Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
UK diy (uk.d-i-y) For the discussion of all topics related to diy (do-it-yourself) in the UK. All levels of experience and proficency are welcome to join in to ask questions or offer solutions. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
Hi i do a lot of odd jobs for people and have been considering
upgrading my jigsaw but someone mentioned to me a router would be better. I always thought a router was just for making patterns and carvings of wood not for cutting through wood, so what exactly can a router do? i usaully spend approx £65 on a jigsaw what router would you get? is there any guides on the net to see what a router can do? and what accesories would i need. i do a lot of kitchen tops, loft flooring, self build sheds, doors etc steve |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 16:35:27 +0000, SJ wrote:
Hi i do a lot of odd jobs for people and have been considering upgrading my jigsaw but someone mentioned to me a router would be better. I always thought a router was just for making patterns and carvings of wood not for cutting through wood, so what exactly can a router do? i usaully spend approx £65 on a jigsaw what router would you get? is there any guides on the net to see what a router can do? and what accesories would i need. i do a lot of kitchen tops, loft flooring, self build sheds, doors etc steve You could start by looking at Trend Machinery's web site. They have a lot of downloadable guides about routing and what can be done. Certainly for trimming worktops and edges of material a router is ideal. It is also useful for hinge rebating, mortises for locks etc. Another example is neatening after having used a jigsaw. Applications are more limited by imagination than anything else; but you can't really say that a router is a one for one alternative to a jigsaw. For the kind of applications that you describe, you really need a 1/2" rather than a 1/4" router because of the power and size of machine. The bad news is that you won't buy anything worth having in the sub-£100 price range - the DIY store own brands, by experience of people here are largely underpowered junk. A good value start is the Freud 2000, but you are looking at around £160 for that. ..andy To email, substitute .nospam with .gl |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
SJ wrote:
|| Hi i do a lot of odd jobs for people and have been considering || upgrading my jigsaw but someone mentioned to me a router would be || better. || I always thought a router was just for making patterns and carvings || of wood not for cutting through wood, so what exactly can a router || do? i usaully spend approx £65 on a jigsaw what router would you || get? is there any guides on the net to see what a router can do? and || what accesories would i need. || || i do a lot of kitchen tops, loft flooring, self build sheds, doors || etc || || || steve A Router in respect to a Jigsaw can do numerous jobs that a Jigsaw can't i.e cut channels/bore holes/chamfer edges/fancy edging/ the list is endless, it can cut straight edges but this normally takes 2 to three cut's depending on thickness of wood, cuts a lot straighter than a Jig. Two models here the higher the wattage the better, also half inch chuck JCB are decent quality tools. http://tinyurl.com/23o27 -- Grouch If things get any worse, I'll have to ask you to stop helping me. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
Andy Hall wrote:
A good value start is the Freud 2000, but you are looking at around £160 for that. And a very nice router it is too. Hell of a kick compared to my little 1/4" 1kW jobbie. -- Grunff |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 17:37:14 -0000, "Grouch"
wrote: A Router in respect to a Jigsaw can do numerous jobs that a Jigsaw can't i.e cut channels/bore holes/chamfer edges/fancy edging/ the list is endless, it can cut straight edges but this normally takes 2 to three cut's depending on thickness of wood, cuts a lot straighter than a Jig. Two models here the higher the wattage the better, also half inch chuck JCB are decent quality tools. http://tinyurl.com/23o27 Out of the two that you list one is £49 the other is £59 what would you go for? |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 17:37:14 -0000, "Grouch" wrote:
SJ wrote: || Hi i do a lot of odd jobs for people and have been considering || upgrading my jigsaw but someone mentioned to me a router would be || better. || I always thought a router was just for making patterns and carvings || of wood not for cutting through wood, so what exactly can a router || do? i usaully spend approx £65 on a jigsaw what router would you || get? is there any guides on the net to see what a router can do? and || what accesories would i need. || || i do a lot of kitchen tops, loft flooring, self build sheds, doors || etc || || || steve A Router in respect to a Jigsaw can do numerous jobs that a Jigsaw can't i.e cut channels/bore holes/chamfer edges/fancy edging/ the list is endless, it can cut straight edges but this normally takes 2 to three cut's depending on thickness of wood, cuts a lot straighter than a Jig. Two models here the higher the wattage the better, also half inch chuck JCB are decent quality tools. http://tinyurl.com/23o27 -- Grouch If things get any worse, I'll have to ask you to stop helping me. On the other tand I would not want to cut a wavey line in some thin sheets of 8x4 using my big heavy router ........ Rick |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
