Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an extension (thread a couple of
months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other day
and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a domestic
property, but is there any other reason not to?

Cheers


Dave R

--
Windows 8.1 on PCSpecialist box

On 08/07/16 14:42, David wrote:
Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an extension (thread a couple of
months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other day
and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a domestic
property, but is there any other reason not to?

Cheers


Dave R


If it were me, I'd consider zinc or aluminium.

David wrote:

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other day
and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.
I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a domestic
property, but is there any other reason not to?

Noise? ether when it rains, or possible annoying clicky noises when it
expands/contracts ...

Is that not going to generate a lot of noise when it rains?
Brian

--
----- -
This newsgroup posting comes to you directly from...
The Sofa of Brian Gaff...

Blind user, so no pictures please!
"Tim Watts" wrote in message
...
On 08/07/16 14:42, David wrote:
Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an extension (thread a couple
of
months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other day
and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a
domestic
property, but is there any other reason not to?

Cheers


Dave R


If it were me, I'd consider zinc or aluminium.

On Friday, 8 July 2016 14:42:46 UTC+1, David wrote:
Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an extension (thread a couple of
months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other day
and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a domestic
property, but is there any other reason not to?

It works well. But eventually it'll be a rusting eyesore.


NT

David wrote:
Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an extension (thread a
couple of months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other
day and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a
domestic property, but is there any other reason not to?

Cheers


Dave R

Many years ago when I lived in Australia :-( some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

On 08/07/16 16:37, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:
David wrote:
Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an extension (thread a
couple of months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other
day and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a
domestic property, but is there any other reason not to?

Cheers


Dave R

Many years ago when I lived in Australia :-( some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.


I lived in a tin roofed converted garden shed in S Africa. When it
hailed, which it did, often, it was deafening.

Mind you it wasn't insulated either.



--
The biggest threat to humanity comes from socialism, which has utterly
diverted our attention away from what really matters to our existential
survival, to indulging in navel gazing and faux moral investigations
into what the world ought to be, whilst we fail utterly to deal with
what it actually is.

On Friday, 8 July 2016 17:39:39 UTC+1, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 08/07/16 16:37, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:
David wrote:
Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an extension (thread a
couple of months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other
day and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a
domestic property, but is there any other reason not to?

Many years ago when I lived in Australia :-( some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.


I lived in a tin roofed converted garden shed in S Africa. When it
hailed, which it did, often, it was deafening.

Mind you it wasn't insulated either.

I assume that insulation, joists & ceiling would much reduce the noise.


NT

wrote
The Natural Philosopher wrote
Mr Pounder Esquire wrote
David wrote

Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an
extension (thread a couple of months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other
day and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a
domestic property, but is there any other reason not to?

I'd personally have galvanised instead of powder coated.

Many years ago when I lived in Australia :-(
some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Even sillier than you usually manage.

I lived in a tin roofed converted garden shed in S Africa.
When it hailed, which it did, often, it was deafening.

I just dont believe that it hails anywhere often.

Mind you it wasn't insulated either.

I assume that insulation, joists & ceiling would much reduce the noise.

They dont actually with hail. But it isnt hard to have rockwool or similar
insulation immediately under the metal decking with chicken wire under
that which holds the rockwool up against the underside of the decking
which makes a hell of a difference with heavy rain.

On Fri, 08 Jul 2016 16:23:15 +0100, Brian Gaff wrote:

Is that not going to generate a lot of noise when it rains?
Brian

We have a powder coated steel roof on our house extension (specialist
roofing from Tata Steel) but this is designed to look like a zinc roof. It
is a number of sheets with crimped joints. Looks pretty good.

It isn't particularly noisy in heavy rain because it is laid on wooden
sheets (can't now remember if they were OSB or chip board) designed for
roofing.

Under that is a significant amount of Celotex (or similar) to modern
building regs.

However here I am looking at the corrugated (square section) roofing more
commonly used in agricultural buildings.

It won't look pretty, but it should be durable. Possibly as durable as
torch on felt.

It has just occurred to me that if it does get worn out (or at least
rusty) then all you have to do is unscrew the bolts and bolt new metal
sheeting in place.

Just idly toying with the idea at the moment, but it could be an
interesting option.

