Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
![]() |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Phouka" wrote in message ... Kenny-Z wrote: I hear Carrier has a good rep, but I have contractor friends who can cut me a deal on Janitrol and Coleman models (and on the install!)... Any advice? Coleman is a York unit...good when installed correctly....Goodman makes JaniJunks..err..Janitrols...even installed correctly, they suck total complete ass... I keep more parts on the trucks and in stock for that POS than anything. And to be fair, out of all the Yorks we install a year, we average about 4 warranty issues a month..on some equipment we didnt install, but out of the units we have, only one has had a major warranty callback, and that was a simple fan motor, and one that the local Rheem dealer installed about 6 years ago had a compressor go out, and that was warranty... We just had central ac installed in our new house, and I read through most of the past posts -- here's what I got, loud and clear: Get a Trane or Carrier (they are also branded as Bryant and American Std). Avoid Rheem, Ruud, etc, as these are usually low-end "contractor" models. Rheem/Ruud are some of the best units out there...when installed correctly. Trane, MADE by American Standard, is a POS too...So is Lennox. Carrier thinks the world is a guinea pig..All units use a scroll compressor, unlike Trane, or York (has several models with Scrolls) and if I wasnt a York Dealer, I would be a Rheem/Ruud dealer due to the fact they are tough as tanks, ugly as sin ( the biggest drawback next to the service end) and last. Trane was on the verge of going out of business, when American Standard, who had aquired the GEs HVAC division saved them. Trane, has a GREAT marketing campaign...but ask me what I repair, and replace more of than Goodmans.....Tranes... But, it's more critical to get it sized properly for your house and heat/cooling load -- too small and it will run constantly and cost you tons of money, too large and it will not run often enough to remove the humidity from the air. Close...too small, and its gonna remove lots of humidity, but not cool worth a damn... Too large, and its gonna cool, and its gonna run the bill as high, or higher than a smaller unit, due to larger energy consumption. The hvac guys have a set of calculations they go through(manual j? something like that) to determine the size of the compressor. Nope...we determine total system size based upon Manual J, or T, or N...depends on the situation, and type of system, and structure. Then, we do a manual D, to make sure that enough air is delivered, and at the proper speed, and volume to maintain the temps as the system is designed, while maintaining the correct static pressures in the system. There is no "rule of thumb" -- ie, no x square foot = y tons of cooling. Excellent..bravo.. We got a Carrier, BTW. Installed correctly, it will be fine, I just hope you didnt get the R410 (Puron) system. Each and every system has its issues. I went with a brand I knew from prior experence was a winner, and figured if it could hold up in the Ca deserts, it would be fine here, and was right... Bottom line Name means NOTHING Install means ALL. Even a Janitrol, with all their issues, and problems, cheap cases, cheaper parts, will do the job as its designed..till it breaks...and it will break.. We recently got a new account...an apartment complex with a few new Goodmans, (about 50) some older Rheems, and some ancient (pre 78 era) GE and Payne units...out of all the units.....we have been running our asses silly with Goodman warranty...in one day alone, we put in 5 compressors...sorry..but thats life with a Goodman. Robin |
#2
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I have a Carriar, no problems with it, very little maintenance in the 5
years I've had it. It cools our house in less than an hour after turning it on. It was installed by my Plumbing/Electrician company. I had to have separate vents for my central AC. We have a ranch home, 3 bedrooms. |
#3
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
CBHvac wrote
Coleman is a York unit...good when installed correctly....Goodman makes JaniJunks..err..Janitrols...even installed correctly, they suck total complete ass... I keep more parts on the trucks and in stock for that POS than anything. And to be fair, out of all the Yorks we install a year, we average about 4 warranty issues a month..on some equipment we didnt install, but out of the units we have, only one has had a major warranty callback, and that was a simple fan motor, and one that the local Rheem dealer installed about 6 years ago had a compressor go out, and that was warranty... Rheem/Ruud are some of the best units out there...when installed correctly. Trane, MADE by American Standard, is a POS too...So is Lennox. Carrier thinks the world is a guinea pig..All units use a scroll compressor, unlike Trane, or York (has several models with Scrolls) and if I wasnt a York Dealer, I would be a Rheem/Ruud dealer due to the fact they are tough as tanks, ugly as sin ( the biggest drawback next to the service end) and last. Trane was on the verge of going out of business, when American Standard, who had aquired the GEs HVAC division saved them. Trane, has a GREAT marketing campaign...but ask me what I repair, and replace more of than Goodmans.....Tranes... Nope...we determine