Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x
20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
Roanin wrote:
I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R I think you take (square feet of surface X deltaT inF )/R-value = btu/hr http://www.pexuniverse.com/content/calculate-heat-loss |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On Wed, 7 Dec 2011 21:54:38 -0500, "Roanin"
wrote: I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R Sounds a bit light to me. How did you come up with that number? Thee are some calculators on line that will help you. You have to include window area also for a really accurate number. |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On Wed, 7 Dec 2011 21:54:38 -0500, "Roanin"
wrote: I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, 'work in'? Man cave or workshop? To me, 'Man cave' implies' warm enough to lounge around-- workshop would want to be cool enough so you don't sweat all over your work. You need to figure in windows, doors, and 'infiltration'. Then decide whether you're going to keep it warm all the time, or if you're going to go out there when it is -20F & hope to have a party in an hour. Jim |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
"mike" wrote in message ... Roanin wrote: I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R I think you take (square feet of surface X deltaT inF )/R-value = btu/hr http://www.pexuniverse.com/content/calculate-heat-loss Thanks Mike I will check that site out. R |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
"Jim Elbrecht" wrote in message ... On Wed, 7 Dec 2011 21:54:38 -0500, "Roanin" wrote: I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, 'work in'? Man cave or workshop? To me, 'Man cave' implies' warm enough to lounge around-- workshop would want to be cool enough so you don't sweat all over your work. You need to figure in windows, doors, and 'infiltration'. Then decide whether you're going to keep it warm all the time, or if you're going to go out there when it is -20F & hope to have a party in an hour. Jim Actually it is just a room that I want to make comfortable when I go out there to do whatever. Probably will not be out there when it is -20F. Who knows what I will use it for. Plans are always changing. R |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
"Roanin" wrote:
-snip- Then decide whether you're going to keep it warm all the time, or if you're going to go out there when it is -20F & hope to have a party in an hour. Actually it is just a room that I want to make comfortable when I go out there to do whatever. Probably will not be out there when it is -20F. Who knows what I will use it for. Plans are always changing. In that case- throw out all the BTU factors and whatnot, and put a torpedo heater there to bring you up to comfort level. [100k wouldn't be overkill] Or look into infra-red heating. Then you need to pay more attention to the surfaces in the room-- color and material. You don't say what kind of fuel you'd prefer. That might affect how much it pays to just over-build to capacity. Jim |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On Dec 8, 8:27*am, Jim Elbrecht wrote:
"Roanin" wrote: -snip- Then decide whether you're going to keep it warm all the time, or if you're going to go out there when it is -20F & hope to have a party in an hour. Actually it is just a room that I want to make comfortable when I go out there to do whatever. Probably will not be out there when it is -20F. Who knows what I will use it for. Plans are always changing. In that case- throw out all the BTU factors and whatnot, and put a torpedo heater there to bring you up to comfort level. [100k wouldn't be overkill] Or look into infra-red heating. * * * Then you need to pay more attention to the surfaces in the room-- color and material. You don't say what kind of fuel you'd prefer. * That might affect how much it pays to just over-build to capacity. Jim I don't know about 100K BTU, which is enough for a whole house. But I would factor in that you most likely want it to be able to raise the temp quickly. Scenario being you keep it off or at a low temp and turn the temp up on the random times you decide to use it. That's a different usage than what the standard calculations are based on. For example, if you size a whole house system, you should wind up with BTUs that are slightly more than required to maintain the temp on the coldest day. However, with that sizing, if you let the house get down to 40, it would take a very long time to heat it back up, even when it's only 30 outside. So, I think you need to be large enough to heat the place quickly. On the other hand, you don't want it so large that there are short cycles, wide swings, etc. |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
|
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
Need to know if you're maintaing temp all the time, or just a quick warm up
for occasional use. For quick warm up, an over size heater may be needed, for rapid temp rise. Of course, you could do the practical trying out method. Try one plug in space heater, typically 5,200 BTU. If that isn't enough, try a second. Three is fairly close to your 14k. Once you get a rough idea how much BTU you need, then look at natural gas heaters, how to vent the flue, etc. Just from a wild guess, 14k sounds about right. You can also combine techniques. Have a gas heater of 14k, and use a plug in space heater for rapid warm up. -- Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org .. "Roanin" wrote in message ... I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
