Hi

I posted here a week or so back asking what woodworking machines people
recommended for a workshop that would initially be used for a house
renovation project.

Well I've got a fairly limited budget so I've been looking at the Axminster
own brand tools as follows

Axminster compound mitre saw 300mm - Axminster part MS12C
Axminster saw bench - Aminster part BTS10P
Perform planer thicknesser - Aminster part CCNPT

I'm also going to upgrade my current fixed speed Bosch router to a 1/2"
Axminster model AW127R

What sort of experiences have people had with these machines?
Any problems?
Any comments on this machinery setup?

Cheers
Chris

"Chris Harris" wrote in message ...
Hi

I posted here a week or so back asking what woodworking machines people
recommended for a workshop that would initially be used for a house
renovation project.

Well I've got a fairly limited budget so I've been looking at the Axminster
own brand tools as follows

Axminster compound mitre saw 300mm - Axminster part MS12C
Axminster saw bench - Aminster part BTS10P
Perform planer thicknesser - Aminster part CCNPT

I'm also going to upgrade my current fixed speed Bosch router to a 1/2"
Axminster model AW127R


I can't imagine what sort of use that a planer thicknesser is going to
be to you. For a lot less money you could take what few items you
might have to a workshop or timberyardand pay for a real machine to do
it.

DIY planer thicknessers are toys.

On Thu, 3 Jul 2003 09:52:51 -0400, "Chris Harris"
wrote:

Axminster saw bench - Aminster part BTS10P

I don't know how close this might be to your needs or preference, but
I often remember a potential bargain when I see one, even if it's not
something I could make use of myself.

http://www.screwfix.com/app/sfd/cat/...49776&id=92632

It may make your day, with any luck, here's hoping anyway!

Good for carving a large roast penguin come xmas day too I 'd guess.
;O)

I have some judiciously selected Ferm stuff, and while is not always
the latest thing, trying to provide fair quality at a fair price seem
to be something they are familiar with, not as common as it used to
be. Of course if it has to look the part too, then it quite probably
won't do! ;O)

Worth a look I guess.

Take Care,
Gnube

Andy Hall wrote:

On Fri, 4 Jul 2003 14:55:55 -0400, "Chris Harris"
wrote:



Not all of us live next door to a timberyard, with a "real" machine. Take
a look at my email address for a clue!

Cheers


So how do you get connectivity down there Chris? Satellite?


.andy

To email, substitute .nospam with .gl

yes. Well I dialup to the local ISP, but it's satellite at the end of the
day. Actually that's my real job!

Chris
--
remove ".nospam" from my reply address

I don't know how close this might be to your needs or preference, but
I often remember a potential bargain when I see one, even if it's not
something I could make use of myself.

http://www.screwfix.com/app/sfd/cat/...49776&id=92632

It may make your day, with any luck, here's hoping anyway!

Thanks for that. I had a look at the Screwfix site the other day, and they
seem to have some good stuff at reasonable prices. This one looks good but
the capacity is less than the Axminster one
http://www.screwfix.com/app/sfd/cat/...69101&id=97825 I think one
of the local tool shops has a Screwfix agency but they don't stock any
machinery, probably would get it for me as a special though.

I tend to shy away from anything billed as a site saw/planner whatever as
that generally means the manufacturers have put it together with stuff left
over from other projects, like 1 1/8" bearings on 1" spindles so you end up
with a wobble saw etc.

I am also trying to stick with one supplier as it makes shipping, insurance
etc., easier. And I know people who have used Axminster before with good
service.

Don't need to carve a penguin if it's cooked right ;-)

Chris

On Fri, 04 Jul 2003 21:56:18 -0400, CJ
wrote:

I tend to shy away from anything billed as a site saw/planner whatever as
that generally means the manufacturers have put it together with stuff left
over from other projects, like 1 1/8" bearings on 1" spindles so you end up
with a wobble saw etc.