total system size based upon Manual J, or T, or N...depends on the situation, and type of system, and structure. Then, we do a manual D, to make sure that enough air is delivered, and at the proper speed, and volume to maintain the temps as the system is designed, while maintaining the correct static pressures in the system. Bottom line: Name means NOTHING Install means ALL. Even a Janitrol, with all their issues, and problems, cheap cases, cheaper parts, will do the job as its designed..till it breaks...and it will break.. We recently got a new account...an apartment complex with a few new Goodmans, (about 50) [50 What, Goodman's or Rheems?] Who installed them and what was causing the compressor failures? Those factors will be the key as to why the compressors failed at that rate! I'm willing to bet that if you investigate sufficiently you will find a maintenance or install cause for most of those compressor failures. D- some older Rheems, and some ancient (pre 78 era) GE and Payne units...out of all the units.....we have been running our asses silly with Goodman warranty...in one day alone, we put in 5 compressors...sorry..but thats life with a Goodman. We both know there are a "Major Qualifications" to make in most of these cases. How were they installed and maintained! These are the major determining factors when assessing or drawing any conclusions concerning the difference in equipment. Most of the working components of most air conditioner's are manufactured by the same companies. Yes, some makes and models of compressors and fan motors may be better than others but in my many years in this industry I have not known of some companies putting seconds' in their units. Therefore, if the entire system duct work, airflow, etc., is designed and operating at its spec standards, I see no reason why one Brand Name is going to be much superior to another Brand Name. The cabinets were a bit light and the paint faded on Goodmans, but if operating to specs they held up better than many other Brands I worked on. I did hate the aluminum coils Carrier and others had for years. Retired since September 1992. D- -- Get the Cooling Capacity and Efficiency you Paid for - http://www.udarrell.com/air-conditio...city-seer.html |
#4
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
trane or carrier has my vote
|
#5
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "D-" wrote in message ... Who installed them and what was causing the compressor failures? Those factors will be the key as to why the compressors failed at that rate! I'm willing to bet that if you investigate sufficiently you will find a maintenance or install cause for most of those compressor failures. D- Three different companies, one, the one that installed the majority of them, is an excellent company, and when I have more work than we can handle at this office, we send work their way, and hes been around since the 60s...he IS the ONLY other company in the area I fully trust. Bristol comps used in the 96-99 era Goodmans are known for early failure...anyone in the trade can tell you that....go to any Goodman stocking distributor this week here, (hitting upper 90s) and see if they have any in stock...doubtful.. some older Rheems, and some ancient (pre 78 era) GE and Payne units...out of all the units.....we have been running our asses silly with Goodman warranty...in one day alone, we put in 5 compressors...sorry..but thats life with a Goodman. We both know there are a "Major Qualifications" to make in most of these cases. How were they installed and maintained! These are the major determining factors when assessing or drawing any conclusions concerning the difference in equipment. Every units been spotless, with the exception of one, and it was a nightmare in itself. I am the ONLY York/Coleman dealer in my area, and here we find ONE York airhandler, with a Goodman condensor, and the units been hacked in from hell and back. Once we got the wiring right, found out who bought the unit, and as it turned out, this was the ONLY unit they replaced out there, got the state board involved with competence hearings, etc, we found out the Goodman 1.5ton unit outside, had bad valves in it...it had not been run in a while, and that was evidenced by the fact that the valves on it were shut when they installed the air handler. Now..here is the bad thing..there are MANY of the old 73-74 era Bryants out there...old slab condensors that are running like a champ, and I ordered 3 condensate pans today for 3 units that finally started to rust out. So...all in all, Goodmans track record there, is like anywhere else, they suck. And yes, you better believe I can make comparasons on equipment. Lets take a Lennox air handler for example, and a Goodman. Ok...both have A coils, heat strips, and electrical hookups....the Lennox has a computer ICB that controls everything....the stat wires into it, and badda bing, make your 220VAC hookup and you have a unit thats gonna run...York/Luxaire/Coleman, same thing..Trane..same thing..Carrier..same thing...only some of the Carriers have two controls... Then...you open that cheap, flimsy, non painted, textured aluminuim case on the Goodman/Janitrol....the thermostat wiring is nothing but a cluster of wires, ran into a snap lock romex holder and each one goes to SEQUENCERS....holy crap..not a damn relay in the box....not a computer part showing..nothing...total