an 85 decibel compressor, it should be sufficient for a computer box. |
#34
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Bill wrote:
"J. Clarke" wrote in message ... IF the machine doesn't need 3d accelerated graphics or full motion video, then a thin client might be a possibility--there are several ways to set that up--a netbook or a mini-itx system does fine as a thin client and they can be made as quiet as a lamp, while you can put the main machine in another room. If you haven't checked out http://www.silentpcreview.com you might want to. Search that site with keyword "wood" and you'll find some discussion of wooden cases and some articles by people who have tried them. If your objective is to do a woodworking project by all means have at it, but if the objective is to have a quiet machine in a reasonable time then I think that buying one is going to be a better plan. I have not read all of the posts in this thread. But, if one's objective is to have a quiet machine, then building one with a graphics cards having ambient cooling is a good start. Giga-byte makes some. I think their URL is giga-byte.com I like mine. If you want a quiet machine, you will probably need to build it yourself. The specifications of most components will list their sound level in db. As may have been pointed out, "water cooling" may offer the quietest system--but I'm not willing to bother with that yet. Reviewing the entire thread it's clear that the OP doesn't want a quiet machine, he wants a cabinet to hold a noisy one. Googling "DIY computer isolation box" will yield a good deal of useful material. |
#35
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On 10/01/2009 07:06 PM, Christopher Glaeser wrote:
2) Reduce the power requirements on the computer as much as possible. Without changing the hardware this basically means move stuff from your 10TB of local disks to the NAS. The local RAID is required for uncompressed HD video editing. You want the air to have to travel in a zigzag pattern so that there is no direct path for sound to escape. I was thinking along the same lines, but check out the 3D Model Tour at http://www.kellsystems.com/3d.asp#tab9 It appears the air intake is at the bottom back of the unit, and the air exhausts are a relatively simple modular package at attach to the back of the unit. The way I interpret that video is that the air intakes are at the bottom and top but near the front. (They advertise "front to back airflow" in the text".) The exit is at the back. For a tower enclosure I'd just do intake at the front and exit at the back, but with zigzag passages lined with sound absorber panels. If you've got carpet it may be beneficial to orient the openings facing downwards to get a bit more muffling effect. You probably want the enclosure to fit fairly snugly around the side of the tower to avoid warm exhaust mixing with the incoming cool air. Chris |
#36
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Chris Friesen wrote:
On 10/01/2009 07:06 PM, Christopher Glaeser wrote: 2) Reduce the power requirements on the computer as much as possible. Without changing the hardware this basically means move stuff from your 10TB of local disks to the NAS. The local RAID is required for uncompressed HD video editing. You want the air to have to travel in a zigzag pattern so that there is no direct path for sound to escape. I was thinking along the same lines, but check out the 3D Model Tour at http://www.kellsystems.com/3d.asp#tab9 It appears the air intake is at the bottom back of the unit, and the air exhausts are a relatively simple modular package at attach to the back of the unit. The way I interpret that video is that the air intakes are at the bottom and top but near the front. (They advertise "front to back airflow" in the text".) The exit is at the back. For a tower enclosure I'd just do intake at the front and exit at the back, but with zigzag passages lined with sound absorber panels. If you've got carpet it may be beneficial to orient the openings facing downwards to get a bit more muffling effect. You probably want the enclosure to fit fairly snugly around the side of the tower to avoid warm exhaust mixing with the incoming cool air. Consider that the Kell cabinets are not intended to render a machine recording-studio quiet, they are intended to reduce a racket of servers to a tolerable rack. |
#37
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Reviewing the entire thread it's clear that the OP doesn't want a quiet
machine, he wants a cabinet to hold a noisy one. Thanks, this car keeps veering off the road, and I appreciate your efforts to regain control of the steering wheel. It was probably a mistake to mention the word "computer". In hind sight I should have said "acoustic enclosure for noisy doohicky" and avoided all the discussions about replacing videos cards etc. Googling "DIY computer isolation box" will yield a good deal of useful material. I had not tried that particular Google phrase and that did turn up some new ideas. Thanks again. Best, Christopher |
#38
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
The way I interpret that video is that the air intakes are at the bottom
and top but near the front. (They advertise "front to back airflow" in the text".) The exit is at the back. Yeah, I watched it again and I think you are right. It's interesting that all the wiring in the back is sealed within soft foam panels. Originally I had assumed that was to reduce noise, but now I'm guessing the major reason is to ensure air flow comes from the front, as you point out. For a tower enclosure I'd just do intake at the front and exit at the back, Yes, I should probably do that for a desktop as well. but with zigzag passages lined with sound absorber panels. If you've got carpet it may be beneficial to orient the openings facing downwards to get a bit more muffling effect. I was thinking either carpet with a non-straight patter as you suggest, or posssibly using the egg crate foam used in sound studios that directs the sound waves into the foam channels. You probably want the enclosure to fit fairly snugly around the side of the tower to avoid warm exhaust mixing with the incoming cool air. At first I was thinking I could rely on an air exchange at the back, but I think you're right, I should design something that puts the incoming air at the front of the equipment, perhaps using a false bottom or false side to redirect the air flow so there is no straight line path from the inside to the outside of the acoustic enclosure. Best, Christopher |
#39
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
Christopher Glaeser wrote:
Is most of this noise transmitted via vibration or is it airborne? IOW.. can you feel the case vibrate? Vibration is relatively low. There is some noise due to the six drives, but most of the noise is due to all the fans (fans for dual cpu chips, fan for hign-end graphics card, and multiple fans for power and enclosure). A Kell System enclosure would be ideal, but they are pricey (though I'm sure they are worth it). I expect a reasonable design would use 1/2" or 3/4" birch plywood lined with carpeting and/or sound proofing material. One key feature is the air flow. Needs to cool 600-800 watts, yet baffle the noise inside the enclosure. Several superquiete 120mm fans could be used to exchange the air. Another feature is the door. Needs to provide easy access, but also a seal to minimize noise. I've seen plans on the net to build the computer case out of wood. I have no desire to do that. I want the ability to swap in a new computer every couple of years, but keep the acoustic enclosure. Best, Christopher Have you considered putting the whole tower into a dorm type refrigerator modified for cable exits? -- Jack Novak Buffalo, NY - USA |
#40
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
plans for acoustic computer enclosure?
On Oct 2, 10:24*am, "Christopher Glaeser" wrote:
Reviewing the entire thread it's clear that the OP doesn't want a quiet machine, he wants a cabinet to hold a noisy one. Thanks, this car keeps veering off the road, and I appreciate your efforts to regain control of the steering wheel. *It was probably a mistake to mention the word "computer". *In hind sight I should have said "acoustic enclosure for noisy doohicky" and avoided all the discussions about replacing videos cards etc. Googling "DIY computer isolation box" will yield a good deal of useful material. I had not tried that particular Google phrase and that did turn up some new ideas. *Thanks again. Whichever way you go, you may want to consider using an indoor/outdoor thermometer to keep an eye on actual in-the-box temps. Best of luck, and happy building! |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Acoustic Trickle Vents? | UK diy | |||
Acoustic Ceilings - Read it all here... | Home Repair | |||
Acoustic Ceilings - Read it all here... | Woodworking | |||
Acoustic Glass..... | UK diy | |||
acoustic damping solutions | UK diy |