"Stormin Mormon" wrote in message .. . Need to know if you're maintaing temp all the time, or just a quick warm up for occasional use. For quick warm up, an over size heater may be needed, for rapid temp rise. Of course, you could do the practical trying out method. Try one plug in space heater, typically 5,200 BTU. If that isn't enough, try a second. Three is fairly close to your 14k. Once you get a rough idea how much BTU you need, then look at natural gas heaters, how to vent the flue, etc. Just from a wild guess, 14k sounds about right. You can also combine techniques. Have a gas heater of 14k, and use a plug in space heater for rapid warm up. -- Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org . "Roanin" wrote in message ... I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R I will use electric as I do not have gas or the desire to cut a hole in the wall/ceiling for a flue. That being said, what I am looking for is something that I can go out and turn on and have it heat it up so it is not freezing. It will not be on all the time only when I am out there putzing around. Don't want a kerosene heater as they stink. R R |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
" wrote:
On Dec 8, 8:27*am, Jim Elbrecht wrote: "Roanin" wrote: -snip- Then decide whether you're going to keep it warm all the time, or if you're going to go out there when it is -20F & hope to have a party in an hour. Actually it is just a room that I want to make comfortable when I go out there to do whatever. Probably will not be out there when it is -20F. Who knows what I will use it for. Plans are always changing. In that case- throw out all the BTU factors and whatnot, and put a torpedo heater there to bring you up to comfort level. [100k wouldn't be overkill] -snip- I don't know about 100K BTU, which is enough for a whole house. You made me look. I don't know where 200K came from, but that's what I thought I had in my un-insulated 2 car garage. It is a 50K. So I'd cut *that* in half and come up with 25K. [or leave it the same if there is a window the OP can open- and he might ever want to use it in a bigger/draftier space] -snip- quickly. On the other hand, you don't want it so large that there are short cycles, wide swings, etc. It all depends on how you're using the space. I heat mine up for 15-20 minutes, then go to work. When it gets too warm, I take off my jacket. Then if it gets warm, I turn off the heater. If I get cool I either put the jacket back on or turn the heater on again. $5-600 worth of infrared would make life easier, but it wouldn't be portable. Jim |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On Thu, 8 Dec 2011 10:26:40 -0500, "Roanin"
wrote: "Roanin" wrote in message ... I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R I will use electric as I do not have gas or the desire to cut a hole in the wall/ceiling for a flue. That being said, what I am looking for is something that I can go out and turn on and have it heat it up so it is not freezing. It will not be on all the time only when I am out there putzing around. Don't want a kerosene heater as they stink. If it's electric, first consider the circuit amps you have there. Common and cheap 120V 1500 watt heaters need a 15 amp circuit. About 5000 btu/hr each. After you figure that out, just add them until it suits you. --Vic |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On 12/8/2011 9:26 AM, Roanin wrote:
"Stormin wrote in message .. . Need to know if you're maintaing temp all the time, or just a quick warm up for occasional use. For quick warm up, an over size heater may be needed, for rapid temp rise. Of course, you could do the practical trying out method. Try one plug in space heater, typically 5,200 BTU. If that isn't enough, try a second. Three is fairly close to your 14k. Once you get a rough idea how much BTU you need, then look at natural gas heaters, how to vent the flue, etc. Just from a wild guess, 14k sounds about right. You can also combine techniques. Have a gas heater of 14k, and use a plug in space heater for rapid warm up. -- Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org . wrote in message ... I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R I will use electric as I do not have gas or the desire to cut a hole in the wall/ceiling for a flue. That being said, what I am looking for is something that I can go out and turn on and have it heat it up so it is not freezing. It will not be on all the time only when I am out there putzing around. Don't want a kerosene heater as they stink. R R I built a 12' x 20' shed to live in while I was building my house. The shed is standard 2 x 4 frame construction, R-12 in the walls and R20 in the ceiling. It was heated with a 240V 4800W construction heater like this. http://www.homedepot.ca/product/4800...-almond/954396 I slept comfortably in that shed when outside temps were down to -45 Deg. The heater is now over ten years old and I still use it to heat my 22' x 28' garage/workshop. LdB |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
Roanin wrote:
"Stormin Mormon" wrote in message .. . Need to know if you're maintaing temp all the time, or just a quick warm up for occasional use. For quick warm up, an over size heater may be needed, for rapid temp rise. Of course, you could do the practical trying out method. Try one plug in space heater, typically 5,200 BTU. If that isn't enough, try a second. Three is fairly close to your 14k. Once you get a rough idea how much BTU you need, then look at natural gas heaters, how to vent the flue, etc. Just from a wild guess, 14k sounds about right. You can also combine techniques. Have a gas heater of 14k, and use a plug in space heater for rapid warm up. -- Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org . "Roanin" wrote in message ... I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R I will use electric as I do not have gas or the desire to cut a hole in the wall/ceiling for a flue. That being said, what I am looking for is something that I can go out and turn on and have it heat it up so it is not freezing. It will not be on all the time only when I am out there putzing around. Don't want a kerosene heater as they stink. R R Remember that temperature is not your only problem. You also gotta consider dew point. If you have electronics or machinery that can rust, or furniture that can mildew, you need to worry a LOT about relative humidity. That's the reason an unvented combustion heater is a bad choice. But your body puts out a LOT of moisture that will condense everywhere that's below the dew point. You may find you need to add ventilation, and heating that air as it enters might make the place feel less drafty. For electric resistance heat, the incremental cost of overkill is pretty low...as is the cost of adding more if you undershoot. |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On Thu, 8 Dec 2011 05:37:09 -0800 (PST), "
