Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Metalworking (rec.crafts.metalworking) Discuss various aspects of working with metal, such as machining, welding, metal joining, screwing, casting, hardening/tempering, blacksmithing/forging, spinning and hammer work, sheet metal work. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34 yrs old....
The red button is a thermal protection device that is designed to open when
the air passing over it (motor heat) reaches a set temperature. This prevents further temperature rise, and protects the motor's wiring insulation. The TP thermal protection button/switch won't reset until the motor cools down to a reasonable temperature, so if the motor gets hot and the TP opens, pushing the reset button won't reset the TP if the motor hasn't cooled sufficiently. Testing the TP can be done with an ohm meter or a battery powered continuity tester. A continuity test is only to be done on circuits or parts with no power applied. An ohm meter check will show very low (near zero ohms) resistance, and the continuity tester will light if the TP is closed, as it should be, at room temperature. If the TP has failed, you can probably get a suitable replacement at a motor repair shop. There is most likely a temperaure marked on the part itself, indicating the temperature rating. For your extension cord, longer cords should always be a larger gage than the power cord for motor powered equipment and other moderately heavy loads.. heaters, welders, pumps etc. Old extension cords can have loose terminal screws, weak contact pressure and broken strands. If the motor's centrifugal switch is making good contact, has a good start capacitor and the TP is closed, and the motor doesn't start with the proper voltage applied.. then it's very likely that the stator windings are damaged assuming all other connections are secure). If the stator windings are damaged, it's not going to be cost effective to have the motor repaired. If the pressure swich is faulty, that's a separate issue as far as troubleshooting the motor (but you said it's been bypassed). Check TP continuity. Confirm that the centrifugal switch contacts are closed. Motor should run with proper voltage. Confirm that the new capacitor isn't faulty. If you're uncertain of any of these comments, have an experienced and qualified person check these items for you. -- WB .......... metalworking projects www.kwagmire.com/metal_proj.html "dave" wrote in message ... sprayed some welder tinware out in the yard, started cleaning the gun afterward, notice pressure getting low, but I'm still plugged in, checked everything... a day later: bypassed the on/off switch, then bypassed that AND the 'blowoff' switch thing too ("for good measure"), still no go/all still VMB (very much bricklike). ordered, bought (and waited for) then installed, today, the new 'mcmaster' capacitor (recommended here, thanks guys :-), but -still- no good. and, yeah, I just 'assumed' the old capacitor was bad...(though "hoped" might be the better word) see some of the compressor glamor, or "lack thereof" at my site: http://machines.2x.nu/air_compressor_krapped_out/ motor still belly-up, even with the new capacitor installed. what's the reset button SUPPOSED to do and how do I know if it WORKS? tried that, too, of course, to no avail. feels like a spring-loaded button pressing against a steel plate "all ahead dead stop" or some damn thing. tested the incoming 'hots', and they're live (neon test light) and the electric is likewise live where the tiny spades push onto the motor male spade connectors, inside the tiny stomach-shaped motor end-cap. they're tight there, too. had that entire endbell off the motor a few days ago too, to 'look it over in there' a bit: centrifugal switch contacts have been lightly sanded (280 wet and dry/used dry) then cleaned with lacq thinner on paper, so they're clean. functionally looks OK, motion and slides good, no busted springs, all groovey. we're "good to go" in there. get the motor specifics in this image: http://machines.2x.nu/air_compressor...os/photo5.html freakin' motor. need this thing. got some die grindering to do 'yesterday'. this *SUCKS* one of those ol' craftsman "4 hp" motors with the 5/8ths shaft. 15 amp, 1.0 SF, 3450 RPM, capacitor start (but not capacitor run), single phase, made by goulds-Century. needs to run Counter-C'wise when viewed facing shaft end. probably cheaper to buy a 'new' (used) compressor COMPLETE than a motor for THIS one. maybe we can work a swapfest? if you have time to burn, see my "air compressor KRAPPED OUT" movie, too: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TvmDd1nvdd0 anybody got an old "electric motors - troubleshooting them by their symptoms" book? thanks guys :-/ toolie the perplexed |
#2
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34yrs old....