and complete garbage. I have 7...thats SEVEN of the fan "relays" as they call them on the vans....we go through about 14 a week some weeks, on installs that we had nothing to do with. My supplier does not even charge me for them anymore...used to wait till Goodman kicked back the authorization codes to pay me, and now, I go in, and he asks every time..how many? I have the Goodman parts book....about 5X as thick as anyone elses...funny for a company that can only claim to be the #2 in volume sales in the country, they had to do it by selling to anyone with a pocket book that could afford the stuff...non licenced people...and thats 99% of Goodmans problem..no control of the units until something breaks, and then, the homeowner that bought one off the net, suddenly finds out that he, as a non licenced person, cant handle the warranty. Go figure... Thats like buying a new car...say...Honda, and taking it in for service, that you think is warranty, and because you didnt buy it at one particular dealer, you have no warranty. Shame, but it IS what is happening. Most of the working components of most air conditioner's are manufactured by the same companies. Yes, some makes and models of compressors and fan motors may be better than others but in my many years in this industry I have not known of some companies putting seconds' in their units. I never said they did, however, the quality of the parts varies. Another automotive comparason would be Hyundai and Mitsubishi. Back when I was in automotive, I worked at an auto mall, 7 different lines. It amazed me how many Mitsubishi owners would ask outloud why why had that Hyundai crap in the same building, when under the hood of all but the Scoupe with the Alpha engine, it was identical to the Mitsubishi...trannys, drivelines...etc..all were Mitsubishi.... And of course, you could not tell a 3000GT owner with the 3.0L V6 that was the SAME motor used in the Hyundai Sonota...the Dodge Caravan, the LeBaron...etc... Back to Goodman...it would be one thing if they used the exact same parts, but they do not. Condensor fan motors are the cheapest they can find...not AO Smith, or GE...unless they got a hell of a deal on them..you never know what kind of crap you will find on one..look at the stamped lids..the fans are bolted directly to the stamped out lid that is a bitch to get back on like a Miller, or Nordyne unit...the reversing valves normally have been brazed in by what looks like bubblegum.. The air handlers are as cheap as you can get, and leak. No real computer parts on a single unit...unless, of course, its a heat pump, and then you have that tiny timer for the defrost cycle made in China or somewhere, with no real name on it...and it might last 3 seasons. Bottom line...you can put all the first quality parts into a unit, but if they are bottom of the barrel 1st quality, when you compare the same unit to a better made unit, its not even 2nd quality, and you know it. Therefore, if the entire system duct work, airflow, etc., is designed and operating at its spec standards, I see no reason why one Brand Name is going to be much superior to another Brand Name. The cabinets were a bit light and the paint faded on Goodmans, True, but we are not dealing with a home here...apartment units...return directly beneath the airhandler, and the duct is proper...believe it or not. Checking with a pitot, all is good. And yes, one brand name, when dealing with Goodman Janitrol IS better than the other. I did say, the name means little, and the install means all, and I have said that for years... BTW...you must not have worked on many Goodmans....the screws start to rust before we pick them up at the distribution center...and that sir, is a sign of **** poor work. I can show you many right now, that the lids are stress cracked from the fan motors...and they are not out of balance... Its a design issue, and there are better choices out there, that cost less in some cases. but if operating to specs they held up better than many other Brands I worked on. Only, and I mean the ONLY units I have seen that held up somewhat well, were in the Deserts of CA...no moisture to speak of, and thus, little rust. I did hate the aluminum coils Carrier and others had for years. Retired since September 1992. D- You mean like Trane STILL has? Nothing like a damn spiney to make ones day...used to hate the round Carriers...garbage... I have said this many times...said it again today...Tranes got a GREAT marketing system....and the equipment is fine, albiet overpriced. Also, propriatary parts...you cant go fixing a Trane with common parts, as Amercian Standard had to add this, or change that...and it didnt help it last one bit, but it sure as hell took a $10 relay and turned it into a $75 relay real fast.. The only real unit that is on the market now, that is too high in my opinion, but is the only alternative for many people, is a Spacepak. -- Get the Cooling Capacity and Efficiency you Paid for - http://www.udarrell.com/air-conditio...city-seer.html |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Rayburn integrated into central heating | UK diy | |||
15mm or 22mm copper pipe for central heating? | UK diy | |||
Central Heating costs + other questions | UK diy | |||
Pool water in central heating system | UK diy | |||
Further to my last post entitled 'Flushing and treating central heating question' | UK diy |