Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#82
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
On 13/07/2017 23:27, wrote:
On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 11:28:13 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 09:33, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 07:04:53 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 03:57, wrote: On Wed, 12 Jul 2017 10:23:24 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 12/07/2017 08:54, wrote: My "suspicion" is any one , or possibly combination of 2, would cause the problem. Still don't know exactly what amperage the branch breakers are, but he has a 63 amp "sub-main" that trips. If he has 7.5 amp breakers (equivalent to 15 amp 120 volt) and he has 25 running an average of 1/4 capacity, that is 46.875 amps. Say the other 4 are at 6 amps each, the main may trip,(70 amps) while shutting any 1 off may keep it from tripping at 64. The "short" resistance in the 4 may not be exactly the same - one may draw heavier than the other on a given day (it IS a "random" fault) - so shutting all 4 off, then turning the others on, it may be different combinations that work from day to day. Well, I have about 10 lights, one water heater (about 30 gallon), one ceiling fan, three refrigerators. When I turned on TV/DVD, used a kettle, turned on A/C, used the range in the kitchen, the breaker was not tripped. It would take a lot more than these to overload a 63A breaker. You have NO IDEA what amperage the other 4 (that cause the trip) are drawing. What is the rating of the branch circuit breakers? The water heater is likely 30 amps, the range is likely 40 amps (if it's all turned on). That is already more than 63 amps!!! If the range is off, it draws nothing, of course - but you do not indicate if it is in use. The fridges could be drawing 3.5 amps each - perhaps 7 when starting, and about the same when running the auto defrost cycle. When it kicked the kettle wa not in use? Or the AC? Were the lights on? With everything else turned off, can you turn on the 4 "bad" breakers without tripping the main? Can't tell the rating of most of the breakers. The electrician who installed them did a great job labeling every one of them. The label sticker is right on the rating. Judging from the size of the breakers, they could be 13, 16, or 20 A. In a euro 240 style system I highly doubt most are over 7.5 amps. My point of mentioning A/C, range, etc. was that besides those constantly on appliances, the breaker was not tripped when A/C or range was turned on. The breaker was tripped when A/C or range was not on. So, it kind of excludes overloading. Now it turns out that the tripped sub-main breaker is a GFCI, a wet circuit is almost certain the cause of the problem. \Being the sub-mains which are being tripped are GFCI breakers, you can bet the farm on it. No idea why they have such a ludicrous system - the branch circuits should be GFCI protected. I just checked eBay. The price is still around $50 a piece. Maybe I should replace those four problematic breakers with GFCI, beside replacing the sub-main breaker. I'd try just replacing the breakers on the problem circuits first - they should trip at something like 5ma where the mains trip at 30ma? fault current. There are so many wires in the sub panel. How do I find the neutral for the particular breakers? The breaker boxes in the US have bus to which all the neutral and ground wires connect to. Not this box. So, where are the neutral wires? And I heard that three phase circuit shares neutral wire. That makes things more complex. Even for the breaker boxes in the US, how to find out which neutral wire goes with which breaker? |
#83
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
On Friday, July 14, 2017 at 9:50:56 PM UTC-4, Lenny Jacobs wrote:
On 13/07/2017 23:27, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 11:28:13 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 09:33, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 07:04:53 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 03:57, wrote: On Wed, 12 Jul 2017 10:23:24 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 12/07/2017 08:54, wrote: My "suspicion" is any one , or possibly combination of 2, would cause the problem. Still don't know exactly what amperage the branch breakers are, but he has a 63 amp "sub-main" that trips. If he has 7.5 amp breakers (equivalent to 15 amp 120 volt) and he has 25 running an average of 1/4 capacity, that is 46.875 amps. Say the other 4 are at 6 amps each, the main may trip,(70 amps) while shutting any 1 off may keep it from tripping at 64. The "short" resistance in the 4 may not be exactly the same - one may draw heavier than the other on a given day (it IS a "random" fault) - so shutting all 4 off, then turning the others on, it may be different combinations that work from day to day. Well, I have about 10 lights, one water heater (about 30 gallon), one ceiling fan, three refrigerators. When I