wrote: On Dec 8, 8:27Â*am, Jim Elbrecht wrote: "Roanin" wrote: -snip- Then decide whether you're going to keep it warm all the time, or if you're going to go out there when it is -20F & hope to have a party in an hour. Actually it is just a room that I want to make comfortable when I go out there to do whatever. Probably will not be out there when it is -20F. Who knows what I will use it for. Plans are always changing. In that case- throw out all the BTU factors and whatnot, and put a torpedo heater there to bring you up to comfort level. [100k wouldn't be overkill] Or look into infra-red heating. Â* Â* Â* Then you need to pay more attention to the surfaces in the room-- color and material. You don't say what kind of fuel you'd prefer. Â* That might affect how much it pays to just over-build to capacity. Jim I don't know about 100K BTU, which is enough for a whole house. But I would factor in that you most likely want it to be able to raise the temp quickly. Scenario being you keep it off or at a low temp and turn the temp up on the random times you decide to use it. That's a different usage than what the standard calculations are based on. For example, if you size a whole house system, you should wind up with BTUs that are slightly more than required to maintain the temp on the coldest day. However, with that sizing, if you let the house get down to 40, it would take a very long time to heat it back up, even when it's only 30 outside. So, I think you need to be large enough to heat the place quickly. On the other hand, you don't want it so large that there are short cycles, wide swings, etc. The SMART way to do it is with multiple units. If you need to come up to temp quickly, you pull out all the stops - and if you just want to "keep" it warm you use only a fraction of the total capacity. Easy to do with electrics, and not hard to do with gas, oil, or propane if you install a minimum of 2 units. One relativly small unit to maintain temp, and one "big muthu" to warm up quickly. |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On 12/7/2011 9:54 PM, Roanin wrote:
I have a room in my pole barn that I am building for my man cave. It is 14 x 20. I have R19 insulation in the walls and R38 in the floor and ceilings. It is on the second floor and the ceiling is about 7' tall. I am located in central Ohio. How would I figure out what size heater I need to make it relatively comfortable to work in when it is cold out. Near as I can figure I need about 14,000 BTU, do you think this is correct? Thanks, R Too bad you don't want to go with gas. Sounds like a perfect place for a Rinnai heater. Quiet, efficient, Very unobtrusive, and very reliable. I've been installing them for over 15 years, and after we install them, we usually tell the customer that it's more than likely that they won't be seeing us again for the heater. Only takes a 3" hole for the vent and a small hole for the gas line. Check them out at Rinnaiusa.com, or do a search for Rinnai heaters. |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
"Tom Lachance" wrote in message news:C4mdnRQujdcOo3zTnZ2dnUVZ_hOdnZ2d@metrocastcab levision.com... Too bad you don't want to go with gas. Sounds like a perfect place for a Rinnai heater. Quiet, efficient, Very unobtrusive, and very reliable. I've been installing them for over 15 years, and after we install them, we usually tell the customer that it's more than likely that they won't be seeing us again for the heater. Maybe that's because they wont be alive to call you? http://www.cpsc.gov/cpscpub/prerel/prhtml08/08199.html |
#19
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
In that case, how much power do you have? If you've got two eaches 15 amp
circuits, you can buy a couple "ceramic" heaters at the hardware, and set them on the floor. Heat rises, y'know and all. That plus a box fan should be good for a test. If that's not enough, you can also consider an over head electric heater with a fan, and wire it for 230 volts. More watts, with the same wire size. If you're comfortable with propane, these are effective, and less stinky. http://www.ebay.com/itm/NEW-DH-Propa...em27bc8d 7152 Variations available, single burner typically 14,000 BTU. http://www.ebay.com/itm/REDDY-ALL-PR...em256a30 de86 I've got a single burner heater, and have used it for friends when their heat was out. A lot better than freezing. I have much smaller heater (3,500 BTU in the back of my service van, I have used it while doing work in the van. Again, much better than freezing. Really makes a difference. -- Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org .. "Roanin" wrote in message ... I will use electric as I do not have gas or the desire to cut a hole in the wall/ceiling for a flue. That being said, what I am looking for is something that I can go out and turn on and have it heat it up so it is not freezing. It will not be on all the time only when I am out there putzing around. Don't want a kerosene heater as they stink. R |
#20
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
And, eventually figure how many BTU are actually needed.