SJ wrote:
|| On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 17:37:14 -0000, "Grouch" || wrote: || || ||| A Router in respect to a Jigsaw can do numerous jobs that a Jigsaw ||| can't i.e cut channels/bore holes/chamfer edges/fancy edging/ the ||| list is endless, it can cut straight edges but this normally takes ||| 2 to three cut's depending on thickness of wood, cuts a lot ||| straighter than a Jig. ||| ||| Two models here the higher the wattage the better, also half inch ||| chuck ||| ||| JCB are decent quality tools. ||| http://tinyurl.com/23o27 || || || Out of the two that you list one is £49 the other is £59 what would || you go for? Well the problem there is should you go for the £49 jobbie which is 1500watts and the other is £59 1200Watts. I think the prices have been mixed up, who knows, best to go to nearest Argos and find out. 1500Watts is what I would go for. -- Grouch If things get any worse, I'll have to ask you to stop helping me. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 18:24:15 +0000, SJ wrote:
On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 17:37:14 -0000, "Grouch" wrote: A Router in respect to a Jigsaw can do numerous jobs that a Jigsaw can't i.e cut channels/bore holes/chamfer edges/fancy edging/ the list is endless, it can cut straight edges but this normally takes 2 to three cut's depending on thickness of wood, cuts a lot straighter than a Jig. Two models here the higher the wattage the better, also half inch chuck JCB are decent quality tools. http://tinyurl.com/23o27 Out of the two that you list one is £49 the other is £59 what would you go for? Neither. You won't get good results out of a router in this price range if you are planning regular use. ..andy To email, substitute .nospam with .gl |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
Andy Hall wrote:
|| On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 18:24:15 ?, SJ wrote: || ||| On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 17:37:14 -0000, "Grouch" ||| wrote: ||| ||| |||| A Router in respect to a Jigsaw can do numerous jobs that a Jigsaw |||| can't i.e cut channels/bore holes/chamfer edges/fancy edging/ the |||| list is endless, it can cut straight edges but this normally takes |||| 2 to three cut's depending on thickness of wood, cuts a lot |||| straighter than a Jig. |||| |||| Two models here the higher the wattage the better, also half inch |||| chuck |||| |||| JCB are decent quality tools. |||| http://tinyurl.com/23o27 ||| ||| ||| Out of the two that you list one is £49 the other is £59 what would ||| you go for? || || Neither. || || You won't get good results out of a router in this price range if you || are planning regular use. || || || .andy || || To email, substitute .nospam with .gl Why.? JCB is not a own brand store spin off. Plus he's not going into Mass production. I have a B/D which has been taken a lot of punishment the 850W, had it for two years now and it's still working. Power tools will last for ages provided the operater does not force it through the Job. I also have Bosch 1500w. The one,s your on about are more for Industry work rather than the average DIYer. -- Grouch If things get any worse, I'll have to ask you to stop helping me. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 19:00:28 -0000, "Grouch"
wrote: I also have Bosch 1500w. The one,s your on about are more for Industry work rather than the average DIYer. I would be using it roughly 3 times a week probably more as i get used to it i think, at the moment i use a jigsaw a lot so going by what people have said the router will be a jigsaw replacement, would it be better to spend say £50 till i got used to a router or jump in with a "proper £££" one, as i said i have a diy business so some weeks it might get used once some weeks then could be out every day steve |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
So if im correct im looking at a 1500w motor and half inch collet at
the moment and prices from £59 (jcb) upto £160 (Freud 2000) what about the bits to go in the end what would be a good selection to have. (kitchen worktops, letter boxs, sheds, doors etc) thanks steve |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
SJ wrote:
I would be using it roughly 3 times a week probably more as i get used to it i think That's almost "pro" tool territory. I'd definitely be looking at a 1/2" in the £150-£200 bracket if I were you. at the moment i use a jigsaw a lot so going by what people have said the router will be a jigsaw replacement I wouldn't say that it's a replacement. I use router/jigsaw/circular saw for different things, and wouldn't really want to be without any one of them. would it be better to spend say £50 till i got used to a router or jump in with a "proper £££" one, If you intend to use it as you say, you're unlikely to find a £50 up to the jobs you want to do. as i said i have a diy business so some weeks it might get used once some weeks then could be out every day Then you need something which is powerful, has a decent level of precision and will last. -- Grunff |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