turned on TV/DVD, used a kettle, turned on A/C, used the range in the kitchen, the breaker was not tripped. It would take a lot more than these to overload a 63A breaker. You have NO IDEA what amperage the other 4 (that cause the trip) are drawing. What is the rating of the branch circuit breakers? The water heater is likely 30 amps, the range is likely 40 amps (if it's all turned on). That is already more than 63 amps!!! If the range is off, it draws nothing, of course - but you do not indicate if it is in use. The fridges could be drawing 3.5 amps each - perhaps 7 when starting, and about the same when running the auto defrost cycle. When it kicked the kettle wa not in use? Or the AC? Were the lights on? With everything else turned off, can you turn on the 4 "bad" breakers without tripping the main? Can't tell the rating of most of the breakers. The electrician who installed them did a great job labeling every one of them. The label sticker is right on the rating. Judging from the size of the breakers, they could be 13, 16, or 20 A. In a euro 240 style system I highly doubt most are over 7.5 amps. My point of mentioning A/C, range, etc. was that besides those constantly on appliances, the breaker was not tripped when A/C or range was turned on. The breaker was tripped when A/C or range was not on. So, it kind of excludes overloading. Now it turns out that the tripped sub-main breaker is a GFCI, a wet circuit is almost certain the cause of the problem. \Being the sub-mains which are being tripped are GFCI breakers, you can bet the farm on it. No idea why they have such a ludicrous system - the branch circuits should be GFCI protected. I just checked eBay. The price is still around $50 a piece. Maybe I should replace those four problematic breakers with GFCI, beside replacing the sub-main breaker. I'd try just replacing the breakers on the problem circuits first - they should trip at something like 5ma where the mains trip at 30ma? fault current. There are so many wires in the sub panel. How do I find the neutral for the particular breakers? The breaker boxes in the US have bus to which all the neutral and ground wires connect to. Not this box. So, where are the neutral wires? And I heard that three phase circuit shares neutral wire. That makes things more complex. Even for the breaker boxes in the US, how to find out which neutral wire goes with which breaker? You follow the hot wire from the breaker back to the incoming cable and find the white neutral wire that's with it, that's how you figure it out in the US. In your case, that RCD breaker has 4 wires going through it, with one labeled "N" doesn't it? I don't have the spec sheet for the breaker, but it seems pretty obvious to me that would be the neutral. But does any of this really matter? It sounds like you have a serious safety problem, one that could be lethal, the fault you have must exceed 100ma, isn't it time to hire an electrician and get it fixed? |
#84
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
On 15/07/2017 08:39, trader_4 wrote:
On Friday, July 14, 2017 at 9:50:56 PM UTC-4, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 23:27, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 11:28:13 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 09:33, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 07:04:53 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 03:57, wrote: On Wed, 12 Jul 2017 10:23:24 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 12/07/2017 08:54, wrote: My "suspicion" is any one , or possibly combination of 2, would cause the problem. Still don't know exactly what amperage the branch breakers are, but he has a 63 amp "sub-main" that trips. If he has 7.5 amp breakers (equivalent to 15 amp 120 volt) and he has 25 running an average of 1/4 capacity, that is 46.875 amps. Say the other 4 are at 6 amps each, the main may trip,(70 amps) while shutting any 1 off may keep it from tripping at 64. The "short" resistance in the 4 may not be exactly the same - one may draw heavier than the other on a given day (it IS a "random" fault) - so shutting all 4 off, then turning the others on, it may be different combinations that work from day to day. Well, I have about 10 lights, one water heater (about 30 gallon), one ceiling fan, three refrigerators. When I turned on TV/DVD, used a kettle, turned on A/C, used the range in the kitchen, the breaker was not tripped. It would take a lot more than these to overload a 63A breaker. You have NO IDEA what amperage the other 4 (that cause the trip) are drawing. What is the rating of the branch circuit breakers? The water heater is likely 30 amps, the range is likely 40 amps (if it's all turned on). That is already more than 63 amps!!! If the range is off, it draws nothing, of course - but you do not indicate if it is in use. The fridges could be drawing 3.5 amps each - perhaps 7 when starting, and about the same when running the auto defrost cycle. When it kicked the kettle wa not in use? Or the