Wild_Bill wrote:
The red button is a thermal protection device that is designed to open when the air passing over it (motor heat) reaches a set temperature. This prevents further temperature rise, and protects the motor's wiring insulation. The TP thermal protection button/switch won't reset until the motor cools down to a reasonable temperature, so if the motor gets hot and the TP opens, pushing the reset button won't reset the TP if the motor hasn't cooled sufficiently. Testing the TP can be done with an ohm meter or a battery powered continuity tester. I prefer using the "twin LED" tester I made, powered by an old walwart. I just posted images of it... A continuity test is only to be done on circuits or parts with no power applied. I like to wear soaking wet boots, lick salt, then put my tongue on one terminal...and the arc welder on the other, on "high, straight polarity" (livens up my day a bit :-) An ohm meter check will show very low (near zero ohms) resistance, and the continuity tester will light if the TP is closed, as it should be, at room temperature. If the TP has failed, you can probably get a suitable replacement at a motor repair shop. yeah, but I HATE paying retail, bill...and ENJOY 'reverse engineering' too much to pay retail, or to use "the right stuff" when I can adapt something else ENTIRELY (preferably out of my 'stash-heap') to do the job. I mean like, if it's doable... There is most likely a temperaure marked on the part itself, indicating the temperature rating. hmm, didn't realize that, I'm gonna go look, DERN good thing I haven't yet reassemled it yet aGAIN...thank you bill :-) For your extension cord, longer cords should always be a larger gage than the power cord for motor powered equipment and other moderately heavy loads.. heaters, welders, pumps etc. Old extension cords can have loose terminal screws, weak contact pressure and broken strands. what about black tape? one of my cords has a slight rip I taped...I think. that OK? you with OSHA? sometimes I use "odd color" tape too. once I even used SCOTCH tape as an insulator... :-) If the motor's centrifugal switch is making good contact, has a good start capacitor and the TP is closed, and the motor doesn't start with the proper voltage applied.. then it's very likely that the stator windings are damaged assuming all other connections are secure). If the stator windings are damaged, it's not going to be cost effective to have the motor repaired. the way I see it, if the motor has to even go in the DOORWAY of a motor repair shop "that's all she wrote", never mind 'cost effective'. had ONE motor rebuilt ONE time, and found out, years later, the problem wasn't with the motor at ALL, but with the squirrel cage blower fanblade *HUB*...yet, they TOLD me they "rebuilt" it, and charged me for it. they only thing they "rebuilt" I think was my wallet, by thinning it out some.... remind me to tell ya the story of the time I took my radiator in, cause my car was overheating. they said, and I thought, it needed 'rodding out'. so I left it with them, the oldest radiator shop in town. get it back, reinstall it, and months later, I'm still "running a bit hot", even with the AC off. this was 'back in the day' when radiators were all brass. this, of course, was after I personally tested, and/or replaced/rebuilt all the 'more obvious' stuff, like water pumps, thermostat, hoses, etc so I took the frickin' thing out *AGAIN*, this time I used my oxi-acet torch setup, and THIS VERY SAME AIR COMPRESSOR, to blow ALL the solder out of one of the radiator endcaps, all the way around. I'd never ever repaired a radiator before, or even seen one opened up. what'd I find? take a guess? yup, those guys, my BUDDIES, never rodded it out, because about 80 percent of the passages were clogged SOLID, and another 16 percent were partially clogged...so...I rodded the ****a out MYDAMNSELF, with a thin piece of sheet metal. took a LONG time, too, it kept bending (wasn't hardened, or even spring steel). but guess what? AFTER *my* work, it runs WAY better and VASTLY cooler than after "their" work.... word to the weary: if you have a car with a brass radiator, and you're 'contemplating' having it rodded out: centerpunch both end solder seams in a few places lightly, that way you can tell afterward if they EVEN OPENED THE THING UP, LIKE IS *REQUIRED* FOR THE ROD-OUT procedure. or, maybe the just repainted it... woops, sorry, maybe I got carried away... If the pressure swich is faulty, that's a separate issue as far as troubleshooting the motor (but you said it's been bypassed). yeah, and I meant it, too. it was bypassed. still is. I might bypass 90% of the electrics on this heap, too, just to get it goin'....call me "the ol' bypasser" ;-) Check TP continuity. Confirm that the centrifugal switch contacts are closed. Motor should run with proper voltage. Confirm that the new capacitor isn't faulty. hmm, thought of that too. if it's a bad new one, maybe I can temporarily replace it with my OTHER "bummer" capacitor, the old original one "of dubious functionality" ? that be better? worse? a wash? sometimes baffilation sweeps over bubbaland If you're uncertain of any of these comments, have an experienced and qualified person check these items for you. if I can't do, bill, with help from you guys, it AIN'T gonna get fixed. it'd be "end of story" for bubba's compressor. but, it'll get fixed...yet. after a few days research lately, I've decided "newer" compressors have little appeal: they make WAY too much noise, last WAY TOO SHORT a time for what you pay for them, and their parts are made in WAY TOO MANY distant lands, from 'weirdoleum' components. PLUS this one is "right sized" for my needs, barely, but workable...I'd LOVE a bigger one, two stage, but got no place to house it. I'd actually love a 90 hp 880 volt atlas-copco rotary screw, with a refrigerator-sized dryer....but, then again who wouldn't? thanks bill :-) |
#3
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34 yrs old....