Grunff wrote:
SJ wrote: I would be using it roughly 3 times a week probably more as i get used to it i think That's almost "pro" tool territory. I'd definitely be looking at a 1/2" in the ?150-?200 bracket if I were you. at the moment i use a jigsaw a lot so going by what people have said the router will be a jigsaw replacement I wouldn't say that it's a replacement. I use router/jigsaw/circular saw for different things, and wouldn't really want to be without any one of them. It certainly can't substitute for a jigsaw, in any but the crudest sense. The problems with it are it's practically impossible to use free-hand, and keep anywhere close to a line (at least in many materials.) It's lots louder, has a much, much wider kerf, and the bits are many times more expensive. |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
SJ wrote:
Hi i do a lot of odd jobs for people and have been considering upgrading my jigsaw but someone mentioned to me a router would be better. I always thought a router was just for making patterns and carvings of wood not for cutting through wood, so what exactly can a router do? i usaully spend approx £65 on a jigsaw what router would you get? is there any guides on the net to see what a router can do? and what accesories would i need. i do a lot of kitchen tops, loft flooring, self build sheds, doors etc Well last weekend I needed to make two 2m lengths of 18mm gravel board 2cm narrower. I screwed one to the other so that it was 2cm back, loaded a bearing guided trimmer in my £20 1100W Power Devil Router and working in sections had them down and straight quite easily. I did have to stop after the first one and give the cutter a tickle to sharpen it but it went well if you took it steady and didn't force the issue. If you are planning on doing worktops then you will need a decent sized and powered 1/2" model and a template. A trimming cutter and a straight edge will size a door for you very nicely, a straight cutter and template will do your lock mortices and hinges too. A 1/2" jobbie in a table will make you T&G for your flooring too, though you will likely need a fairly robust one to do more than a few tens of meters worth. Peter -- Add my middle initial to email me. It has become attached to a country |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 19:29:48 +0000, SJ wrote:
So if im correct im looking at a 1500w motor and half inch collet at the moment and prices from £59 (jcb) upto £160 (Freud 2000) what about the bits to go in the end what would be a good selection to have. (kitchen worktops, letter boxs, sheds, doors etc) thanks steve The price range for good quality 1/2" routers is up to £300. The Freud one is at the starting point of "worth buying for regular use" The jobs that you describe mainly involve trimming bits that are fairly long, so they don't tend to come in the assorted packs. Trend, Freud and CMT do kitchen fitter's sets which would actually cover a lot of what you describe. You could buy a mixed pack of bits, but to be honest you probably wouldn't use a lot of the fancy shaped ones in the tasks you described. On the other hand, you can pick up sets of assorted bits quite cheaply if you feel like trying things out. For jobs like lock mortises, hinge mortises and worktops there are jigs that you can buy or even make pretty easily. I would suggest cherry picking the bits that you need as you go. ..andy To email, substitute .nospam with .gl |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
"Andy Hall" wrote in message ... On Wed, 17 Mar 2004 16:35:27 +0000, SJ wrote: Hi i do a lot of odd jobs for people and have been considering upgrading my jigsaw but someone mentioned to me a router would be better. I always thought a router was just for making patterns and carvings of wood not for cutting through wood, so what exactly can a router do? i usaully spend approx £65 on a jigsaw what router would you get? is there any guides on the net to see what a router can do? and what accesories would i need. i do a lot of kitchen tops, loft flooring, self build sheds, doors etc steve You could start by looking at Trend Machinery's web site. They have a lot of downloadable guides about routing and what can be done. Certainly for trimming worktops and edges of material a router is ideal. It is also useful for hinge rebating, mortises for locks etc. Another example is neatening after having used a jigsaw. Applications are more limited by imagination than anything else; but you can't really say that a router is a one for one alternative to a jigsaw. For the kind of applications that you describe, you really need a 1/2" rather than a 1/4" router because of the power and size of machine. The bad news is that you won't buy anything worth having in the sub-£100 price range - the DIY store own brands, by experience of people here are largely underpowered junk. A good value start is the Freud 2000, but you are looking at around £160 for that. My local power tool shop is selling a Router table including a 1/2" Ryobi Router for £98 The table is cast Al and much better built the B&Q Performance Pro Router table that is on sale for same price in B&Q. Anybody have any opinions on Ryobi ... never owned any Ryobi kit. Rick |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
