Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
I've in the middle of building a play/swingset for my kids, and now I'm
second guessing the safety of my design. Since I don't have a huge amount of space I modified a typical design I've seen around the internet. First, I secured four 4x4's in the ground w/ cement to make a 5'x5' "fort/platform" 5' off the ground. I have a 6"x6"x12' that I plan to use for the swing beam off one side of the fort (I think a 6x6 should be okay for a 12' span from what I've read, if not correct me here too please). I plan on bolting a 4x6 across 2 of the 4x4's to support the swing beam. This next part is where I'm starting to worry that I made a bad choice. Since I didn't want to take up a large amount of space w/ the traditional A-frame, I put a 6"x6"x12' four feet into the ground, secured w/ about 300lbs of cement. This gives me my 8' swing beam, which is what I wanted. So my question is, will the 6"x6"x12' that I will use instead of the traditional A-frame be strong enough at the base to support the swinging? If not I guess I could add some 4x4 supports, but that brings up the next question of how high and what angle would I need to put them? Thanks in advance for your input. |
#2
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
|
#3
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
Wow, If a 2 X 2 is all that is needed to do the job, then a 4 X 4 is
better so lets use an 8 X 8. I have lifted my car off of the ground with less than that. I have lifted the front end of my car from a 2 X 12 which spanned 12 feet, with a chain hoist. But then maybe I just take a lot of chances when I went under it to work on it. My house, which is a wood frame, sits on a sill which is an 8 X 10 and spans 10 feet between foundation supports. That house is heavy enough that when jacking up a section of it, that it broke my 5 ton jack, and I had to go to a 20 ton jack. You see, that wood beam was supporting and holding at least 5 tons or more of weight pushing down on it without failing. Now do you really think that your swing and children will really weigh even a half a ton of weight??? I am sure that there will be many out there that will disagree with me, and that is Ok with me. But I personally think that you are into overkill. With what you are building, I would not hesitate to put my children on it, and all the rest of the kids in the neighborhood at the same time. But I tell you what, why don't you throw a rope over it and lift yourself up and swing on that rope. you will know just as soon as you do so if you can trust it to having your children on it. Zap wrote: I've in the middle of building a play/swingset for my kids, and now I'm second guessing the safety of my design. Since I don't have a huge amount of space I modified a typical design I've seen around the internet. First, I secured four 4x4's in the ground w/ cement to make a 5'x5' "fort/platform" 5' off the ground. I have a 6"x6"x12' that I plan to use for the swing beam off one side of the fort (I think a 6x6 should be okay for a 12' span from what I've read, if not correct me here too please). I plan on bolting a 4x6 across 2 of the 4x4's to support the swing beam. This next part is where I'm starting to worry that I made a bad choice. Since I didn't want to take up a large amount of space w/ the traditional A-frame, I put a 6"x6"x12' four feet into the ground, secured w/ about 300lbs of cement. This gives me my 8' swing beam, which is what I wanted. So my question is, will the 6"x6"x12' that I will use instead of the traditional A-frame be strong enough at the base to support the swinging? If not I guess I could add some 4x4 supports, but that brings up the next question of how high and what angle would I need to put them? Thanks in advance for your input. |
#4
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
|
#6
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
300 lbs of cement? four feet into the ground, hell why not just use
telephone poles? While your at it get a well drilling rig and really sink them in the ground! My son's swing set is red cedar 3" timbers and 1X4's and all that sits ON THE GROUND with a couple of stakes hammered in. The only thing that is cemented is the pole for the slide and I only used a 1/2 bag of cement for that. What you've got is the frame work for a nuclear blast proof set! My set cost 700.00 and took me a day and used about 15x6 ft of land! I think what we've got here is a troll.. Searcher |
#7
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
I think the only real concern would be the lateral forces on the dsingle