AC? Were the lights on? With everything else turned off, can you turn on the 4 "bad" breakers without tripping the main? Can't tell the rating of most of the breakers. The electrician who installed them did a great job labeling every one of them. The label sticker is right on the rating. Judging from the size of the breakers, they could be 13, 16, or 20 A. In a euro 240 style system I highly doubt most are over 7.5 amps. My point of mentioning A/C, range, etc. was that besides those constantly on appliances, the breaker was not tripped when A/C or range was turned on. The breaker was tripped when A/C or range was not on. So, it kind of excludes overloading. Now it turns out that the tripped sub-main breaker is a GFCI, a wet circuit is almost certain the cause of the problem. \Being the sub-mains which are being tripped are GFCI breakers, you can bet the farm on it. No idea why they have such a ludicrous system - the branch circuits should be GFCI protected. I just checked eBay. The price is still around $50 a piece. Maybe I should replace those four problematic breakers with GFCI, beside replacing the sub-main breaker. I'd try just replacing the breakers on the problem circuits first - they should trip at something like 5ma where the mains trip at 30ma? fault current. There are so many wires in the sub panel. How do I find the neutral for the particular breakers? The breaker boxes in the US have bus to which all the neutral and ground wires connect to. Not this box. So, where are the neutral wires? And I heard that three phase circuit shares neutral wire. That makes things more complex. Even for the breaker boxes in the US, how to find out which neutral wire goes with which breaker? You follow the hot wire from the breaker back to the incoming cable and find the white neutral wire that's with it, that's how you figure it out in the US. In your case, that RCD breaker has 4 wires going through it, with one labeled "N" doesn't it? I don't have the spec sheet for the breaker, but it seems pretty obvious to me that would be the neutral. But does any of this really matter? It sounds like you have a serious safety problem, one that could be lethal, the fault you have must exceed 100ma, isn't it time to hire an electrician and get it fixed? As I have said earlier, I did ask an electrician about the tripping. He just shrugged and said it's due to moisture. No need to fix it. Indeed, during dry season, there is no problem even when all the four problematic breaker are flipped up. |
#85
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
On Sat, 15 Jul 2017 08:20:53 +0630, Lenny Jacobs
wrote: On 13/07/2017 23:27, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 11:28:13 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 09:33, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 07:04:53 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 03:57, wrote: On Wed, 12 Jul 2017 10:23:24 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 12/07/2017 08:54, wrote: My "suspicion" is any one , or possibly combination of 2, would cause the problem. Still don't know exactly what amperage the branch breakers are, but he has a 63 amp "sub-main" that trips. If he has 7.5 amp breakers (equivalent to 15 amp 120 volt) and he has 25 running an average of 1/4 capacity, that is 46.875 amps. Say the other 4 are at 6 amps each, the main may trip,(70 amps) while shutting any 1 off may keep it from tripping at 64. The "short" resistance in the 4 may not be exactly the same - one may draw heavier than the other on a given day (it IS a "random" fault) - so shutting all 4 off, then turning the others on, it may be different combinations that work from day to day. Well, I have about 10 lights, one water heater (about 30 gallon), one ceiling fan, three refrigerators. When I turned on TV/DVD, used a kettle, turned on A/C, used the range in the kitchen, the breaker was not tripped. It would take a lot more than these to overload a 63A breaker. You have NO IDEA what amperage the other 4 (that cause the trip) are drawing. What is the rating of the branch circuit breakers? The water heater is likely 30 amps, the range is likely 40 amps (if it's all turned on). That is already more than 63 amps!!! If the range is off, it draws nothing, of course - but you do not indicate if it is in use. The fridges could be drawing 3.5 amps each - perhaps 7 when starting, and about the same when running the auto defrost cycle. When it kicked the kettle wa not in use? Or the AC? Were the lights on? With everything else turned off, can you turn on the 4 "bad" breakers without tripping the main? Can't tell the rating of most of the breakers. The electrician who installed them did a great job labeling every one of them. The label sticker is right on the rating. Judging from the size of the breakers, they could be 13, 16, or 20 A. In a euro 240 style system I highly doubt most are over 7.5 amps. My point of mentioning A/C, range, etc. was that besides those constantly on appliances, the