Never thought of that, you may well have a point now I have thought
about it! ;O)

I am also trying to stick with one supplier as it makes shipping, insurance
etc., easier. And I know people who have used Axminster before with good
service.

Yep, I just tried them for the first time this week, and while it
seemed to be a bit more chaotic that a Screwfix encounter, the goods
arrived at a similar rate of knots. The presentation quality was a bit
of a let down, but the goods did work as advertised, so it's at least
functional as expected.

Don't need to carve a penguin if it's cooked right ;-)

I'll bow to your clearly superior local knowledge - we can't all have
access to penguins you know! VBG


Take Care,
Gnube

On 4 Jul 2003 11:28:41 -0700, (Michael
McNeil) wrote:

"Chris Harris" wrote in message ...
Hi

I posted here a week or so back asking what woodworking machines people
recommended for a workshop that would initially be used for a house
renovation project.

Well I've got a fairly limited budget so I've been looking at the Axminster
own brand tools as follows

Axminster compound mitre saw 300mm - Axminster part MS12C
Axminster saw bench - Aminster part BTS10P
Perform planer thicknesser - Aminster part CCNPT

I'm also going to upgrade my current fixed speed Bosch router to a 1/2"
Axminster model AW127R


I can't imagine what sort of use that a planer thicknesser is going to
be to you. For a lot less money you could take what few items you
might have to a workshop or timberyardand pay for a real machine to do
it.

DIY planer thicknessers are toys.


To answer your first point, this is uk d-i-y and running to a local
timber yard every time one wants a piece to size might turn out to be
a pita. O/K if one is working on one particular project but
otherwise.....

On your second point you are assuming his usage is going to be similar
to your own which is not necesasarily so.

At one extreme if he was into making modesl I imagine a DIY (whatever
that is) plane thicknesser would do fine.

At another extreme if he wanted to build an oak framed barn then I
imgine whatever you have in your back shed is going to look laughable.

My first 'table' saw was a saw attachment on a b&d drill which I
mounted in a piece of chipboard and clamped to the side of a bench I
made from timber discarded on a building site. It served me o/k ,(I
can remember using it to help me make two beds out of parana pine),
until I was ready to progress to better things (Just married, 3 kids,
mortgage. Severe financial handicap)

Paul Mc Cann

On Thu, 3 Jul 2003 09:52:51 -0400, "Chris Harris"
wrote:

Axminster compound mitre saw 300mm - Axminster part MS12C

Definitely get a 12" not a 10" though.

Never really seen the point in these. They're not big enough to do
most workshop jobs. Until the day you're building a new roof / doing
internal studwork, then you buy two of them just to keep your chippies
working faster. For general use though, the cut width isn't enough.
Personally I'd go for a really good handheld circular saw, like a
Hitachi C7U / C9U

Now a _sliding_ chopsaw, now you're talking. 500 notes though, until I
get my hands on the Axminster one and see if their 150 quid one-bar
design is any good.

The cheapie page on the web also lists this:
DELTA 36255 240v COMPOUND MITRE SAW 12" £144.63


Axminster saw bench - Aminster part BTS10P

I had two years out of this before I replaced it with a big cast iron
Wadkin. Excellent bit of kit.

I'd probably sell it, except that it's cheaper now than when I bought
it, and it's worth hanging onto for on-site work.

Worst part is the fence (which is why I finally swapped it) It's not
rigid enough unless you use the far-end clamp. This is slow, and you
have to check the alignment carefully.

Great guarding, and it comes off easily for rebating. Incredibly
powerful for a plastic bucket with a piece of windowframe on top. I
ran lots of 3" rips through oak and it didn't even burn them.

The noise is incredible. Sounds like it blew a gasket whenever you
turn it on.

Damn cheap, as they seem to be offering bargain deals on it (check the
cheapie list) Make sure you get the stand and the extension tables.

