Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Good info on UHMW - what about phenolic?
On Sat, 24 Jan 2009 13:36:53 -0600, "DanG" wrote:
You might be quite shocked to find out what toilet partitions cost. Gibraltor brand are solid phenolic capped with a melamine final surface. Santana is solid plastic . Bobrick is a hybrid fiberglass/plastic type product. Stainless steel, marble, etc round out the possibilities. At the bottom end are painted steel and Formica clad particle board. Painted steel is the cheapest. $50-75 per surface - each door, pilaster, side wall and additional money for hardware and clips. Santana well over $200 per surface. Gibraltor and Bobrick quite a bit higher. Santana partitions are pretty good and reasonably priced compared to competition. The School District I work for has used it extensively as it does a good job of resisting the efforts of the little bast... er, little darlings to write on it, carve on it, burn it and otherwise trash their schools. It also doen't rust (even when regularly peed upon), doesn't absorb odors, is easily installed, holds well to fasteners, etc. I have a nice sheet of their stuff in black from when a renovation was done. Many years old (I think it was in that restroom for about 25 years) and still in great shape. Have had it for several years and haven't quite decided what to use it for... For the prior poster, a decent set of stalls in a reasonably sized public restroom that are designed to take this kind of abuse for 30 to 40 years will most definitely cost more than $5,000 when you include hardware and installation. Material cost differences between a good product like Santana and some painted steel stalls that will be ready for the dumpster in 5 years (if they can even last that long) is really minimal to the overall project cost. |
#2
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Good info on UHMW - what about phenolic?
On Jan 24, 4:42*pm, dhall987 wrote:
On Sat, 24 Jan 2009 13:36:53 -0600, "DanG" wrote: You might be quite shocked to find out what toilet partitions cost. *Gibraltor brand are solid phenolic capped with a melamine final surface. *Santana is solid plastic . *Bobrick is a hybrid fiberglass/plastic type product. *Stainless steel, marble, etc round out the possibilities. *At the bottom end are painted steel and Formica clad particle board. Painted steel is the cheapest. *$50-75 per surface - each door, pilaster, side wall and additional money for hardware and clips. Santana well over $200 per surface. *Gibraltor and Bobrick quite a bit higher. Santana partitions are pretty good and reasonably priced compared to competition. The School District I work for has used it extensively as it does a good job of resisting the efforts of the little bast... er, little darlings to write on it, carve on it, burn it and otherwise trash their schools. It also doen't rust (even when regularly peed upon), doesn't absorb odors, is easily installed, holds well to fasteners, etc. I have a nice sheet of their stuff in black from when a renovation was done. Many years old (I think it was in that restroom for about 25 years) and still in great shape. Have had it for several years and haven't quite decided what to use it for... *For the prior poster, a decent set of stalls in a reasonably sized public restroom that are designed to take this kind of abuse for 30 to 40 years will most definitely cost more than $5,000 when you include hardware and installation. Material cost differences between a good product like Santana and some painted steel stalls that will be ready for the dumpster in 5 years (if they can even last that long) is really minimal to the overall project cost. I have installed 3/4" Corian as partitions. Can be refinished, impervious to acidic fluids, easy to clean. Mind you, the installations were in a community college, so the abuse was somewhat less than the abuse younger, more energetic little snowflakes seem to impart on ****houses. No more pricey, at the time, than phenolic. I'm not even sure DuPont makes 3/4" anymore. I also installed some smaller partitions at a Holiday Inn. The were 1/2" material and were installed between urinals. Colour matched to a series of 4-bowl vanities. Looked great years later. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Good info on UHMW - what about phenolic? | Woodworking | |||
Good info on UHMW - what about phenolic? | Woodworking | |||
Good info on UHMW - what about phenolic? | Woodworking | |||
Good info on UHMW - what about phenolic? | Woodworking | |||
Some good info and ideas | Woodworking |