Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Metalworking (rec.crafts.metalworking) Discuss various aspects of working with metal, such as machining, welding, metal joining, screwing, casting, hardening/tempering, blacksmithing/forging, spinning and hammer work, sheet metal work. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a
screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? -- EA |
#2
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
On Mon, 14 May 2012 22:28:13 -0400, "Existential Angst"
wrote: Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? There are epoxy thread-lockers made for volume production. They're hollow phenolic beads, half of them filled with resin and half of them with hardener. The threads are dipped in a weak adhesive and then in the beads, whereupon they can be stored for as long as you want. When you tighten the nut the beads crush, the epoxy and hardener mix, and the mess hardens. For non-production use, Loctite is much more convenient. Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? A fair amount of heat. And the epoxy doesn't melt. It may get soft, but it chars. Five-minute epoxies can handle less heat than the slow-cure types. -- Ed Huntress |
#3
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
"Ed Huntress" wrote
On Mon, 14 May 2012 22:28:13 -0400, "Existential Angst" wrote: Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? There are epoxy thread-lockers made for volume production. They're hollow phenolic beads, half of them filled with resin and half of them with hardener. The threads are dipped in a weak adhesive and then in the beads, whereupon they can be stored for as long as you want. When you tighten the nut the beads crush, the epoxy and hardener mix, and the mess hardens. For non-production use, Loctite is much more convenient. Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? A fair amount of heat. And the epoxy doesn't melt. It may get soft, but it chars. Five-minute epoxies can handle less heat than the slow-cure types. What Ed wrote, but also.. Split Lock washers DO NOT work and should not be used. Steve W.'s link http://www.boltscience.com/index.htm has a graph showing that they fail quicker under vibration than a straight bolted conection. Basicaly when fully compressed they act as a flat washer giving two surfaces that can slip. Once slightly released, they activly permote the rotation of the bolt or nut. Star washers I think work as long as the conection is tight enough to actualy cut into the two surfaces. Look at how cars are put together now. IIRC for critical areas they use belvel washers with embosed squares or stars that alow for higher clamping force upon compression. -- Stephen B. |
#4
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
"Ed Huntress" wrote in message ... On Mon, 14 May 2012 22:28:13 -0400, "Existential Angst" wrote: Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? There are epoxy thread-lockers made for volume production. They're hollow phenolic beads, half of them filled with resin and half of them with hardener. The threads are dipped in a weak adhesive and then in the beads, whereupon they can be stored for as long as you want. When you tighten the nut the beads crush, the epoxy and hardener mix, and the mess hardens. For non-production use, Loctite is much more convenient. Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? A fair amount of heat. And the epoxy doesn't melt. It may get soft, but it chars. Five-minute epoxies can handle less heat than the slow-cure types. -- Ed Huntress Even with heat, removing bolts with epoxy on the threads is not very easy. Epoxy just dribbled around the outside of a bolt does not work well. The army uses this stuff in the turret of the Abrams tank. http://www.vibra-tite.com/vc3.php They found it is the only removable thread locker that can withstand the shock and vibration they get there. You apply it to the male threads and let it dry. It is the consistency of soft plastic. It cold flows into the threads when assembled to fill all the gaps. It is also great for screws that have to be adjusted and then stay put. You can also use castle nuts and cotter pins or tie wires. |
#5
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
"anorton" wrote in message
m... "Ed Huntress" wrote in message ... On Mon, 14 May 2012 22:28:13 -0400, "Existential Angst" wrote: Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? There are epoxy thread-lockers made for volume production. They're hollow phenolic beads, half of them filled with resin and half of them with hardener. The threads are dipped in a weak adhesive and then in the beads, whereupon they can be stored for as long as you want. When you tighten the nut the beads crush, the epoxy and hardener mix, and the mess hardens. For non-production use, Loctite is much more convenient. Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? A fair amount of heat. And the epoxy doesn't melt. It may get soft, but it chars. Five-minute epoxies can handle less heat than the slow-cure types. -- Ed Huntress Even with heat, removing bolts with epoxy on the threads is not very easy. Epoxy just dribbled around the outside of a bolt does not work well. The army uses this stuff in the turret of the Abrams tank. http://www.vibra-tite.com/vc3.php They found it is the only removable thread locker that can withstand the shock and vibration they get there. You apply it to the male threads and let it dry. It is the consistency of soft plastic. It cold flows into the threads when assembled to fill all the gaps. It is also great for screws that have to be adjusted and then stay put. You can also use castle nuts and cotter pins or tie wires. Well, apropos of Ed's 5 min epoxy, of which I have quite a bit (and which HF sells dert cheap), if I applied that well to the threads, would it do an effective job? At least until I figger out exactly what direction I want to take. -- EA |