You've certainly got your money's worth out of the compressor in the time
you've owned it. The cost of the thermal protector is small compared to a new motor, or new compressor. The TP is what saves the motor when it gets hot, or the motor is heating due to the voltage drop from an inadequate extension cord, or too heavy of a load. If your motor hadn't had the TP, it might've just burned the windings the last time you used the compressor. Fuses and circuit breakers aren't sensitive to the temperature of the motor, so they can't replace the TP. The cost of a new TP is the best insurance you can buy to protect the motor from damage due to overheating in the future. With a new capacitor and TP, and a little cleaning of the internal parts and some oil for the bearings, you're not likely to have any other problems with that motor for quite a while. -- WB .......... metalworking projects www.kwagmire.com/metal_proj.html "dave" wrote in message ... yeah, but I HATE paying retail, bill...and ENJOY 'reverse engineering' too much to pay retail, or to use "the right stuff" when I can adapt something else ENTIRELY (preferably out of my 'stash-heap') to do the job. I mean like, if it's doable... |
#4
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34yrs old....
Wild_Bill wrote:
You've certainly got your money's worth out of the compressor in the time you've owned it. not quite yet... The cost of the thermal protector is small compared to a new motor, or new compressor. well, yeah, bill, but I'm still shopping. the deal is, though: in the entire 34 or 35 years i've owned it, I don't recall *EVER* pressing the thermal reset button. and now, all of a sudden, right after I finish the days spraying, whamo! it kraps out. compressor was indoors, in the shade, same ventilation as usual, same cords and breaker, ambient air temp same as usual, everything 'as usual' (except the "failed open" that is). I have the thermal protector 'jumped' now, I soldered a heavy wire across the klixon termnals (though couldn't say for sure why I didn't just REMOVE the thing entirely, and REPLACE it with the wire) iggy suggested opening the TP up, noticed online good blowup drawings of ones JUST like mine, by klixon, with a thin bimetallic disc inside, and, apparently, a -tiny- epoxied center stud piercing the disc. also some tiny contacts (which I like to clean and sand, on contactors and stuff). I assume the tiny dark-red epoxied center stud is for the 'initial factory adjustment', so, not having the right stuff to 'readjust' it during a reassembly, I opted not to dismantle it (though still might). seems to be running and starting OK, with the jumper wire "for the moment anyway". I'm rewiring it today, the SO cords from motor to pressure switch, and pressure switch to plug. also putting heavier gauge from cord outlet end to the wall breaker (cord from wall was always 'a bit warm' when I coiled it up at end of day). thanks again and giant salute to royj our "capacitor size and source suggestor and thermal suggestor fault KING", and to *all* you other guys, and to you too stormin' - I'm still shopping for a better price on the 'correct' klixon-thing for my application, but I might YET take you up on the frige-overload protector thing :-) The TP is what saves the motor when it gets hot, or the motor is heating due to the voltage drop from an inadequate extension cord, or too heavy of a load. If your motor hadn't had the TP, it might've just burned the windings the last time you used the compressor. Fuses and circuit breakers aren't sensitive to the temperature of the motor, so they can't replace the TP. The cost of a new TP is the best insurance you can buy to protect the motor from damage due to overheating in the future. With a new capacitor and TP, and a little cleaning of the internal parts and some oil for the bearings, yeah. bearings sounded "a bit dry" when I first plugged it back in, with the belt OFF, especially when it coasted to a stop...saw the numbers on the side of the bearings, and ALSO "could have" measured them w/my dial caliper, but *didn't* for unknown reasons... so just call me the "open your compressor motor's endbell cover every other day for some damn reason or another" guy thanks again to ALL :-) you're not likely to have any other problems with that motor for quite a while. now if I can figure out a way to get grease into sealed both sides motor bearings withOUT ruining their seals... |
#5
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34yrs old....