upright leg when big folks are swinging in synch.. I'd get a couple of adults (one for each swing you have), and get them all swinging together (in phase). Have someone stand by the side, and see how much the leg deflects. Make your decision based on that. empiracle evidence is always best.... -_JD wrote in message oups.com... I've in the middle of building a play/swingset for my kids, and now I'm second guessing the safety of my design. Since I don't have a huge amount of space I modified a typical design I've seen around the internet. First, I secured four 4x4's in the ground w/ cement to make a 5'x5' "fort/platform" 5' off the ground. I have a 6"x6"x12' that I plan to use for the swing beam off one side of the fort (I think a 6x6 should be okay for a 12' span from what I've read, if not correct me here too please). I plan on bolting a 4x6 across 2 of the 4x4's to support the swing beam. This next part is where I'm starting to worry that I made a bad choice. Since I didn't want to take up a large amount of space w/ the traditional A-frame, I put a 6"x6"x12' four feet into the ground, secured w/ about 300lbs of cement. This gives me my 8' swing beam, which is what I wanted. So my question is, will the 6"x6"x12' that I will use instead of the traditional A-frame be strong enough at the base to support the swinging? If not I guess I could add some 4x4 supports, but that brings up the next question of how high and what angle would I need to put them? Thanks in advance for your input. |
#8
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
Well I must say, my wife and I did laugh at some of the responses, but
honestly I'm not just trolling the boards or looking to lob a softball for someone to practice their funnies. There's going to be 3 swings, and at times, could have an adult or two along w/ a child. JD summed up my concerns best "the lateral forces on the dsingle upright leg when big folks are swinging." With big folks being 140-200lb adults swinging, I just was unsure of how much force would be generated on the single upright leg. jd wrote: I think the only real concern would be the lateral forces on the dsingle upright leg when big folks are swinging in synch.. I'd get a couple of adults (one for each swing you have), and get them all swinging together (in phase). Have someone stand by the side, and see how much the leg deflects. Make your decision based on that. empiracle evidence is always best.... -_JD |
#9
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
wrote in message oups.com... Well I must say, my wife and I did laugh at some of the responses, but honestly I'm not just trolling the boards or looking to lob a softball for someone to practice their funnies. There's going to be 3 swings, and at times, could have an adult or two along w/ a child. JD summed up my concerns best "the lateral forces on the dsingle upright leg when big folks are swinging." With big folks being 140-200lb adults swinging, I just was unsure of how much force would be generated on the single upright leg. Acceleration would be one G, so you can use the weight and standard angular momentum calculations for the radius of the swing. Not that it makes a lot of difference unless you're going to compute the length and leverage of the elastic upright. |
#11
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Is my swing set gonna be safe, now I'm doubting myself?
wrote in
oups.com: Yep you are correct, the only thing I am concerned with is the single upright 6x6 post that's being used in lieu of the traditional A-frame. I don't know how to do the calculations, but if you have 200-400 hundred pounds of people swinging in phase on a 5 1/2 foot chain, it's going to be a lot more than just that few hundred pounds of force at the base of that upright post. I don't have much experience w/ building things like this and wasn't sure if the post could easily shake loose or crack the concrete from the swinging. It's reassuring to hear the 4x4 swing at your campground hasn't moved even when bigger kids have played on it, thanks for the info. It seems some people are misunderstanding your concern. You will have ZERO issues with downward weight. You ropes or chains will break before the beam or post would You concern is the lateral (side to side) force. Will it start moving back and forth when someone is swinging. It could be a 12x12 post and still come crashing down if enough side force is applied. At my campground there is a baby/toddler swing set made of two 4x4 posts, set in concrete to an unknown depth. with a 4x4 cross member on top. The swings, although designed for little kids, do attract some big kids too. It is holding up OK and not moving. I think you will be fine. Inviato da X-Privat.Org - Registrazione gratuita http://www.x-privat.org/join.php I have a yard swing out back made from landscape timbers and it has been with us for 20+ years now. In its time it has seen well over 400 pounds of various and sundry sized urchins abusing it and hasn't given out on us yet. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Photos of pie safe | Woodworking | |||
Who has a Fire Safe? AnyTestimonials? | Home Repair | |||
Food Safe Finishes (aka Speaking of Goblets) | Woodturning | |||
How to get a safe out of your basement | Home Repair | |||
OT - Domestic Safe | UK diy |