#6
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
"Existential Angst" wrote in message ... "anorton" wrote in message m... "Ed Huntress" wrote in message ... On Mon, 14 May 2012 22:28:13 -0400, "Existential Angst" wrote: Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? There are epoxy thread-lockers made for volume production. They're hollow phenolic beads, half of them filled with resin and half of them with hardener. The threads are dipped in a weak adhesive and then in the beads, whereupon they can be stored for as long as you want. When you tighten the nut the beads crush, the epoxy and hardener mix, and the mess hardens. For non-production use, Loctite is much more convenient. Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? A fair amount of heat. And the epoxy doesn't melt. It may get soft, but it chars. Five-minute epoxies can handle less heat than the slow-cure types. -- Ed Huntress Even with heat, removing bolts with epoxy on the threads is not very easy. Epoxy just dribbled around the outside of a bolt does not work well. The army uses this stuff in the turret of the Abrams tank. http://www.vibra-tite.com/vc3.php They found it is the only removable thread locker that can withstand the shock and vibration they get there. You apply it to the male threads and let it dry. It is the consistency of soft plastic. It cold flows into the threads when assembled to fill all the gaps. It is also great for screws that have to be adjusted and then stay put. You can also use castle nuts and cotter pins or tie wires. Well, apropos of Ed's 5 min epoxy, of which I have quite a bit (and which HF sells dert cheap), if I applied that well to the threads, would it do an effective job? At least until I figger out exactly what direction I want to take. -- EA A small bottle of Loctite which was designed for the job would probably be just as cost effective. No mixing or faffing about - one drip & its done properly. One little bottle goes a looong way. |
#7
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
Aye.. and Loctites are also available as tape/film or stick forms. The tape
is supplied on a small spool like thread sealer, and the stick type is similar to a wax stick/chapstick. Either product is available as blue or red/permanent types. -- WB .......... "Dennis" wrote in message . au... A small bottle of Loctite which was designed for the job would probably be just as cost effective. No mixing or faffing about - one drip & its done properly. One little bottle goes a looong way. |
#8
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
I dunno why anyone would want to mix and apply 2-part products when Loctite
formulas will do an excellent/proven job. Numerous fasteners are available with an epoxy-type product already applied for numerous applications from nails/staples to more heavy duty steel fabrication fasteners.. generally considered OTU one-time-use permanent fasteners, not removed for maintenance/service. Screws and nuts are available as nyloc types which will essentially insure that the fastener won't separate from vibration, such as a nyloc nut mounted on a screw acting as a pin, but I dunno about (doubt) the effectiveness at maintaining a specified torque. The mil-spec and aviation self-locking nuts with synthetic inserts may hold to a specified torque when used as specified for one-time-use only. To insure that a nut doesn't come off with general hardware, the screw threads can be distorted/smashed after the nut's in place to ensure that the screw will need to be broken to separate the pieces.. or use stainless steel for intentional gall/seizing of the threads. And rust is still considered fairly effective. As far as a "little heat" being effective at loosening epoxied hardware (or red Loctite), a soldering iron may be useful for small fasteners up to maybe 1/8" but not enough heat for anything larger, assuming the heat can be applied to a nut on a screw, not heating a screw length imbedded in heat-sinking material. -- WB .......... "Existential Angst" wrote in message ... Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? -- EA |
#9
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
"Wild_Bill" wrote in message ... Aye.. and Loctites are also available as tape/film or stick forms. The tape is supplied on a small spool like thread sealer, and the stick type is similar to a wax stick/chapstick. Either product is available as blue or red/permanent types. -- WB ......... Interesting - I was only aware of the liquid in the little dripper bottles. |
#10
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