dave wrote:
Wild_Bill wrote: You've certainly got your money's worth out of the compressor in the time you've owned it. not quite yet... The cost of the thermal protector is small compared to a new motor, or new compressor. well, yeah, bill, but I'm still shopping. the deal is, though: in the entire 34 or 35 years i've owned it, I don't recall *EVER* pressing the thermal reset button. and now, all of a sudden, right after I finish the days spraying, whamo! it kraps out. compressor was indoors, in the shade, same ventilation as usual, same cords and breaker, ambient air temp same as usual, everything 'as usual' (except the "failed open" that is). I have the thermal protector 'jumped' now, I soldered a heavy wire across the klixon termnals (though couldn't say for sure why I didn't just REMOVE the thing entirely, and REPLACE it with the wire) iggy suggested opening the TP up, noticed online good blowup drawings of ones JUST like mine, by klixon, with a thin bimetallic disc inside, and, apparently, a -tiny- epoxied center stud piercing the disc. also some tiny contacts (which I like to clean and sand, on contactors and stuff). I assume the tiny dark-red epoxied center stud is for the 'initial factory adjustment', so, not having the right stuff to 'readjust' it during a reassembly, I opted not to dismantle it (though still might). seems to be running and starting OK, with the jumper wire "for the moment anyway". I'm rewiring it today, the SO cords from motor to pressure switch, and pressure switch to plug. also putting heavier gauge from cord outlet end to the wall breaker (cord from wall was always 'a bit warm' when I coiled it up at end of day). thanks again and giant salute to royj our "capacitor size and source suggestor and thermal suggestor fault KING", and to *all* you other guys, and to you too stormin' - I'm still shopping for a better price on the 'correct' klixon-thing for my application, but I might YET take you up on the frige-overload protector thing :-) The TP is what saves the motor when it gets hot, or the motor is heating due to the voltage drop from an inadequate extension cord, or too heavy of a load. If your motor hadn't had the TP, it might've just burned the windings the last time you used the compressor. Fuses and circuit breakers aren't sensitive to the temperature of the motor, so they can't replace the TP. The cost of a new TP is the best insurance you can buy to protect the motor from damage due to overheating in the future. With a new capacitor and TP, and a little cleaning of the internal parts and some oil for the bearings, yeah. bearings sounded "a bit dry" when I first plugged it back in, with the belt OFF, especially when it coasted to a stop...saw the numbers on the side of the bearings, and ALSO "could have" measured them w/my dial caliper, but *didn't* for unknown reasons... so just call me the "open your compressor motor's endbell cover every other day for some damn reason or another" guy thanks again to ALL :-) you're not likely to have any other problems with that motor for quite a while. now if I can figure out a way to get grease into sealed both sides motor bearings withOUT ruining their seals... Sealed or shielded, the former has rubber seals and the latter metal shields. Both are easy to remove with care and a very small screwdriver if nothing better. IIRC the sealed ones require more care as one surface, normally the inner diameter is the rubbing surface, so prise them out from the outer diameter of the seal. They snap back in easily in my experience. If you look in a bearing catalogue there is a differentiation between seals designed for an outer rotating or inner rotating race, for motors the inner rotates which is the common case. |
#6
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34yrs old....
dave wrote:
Wild_Bill wrote: You've certainly got your money's worth out of the compressor in the time you've owned it. not quite yet... The cost of the thermal protector is small compared to a new motor, or new compressor. well, yeah, bill, but I'm still shopping. the deal is, though: in the entire 34 or 35 years i've owned it, I don't recall *EVER* pressing the thermal reset button. and now, all of a sudden, right after I finish the days spraying, whamo! it kraps out. compressor was indoors, in the shade, same ventilation as usual, same cords and breaker, ambient air temp same as usual, everything 'as usual' (except the "failed open" that is). I have the thermal protector 'jumped' now, I soldered a heavy wire across the klixon termnals (though couldn't say for sure why I didn't just REMOVE the thing entirely, and REPLACE it with the wire) Wild_Bill speaks the truth. We know that the protector actuated once, Bubba. It saved you a motor. You've finished troubleshooting but you haven't started the repair yet! Please consider replacing the thermal protector so you can get another 35 years safe use from your compressor. Think of it as an insurance policy on your motor that costs $0.86 per *year*. Thanks! --Winston -- In the middle of some desert, is a gigantic pile consisting of nothing but your ballpoint pens and spray bottles of glass cleaner. |
#7
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34 yrs old....
