Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
gun blue a table saw surface
Like most of you, I am careful to clean/wax my table saw whenever I use it
(or sometime more often depending on the weather) to keep the surface clean and 'non-stick'. Now, I don't fish much anymore (stay with me here), but recently went with my brother to the Texas gulf coast and in my old tackle box was a "file knife" (a squid knife as we called them) that I had made from a metal file some 35+ years ago. We didn't catch any keepers in case you're wondering, but the knife still had a descent edge from whenever the last time I sharpened it, and I can't really remember when that was. In any case, that file knife was treated with generic gun bluing agent when it was made - after grinding, sanding, and rough sharpening. After 35+ years and plenty of uses this file knife had minimal rust (oxidation) other than on the sharpened edge surface and had required no virtually no care over time, even after a number of trips to both fresh and salt water. This caused me to wonder how gun bluing (an acid of sorts, I believe) might work on a cast tablesaw surface. For the record, I'm not about to experiment with my own table saw :-), but was wondering if any of you good people have done this. If so, I'm curious how it has or has not worked out, and any other comments you might have |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Dave wrote:
This caused me to wonder how gun bluing (an acid of sorts, I believe) might work on a cast tablesaw surface. Lots of "gun blue" recipes out there. In general they add minimal rust resistance and they don't take kindly to cast iron (rather than steel). If you're looking for rust resistance from blueing, then you'll be wanting a process a bit more complex than the usual selenium salts in methanol from Bob's Hunt'n Shootin' Supplies (and that's a thread for another day). Besides which Birchwood Casey's blue is one of the worst I've used - even Liberon's is better. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Blueing, certainly is not a rust preventative. It is a coating primarily to
obscure reflection, and give a more palatable color then a stark metal finish. "Dave" wrote in message ... Like most of you, I am careful to clean/wax my table saw whenever I use it (or sometime more often depending on the weather) to keep the surface clean and 'non-stick'. Now, I don't fish much anymore (stay with me here), but recently went with my brother to the Texas gulf coast and in my old tackle box was a "file knife" (a squid knife as we called them) that I had made from a metal file some 35+ years ago. We didn't catch any keepers in case you're wondering, but the knife still had a descent edge from whenever the last time I sharpened it, and I can't really remember when that was. In any case, that file knife was treated with generic gun bluing agent when it was made - after grinding, sanding, and rough sharpening. After 35+ years and plenty of uses this file knife had minimal rust (oxidation) other than on the sharpened edge surface and had required no virtually no care over time, even after a number of trips to both fresh and salt water. This caused me to wonder how gun bluing (an acid of sorts, I believe) might work on a cast tablesaw surface. For the record, I'm not about to experiment with my own table saw :-), but was wondering if any of you good people have done this. If so, I'm curious how it has or has not worked out, and any other comments you might have |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
*Real* blueing (not the kind out of a bottle) actually is a fairly
good rust barrier. On the down side, it requires dunking the material into hot vats of caustic liquids. I suspect this would do wonders for the flatness of a table saw surface, not to mention the general difficulty of dunking your table saw. PK On Tue, 20 Sep 2005 12:09:15 GMT, "HMFIC-1369" Baa wrote: Blueing, certainly is not a rust preventative. It is a coating primarily to obscure reflection, and give a more palatable color then a stark metal finish. "Dave" wrote in message .. . Like most of you, I am careful to clean/wax my table saw whenever I use it (or sometime more often depending on the weather) to keep the surface clean and 'non-stick'. Now, I don't fish much anymore (stay with me here), but recently went with my brother to the Texas gulf coast and in my old tackle box was a "file knife" (a squid knife as we called them) that I had made from a metal file some 35+ years ago. We didn't catch any keepers in case you're wondering, but the knife still had a descent edge from whenever the last time I sharpened it, and I can't really remember when that was. In any case, that file knife was treated with generic gun bluing agent when it was made - after grinding, sanding, and rough sharpening. After 35+ years and plenty of uses this file knife had minimal rust (oxidation) other than on the sharpened edge surface and had required no virtually no care over time, even after a number of trips to both fresh and salt water. This caused me to wonder how gun bluing (an acid of sorts, I believe) might work on a cast tablesaw surface. For the record, I'm not about to experiment with my own table saw :-), but was wondering if any of you good people have done this. If so, I'm curious how it has or has not worked out, and any other comments you might have |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