This one looks expensive, but should work http://www.ebay.com/itm/NEW-G-70-Ele...em256a33 1f15 This kind of thing from the store should be inexpensive, and helpful. Put it on the floor, heat rises. http://www.ebay.com/itm/Portable-Ele...em48407d 5fbc These ceramic heaters, supposed to be safer. No glowing filament, just heat. Same watts and BTU as the other heaters. http://www.ebay.com/itm/Pelonis-1500...em45fe70 773e -- Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org .. "Vic Smith" wrote in message ... If it's electric, first consider the circuit amps you have there. Common and cheap 120V 1500 watt heaters need a 15 amp circuit. About 5000 btu/hr each. After you figure that out, just add them until it suits you. --Vic |
#21
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On 12/8/2011 6:38 PM, Sigmund Freud wrote:
"Tom Lachance" wrote in message news:C4mdnRQujdcOo3zTnZ2dnUVZ_hOdnZ2d@metrocastcab levision.com... Too bad you don't want to go with gas. Sounds like a perfect place for a Rinnai heater. Quiet, efficient, Very unobtrusive, and very reliable. I've been installing them for over 15 years, and after we install them, we usually tell the customer that it's more than likely that they won't be seeing us again for the heater. Maybe that's because they wont be alive to call you? http://www.cpsc.gov/cpscpub/prerel/prhtml08/08199.html It was a voluntary recall. I have done many of the recall repairs, not hundreds, but close. They involved heaters manufactured between 2000 and 2007. It involved a gasket replacement and gas pressure adjustment. That number represents a small portion of the total number of heaters out there. They are sealed combustion, direct vent units. You might thinking of unvented units. I don't like installing them. I try to discourage people from installing them. |
#22
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On Dec 8, 4:45*pm, wrote:
On Thu, 8 Dec 2011 05:37:09 -0800 (PST), " wrote: On Dec 8, 8:27*am, Jim Elbrecht wrote: "Roanin" wrote: -snip- Then decide whether you're going to keep it warm all the time, or if you're going to go out there when it is -20F & hope to have a party in an hour. Actually it is just a room that I want to make comfortable when I go out there to do whatever. Probably will not be out there when it is -20F. Who knows what I will use it for. Plans are always changing. In that case- throw out all the BTU factors and whatnot, and put a torpedo heater there to bring you up to comfort level. [100k wouldn't be overkill] Or look into infra-red heating. * * * Then you need to pay more attention to the surfaces in the room-- color and material. You don't say what kind of fuel you'd prefer. * That might affect how much it pays to just over-build to capacity. Jim I don't know about 100K BTU, which is enough for a whole house. *But I would factor in that you most likely want it to be able to raise the temp quickly. *Scenario being you keep it off or at a low temp and turn the temp up on the random times you decide to use it. * That's a different usage than what the standard calculations are based on. * For example, if you size a whole house system, you should wind up with BTUs that are slightly more than required to maintain the temp on the coldest day. * However, with that sizing, if you let the house get down to 40, it would take a very long time to heat it back up, even when it's only 30 outside. So, I think you need to be large enough to heat the place quickly. *On the other hand, you don't want it so large that there are short cycles, wide swings, etc. *The SMART way to do it is with multiple units. If you need to come up to temp quickly, you pull out all the stops - and if you just want to "keep" it warm you use only a fraction of the total capacity. Easy to do with electrics, and not hard to do with gas, oil, or propane if you install a minimum of 2 units. One relativly small unit to maintain temp, and one "big muthu" to warm up quickly.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Maybe I'm missing something, but I don't see multiple gas or oil units being smart. It's one 280 sqft room. Just get one that's sized to heat the room from being cold when unoccupied to 65F in a reasonable time, say 30 mins to an hour? With electric, being easier to install, no service, cheap, etc, then I could see using multiple units, primarily if it's desirable to heat the whole space more evenly. But for a shop, maybe all he really cares about, at least for quick heat up, is one area around a workbench, etc. In which case one electric could be fine. |
#23
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Heater Sizing
On Thu, 8 Dec 2011 07:37:16 -0500, "Roanin"
wrote: Actually it is just a room that I want to make comfortable when I go out there to do whatever. Probably will not be out there when it is -20F. Who knows what I will use it for. Plans are always changing. This makes me think of the old motel room's HVAC units through the wall. Push buttons for heat or cooling. Mitsubishi may have a modern version. Maybe even a heater if you have no need for air conditioning. .. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Kick Toe heater sizing | Home Repair | |||
Sizing electric heater for garage | Home Repair | |||
AC sizing | Home Repair | |||
Sizing a fan | UK diy | |||
Sizing A/C and Furnace | Home Repair |