You get it, Winston. For Dave to hold onto the hope that a thermal protector
from a refrigerator or window A/C unit will suffice for his (greater HP) air compressor motor, isn't likey to happen. The peak starting current drawn by the air compressor motor will far exceed the peak starting current of a fractional-HP household refrigerator or window A/C unit. The compressor motor's nameplate shows the HP as 4.0SPL (spl special). The 2-cylinder pump on the compressor can most likely easily be run with a 2 HP motor (I owned a similar new compressor from Sears about the same time Dave bought his), which is still considerbly larger than the motors in a typical residential 'frige or window-sized A/C unit. It's just far easier to get the correct part, which will fit properly inside the motor (the only place it should be installed), and have the proper protection. I don't believe I've ever purchsed anything with the expectation that it should or would work properly for over 30 years. I could see myself using a 240VAC-rated TP device inside the motor, wired to a properly-rated motor starter (inside a metal box) and secured to the compressor.. IF a perfect replacement for the original part was NLA no longer available. But this method would very likely cost several times more than the replacement part. A lower voltage TP device (120VAC or lower starter coil control voltage) would require the power cord to have a neutral conductor, and possibly a stepdown transformer, to be wired properly. -- WB .......... metalworking projects www.kwagmire.com/metal_proj.html "Winston" wrote in message ... dave wrote: Wild_Bill wrote: You've certainly got your money's worth out of the compressor in the time you've owned it. not quite yet... The cost of the thermal protector is small compared to a new motor, or new compressor. well, yeah, bill, but I'm still shopping. the deal is, though: in the entire 34 or 35 years i've owned it, I don't recall *EVER* pressing the thermal reset button. and now, all of a sudden, right after I finish the days spraying, whamo! it kraps out. compressor was indoors, in the shade, same ventilation as usual, same cords and breaker, ambient air temp same as usual, everything 'as usual' (except the "failed open" that is). I have the thermal protector 'jumped' now, I soldered a heavy wire across the klixon termnals (though couldn't say for sure why I didn't just REMOVE the thing entirely, and REPLACE it with the wire) Wild_Bill speaks the truth. We know that the protector actuated once, Bubba. It saved you a motor. You've finished troubleshooting but you haven't started the repair yet! Please consider replacing the thermal protector so you can get another 35 years safe use from your compressor. Think of it as an insurance policy on your motor that costs $0.86 per *year*. Thanks! --Winston -- In the middle of some desert, is a gigantic pile consisting of nothing but your ballpoint pens and spray bottles of glass cleaner. |
#8
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34yrs old....
On 2009-10-20, Wild_Bill wrote:
I don't believe I've ever purchsed anything with the expectation that it should or would work properly for over 30 years. I have a 58 year old Quincy compressor, that works great, and I do expect it to last 30 years for me. I will be 67, by that time, and the compressor would be 88 years old if it lasts that long. i |
#9
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34 yrs old....
It would interesting/funny, I'd imagine, to know how much the compressor
sold for when it was new in 1951. -- WB .......... metalworking projects www.kwagmire.com/metal_proj.html "Ignoramus6669" wrote in message ... On 2009-10-20, Wild_Bill wrote: I don't believe I've ever purchsed anything with the expectation that it should or would work properly for over 30 years. I have a 58 year old Quincy compressor, that works great, and I do expect it to last 30 years for me. I will be 67, by that time, and the compressor would be 88 years old if it lasts that long. i |
#10
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34yrs old....
On 2009-10-20, Wild_Bill wrote:
It would interesting/funny, I'd imagine, to know how much the compressor sold for when it was new in 1951. Good question. I have a promotional ad by Quincy from that time, it asks "Is there compressed air on Mars? QUINCY COMPRESSOR, FIT INTO YOUR FUTURE". It hangs on the wall behind the compressor. http://igor.chudov.com/projects/Quin...ir-On-Mars-Ad/ Note also that, though the compressor is that old, I installed a new single phase motor on it. i |
#11
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34 yrs old....
On Tue, 20 Oct 2009 06:47:59 -0500, Ignoramus21294
wrote: On 2009-10-20, Wild_Bill wrote: It would interesting/funny, I'd imagine, to know how much the compressor sold for when it was new in 1951. Good question. I have a promotional ad by Quincy from that time, it asks "Is there compressed air on Mars? QUINCY COMPRESSOR, FIT INTO YOUR FUTURE". It hangs on the wall behind the compressor. http://igor.chudov.com/projects/Quin...ir-On-Mars-Ad/ Note also that, though the compressor is that old, I installed a new single phase motor on it. i Dunno bout Quincys or Mars, but my Gardner Denver looks to be older than me. I started out running it with two 1/4 HP motors belted together, then an older 1/2 that needed the re-set poked about every third start. now I have it on a 50Hz. half that seems to work OK and drives the compressor at 535 RPM (Max. 600). I have a 3/4 in reserve if I ever need it. I never realized how much I needed air until I got it! Gerry :-)} London, Canada |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
freakin' compressor motor's ALREADY krapped out, and only 34yrs old.... | Metalworking | |||
Which compressor to buy. | Woodworking | |||
Freakin Ants | Home Repair | |||
Air compressor help!! | Woodworking | |||
Air Compressor | Metalworking |