breaker was not tripped when A/C or range was turned on. The breaker was tripped when A/C or range was not on. So, it kind of excludes overloading. Now it turns out that the tripped sub-main breaker is a GFCI, a wet circuit is almost certain the cause of the problem. \Being the sub-mains which are being tripped are GFCI breakers, you can bet the farm on it. No idea why they have such a ludicrous system - the branch circuits should be GFCI protected. I just checked eBay. The price is still around $50 a piece. Maybe I should replace those four problematic breakers with GFCI, beside replacing the sub-main breaker. I'd try just replacing the breakers on the problem circuits first - they should trip at something like 5ma where the mains trip at 30ma? fault current. There are so many wires in the sub panel. How do I find the neutral for the particular breakers? The breaker boxes in the US have bus to which all the neutral and ground wires connect to. Not this box. So, where are the neutral wires? And I heard that three phase circuit shares neutral wire. That makes things more complex. Even for the breaker boxes in the US, how to find out which neutral wire goes with which breaker? Neutrals are not really tied to a breaker except for that RCCB and that is all of the neutrals on that feeder. You do need to keep track of the neutral for each outgoing cable but it is only important when you are disconnecting it and you want to keep the ungrounded conductors grouped so you can assure they are on different phases. |
#86
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
On Sat, 15 Jul 2017 08:47:11 +0630, Lenny Jacobs
wrote: As I have said earlier, I did ask an electrician about the tripping. He just shrugged and said it's due to moisture. No need to fix it. Indeed, during dry season, there is no problem even when all the four problematic breaker are flipped up. With that much fault current this is probably more than a little moisture. I bet you have boxes filling up with water. I would start with a visual inspection of all of your outdoor fixtures and junction boxes. You might also have some splices underground that are not waterproof. Without actually looking at your installation it is hard to guess from half way around the planet. ;-) |
#87
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
|
#88
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
On 15/07/2017 08:55, wrote:
On Sat, 15 Jul 2017 08:20:53 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 23:27, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 11:28:13 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 09:33, wrote: On Thu, 13 Jul 2017 07:04:53 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 13/07/2017 03:57, wrote: On Wed, 12 Jul 2017 10:23:24 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 12/07/2017 08:54, wrote: My "suspicion" is any one , or possibly combination of 2, would cause the problem. Still don't know exactly what amperage the branch breakers are, but he has a 63 amp "sub-main" that trips. If he has 7.5 amp breakers (equivalent to 15 amp 120 volt) and he has 25 running an average of 1/4 capacity, that is 46.875 amps. Say the other 4 are at 6 amps each, the main may trip,(70 amps) while shutting any 1 off may keep it from tripping at 64. The "short" resistance in the 4 may not be exactly the same - one may draw heavier than the other on a given day (it IS a "random" fault) - so shutting all 4 off, then turning the others on, it may be different combinations that work from day to day. Well, I have about 10 lights, one water heater (about 30 gallon), one ceiling fan, three refrigerators. When I turned on TV/DVD, used a kettle, turned on A/C, used the range in the kitchen, the breaker was not tripped. It would take a lot more than these to overload a 63A breaker. You have NO IDEA what amperage the other 4 (that cause the trip) are drawing. What is the rating of the branch circuit breakers? The water heater is likely 30 amps, the range is likely 40 amps (if it's all turned on). That is already more than 63 amps!!! If the range is off, it draws nothing, of course - but you do not indicate if it is in use. The fridges could be drawing 3.5 amps each - perhaps 7 when starting, and about the same when running the auto defrost cycle. When it kicked the kettle wa not in use? Or the AC? Were the lights on? With everything else turned off, can you turn on the 4 "bad" breakers without tripping the main? Can't tell the rating of most of the breakers. The electrician who installed them did a great job labeling every one of them. The label sticker is right on the rating. Judging from the size of the breakers, they could be 13, 16, or 20 A. In a euro 240 style system I highly doubt most are over 7.5 amps. My point of mentioning A/C, range, etc. was that besides those constantly on appliances, the breaker was not tripped when A/C or range was turned on. The breaker was tripped when A/C or range was not on. So, it kind of excludes overloading. Now it turns