"Dave" wrote in message ... Like most of you, I am careful to clean/wax my table saw whenever I use it (or sometime more often depending on the weather) to keep the surface clean and 'non-stick'. snipped This caused me to wonder how gun bluing (an acid of sorts, I believe) might work on a cast tablesaw surface. For the record, I'm not about to experiment with my own table saw :-), but was wondering if any of you good people have done this. If so, I'm curious how it has or has not worked out, and any other comments you might have Gun blue offers some protection in that it is a controlled surface oxidation, which inhibits further oxidation/rust. The benefit is about equal to a nice patina that only time can achieve. A generally available treatment is black oxide, a process available in most industrial cities. It is similar in process, if not color, to gun blue. In fact, some gun 'blue' is closer to black in color. Contact a black oxide processor and discuss the process, it's benefits, how it works on cast iron, and get their opinion on whether the heat of the solution is enough to warp your table. Don't waste your time on "cold blue" applications. -- ******** Bill Pounds http://www.billpounds.com |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Dave wrote:
Like most of you, I am careful to clean/wax my table saw whenever I use it (or sometime more often depending on the weather) to keep the surface clean and 'non-stick'. Now, I don't fish much anymore (stay with me here), but recently went with my brother to the Texas gulf coast and in my old tackle box was a "file knife" (a squid knife as we called them) that I had made from a metal file some 35+ years ago. We didn't catch any keepers in case you're wondering, but the knife still had a descent edge from whenever the last time I sharpened it, and I can't really remember when that was. In any case, that file knife was treated with generic gun bluing agent when it was made - after grinding, sanding, and rough sharpening. After 35+ years and plenty of uses this file knife had minimal rust (oxidation) other than on the sharpened edge surface and had required no virtually no care over time, even after a number of trips to both fresh and salt water. This caused me to wonder how gun bluing (an acid of sorts, I believe) might work on a cast tablesaw surface. For the record, I'm not about to experiment with my own table saw :-), but was wondering if any of you good people have done this. If so, I'm curious how it has or has not worked out, and any other comments you might have Don't know about your knife, might be some flim flam there. Bluing is nothing but controlled rust process and it is not durable nor is it a very good rust preventative. Maybe that's why England switch to paint on the Enfields. Boards sliding over the bluing will remove it rather quickly and lots of other stuff will scratch it. You would be better off with a phosphate process. But best of all, you probably want to stick with what the woodworkers in high humidity areas suggest. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
If it would hurt your tablesaw, what do you think it would do to a rifle
barrel? Warped barrels are fine, right? Think about it. Hot bluing will not change the shape or damage anything. In any case, hot bluing is a time expedient, modern method. No need for heat unless you are trying for speed.. "PK" wrote in message ... *Real* blueing (not the kind out of a bottle) actually is a fairly good rust barrier. On the down side, it requires dunking the material into hot vats of caustic liquids. I suspect this would do wonders for the flatness of a table saw surface, not to mention the general difficulty of dunking your table saw. PK |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 21 Sep 2005 01:15:48 GMT, "CW" wrote:
If it would hurt your tablesaw, what do you think it would do to a rifle barrel? Warped barrels are fine, right? Think about it. Hot bluing will not change the shape or damage anything. In any case, hot bluing is a time expedient, modern method. No need for heat unless you are trying for speed.. "PK" wrote in message .. . *Real* blueing (not the kind out of a bottle) actually is a fairly good rust barrier. On the down side, it requires dunking the material into hot vats of caustic liquids. I suspect this would do wonders for the flatness of a table saw surface, not to mention the general difficulty of dunking your table saw. PK Good point about the heat involved and metal stresses. Hot bluing is better than the cold blue solutions, and about the same as a more natural browning process, as far as continuing rust protection is concerned. That is, better than nothing, but not as good as other treatments. PK |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
It would appear that none of the nay-sayers have tried Brownell's
Oxphoblue. I've tried several finish types, and that's the only one that came out well. Excellent in fact. Use several coats, one won't do it, and probably not two. JOAT If it ain't broke - fix it 'til it is. - Unknown |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
"J T" wrote in message ... It would appear that none of the nay-sayers have tried Brownell's Oxphoblue. I've tried several finish types, and that's the only one that came out well. Excellent in fact. Use several coats, one won't do it, and probably not two. On the contrary, I have used it, and it is arguably the best of the breed. And, that's kind of sad. I have had some good results, but even then the color was not permanent. I am leaving tomorrow for a week in WY chasing prairie goats. Had my custom Mauser at the range last weekend looking it over. I did a modification to the trigger guard about 15 years ago, and used the Brownell product to avoid rebluing the guard (would be expensive for one small part). The color of the blue has faded and I'm glad that it is on the bottom and not often seen. Would be a waste of time on a TS table IMO. -- ******** Bill Pounds http://www.billpounds.com |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Gun Blue is not a "rust preventative" and never has been. Wasn't designed
