Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,287
Default Finish problems again....

On Feb 25, 7:56 pm, "mcgyver" wrote:

Spraying a piece with nitrocellulous pre cat lacquer, have about 50/50
results over the past 2 gallons. problem is that i have to wait for a
"nice" day because i have to spray outside.


Not to sound glib, but nice days are a real luxury when finishing. A
perfect day would be 65 degrees, 30% humidity, no breeze (at all), no
bright sun, and having all of those conditions stable for the entire
day.

Where I live it is high humidity almost all the time (80+ percent is
not at all uncommon), the temps easily move 25 degrees or more in a
day, and if we aren't having thunderstorms it is a drought, with harsh
sun and 100 degree days. Welcome to South Texas.

here in the northwest, hasn't rained for days, temp got to 45-50 degrees.
and damn got a blush finish!


Blush is moisture, period. It can be moisture on the surface of the
material you are spraying, it can be moisture in your air lines (you
didn't say what system you are using to apply) that will give you
blush at the start of the spray, your moisture trap may be full, or a
few other things.

I hope you are keeping a log of your efforts so you will know what
works and what doesn't. You should note all the variables mentioned
above as well as the temp, the amount of solvent applied, and the temp
fluctuations during the cure time.

For what ever reason it may be, the material "blushes" because
moisture is trapped underneath the lacquer as it dries. The dried top
coat doesn't allow the lacquer to properly outgas the solvents,
including any moisture that will be a part of the application process.

So taking for granted that you have already made sure your gun is
clean, your solvent is clean (and isn't really cheap crap), your
moisture traps are clean, etc., etc., take a look at one of the most
common variables that cause blush.

Incorrect solvent mix, coupled with incorrect application. In your
case, it may be something as simple as the surface of your project
being much cooler than your applied material

Depending on the thickness you spray, the bottom of the film will dry
at a different rate as the cold surface will slow down the curing
process, causing it to be behind the curing process as compared to the
top of the film which will freely outgas its solvent to start to cure
right away. That was hard for me to learn, and until I did, I didn't
believe it.

It is almost impossible to diagnose long distance, but these tips
might help. Here's what I do when I have blush in parts of the

project, but not the whole thing. (This tip was worth the price of
admission when I got it!)

I respray the areas with a mix of 20% lacquer material and the rest
lacquer thinner at about 6 mil thick. Sounds like suicide... but it
may be the ticket for you. It works best if sprayed when the lacquer
is at "thumbprint" dry. You would be surprised how well that works.
It softens and redissolves that top layer and allows the moisture to
escape. This is the most valuable tip you can get for a lacquer
finish when you are dealing with stained or dyed woods that cannot be
sanded.

The other thing I do after I sand off the blush and quit swearing is
to start from scratch. Since lacquer resolvates, it is hard to mess
up if you have a grasp of how it works.

I sprayed out big mahogany doors at a restaurant, outside in the
elements when it was in the upper 90s, and the relative humidity was
at our normal 80+ percent.
I started with my lacquer thinned with low VOC (L2 - not hot) at 50%.
It was like spraying water. I put it on heavy, and it dried nice. I
got it up to about 75% or so lacquer to 25% thinner before I started
to see the finish acting up. I cut it back to a 70/30 mix and it was
fine.

But until I got my mix right, it took me several hours of work just to
spray one side of one door. When I got blush, I sprayed with super
thinned material and it fixed it. I wanted to move inside or take the
doors to the shop, but the door couldn't leave the premises as is the
case so many times. I was trapped, and the elements were killing me.
I wound up spraying out on the large veranda of the club in the open
air during off hours and it was just painful I was there so long.

But for the rest of the project, I had my notes with temps and
batching mixes with the time of day and it was a breeze.

i'm ready to try my hand at another type of
finish, I've heard of conversion varnishes...what are they? sprayable?
durable? would i get in the same trouble with say an Oxford waterborn
lacquer? I'm always dealing with temperature and humidity problems where i
live and would like suggestions.


Too long to explain here, and too easy to Google. There are precats,
post cats, CABs, conversion lacquers, conversion varnishes, etc. It
is too easy to confuse the names and their applications.

Try starting here, and explore the site. The goal of good finishing
is reached by a lot of different methods, and you won't find a more
knowledgeable library than this:

http://tinyurl.com/379e6w

Good luck!

Robert
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 48
Default Finish problems again....

Thank you, Robert........
So should I stay with lacquer and tweak my technique...love the ease and
look of lacquer...when everything goes well....;-)



wrote in message
...
On Feb 25, 7:56 pm, "mcgyver" wrote:

Spraying a piece with nitrocellulous pre cat lacquer, have about 50/50
results over the past 2 gallons. problem is that i have to wait for a
"nice" day because i have to spray outside.


Not to sound glib, but nice days are a real luxury when finishing. A
perfect day would be 65 degrees, 30% humidity, no breeze (at all), no
bright sun, and having all of those conditions stable for the entire
day.

Where I live it is high humidity almost all the time (80+ percent is
not at all uncommon), the temps easily move 25 degrees or more in a
day, and if we aren't having thunderstorms it is a drought, with harsh
sun and 100 degree days. Welcome to South Texas.

here in the northwest, hasn't rained for days, temp got to 45-50 degrees.
and damn got a blush finish!


Blush is moisture, period. It can be moisture on the surface of the
material you are spraying, it can be moisture in your air lines (you
didn't say what system you are using to apply) that will give you
blush at the start of the spray, your moisture trap may be full, or a
few other things.

I hope you are keeping a log of your efforts so you will know what
works and what doesn't. You should note all the variables mentioned
above as well as the temp, the amount of solvent applied, and the temp
fluctuations during the cure time.