"Wild_Bill" wrote in message ... I dunno why anyone would want to mix and apply 2-part products when Loctite formulas will do an excellent/proven job. Numerous fasteners are available with an epoxy-type product already applied for numerous applications from nails/staples to more heavy duty steel fabrication fasteners.. generally considered OTU one-time-use permanent fasteners, not removed for maintenance/service. Segways are assembled with screws with pre-applied threadlocker. In the lab we just re-used them on in-house-only machines. They still took some force to install or remove and AFAIK none of them ever loosened. When I had to remove a batch of particularly reluctant screws installed with permanent Loctite I heated them with a soldering iron in a blob of solder in the socket recess. |
#11
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
On 5/14/2012 10:28 PM, Existential Angst wrote:
Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? Have you ever heard of "Stoverized" nuts? Those are the ticket! |
#12
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
On May 14, 8:28*pm, "Existential Angst" wrote:
Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? -- EA Nylon insert nuts or deformed locking nut will do it, if you ever have to get it apart. A nut with a check nut will work as well. Could drill and wire, too. Castle nut with a cotter pin works for car hubs. If you NEVER have to remove the fastener, just rivet the joint. Threadlockers are really meant for bolts or studs going into tapped holes, there are nuts designed for locking duty, see above. Epoxies really suck at holding shear forces, which is what you get with a nut unscrewing. Stan |
#13
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
|
#14
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
On Tue, 15 May 2012 19:51:23 -0400, "J. Clarke"
wrote: In article , says... Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? If you really want to be sure, hit it with an arc welder. Prevailing torque nuts do the job extremely well (stovers). And drilling and safety wiring them is just icing on the cake. |
#15
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
On Tue, 15 May 2012 09:03:51 -0700 (PDT), Stanley Schaefer
wrote: On May 14, 8:28*pm, "Existential Angst" wrote: Iffin you REALLY wanted to be sure that a nut won't fall off a screw, or a screw will loosen, wouldn't plain ole 2-part epoxy be the best bet? Also, if an epoxied screw/nut did have to come off, wouldn't a little heat do it? -- EA Nylon insert nuts or deformed locking nut will do it, if you ever have to get it apart. A nut with a check nut will work as well. Could drill and wire, too. Castle nut with a cotter pin works for car hubs. If you NEVER have to remove the fastener, just rivet the joint. Threadlockers are really meant for bolts or studs going into tapped holes, there are nuts designed for locking duty, see above. Epoxies really suck at holding shear forces, which is what you get with a nut unscrewing. I am not sure how epoxy behaves on threads but in a "shaft-in-a-hole" application when epoxy fails it is a catastrophic failure and the shaft then moves quite freely. If one uses a retaining compound similar to a threadlocker (Loctite 680 or Vibratite equivalent) the shaft may move if enough force is applied but once the level of force drops the shaft is stuck in this new position and one needs almost an equal amount of force to shift it again. Michael Koblic, Campbell River, BC |
#16
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
On May 15, 12:36*am, "anorton"
wrote: .... The army uses this stuff in the turret of the Abrams tank.http://www.vibra-tite.com/vc3.php They found it is the only removable thread locker that can withstand the.... The web page says that the solvent is MEK and a plastic like substance is deposited. So, I guess, the obvious question is "What plastic dissolves in MEK" ? DOC Something about inquiring minds... .... |
#17
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Loctite vs. various lock/split washers vs...... epoxy??
I believe you'll find that numerous plastics "melt" with MEK.. it's an
ingredient in PVC-ABS plumbing fitting cement. If a solvent is hot enough that it "burns" a plastic (melts the surface on contact), the plastic material will typically continue to soften as more of the solvent comes into contact with it. Hot solvents such as acetone, lacquer thinner and toluene will generally melt hard plastic compounds and styrene, or many of the rigid plastic compounds that don't bend easily/aren't typically flexible, but also foams such as styrofoam. -- WB .......... "doc" wrote in message ... On May 15, 12:36 am, "anorton" wrote: .... The army uses this stuff in the turret of the Abrams tank.http://www.vibra-tite.com/vc3.php They found it is the only removable thread locker that can withstand the... The web page says that the solvent is MEK and a plastic like substance is deposited. So, I guess, the obvious question is "What plastic dissolves in MEK" ? DOC Something about inquiring minds... .... |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Best way to apply Loctite 290 | Home Repair | |||
Which do you like more, split ring lock washers or the other kind? | Home Repair | |||
nuts with nylon inserts versus lock washers and jamb nuts | Home Repair | |||
Does fresh epoxy stick to dried epoxy? | Woodworking | |||
Source for GOOD bolts, washers, copper washers, etc? | Metalworking |