Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but noheat
Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke!
http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components? http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Jan 15, 3:20*am, Zen wrote:
Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke!http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. *There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components?http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Some observations: I don't know how your furnace is designed or hooked up. But I've never seen a forced air furnace where the blower goes on for a minute BEFORE the furnace fires. Every one I've ever seen works exactly the opposite. The burner fires FIRST and then the blower comes on a minute or so later. That avoids the furnace blowing cold air. The blower is triggered either by a temperature switch in the plenum or by a control board. It's usually not a good idea to just start replacing components randomly. Regarding the list of suspects: 1. The flame apparatus what's that? the actual burner assembly? 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch Which lockout switch? There typically are several mechanisms involved. If it's a simple switch, it can be bypassed for test purposes instead of just replacing it on the theory it might be bad. And if it's the switch on the blower compartment, in the furnaces I've worked on, that switch only disabled the blower. The fact that the blower works tells you that switch is OK. First area I'd be looking into is if the ignitor is activating, ie is it trying to light at all? That's the first step in the process and the ignitor going bad is one frequent source of problems. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
Sorry to hear your furnace went out. I'd suggest to call
your friends and relatives, and see who they hire for furnace repair. Home furnace isn't a good place to learn on. Too many things can go wrong. Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org .. "Zen" wrote in message ... Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke! http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components? http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Tue, 15 Jan 2013 08:20:03 +0000 (UTC), Zen wrote:
Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke! http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components? http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Don't waste money throwing parts at it. Get the model number, then post this with model number to alt.hvac. You might get troubleshooting procedures there. If not, get the manual which should allow you to pinpoint the problem. For parts, just google the model number. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Jan 15, 5:33*am, "
wrote: On Jan 15, 3:20*am, Zen wrote: Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke!http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. *There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components?http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Some observations: I don't know how your furnace is designed or hooked up. But I've never seen a forced air furnace where the blower goes on for a minute BEFORE the furnace fires. *Every one I've ever seen works exactly the opposite. *The burner fires FIRST and then the blower comes on a minute or so later. *That avoids the furnace blowing cold air. *The blower is triggered either by a temperature switch in the plenum or by a control board. It's usually not a good idea to just start replacing components randomly. * Regarding the list of suspects: 1. The flame apparatus what's that? *the actual burner assembly? 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch Which lockout switch? *There typically are several mechanisms involved. *If it's a simple switch, it can be bypassed for test purposes instead of just replacing it on the theory it might be bad. *And if it's the switch on the blower compartment, in the furnaces I've worked on, that switch only disabled the blower. The fact that the blower works tells you that switch is OK. First area I'd be looking into is if the ignitor is activating, ie is it trying to light at all? *That's the first step in the process and the ignitor going bad is one frequent source of problems. I would have agreed with T4 on his commentary UNTIL I watched this YouTube video. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEcJe60oQlk seems like a blower (gas combustion related) comes on first, then the unit fires up. I guess my question is "which blower" does the OP refer to? The YouTube search function aint great and this furnance isnt the OP's make/ model but it might be helpful. cheers Bob |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
Vic Smith wrote:
Don't waste money throwing parts at it. Get the model number, then post this with model number to alt.hvac. You might get troubleshooting procedures there. If not, get the manual which should allow you to pinpoint the problem. For parts, just google the model number. Are they still rude to do-it-yourself-ers over at alt.hvac as they used to be? |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Jan 15, 12:04*pm, DD_BobK wrote:
On Jan 15, 5:33*am, " wrote: On Jan 15, 3:20*am, Zen wrote: Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke!http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. *There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components?http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Some observations: I don't know how your furnace is designed or hooked up. But I've never seen a forced air furnace where the blower goes on for a minute BEFORE the furnace fires. *Every one I've ever seen works exactly the opposite. *The burner fires FIRST and then the blower comes on a minute or so later. *That avoids the furnace blowing cold air. *The blower is triggered either by a temperature switch in the plenum or by a control board. It's usually not a good idea to just start replacing components randomly. * Regarding the list of suspects: 1. The flame apparatus what's that? *the actual burner assembly? 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch Which lockout switch? *There typically are several mechanisms involved. *If it's a simple switch, it can be bypassed for test purposes instead of just replacing it on the theory it might be bad. *And if it's the switch on the blower compartment, in the furnaces I've worked on, that switch only disabled the blower. The fact that the blower works tells you that switch is OK. First area I'd be looking into is if the ignitor is activating, ie is it trying to light at all? *That's the first step in the process and the ignitor going bad is one frequent source of problems. I would have agreed with T4 on his commentary UNTIL I watched this YouTube video. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEcJe60oQlk seems like a blower (gas combustion related) comes on first, then the unit fires up. I guess my question is "which blower" does the OP refer to? The YouTube search function aint great and this furnance isnt the OP's make/ model but it might be helpful. cheers Bob- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - The video clearly states that it's the "vent stack blower" that's coming on. It's a newer, higher efficiency furnace. The blower is actually called an inducer blower. Since the OP said that the furnace blower blows cold air and there is no evidence of an inducer blower in the pic he supplied, I assume it's the air handler fan that he's tallking about when he refers to the blower a second time. But, then George here gets all upset if one makes what appear to be reasonable assumptions when responding to a question. According to George, I'm not supposed to answer, only ask for "clarification". |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant butno heat
On 1/15/2013 12:20 AM, Zen wrote:
Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke! http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components? http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Probably a bad idea to just start replacing parts. It's strange that the main blower starts up at all, because normally it doesn't start until after the flame is detected by the flame sensor and the burners start (so it doesn't blow cold air), unless you have the fan always on at the thermostat. The sequence should be: 1. Draft inducer fan starts up and closes switch (via suction) so the controller knows that the draft inducer is operating and it's safe to light the burner. You can check this with an ohm meter, or jumper across it to test it (however it must be open when the furnace starts, then closed after the draft inducer fan starts, you can't jumper it closed before the draft inducer fan starts). 2. Glow plug heats up (or spark ignitor starts sparking). You can check that a glow plug is getting power with a voltmeter (should be 24VAC) and you can see it glow red. A spark ignitor should make a noise. 3. Gas valve opens and burners ignite. Audible thunk as the solenoid is activated. Controller knows that the burners are lit by looking at the flame sensor and will close the gas valve after a short time if there is no flame. You can test the gas valve by turning off the gas to the furnace, unplugging the wires to the valve, and connecting 24VAC or so to the valve from a small transformer. If you hear a thunk then the solenoid is activating and the gas valve is probably okay. 4. Main blower starts up. If one of the flame-out sensors is bad (open) the gas valve won't turn on. There are usually three or four flame-out sensors in series. If there's a crack in the heat exchanger then flames can shoot out the front of the furnace and the flame-out sensors will shut off the gas. When my furnace broke a couple of months ago it was an intermittent gas valve. When my friend's furnace broke last month it was an intermittent draft inducer fan switch (sometimes it's just a clogged suction hose, but this time the switch was bad). If it's an older furnace with relays on the controller board you can hear the relays click as various things are activated. The draft inducer fan relay will click, the ignitor relay will click, and the gas valve relay will click. |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Jan 15, 12:50*pm, sms wrote:
On 1/15/2013 12:20 AM, Zen wrote: Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke! http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. *There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components? http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Probably a bad idea to just start replacing parts. It's strange that the main blower starts up at all, because normally it doesn't start until after the flame is detected by the flame sensor and the burners start (so it doesn't blow cold air), unless you have the fan always on at the thermostat. The sequence should be: 1. Draft inducer fan starts up and closes switch (via suction) so the controller knows that the draft inducer is operating and it's safe to light the burner. You can check this with an ohm meter, or jumper across it to test it (however it must be open when the furnace starts, then closed after the draft inducer fan starts, you can't jumper it closed before the draft inducer fan starts). Agree, IF it has an inducer. From the picture, there was no evidence of one. It looks like an older furnace. 2. Glow plug heats up (or spark ignitor starts sparking). You can check that a glow plug is getting power with a voltmeter (should be 24VAC) and you can see it glow red. A spark ignitor should make a noise. 3. Gas valve opens and burners ignite. Audible thunk as the solenoid is activated. Controller knows that the burners are lit by looking at the flame sensor and will close the gas valve after a short time if there is no flame. You can test the gas valve by turning off the gas to the furnace, unplugging the wires to the valve, and connecting 24VAC or so to the valve from a small transformer. If you hear a thunk then the solenoid is activating and the gas valve is probably okay. 4. Main blower starts up. Yes, usually after a delay of a minute or so If one of the flame-out sensors is bad (open) the gas valve won't turn on. There are usually three or four flame-out sensors in series. If there's a crack in the heat exchanger then flames can shoot out the front of the furnace and the flame-out sensors will shut off the gas. When my furnace broke a couple of months ago it was an intermittent gas valve. When my friend's furnace broke last month it was an intermittent draft inducer fan switch (sometimes it's just a clogged suction hose, but this time the switch was bad). If it's an older furnace with relays on the controller board you can hear the relays click as various things are activated. The draft inducer fan relay will click, the ignitor relay will click, and the gas valve relay will click.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant butno heat
On 1/15/2013 9:04 AM, DD_BobK wrote:
On Jan 15, 5:33 am, " wrote: On Jan 15, 3:20 am, Zen wrote: Just as it gets cold, my Payne hot air propane-fired furnace broke!http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg All of a sudden, the blower just blows cold air constantly without letup. The pilot flame never starts. Obviously, the gas never lights up either. This happened, all of a sudden. Normally, it has an electronic pilot, which lights the gas about a minute after the blower starts. There is plenty of propane. Any troubleshooting ideas? I think there are three main components: 1. The flame apparatus 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch I'm inclined to just buy all three, and replace (and have a spare), since I remember the last service call was expensive and the circuit board was replaced in seconds after a three week wait for the parts to arrive. Do you have any idea WHERE I can get the three main components?http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Some observations: I don't know how your furnace is designed or hooked up. But I've never seen a forced air furnace where the blower goes on for a minute BEFORE the furnace fires. Every one I've ever seen works exactly the opposite. The burner fires FIRST and then the blower comes on a minute or so later. That avoids the furnace blowing cold air. The blower is triggered either by a temperature switch in the plenum or by a control board. It's usually not a good idea to just start replacing components randomly. Regarding the list of suspects: 1. The flame apparatus what's that? the actual burner assembly? 2. The circuit board 3. The lockout switch Which lockout switch? There typically are several mechanisms involved. If it's a simple switch, it can be bypassed for test purposes instead of just replacing it on the theory it might be bad. And if it's the switch on the blower compartment, in the furnaces I've worked on, that switch only disabled the blower. The fact that the blower works tells you that switch is OK. First area I'd be looking into is if the ignitor is activating, ie is it trying to light at all? That's the first step in the process and the ignitor going bad is one frequent source of problems. I would have agreed with T4 on his commentary UNTIL I watched this YouTube video. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEcJe60oQlk seems like a blower (gas combustion related) comes on first, then the unit fires up. That's the draft inducer fan. The furnace won't start at all unless that fan is running. There's a tube going to a suction activated switch that indicates that the draft inducer fan is running. My friend's furnace had an intermittent draft inducer switch and sometimes would not start at all, sometimes would start and run for a while then stop. I suspect that the reason that the main blower is running is that the OP has it turned on at the thermostat, i.e. "Fan On" instead of "Auto." |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Tue, 15 Jan 2013 09:04:58 -0800, "Bob F"
wrote: Vic Smith wrote: Don't waste money throwing parts at it. Get the model number, then post this with model number to alt.hvac. You might get troubleshooting procedures there. If not, get the manual which should allow you to pinpoint the problem. For parts, just google the model number. Are they still rude to do-it-yourself-ers over at alt.hvac as they used to be? Don't know. It was just a suggestion. There are internet forums too. This seems generally polite to DIY'ers. http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/hvac/ My main point was to DIY you should have model number and/or a manual as your starting point. |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Jan 15, 12:03*pm, Vic Smith
wrote: On Tue, 15 Jan 2013 09:04:58 -0800, "Bob F" wrote: Vic Smith wrote: Don't waste money throwing parts at it. Get the model number, then post this with model number to alt.hvac. You might get troubleshooting procedures there. If not, get the manual which should allow you to pinpoint the problem. For parts, just google the model number. Are they still rude to do-it-yourself-ers over at alt.hvac as they used to be? Don't know. *It was just a suggestion. *There are internet forums too.. This seems generally polite to DIY'ers.http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/hvac/ My main point was to DIY you should have model number and/or a manual as your starting point. Are you sure the unit is not in the air-conditioning mode????? |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
I went back and looked at the photos. That design is totally obvious to me,
it's a gravity draft 70 percenter. Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org .. "SMS" wrote in message ... On 1/15/2013 2:46 PM, wrote: On Jan 15, 5:42 pm, "Stormin Mormon" wrote: If you look at the pictures OP provided, you can see how many blowers the furnace has, and what their function are. http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org By my count there is only one blower, the one that serves as the air handler. Yes? Can't tell because the draft inducer fan is normally high up, above where the photo stops. |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Jan 15, 2:46*pm, "
wrote: On Jan 15, 5:42*pm, "Stormin Mormon" wrote: If *you look at the pictures OP provided, you can see how many blowers the furnace has, and what their function are. * * *http://www4.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964117.jpg * * *http://www3.picturepush.com/photo/a/...g/11964131.jpg Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus *www.lds.org By my count there is only one blower, the one that serves as the air handler. *Yes? Yes...seems reasonable. Unit looks old probably only one fan |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
On Jan 15, 10:29*pm, "Stormin Mormon"
wrote: I went back and looked at the photos. That design is totally obvious to me, it's a gravity draft 70 percenter. Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus *www.lds.org . +1 That's sure what it looked exactly like to me. But I have to be careful now. George says it's not OK to try to decipher what a poster actually has based on what he gives us. I'm supposed to only ask clarifying questions, otherwise the thread becomes too long as we try to sort it out. |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Troubleshooting Payne propane furnace blower fan constant but no heat
That's for sure, we have to do what George says.
Wonder if the OP ever got the heat back on? And, if he got permission from George to have it fixed? Christopher A. Young Learn more about Jesus www.lds.org .. wrote in message ... But I have to be careful now. George says it's not OK to try to decipher what a poster actually has based on what he gives us. I'm supposed to only ask clarifying questions, otherwise the thread becomes too long as we try to sort it out. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Payne Furnace LED Code indicator? | Home Repair | |||
Is this a Payne or a BDP gas air furnace/ac & how is it cleaned? | Home Repair | |||
Payne furnace | Home Repair | |||
problem with Payne Plus 90 furnace | Home Repair | |||
Pain furnace, er I mean Payne | Home Repair |