for it, isn't used for it either. If you treat a blued fire arm like stainless steel you'd get a rust bucket. There are other coatings designed for that! Take your S&W or Colt dip in a bucket o water and then tell me What a great rust preventative it is!!!! "PK" wrote in message ... *Real* blueing (not the kind out of a bottle) actually is a fairly good rust barrier. On the down side, it requires dunking the material into hot vats of caustic liquids. I suspect this would do wonders for the flatness of a table saw surface, not to mention the general difficulty of dunking your table saw. PK On Tue, 20 Sep 2005 12:09:15 GMT, "HMFIC-1369" Baa wrote: Blueing, certainly is not a rust preventative. It is a coating primarily to obscure reflection, and give a more palatable color then a stark metal finish. "Dave" wrote in message .. . Like most of you, I am careful to clean/wax my table saw whenever I use it (or sometime more often depending on the weather) to keep the surface clean and 'non-stick'. Now, I don't fish much anymore (stay with me here), but recently went with my brother to the Texas gulf coast and in my old tackle box was a "file knife" (a squid knife as we called them) that I had made from a metal file some 35+ years ago. We didn't catch any keepers in case you're wondering, but the knife still had a descent edge from whenever the last time I sharpened it, and I can't really remember when that was. In any case, that file knife was treated with generic gun bluing agent when it was made - after grinding, sanding, and rough sharpening. After 35+ years and plenty of uses this file knife had minimal rust (oxidation) other than on the sharpened edge surface and had required no virtually no care over time, even after a number of trips to both fresh and salt water. This caused me to wonder how gun bluing (an acid of sorts, I believe) might work on a cast tablesaw surface. For the record, I'm not about to experiment with my own table saw :-), but was wondering if any of you good people have done this. If so, I'm curious how it has or has not worked out, and any other comments you might have |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
"HMFIC-1369" Baa wrote in message news:AyhYe.19472$Yu2.15298@trnddc02... Gun Blue is not a "rust preventative" and never has been. Wasn't designed for it, isn't used for it either. If you treat a blued fire arm like stainless steel you'd get a rust bucket. There are other coatings designed for that! Not a preventative - true. But it is intended for that purpose, primarily. Oh, we like the blue/black color, it looks nice, but that was not the original purpose. The process also adds the ability of the surface to take and hold oil, better than bare steel. No, I won't stick my guns in a bucket of water. I also would not want to handle guns in a white metal state either. They would pick up fingerprint rust spots much easier than blued pieces. Ever wonder why heat treated allen cap bolts come with a black oxide coating? It's because the heat treating process has removed all traces of oil from the surface leaving them to start corroding immediately. Black oxide is an inexpensive process that will slow the corrosion process AND hold a coating of oil. Such bolts can also be zinc plated, but a post plating baking process is required to prevent hydrogen embrittlement, which adds cost. So, in fact, the protection is modest at best, but is some protection nonetheless. Resources: http://www.unibath.com/blackoxide.php3 http://www.allblackco-llc.com/ Incidentally, painting is one of the worst things you can do to a firearm. The result will be rust UNDER the paint where you cannot treat with oil. -- ******** Bill Pounds http://www.billpounds.com |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
|
#14
|
|||
|
|||
"PK" wrote in message ... On Wed, 21 Sep 2005 01:15:48 GMT, "CW" wrote: Good point about the heat involved and metal stresses. Hot bluing is better than the cold blue solutions, Better than the "instant cold blue". Not better than a good cold bluing job. A good cold bluing job is at least the equal of hot bluing. The only reason gun manufacturers don't use it is time. |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
The instant stuff is what I meant. Sorry I wasn't clear.
PK On Thu, 22 Sep 2005 01:52:48 GMT, "CW" wrote: "PK" wrote in message .. . On Wed, 21 Sep 2005 01:15:48 GMT, "CW" wrote: Good point about the heat involved and metal stresses. Hot bluing is better than the cold blue solutions, Better than the "instant cold blue". Not better than a good cold bluing job. A good cold bluing job is at least the equal of hot bluing. The only reason gun manufacturers don't use it is time. |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Parkerizing is a bit better than bluing at holding oils, but for a good table
surface (slick, rust-resistant), black chrome would work (certainly not easy for the do-it-yourselfer) -Bruce |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
router/outfeed table; previously charted territory? | Woodworking | |||
Resurfacing table with butcher-block surface | Woodworking | |||
Impressions/Review of Craftsman Professional Table Saw | Woodworking | |||
Adjustable Shop/Die Table | Metalworking | |||
New bandsaw saga PartII (long) | Woodworking |