What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?

Philly wrote:
What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?




My faves are the current "MKII" Veritas or Kell.

I've used the Veritas Mark II for some time now and it keeps the bevel
squared up pretty well if you're careful in your setup. Chisels
narrower than 1/4" are, however, difficult to get clamped down in this
guide.

Regards..

Tom

On Sat, 28 Jun 2008 20:31:20 GMT, "Philly"
wrote:

What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?

Philly wrote:
What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?



Some people here will tell you that getting a WorkSharp is the way to go
for honing chisels and plane irons. I can't argue with that, but I don't
have one. I hone all my iron with this:

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.a...=1,43072,43078

and I cannot say enough about it. It's easy to use, once you've done a
few chisels. It's dead accurate and very repeatable. Once you've got
your edge that you want, there is an adjustment on the side of the jig
that allows you to add a microbevel.

There are a couple of limitations. No chisels narrow than 1/4" and I
don't see a way to hone curved carving tools. Once you get the tool,
you're tempted to get the attachments like skew and camber roller. I
also have the camber roller for plane irons.

Regardless, this jig has given me the edges I want on most of the tools
I own. Sharpening truly is a breeze. Hell, it's almost a joy.

Tanus

"Philly" writes:

What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?

You can make one from 2 pieces of wood for a few bucks. I can't find
the web page that describes it, but you use two pieces of wood, and
some t-nuts and screws - to make a wide wooden clamp to hold a blade
at a constant angle.

Philly wrote:
What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?

Slightly different take; there's an article in last FWW on how to learn
to hold the angle consistent and thus do away w/ the need...

--

On Jun 28, 4:31 pm, "Philly" wrote:
What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?



HI, I use the mark II also... I really stink at sharpening, and this
is the only way I can get a 1/2 decent edge. Don't get the cheap
honing guide for about 10$ - it sucks, Also, don't sharpen by hand,
unless you are really good at it, and practice a lot (I dcan never
keep my hand at the same angle)

shelly

On Jun 29, 10:45*pm, Maxwell Lol wrote:
"Philly" writes:
What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? *Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?

You can make one from 2 pieces of wood for a few bucks. *I can't find
the web page that describes it, but you use two pieces of wood, and
some t-nuts and screws - to make a wide wooden clamp to hold a blade
at a constant angle.

This is probably what you are talking about. I use one and it works
great.
http://books.google.com/books?id=gj0... =3&ct=result

or tiny:
http://tinyurl.com/45vlal

Thanks for all of the great inputs. I now need to narrow in on a decision
and go for it.

Philly
"Philly" wrote in message
news:scx9k.34$9W.25@trndny04...
What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure
that the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the
chisel? Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?

On Jun 30, 7:53 am, Limp Arbor wrote:
On Jun 29, 10:45 pm, Maxwell Lol wrote:

"Philly" writes:
What's the groups experience with honing guides for sharpening chisels
(bevel edge woodworkers chisels)? Also, what's the best way to ensure that
the chisel cutting edge will hone perpendicular to the side of the chisel?
Any recommendations for a specific vendor/type?

You can make one from 2 pieces of wood for a few bucks. I can't find
the web page that describes it, but you use two pieces of wood, and
some t-nuts and screws - to make a wide wooden clamp to hold a blade
at a constant angle.

This is probably what you are talking about. I use one and it works
great.http://books.google.com/books?id=gj0...lpg=PA175&dq=c...

or tiny:http://tinyurl.com/45vlal


actually, no. I'm referring to this:
http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?p...&filter=honing

the one in your link looks MUCH better. Still, I don't know if I could
use it

shelly

I have never used one, is this something I should have?
usually if it is a chisel that is really chipped ( like one used for
cutting metal and who knows what) I use a green stone on the tablesaw
( running at reduced speed) to give it a hollow grind, then keep it
sharp by hand honing.
I sometimes just fashion a simple jig to keep the blade angle close
when grinding.
Planes I just do by hand. figure 8's on the oilstone , or waterstone.
It's the way dad always did it, he was a skilled cabinetmaker, but I
am just a novice by comparison.
Of course some of the available tools have changed.
Iv'e done similar with the jointer blades. but I have hear of others
sending them in to be sharpened.this might make them last longer buy
not grinding excessively.

Phil