On Fri, 19 Mar 2004 21:46:42 +0000 (UTC), in uk.d-i-y "Rick Hughes"
strung together this: My local power tool shop is selling a Router table including a 1/2" Ryobi Router for £98 Are you sure that's not 1/4"? The table is cast Al and much better built the B&Q Performance Pro Router table that is on sale for same price in B&Q. Anybody have any opinions on Ryobi ... never owned any Ryobi kit. I've got one of those. The table doesn't inspire total confidence but it is reasonable quality, given the price. The router seems sturdy enough. I've done a bit of trimming with it, nothing too serious yet! -- SJW A.C.S. Ltd. |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
"Lurch" wrote in message ... On Fri, 19 Mar 2004 21:46:42 +0000 (UTC), in uk.d-i-y "Rick Hughes" strung together this: My local power tool shop is selling a Router table including a 1/2" Ryobi Router for £98 Are you sure that's not 1/4"? I was wrong ... it's 1/4" or 8mm ..... my Trend is 8mm, and so are all my cutters so maybe I will look at this again. Rick A.C.S. Ltd. |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
On Sun, 21 Mar 2004 22:58:42 +0000 (UTC), in uk.d-i-y "Rick Hughes"
strung together this: "Lurch" wrote in message ... On Fri, 19 Mar 2004 21:46:42 +0000 (UTC), in uk.d-i-y "Rick Hughes" strung together this: My local power tool shop is selling a Router table including a 1/2" Ryobi Router for £98 Are you sure that's not 1/4"? I was wrong ... it's 1/4" or 8mm ..... my Trend is 8mm, and so are all my cutters so maybe I will look at this again. That's better, I'd have been well hacked off if there was a Ryobi 1/2" and table for the same price as my new Ryobi 1/4" and table Rick A.C.S. Ltd. No you're not, I'd have remembered employing you! -- SJW A.C.S. Ltd. |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
|
#22
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
"Lurch" wrote in message ... On 22 Mar 2004 02:37:15 -0800, in uk.d-i-y (mike) strung together this: It's 1/2" according to Baron Bros website: http://www.buyatool.co.uk/acatalog/B...outing_27.html The website's wrong, the Ryobi ERT1150 is 1/4". I know this because, as I mentioned before, I've got one. back to question - how good are RYOBI routers ? Rick A.C.S. Ltd. |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
On Mon, 22 Mar 2004 22:59:27 +0000 (UTC), in uk.d-i-y "Rick Hughes"
strung together this: "Lurch" wrote in message ... On 22 Mar 2004 02:37:15 -0800, in uk.d-i-y (mike) strung together this: It's 1/2" according to Baron Bros website: http://www.buyatool.co.uk/acatalog/B...outing_27.html The website's wrong, the Ryobi ERT1150 is 1/4". I know this because, as I mentioned before, I've got one. back to question - how good are RYOBI routers ? I seem to think I may have answered this but I can't see it in my outbox so I'll go again, possibly. Mine's doing alright, the ERT1150, I haven't done any worktops yet but for general trimming and light duty routing it's done a decent job. Seems fairly well made. -- SJW A.C.S. Ltd. |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
"mike" wrote in message m... It's 1/2" according to Baron Bros website: http://www.buyatool.co.uk/acatalog/B...outing_27.html Did a searching around and also found this - http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.d...tegory=20 781 text clearly states "New stock of this very popular item has arrived. Please be aware that although the item is a 1/2" router Ryobi forget to mention this on the box! " and " a.. Q: Does the router really take 1/2" shank cutters? a.. A: Yes as stated in the above listing it really really does take 1/2"!!! " Rick |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
On Mon, 22 Mar 2004 23:17:18 +0000 (UTC), in uk.d-i-y "Rick Hughes"
strung together this: "mike" wrote in message om... It's 1/2" according to Baron Bros website: http://www.buyatool.co.uk/acatalog/B...outing_27.html Did a searching around and also found this - http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.d...tegory=20 781 text clearly states "New stock of this very popular item has arrived. Please be aware that although the item is a 1/2" router Ryobi forget to mention this on the box! " and " a.. Q: Does the router really take 1/2" shank cutters? a.. A: Yes as stated in the above listing it really really does take 1/2"!!! " Don't believe everything you read. That's the only place I've seen saying it is a 1/2". I've got one, and it's a 1/4". -- SJW A.C.S. Ltd. |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
Does this help in the confusion.