Cheers


Dave R



--
Windows 8.1 on PCSpecialist box

In article ,
David wrote:
We have a powder coated steel roof on our house extension (specialist
roofing from Tata Steel) but this is designed to look like a zinc roof.
It is a number of sheets with crimped joints. Looks pretty good.

It isn't particularly noisy in heavy rain because it is laid on wooden
sheets (can't now remember if they were OSB or chip board) designed for
roofing.

Under that is a significant amount of Celotex (or similar) to modern
building regs.

Yes - that's unlikely to be much different to a felt roof as the mass of
the board stops it resonating as well as attenuating the noise. As will
the plasterboard ceiling.

Steel sheets with no boarding are likely a different matter.

--
*Work is for people who don't know how to fish.

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:33:48 UTC+1, wrote:
On Friday, 8 July 2016 14:42:46 UTC+1, David wrote:
Looking at replacing a small flat roof on an extension (thread a couple of
months ago).

Expected cost around £1k.

I was looking at the powder coated steel roof of our shed the other day
and thinking that it was looking pretty good 3 years or more on.

I know that this is not a traditional finish for a flat roof on a domestic
property, but is there any other reason not to?

It works well. But eventually it'll be a rusting eyesore.


NT

There is a similar alternative made out of zinc. Expensive.

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Weatherlawyer wrote
Mr Pounder Esquire wrote

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

Not necessarily, we have a wet winter at the moment.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The
major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints.

Not with metal decking which has no joints at all where
the water is, it is one continuous length with the joints
well up from the deck itself where there is no water.

Tin flexes in violent winds and expands
and contracts a lot more than stone or clay.

Yes.

Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall.

Not when they are long and thin with the joint well up from
the deck. Which is why metal decking is done that way.

I imagine going around the finished product with
a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

You're wrong. The way to fix the problem is the way
metal decking does it, very long sheets that have no
joints at all where the water is with the joints between
the individual sheets of decking well up out of the water.
Works very well indeed and very easy to lift up a sheet
to get at the wiring etc and put it back again too.

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred on hot sunny days?

--
Women claim that they never pursue a man. Well, by the same token, a mousetrap never pursues a mouse, but the end result is
the same.

James Wilkinson wrote
Weatherlawyer wrote
Mr Pounder Esquire wrote

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is
preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and
expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being
both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished
product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred
on hot sunny days?

Not when the roof is designed properly so the metal can move.

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:48:01 +0100, "James Wilkinson"
wrote:

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred on hot sunny days?

I recently had a shed roof [Corrougated Steel] replaced, one of the
items charged for that was not included with the original was a tub of
grease. This it turns out was to lubricate the overlapping flashing
that covers the wall/ roof at the edges that don't drain.

Not sure how long it lasts though and I dont see any grease noipples
anywhere for the service :-(

AB

---
This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 22:07:54 +0100, Archibald Tarquin Blenkinsopp wrote:

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:48:01 +0100, "James Wilkinson"
wrote:

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred on hot sunny days?

I recently had a shed roof [Corrougated Steel] replaced, one of the
items charged for that was not included with the original was a tub of
grease. This it turns out was to lubricate the overlapping flashing
that covers the wall/ roof at the edges that don't drain.

Not sure how long it lasts though and I dont see any grease noipples
anywhere for the service :-(

If you want your nipples greased, you need someone other than a tradesman ;-)

--
*Squawk!* Pieces of Nine! Pieces of Nine! [Parroty error]

On Saturday, 9 July 2016 21:48:12 UTC+1, James Wilkinson wrote:
On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred on hot sunny days?

Like the sealant strips always do you mean?

"Weatherlawyer" wrote in message
...
On Saturday, 9 July 2016 21:48:12 UTC+1, James Wilkinson wrote:
On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer
wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is
preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and
expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being
both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished
product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred
on hot sunny days?

Like the sealant strips always do you mean?

You're typing to a known ****.

On Sun, 10 Jul 2016 02:15:07 +0100, Weatherlawyer wrote:

On Saturday, 9 July 2016 21:48:12 UTC+1, James Wilkinson wrote:
On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred on hot sunny days?

Like the sealant strips always do you mean?

Dunno, I have tiles.

--
Experience is what you got by not having it when you need it.

