Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a
Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html ." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? I have to admit that in my mind I was thinking it said 40-45 FOOT-pounds at first, which seemed like way too much. But, then I read it again, and I see that it says lb-IN, not lb-FT. I am guessing that 40-45 lb-in means tighten the screws so they are definitely tight, but do not tighten so much that the threads strip. Does that seem about right? |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On May 17, 10:43*am, "TomR" wrote:
In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? I have to admit that in my mind I was thinking it said 40-45 FOOT-pounds at first, which seemed like way too much. *But, then I read it again, and I see that it says lb-IN, not lb-FT. I am guessing that 40-45 lb-in means tighten the screws so they are definitely tight, but do not tighten so much that the threads strip. *Does that seem about right? Bingo! |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On Fri, 17 May 2013 10:43:23 -0400, "TomR" wrote:
In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html ." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? I have to admit that in my mind I was thinking it said 40-45 FOOT-pounds at first, which seemed like way too much. But, then I read it again, and I see that it says lb-IN, not lb-FT. I am guessing that 40-45 lb-in means tighten the screws so they are definitely tight, but do not tighten so much that the threads strip. Does that seem about right? What sized screws? That seems awfully loose, though probably not for something like an 8-32. 48 lb-in would be four pounds on the end of a 12" wrench (40in-lb would be 4lbs on a 10" wrench). In any case, if you've stripped the threads, it's no longer tight ;-) |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On 05/17/2013 07:43 AM, TomR wrote:
In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html ." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? I have to admit that in my mind I was thinking it said 40-45 FOOT-pounds at first, which seemed like way too much. But, then I read it again, and I see that it says lb-IN, not lb-FT. I am guessing that 40-45 lb-in means tighten the screws so they are definitely tight, but do not tighten so much that the threads strip. Does that seem about right? It's about half the torque of a regular nut, so it's probably a shear nut (take a look at what the bolt screws into). http://www.mechanicsupport.com/shear_nut_usage.html You can convert in-lb to ft-lb by dividing by 12, so your 45 in-lb would equate to about 3.5 ft-lb. For comparison, a 10-32 SS fastener, with a regular nut, has a recommended torque of about 32 in-lb (about 2.5 ft-lb). So make it snug but not much more would be my method. Jon |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On Fri, 17 May 2013 10:43:23 -0400, "TomR"
wrote: My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? If you were to purchase a torque-screwdriver (there are some inexpensive ones these days), you could really get a good feel for torque, with some positive feedback. Something that could be beneficial for a lifetime (both the screwdriver and the, "getting to know the feel"). I always wonder about the folks who write instructions stating: "Do not over-tighten!" and give no torque values at all. That's like putting up speed-limit signs that read, "Don't go too fast!". -- croy |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
TomR wrote:
In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html ." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? ....., Thanks everyone for your replies. I think I now have a fairly good understanding of what 40-45 in-lbs means, so I think I'm on the right track by just tightening the screws so they are definitely tight but not overtightening them Using the concept of about 4 lbs of pressure on a 10-inch bar (or a little less on a 12-inch bar) gives me a good idea of what they mean. I can do that. About the size of the screws -- the kit says it comes with two 1/4-28 x 13/32 screws. So, I think they are 1/4 inch screws, 28 threads per inch, and 13/32 in long. They go into the same threaded holes in the neutral bars that the rest of the regular neutral and ground wire attaching screws go into. |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On Fri, 17 May 2013 13:29:44 -0700, croy
wrote: On Fri, 17 May 2013 10:43:23 -0400, "TomR" wrote: My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? If you were to purchase a torque-screwdriver (there are some inexpensive ones these days), you could really get a good feel for torque, with some positive feedback. Something that could be beneficial for a lifetime (both the screwdriver and the, "getting to know the feel"). I always wonder about the folks who write instructions stating: "Do not over-tighten!" and give no torque values at all. That's like putting up speed-limit signs that read, "Don't go too fast!". You've never seen a "slow" or "slow curve" sign? |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On May 17, 2:33*pm, "TomR" wrote:
TomR wrote: In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? ...., Thanks everyone for your replies. *I think I now have a fairly good understanding of what 40-45 in-lbs means, so I think I'm on the right track by just tightening the screws so they are definitely tight but not overtightening them Using the concept of about 4 lbs of pressure on a 10-inch bar (or a little less on a 12-inch bar) gives me a good idea of what they mean. *I can do that. About the size of the screws -- the kit says it comes with two 1/4-28 x 13/32 screws. *So, I think they are 1/4 inch screws, 28 threads per inch, and 13/32 in long. *They go into the same threaded holes in the neutral bars that the rest of the regular neutral and ground wire attaching screws go into. TomR- You exactly correct... they are 1/4 inch screws with 28 threads per inch (fine thread) Think about the torque in an equivalent wrench or ratchet situation. With your hand on a wrench or ratchet at ~12" from the screw center applying 3-1/2 pounds would give you 42 in-lbs. With your hand at 6" you'd need to apply 7 pounds to get 42 in-lbs. These are pretty small loads. The diameter is of the typical screw driver handle pretty small...less than 1-1/2"? ... the screwdriver / nutdriver equivalent to a torque wrench is a torque watch, IIRC the max torques on these devices are pretty low...like 50 in-lbs and they have bulbous handles. You'd be hard pressed to over torque by hand with a nut driver / square driver if it's handle is "screw driver handle sized" I believe in this situation the torque is so low, either because the ground bar is aluminum or they don't want to crush the hell out of the conductors. cheers Bob |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On Fri, 17 May 2013 10:43:23 -0400, "TomR" wrote:
In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html ." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? I have to admit that in my mind I was thinking it said 40-45 FOOT-pounds at first, which seemed like way too much. But, then I read it again, and I see that it says lb-IN, not lb-FT. I am guessing that 40-45 lb-in means tighten the screws so they are definitely tight, but do not tighten so much that the threads strip. Does that seem about right? I would think so. I'm still looking for my 1/2 to 3/8" adapter so tht I can tighten my trailer hitch to the setting the instructions said. So far the thing hasn't fallen off. I think if you ever really need to get this right, you can take the 45 inch pounds, divide by 12 to get about 4 foot pounds, and then using a string probably, attach a four-pound weight to the wrench 1 foot from the screw head. If the screw goes in vertically, you'll need a pulley for your string. to make it vertical. Or you could just lift four pounds with a string or rope, get a feel for how hard that is to do, and apply that same effort to the wrench, one foot from the screw head. This is the way I did it at the JPL. |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On May 17, 11:37*pm, micky wrote:
On Fri, 17 May 2013 10:43:23 -0400, "TomR" wrote: In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? I have to admit that in my mind I was thinking it said 40-45 FOOT-pounds at first, which seemed like way too much. *But, then I read it again, and I see that it says lb-IN, not lb-FT. I am guessing that 40-45 lb-in means tighten the screws so they are definitely tight, but do not tighten so much that the threads strip. *Does that seem about right? I would think so. I'm still looking for my 1/2 to 3/8" adapter so tht I can tighten my trailer hitch to the setting the instructions said. So far the thing hasn't fallen off. I think if you ever really need to get this right, you can take the 45 inch pounds, divide by 12 to get about 4 foot pounds, and then using a string probably, *attach a four-pound weight to the wrench 1 foot from the screw head. If the screw goes in vertically, you'll need a pulley for your string. to make it vertical. Or you could just lift four pounds with a string or rope, get a feel for how hard that is to do, and apply that same effort to the wrench, one foot from the screw head. * This is the way I did it at the JPL. Or you could just lift four pounds with a string or rope, get a feel for how hard that is to do, and apply that same effort to the wrench, one foot from the screw head. This is the way I did it at the JPL. +1 |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On Fri, 17 May 2013 21:45:06 -0700 (PDT), DD_BobK
wrote: On May 17, 2:33*pm, "TomR" wrote: TomR wrote: In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? ...., Thanks everyone for your replies. *I think I now have a fairly good understanding of what 40-45 in-lbs means, so I think I'm on the right track by just tightening the screws so they are definitely tight but not overtightening them Using the concept of about 4 lbs of pressure on a 10-inch bar (or a little less on a 12-inch bar) gives me a good idea of what they mean. *I can do that. About the size of the screws -- the kit says it comes with two 1/4-28 x 13/32 screws. *So, I think they are 1/4 inch screws, 28 threads per inch, and 13/32 in long. *They go into the same threaded holes in the neutral bars that the rest of the regular neutral and ground wire attaching screws go into. TomR- You exactly correct... they are 1/4 inch screws with 28 threads per inch (fine thread) Think about the torque in an equivalent wrench or ratchet situation. With your hand on a wrench or ratchet at ~12" from the screw center applying 3-1/2 pounds would give you 42 in-lbs. With your hand at 6" you'd need to apply 7 pounds to get 42 in-lbs. These are pretty small loads. The diameter is of the typical screw driver handle pretty small...less than 1-1/2"? .. the screwdriver / nutdriver equivalent to a torque wrench is a torque watch, IIRC the max torques on these devices are pretty low...like 50 in-lbs and they have bulbous handles. You'd be hard pressed to over torque by hand with a nut driver / square driver if it's handle is "screw driver handle sized" I believe in this situation the torque is so low, either because the ground bar is aluminum or they don't want to crush the hell out of the conductors. cheers Bob It IS possible to overtorque a 45 in/lb fastener with a "screwdriverhandle sised" nut driver. |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On May 18, 6:06*pm, wrote:
On Fri, 17 May 2013 21:45:06 -0700 (PDT), DD_BobK wrote: On May 17, 2:33*pm, "TomR" wrote: TomR wrote: In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? ...., Thanks everyone for your replies. *I think I now have a fairly good understanding of what 40-45 in-lbs means, so I think I'm on the right track by just tightening the screws so they are definitely tight but not overtightening them Using the concept of about 4 lbs of pressure on a 10-inch bar (or a little less on a 12-inch bar) gives me a good idea of what they mean. *I can do that. About the size of the screws -- the kit says it comes with two 1/4-28 x 13/32 screws. *So, I think they are 1/4 inch screws, 28 threads per inch, and 13/32 in long. *They go into the same threaded holes in the neutral bars that the rest of the regular neutral and ground wire attaching screws go into. TomR- You exactly correct... they are 1/4 inch screws with 28 threads per inch (fine thread) Think about the torque in an equivalent wrench or ratchet situation. With your hand on a wrench or ratchet at ~12" from the screw center applying 3-1/2 pounds would give you 42 in-lbs. With your hand at 6" you'd need to apply 7 pounds to get 42 in-lbs. These are pretty small loads. The diameter is of the typical screw driver handle pretty small...less than 1-1/2"? .. the screwdriver / nutdriver equivalent to a torque wrench is a torque watch, IIRC *the max torques on these devices are pretty low...like 50 in-lbs and they have bulbous handles. You'd be hard pressed to over torque by hand with a nut driver */ square driver if it's handle is "screw driver handle sized" I believe in this situation the torque is so low, either because the ground bar is aluminum or they don't want to crush the hell out of the conductors. cheers Bob * It IS possible to overtorque a 45 in/lb fastener with a "screwdriverhandle sised" nut driver. You'd be HARD PRESSED to over torque by hand with a nut driver / square driver if it's handle is "screw driver handle sized" it is POSSIBLE.... but highly unlikely, unless, the nut on the handle is an idiot. |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On Fri, 17 May 2013 10:43:23 -0400, "TomR" wrote:
In an earlier post of mine about adding a second neutral/ground bar to a Siemens Main Load Center electrical panel, I posted the instructions for doing that: "Here is a link to the ECCNB16 Instruction Sheet which shows this neutral bar kit and how to install it: http://www74.zippyshare.com/v/43794674/file.html ." In Step 4, on the right hand side, it says to tighten the two screws using 40-45 lb-in of torque. I don't have a torque wrench, and I would rather not buy one just for this unless I need to. My question is, about how tight if 40-45 lb-in when it comes to tightening these screws? I have to admit that in my mind I was thinking it said 40-45 FOOT-pounds at first, which seemed like way too much. But, then I read it again, and I see that it says lb-IN, not lb-FT. I am guessing that 40-45 lb-in means tighten the screws so they are definitely tight, but do not tighten so much that the threads strip. Does that seem about right? Take a screwdriver and tighten it till the screws are tight. You dont need no torque wrench. This is not a piece of fine machinery that requires perfection. Even suggesting that you need to torque it is stupid. |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How tight is 40-45 lb-in (electrical panel)?
On May 19, 1:09*am, wrote:
SNIP Take a screwdriver and tighten it till the screws are tight. *You dont need no torque wrench. This is not a piece of fine machinery that requires perfection. *Even suggesting that you need to torque it is stupid. Take a screwdriver and tighten it till the screws are tight. You dont need no torque wrench. This is not a piece of fine machinery that requires perfection. Even suggesting that you need to torque it is stupid. +1 |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Adding extra ground/neutral buss bar in electrical panel or add sub-panel? | Home Repair | |||
Electrical Sub Panel | Home Repair | |||
2nd panel running off of primary electrical panel | Home Repair | |||
Replacing hose bib - How tight is tight? | Home Repair | |||
Panel Box Electrical Question | Home Repair |