B&Q are selling a £200 version of this with the same table, but what
appears to be a better fence.


Perform planer thicknesser - Aminster part CCNPT

So long as you get the job done before it falls apart, then you're OK.
Tinny as hell though - as bad as Kity or DeWalt.

Personally I'd say to put the same money into their CT330 thicknesser
and use that instead. You can do almost everything except edge
jointing with a good thicknesser, and this is a seriously good
machine. In the future you can get a dedicated jointer, for a total
cost about the same as a decent 10" combination machine.

Don't get the (clearance bargain priced) CT344 though, as it isn't a
patch on it. Short tables, no head lock, and snipey as hell.

The CT machines also take double-edged disposable cutters, which are a
piece of cake to replace. A sharpenable cutter (like the CCNPT) also
means an adjustable cutter, which is a PITA to adjust correctly.

I'm also going to upgrade my current fixed speed Bosch router to a 1/2"
Axminster model AW127R

Get a Freud instead. The Axminster white range portable tools are
failing to impress me at all, and this router certainly doesn't. Not
bad as a first router, but I wouldn't rate it as an "upgrade" router.

Thanks for your comments Andy.


Now a _sliding_ chopsaw, now you're talking. 500 notes though, until I
get my hands on the Axminster one and see if their 150 quid one-bar
design is any good.

Most sliding chop saws don't seem to offer very much advantage over the
straight chop ones.

Anyway I going to bin the chop saw from my shopping list for the time being.
I have plenty of hand saws that will do the job. If I need to do a
repetitive job I can borrow one.


Axminster saw bench - Axminster part BTS10P

I'd probably sell it, except that it's cheaper now than when I bought
it, and it's worth hanging onto for on-site work.

Worst part is the fence (which is why I finally swapped it) It's not
rigid enough unless you use the far-end clamp. This is slow, and you
have to check the alignment carefully.

Great guarding, and it comes off easily for rebating. Incredibly
powerful for a plastic bucket with a piece of windowframe on top. I
ran lots of 3" rips through oak and it didn't even burn them.

The noise is incredible. Sounds like it blew a gasket whenever you
turn it on.

Seems like it has some good points. Everyone is spoilt by induction motors
these days. I can handle a bit of noise.

I was looking at the Elektra PK200 in Axminster which comes with a nice
package of table extensions and a sliding table for £500, but it's just a
bit too small for me, I want to be able to cut 3" on occasion (even if
slowly and carefully ) and all the tables and sliding table would take up a
fair bit of room.


Personally I'd say to put the same money into their CT330 thicknesser
and use that instead. You can do almost everything except edge
jointing with a good thicknesser, and this is a seriously good
machine. In the future you can get a dedicated jointer, for a total
cost about the same as a decent 10" combination machine.

That could be good advice, and I can probably afford a small jointer for the
price of a chop saw, there is a perform on in Axminster for 160 quid. I can
joint by hand though.

20 odd years ago I did an apprenticeship as a joiner, but then went off and
followed my interest in electronics. So I'm not afraid of the hand work,
just want some machines to help me work faster and keep the missus off my
back ;-)


The CT machines also take double-edged disposable cutters, which are a
piece of cake to replace. A sharpenable cutter (like the CCNPT) also
means an adjustable cutter, which is a PITA to adjust correctly.

Adjusting them isn't a problem for, I was an apprentice once, and setting up
the machines was part of the JD :-)


I'm also going to upgrade my current fixed speed Bosch router to a 1/2"
Axminster model AW127R

Get a Freud instead. The Axminster white range portable tools are
failing to impress me at all, and this router certainly doesn't. Not
bad as a first router, but I wouldn't rate it as an "upgrade" router.

I wondered about that, hence the questions here. You mean like the Freud
FT2000E in Screwfix for £164.99? Looks OK to me, but twice the price of the
Axminster, but if its twice the quality then I don't mind paying.

--
remove ".nospam" from my reply address