Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 44
Default 18 v Lithium battery

Are all 18 v Li batteries interchangeable with certain tool products? I have a Worx trimmer and edger that takes such a battery. I realize they eventually will lose their power or so I was told, after so many recharges. Out of curiosity, I checked with the company and they are charging a ridiculous amount for the replacement. For a few dollars more I can buy another edger of theirs, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with the one I have. Recently, I saw an ad for a cordless drill that comes with a 18 v Li battery selling for half the price of what just the battery would cost with Worx. I just as soon as buy 'another drill', just as to benefit from the battery, but I do not know if they are interchangeable.
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,143
Default 18 v Lithium battery

On 08/27/14 04:53 pm, Frank wrote:
Are all 18 v Li batteries interchangeable with certain tool products? I have a Worx trimmer and edger that takes such a battery. I realize they eventually will lose their power or so I was told, after so many recharges. Out of curiosity, I checked with the company and they are charging a ridiculous amount for the replacement. For a few dollars more I can buy another edger of theirs, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with the one I have. Recently, I saw an ad for a cordless drill that comes with a 18 v Li battery selling for half the price of what just the battery would cost with Worx. I just as soon as buy 'another drill', just as to benefit from the battery, but I do not know if they are interchangeable.


I've never seen any two that are interchangeable, even when the
"innards" (the Li-Ion cells) are identical. Many different brands use
the same Sanyo cells with the same part numbers -- even the Ridgid with
the lifetime warranty and the allegedly "19.2V"* Craftsman -- but the
physical configuration of the package differs from one brand to the next.

*Perhaps they show 19.2V for the first few seconds after they're removed
from the charger.

Perce
  #3   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 943
Default 18 v Lithium battery

On 8/27/2014 4:53 PM, Frank wrote:
Are all 18 v Li batteries interchangeable with certain tool products? I have a Worx trimmer and edger that takes such a battery. I realize they eventually will lose their power or so I was told, after so many recharges. Out of curiosity, I checked with the company and they are charging a ridiculous amount for the replacement. For a few dollars more I can buy another edger of theirs, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with the one I have. Recently, I saw an ad for a cordless drill that comes with a 18 v Li battery selling for half the price of what just the battery would cost with Worx. I just as soon as buy 'another drill', just as to benefit from the battery, but I do not know if they are interchangeable.


I had same problem years ago with, I believe a Homelite brand, hedge
trimmer and edger that I bought at HD for $100. These were not Li
batteries, probably NiCad but when both went bad the replacements were
$50 each.

I hated to toss out perfectly good tools but replaced them with corded
tools that were not only about the same price but much more powerful.
  #4   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 6,586
Default 18 v Lithium battery

Percival P. Cassidy wrote:
On 08/27/14 04:53 pm, Frank wrote:
Are all 18 v Li batteries interchangeable with certain tool products?
I have a Worx trimmer and edger that takes such a battery. I realize
they eventually will lose their power or so I was told, after so many
recharges. Out of curiosity, I checked with the company and they are
charging a ridiculous amount for the replacement. For a few dollars
more I can buy another edger of theirs, but there is absolutely
nothing wrong with the one I have. Recently, I saw an ad for a
cordless drill that comes with a 18 v Li battery selling for half the
price of what just the battery would cost with Worx. I just as soon
as buy 'another drill', just as to benefit from the battery, but I do
not know if they are interchangeable.


I've never seen any two that are interchangeable, even when the
"innards" (the Li-Ion cells) are identical. Many different brands use
the same Sanyo cells with the same part numbers -- even the Ridgid with
the lifetime warranty and the allegedly "19.2V"* Craftsman -- but the
physical configuration of the package differs from one brand to the next.

*Perhaps they show 19.2V for the first few seconds after they're removed
from the charger.

Perce

Hi,
eBay could be a source for new battery or control board within. Some
times the board goes bad while battery pack is still good. My B&D 20V
ones parts shows from now and then on eBay.
  #5   Report Post  
Senior Member
 
Posts: 2,498
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Frank[_20_] View Post
Are all 18 v Li batteries interchangeable with certain tool products? I have a Worx trimmer and edger that takes such a battery. I realize they eventually will lose their power or so I was told, after so many recharges. Out of curiosity, I checked with the company and they are charging a ridiculous amount for the replacement. For a few dollars more I can buy another edger of theirs, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with the one I have. Recently, I saw an ad for a cordless drill that comes with a 18 v Li battery selling for half the price of what just the battery would cost with Worx. I just as soon as buy 'another drill', just as to benefit from the battery, but I do not know if they are interchangeable.
I'd try Googling the battery model number and see if anyone is selling them on Amazon or eBay.

So far as I know, the only rechargeable battery packs that can't be rebuilt with new cells are Li-Ion battery packs. Apparantly, each Li-Ion battery pack has it's own circuit board inside it that monitors the voltage of the pack and will shut it down before the voltage gets so low that the circuit board forgets it's own programming. You can't rebuild these battery packs without removing the power to the circuit board, and thereby causing it to lose it's programming so that even with new cells, the rebuilt battery pack is useless.

An alternative might be to just buy yourself a corded trimmer and chalk this one up to experience.


  #6   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,196
Default 18 v Lithium battery

On 8/27/2014 5:53 PM, Percival P. Cassidy wrote:
On 08/27/14 04:53 pm, Frank wrote:
Are all 18 v Li batteries interchangeable with certain tool products?
I have a Worx trimmer and edger that takes such a battery. I realize
they eventually will lose their power or so I was told, after so many
recharges. Out of curiosity, I checked with the company and they are
charging a ridiculous amount for the replacement. For a few dollars
more I can buy another edger of theirs, but there is absolutely
nothing wrong with the one I have. Recently, I saw an ad for a
cordless drill that comes with a 18 v Li battery selling for half the
price of what just the battery would cost with Worx. I just as soon
as buy 'another drill', just as to benefit from the battery, but I do
not know if they are interchangeable.


I've never seen any two that are interchangeable, even when the
"innards" (the Li-Ion cells) are identical. Many different brands use
the same Sanyo cells with the same part numbers -- even the Ridgid with
the lifetime warranty and the allegedly "19.2V"* Craftsman -- but the
physical configuration of the package differs from one brand to the next.

*Perhaps they show 19.2V for the first few seconds after they're removed
from the charger.

Perce

Yeah, I have a really nice 12v LIon Bosch drill ... and a 12v LIon small
Milwaukee sabre saw. The battery packs use virtually identical plastic
case parts, but are assembled in such a way (180 degrees twisted) to
make them totally incompatible. Even the polarity is reversed! When I
acquired the 2nd tool above, I was excited when I looked at the battery
.... that is until I put them side by side.
Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Opened laptop battery to replace lithium ion cells (Lenovo X61tablet PC) -- Where do I get replacement battery cells? JoeSchmoe Home Repair 29 September 11th 15 04:33 PM
Lithium Ion battery renovation [email protected] Electronics Repair 1 April 22nd 14 10:33 AM
Lithium Battery alice thomas Electronics 1 July 25th 13 10:22 PM
Lithium battery suppliers? NoSpam UK diy 10 January 10th 11 01:42 PM
Opened laptop battery to replace lithium ion cells (Lenovo X61tablet PC) -- Where do I get replacement battery cells? JoeSchmoe Electronics Repair 18 September 22nd 10 06:24 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:58 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"