out that the tripped sub-main breaker is a GFCI, a wet circuit is almost certain the cause of the problem. \Being the sub-mains which are being tripped are GFCI breakers, you can bet the farm on it. No idea why they have such a ludicrous system - the branch circuits should be GFCI protected. I just checked eBay. The price is still around $50 a piece. Maybe I should replace those four problematic breakers with GFCI, beside replacing the sub-main breaker. I'd try just replacing the breakers on the problem circuits first - they should trip at something like 5ma where the mains trip at 30ma? fault current. There are so many wires in the sub panel. How do I find the neutral for the particular breakers? The breaker boxes in the US have bus to which all the neutral and ground wires connect to. Not this box. So, where are the neutral wires? And I heard that three phase circuit shares neutral wire. That makes things more complex. Even for the breaker boxes in the US, how to find out which neutral wire goes with which breaker? Neutrals are not really tied to a breaker except for that RCCB and that is all of the neutrals on that feeder. You do need to keep track of the neutral for each outgoing cable but it is only important when you are disconnecting it and you want to keep the ungrounded conductors grouped so you can assure they are on different phases. In the US, one can buy cables that have hot, neutral, and ground wires all in a sheath. It's very easy to tell which hot goes with which neutral. Here, people use separate wires. They maybe black, red, green, blue, etc. How to figure out which two wires go with which breaker? Impossible, I think. |
#89
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
On Sat, 15 Jul 2017 11:57:51 +0630, Lenny Jacobs
wrote: On 15/07/2017 09:03, wrote: On Sat, 15 Jul 2017 08:47:11 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: As I have said earlier, I did ask an electrician about the tripping. He just shrugged and said it's due to moisture. No need to fix it. Indeed, during dry season, there is no problem even when all the four problematic breaker are flipped up. With that much fault current this is probably more than a little moisture. I bet you have boxes filling up with water. I would start with a visual inspection of all of your outdoor fixtures and junction boxes. You might also have some splices underground that are not waterproof. Without actually looking at your installation it is hard to guess from half way around the planet. ;-) I suspect it'd take more than just visual inspection. I see some above-ground junction boxes. Not sure if there are underground junction boxes. I do have an underground junction box for phone line. How to keep water from getting into underground junction boxes? I have no clue. You don't really keep the water out, you just use waterproof splices. They are typically a crimp splice in a silicone filled tube. Above ground you just be sure they are arranged to drain and that the conductors are not near the bottom of the box or touching the sides. |
#90
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
breaker response time
On Sat, 15 Jul 2017 01:33:44 -0400, wrote:
On Sat, 15 Jul 2017 11:57:51 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: On 15/07/2017 09:03, wrote: On Sat, 15 Jul 2017 08:47:11 +0630, Lenny Jacobs wrote: As I have said earlier, I did ask an electrician about the tripping. He just shrugged and said it's due to moisture. No need to fix it. Indeed, during dry season, there is no problem even when all the four problematic breaker are flipped up. With that much fault current this is probably more than a little moisture. I bet you have boxes filling up with water. I would start with a visual inspection of all of your outdoor fixtures and junction boxes. You might also have some splices underground that are not waterproof. Without actually looking at your installation it is hard to guess from half way around the planet. ;-) I suspect it'd take more than just visual inspection. I see some above-ground junction boxes. Not sure if there are underground junction boxes. I do have an underground junction box for phone line. How to keep water from getting into underground junction boxes? I have no clue. You don't really keep the water out, you just use waterproof splices. They are typically a crimp splice in a silicone filled tube. Above ground you just be sure they are arranged to drain and that the conductors are not near the bottom of the box or touching the sides. Perhaps plant "umbrella plants" over the jboxes????? |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
OT - Funny Response From Time Warner Cable Regarding Modem | Home Repair | |||
Building Control Response Time | UK diy | |||
a response to a sci.electronics.repair retard's response. | Electronics Repair | |||
[OT] The Wrong Time to Lose Our Nerve -- A response to Messrs. Buckley, Will and Fukuyama. | Metalworking | |||
Response 400 answer machine - no response | Electronics Repair |