http://www.protrade.co.uk/shop/options.asp?pid=886 "It will also accept 1/2" cutters for occasional use." HTH John |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
On Mon, 22 Mar 2004 23:50:28 +0000 (UTC), in uk.d-i-y "John"
strung together this: Does this help in the confusion. http://www.protrade.co.uk/shop/options.asp?pid=886 "It will also accept 1/2" cutters for occasional use." Yep, think that clears it up a bit. It's still a bit underpowered for continuous use as a 1/2" router. And I think the seller on eBay is advising that the router be used outside the scope of the manufacturers intentions, a definite warranty invalidater! -- SJW A.C.S. Ltd. |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
Yep, think that clears it up a bit. It's still a bit underpowered for
continuous use as a 1/2" router. And I think the seller on eBay is advising that the router be used outside the scope of the manufacturers intentions, a definite warranty invalidater! I would tend to agree. If it is a decent quality router and table then it does seem a good price though. Sean |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
"Sean Delere" wrote in message ... Yep, think that clears it up a bit. It's still a bit underpowered for continuous use as a 1/2" router. And I think the seller on eBay is advising that the router be used outside the scope of the manufacturers intentions, a definite warranty invalidater! I contacted the seller asking why the boxed set has 1/4" / 8mm on it when they are saying it's an 1/2" Router .... here is the reply: he router box is indeed as you describe, however the router is a 1/2"router & comes with a 1/2" collet. For some reason Ryobi have chosen not to market the device as a 1/2". Please be confident that the router is as we state, 164 of our customers can't be wrong!!! Regards, Tony Watt Marketing Administrator Buyatool.co.uk A 1/2" Router and table at less than £100 does seem a good offer. Rick |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
RYOBI router table
On Tue, 23 Mar 2004 22:01:28 +0000 (UTC), in uk.d-i-y "Rick Hughes"
strung together this: "Sean Delere" wrote in message ... Yep, think that clears it up a bit. It's still a bit underpowered for continuous use as a 1/2" router. And I think the seller on eBay is advising that the router be used outside the scope of the manufacturers intentions, a definite warranty invalidater! I contacted the seller asking why the boxed set has 1/4" / 8mm on it when they are saying it's an 1/2" Router .... here is the reply: he router box is indeed as you describe, however the router is a 1/2"router & comes with a 1/2" collet. For some reason Ryobi have chosen not to market the device as a 1/2". Please be confident that the router is as we state, 164 of our customers can't be wrong!!! Regards, Tony Watt Marketing Administrator Buyatool.co.uk Does seem a bit like salesmans patter to me. I'm still not buying it. Occasional use, yes. Continuous use, no. Remember, I've got one and it wouldn't last long as a 1/2" router. Talking ******** is quite a well known ruse in salesman circles! A 1/2" Router and table at less than £100 does seem a good offer. Ever heard the phrase "too good to be true"? -- SJW A.C.S. Ltd. |
#31
|
|||
|
|||
Router or jigsaw
One difference is that a jigsaw can be used one-handed. If you work on your
own, that can be important. From that point of view a trimmer (basically a mini router) might be better. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Router table recomendations. | UK diy | |||
Question about using a router | UK diy | |||
Buying a Router | UK diy |