For what ever reason it may be, the material "blushes" because
moisture is trapped underneath the lacquer as it dries. The dried top
coat doesn't allow the lacquer to properly outgas the solvents,
including any moisture that will be a part of the application process.

So taking for granted that you have already made sure your gun is
clean, your solvent is clean (and isn't really cheap crap), your
moisture traps are clean, etc., etc., take a look at one of the most
common variables that cause blush.

Incorrect solvent mix, coupled with incorrect application. In your
case, it may be something as simple as the surface of your project
being much cooler than your applied material

Depending on the thickness you spray, the bottom of the film will dry
at a different rate as the cold surface will slow down the curing
process, causing it to be behind the curing process as compared to the
top of the film which will freely outgas its solvent to start to cure
right away. That was hard for me to learn, and until I did, I didn't
believe it.

It is almost impossible to diagnose long distance, but these tips
might help. Here's what I do when I have blush in parts of the

project, but not the whole thing. (This tip was worth the price of
admission when I got it!)

I respray the areas with a mix of 20% lacquer material and the rest
lacquer thinner at about 6 mil thick. Sounds like suicide... but it
may be the ticket for you. It works best if sprayed when the lacquer
is at "thumbprint" dry. You would be surprised how well that works.
It softens and redissolves that top layer and allows the moisture to
escape. This is the most valuable tip you can get for a lacquer
finish when you are dealing with stained or dyed woods that cannot be
sanded.

The other thing I do after I sand off the blush and quit swearing is
to start from scratch. Since lacquer resolvates, it is hard to mess
up if you have a grasp of how it works.

I sprayed out big mahogany doors at a restaurant, outside in the
elements when it was in the upper 90s, and the relative humidity was
at our normal 80+ percent.
I started with my lacquer thinned with low VOC (L2 - not hot) at 50%.
It was like spraying water. I put it on heavy, and it dried nice. I
got it up to about 75% or so lacquer to 25% thinner before I started
to see the finish acting up. I cut it back to a 70/30 mix and it was
fine.

But until I got my mix right, it took me several hours of work just to
spray one side of one door. When I got blush, I sprayed with super
thinned material and it fixed it. I wanted to move inside or take the
doors to the shop, but the door couldn't leave the premises as is the
case so many times. I was trapped, and the elements were killing me.
I wound up spraying out on the large veranda of the club in the open
air during off hours and it was just painful I was there so long.

But for the rest of the project, I had my notes with temps and
batching mixes with the time of day and it was a breeze.

i'm ready to try my hand at another type of
finish, I've heard of conversion varnishes...what are they? sprayable?
durable? would i get in the same trouble with say an Oxford waterborn
lacquer? I'm always dealing with temperature and humidity problems where
i
live and would like suggestions.


Too long to explain here, and too easy to Google. There are precats,
post cats, CABs, conversion lacquers, conversion varnishes, etc. It
is too easy to confuse the names and their applications.

Try starting here, and explore the site. The goal of good finishing
is reached by a lot of different methods, and you won't find a more
knowledgeable library than this:

http://tinyurl.com/379e6w

Good luck!

Robert



  #3   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,287
Default Finish problems again....

On Feb 26, 2:17 pm, "mcgyver" wrote:
Thank you, Robert........
So should I stay with lacquer and tweak my technique...love the ease and
look of lacquer...when everything goes well....;-)


Glad to be of some help. There are some good finishers here, and they
all seem to be pretty generous with their time (when they have it!)

Feel free to post away any questions. The more details (like
application equipment, etc.,) the better.

When lacquer works as advertised, it is a thing of beauty. Easy to
apply, easy to repair, and easy to build coats.

When it doesn't, is sucks in the worst way.

Robert
  #4   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,339
Default Finish problems again....

wrote:

When lacquer works as advertised, it is a thing of beauty. Easy to
apply, easy to repair, and easy to build coats.


I've found "dew point spread" to be more reliable than looking at
temperature and humidity.

A 70F day, with a dew point of 52F is an 18 degree spread. A 70F day
with a 62F dew point is an 8 degree spread. The dew point is commonly
available on most weather web pages. I live near two small airports, so
I dial up the automated weather systems, which are updated once a
minute. Weather Underground (wunderground.com) will grab local airports
and rapid fire update it, based on the user's zip code.

Many NC lacquer vendors recommend 20 degrees spread, I've gotten away
with 15 several times. Most product information sheets, available at
the finish mfg's web site, will contain such information, much more than
is usually printed on the can.

On colder days with the proper spread, fast thinners will work fine in
NC lacquer, with no blushing. People sometimes get caught on cool days
by what they think is low humidity, but in reality, the dew point is too
high.

I don't spray water base under 72F without warming the finish in a water
bath. I'll use the water bath down to ~ 65F. Below 65F, I don't spray
WB at all. 1000 watt worklights will also slightly warm the work
surface, helping WB flow-out. WB does not seem to be very humidity
sensitive, but the folks who live in the humid places like Houston, or
the very dry deserts see extremes that I don't see.
Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Finish problems again.... Mike Marlow Woodworking 2 February 26th 08 03:29 PM
Questions on finish/no finish for INSIDE of chests G.E.R.R.Y. Woodworking 12 August 22nd 06 03:30 AM
shiny/matt patches on emulsion finish - how to get the 'mattest' finish [email protected] UK diy 0 February 18th 06 12:50 PM
Finish problems robert hann Woodworking 11 September 16th 05 04:17 PM
Can we use water based finish on oil based finish for maintenance coats? John Smith Woodworking 6 April 28th 04 05:45 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:22 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"