"James Wilkinson" wrote in message
news
On Sun, 10 Jul 2016 02:15:07 +0100, Weatherlawyer
wrote:

On Saturday, 9 July 2016 21:48:12 UTC+1, James Wilkinson wrote:
On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer
wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem
is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds
and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets
being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the
finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure
that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing
occurred on hot sunny days?

Like the sealant strips always do you mean?

Dunno, I have tiles.

Dunno is right.
Dunno **** all.
****.

On Saturday, 9 July 2016 22:08:04 UTC+1, Archibald Tarquin Blenkinsopp wrote:
On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:48:01 +0100, "James Wilkinson"
wrote:

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred on hot sunny days?

I recently had a shed roof [Corrugated Steel] replaced, one of the
items charged for that was not included with the original was a tub of
grease. This it turns out was to lubricate the overlapping flashing
that covers the wall/ roof at the edges that don't drain.

Not sure how long it lasts though and I don't see any grease nipples
anywhere for the service.

Would it have been to allow movement as things expand and contract?

Zinc reacts with sunlight so they used to paint the roof after putting it on. It comes ready treated these days. Why would they use a metal flashing that could rust?

On Sat, 9 Jul 2016 18:21:21 -0700 (PDT), Weatherlawyer
wrote:

On Saturday, 9 July 2016 22:08:04 UTC+1, Archibald Tarquin Blenkinsopp wrote:
On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:48:01 +0100, "James Wilkinson"
wrote:

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 21:18:32 +0100, Weatherlawyer wrote:

On Friday, 8 July 2016 16:37:18 UTC+1, Mr Pounder Esquire wrote:

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred on hot sunny days?

I recently had a shed roof [Corrugated Steel] replaced, one of the
items charged for that was not included with the original was a tub of
grease. This it turns out was to lubricate the overlapping flashing
that covers the wall/ roof at the edges that don't drain.

Not sure how long it lasts though and I don't see any grease nipples
anywhere for the service.

Would it have been to allow movement as things expand and contract?

Yes it is, I think the flat stuff is aluminum. It is bent over the
wall and continues down it for about 400mm. Around a metre lies on the
corrugate. The corrugate was cemented to the wall around half a block
from the top. I suspect that the new corrugate is no longer fixed to
the wall as that was the point where it rusted. I will ask the person
that did the repair as it is around two years since the work was done
and in the warm weather there is the occasional clang from the roof.

Zinc reacts with sunlight so they used to paint the roof after putting it on. It comes ready treated these days. Why would they use a metal flashing that could rust?

The flashing doesn't rust. Sorry I didn't make things clear.

I think the corrugate was treated, most of it was in perfect
condition. Only the bits close to the cement bridging the corrugate
and wall were rusted.

AB

---
This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus

On Sat, 09 Jul 2016 22:03:35 +0100, Rod Speed wrote:

James Wilkinson wrote
Weatherlawyer wrote
Mr Pounder Esquire wrote

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is
preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and
expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being
both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished
product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing occurred
on hot sunny days?

Not when the roof is designed properly so the metal can move.

If the metal moves, the solder is put under strain.

--
Pat Glenn, weightlifting commentator - "And this is Gregoriava from Bulgaria. I saw her snatch this morning and it was amazing!"

James Wilkinson wrote
Rod Speed wrote
James Wilkinson wrote
Weatherlawyer wrote
Mr Pounder Esquire wrote

Many years ago when I lived in Australia some houses had "tin" roofs.
Apparently when it rained the noise was awful.

Made up for, no doubt, by the fact it was raining.

The tin has several inches of insulation under it. The major problem is
preserving the weather seal at joints. Tin flexes in violent winds and
expands and contracts a lot more than stone or clay. Large sheets being
both a blessing and a downfall. I imagine going around the finished
product with a soldering iron might be the only way to cure that.

Wouldn't the solder tend to come away from the steel when flexing
occurred on hot sunny days?

Not when the roof is designed properly so the metal can move.

If the metal moves, the solder is put under strain.

Not if the design allows the metal to move without any strain.

That's how metal decking works, there are clips under the decking
and no screws thru the decking at all so there is no strain on the
metal at all as it heats up and cools down with the weather. Don't
get any clicking from the decking either.