Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago.
The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. So I don't know if weight would be a factor. I think I could get this done for less then 5k. Any advice on this idea? Things I might run into as roadblocks? What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Thanks, Jim |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
On 6/28/2010 11:45 AM, jtpr wrote:
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. So I don't know if weight would be a factor. I think I could get this done for less then 5k. Any advice on this idea? Things I might run into as roadblocks? What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Thanks, Jim Personally, I don't like the idea of ventless. Even with safeguards in place, you'll be breathing combustion products. I'd consider electric. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
jtpr wrote:
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. I like ventless, myself, but with cautions. Check your local laws and insurance regs for the sizing requirements. For peace of mind, install a CO/Explosive gas detector in the room. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. I think you'll find that isn't isn't a good idea to put your TV over a fireplace. Though not terribly extreme if sized right, there will be more than the normal swings of temperature there; a tendency to create a dusty draft; and a higher-than-normal humidity level. None of which is good for a TV. Good luck- Jim |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
On Jun 28, 4:45*pm, jtpr wrote:
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. *Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. *My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. *The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. *So I don't know if weight would be a factor. *I think I could get this done for less then 5k. Any advice on this idea? *Things I might run into as roadblocks? *What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Thanks, Jim The problem with gas fire of any size is they need ventilation for combustion air to come in. So unless you can duct air under the floor, you get a draught. across the room. Larger gas fires need a vent (chimney). The special danger is is there is a problem with a gas fire carbom monoxide (deadly poison) is produced so you need to get this right. BTW, lightweight chimneys are available, that could be suspended from your roof, I have one myself with a woodburner stove. There is one such here. http://www.ecoflue.co.uk/chimneylini...orfolk_011.htm But there are lots more. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
On Jun 28, 1:16*pm, Jim Elbrecht wrote:
jtpr wrote: We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. *Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. I like ventless, myself, but with *cautions. * Check your local laws and insurance regs for the sizing requirements. * *For peace of mind, install a CO/Explosive gas detector in the room. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. I think you'll find that isn't isn't a good idea to put your TV over a fireplace. * * Though not terribly extreme if sized right, there will be more than the normal swings of temperature there; a tendency to create a dusty draft; and a higher-than-normal humidity level. *None of which is good for a TV. Good luck- Jim Thank you for the replies. Here is a picture of the house I am talking about: http://jtpryan.smugmug.com/House/New...56_vRXmM-L.jpg My concern is the hight of the back roof. I want the fireplace to be between the 2 side windows in the front room (lower peak). I haven't checked yet, but I assume they will want the hight to be above the second peak. You can see what that would look like. Not to mention this is in an historic district and I would have to go through a lot of hoops to make it happen, if it would. But a totally interior solution would be somewhat painless, except to my wallet. As for the danger, keep in mind this is an occasional aesthetic use thing, not really a heat source. It would never be left on overnight or unattended. -Jim |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
The problem with gas fire of any size is they need ventilation for
combustion air to come in. So unless you can duct air under the floor, you get a draught. across the room. Larger gas fires need a vent (chimney). The special danger is is there is a problem with a gas fire carbom monoxide (deadly poison) is produced so you need to get this right. From the view of CO, the ventless units are actually safer than the vented models. The ventless units are designed to not emit ANY CO2. Vented units compromise on the air/fuel mixture to increase efficiency. If you have a "tight" house the vented unit may end up exhausting some of it's products inside the house. In any case, if you have any kind of combustion heating in your home, you really, really should get yourself a CO detector. You might want to consider getting a combo combustible gas/CO detector. Some folks don't like the fumes from a ventless unit. You might consider buying a portable space heater that runs from LPG cans. If you don't have any allergy symptoms then you can live with a ventless unit. You will still have the portable heater for use during an extended power failure. BTW, lightweight chimneys are available, that could be suspended from your roof, I have one myself with a woodburner stove. True. Moreover, vented LPG fired "fireplaces" can also be arranged so that they connect to an outside wall via two concentric pipes. These approach the efficiency of a ventless LPG unit but at several times the cost. |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
On Mon, 28 Jun 2010 12:36:24 -0700 (PDT), jtpr
wrote: -snip- As for the danger, keep in mind this is an occasional aesthetic use thing, not really a heat source. It would never be left on overnight or unattended. If it is just for aesthetics, then build a pocket wall to slide the electric fireplace [they make them as realistic looking as gas] out from in front of your TV, or vice-versa. Or build the TV into a fireplace setting and run a fireplace video when you want ambiance. OTOH- I think it is prudent for anyone who lives in the great northeast to have a heat source ready for when the electricity goes out. Jim |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
jtpr wrote:
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. So I don't know if weight would be a factor. I think I could get this done for less then 5k. Any advice on this idea? Things I might run into as roadblocks? What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Thanks, Jim Hi, It is not much of a trouble installing direct vent FP. |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
jtpr wrote:
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. So I don't know if weight would be a factor. I think I could get this done for less then 5k. Any advice on this idea? Things I might run into as roadblocks? What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Thanks, Jim Get a fake fireplace for your TV. Then get a vented gas or pellet heater that can be vented straight through the outside wall. -- LSMFT I haven't spoken to my wife in 18 months. I don't like to interrupt her. |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
On Mon, 28 Jun 2010 08:45:36 -0700 (PDT), jtpr wrote:
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. We have a real fireplace with ventless gas (propane) logs. Ventless logs put out a lot more heat and are a lot more efficient than those designed to be vented. Ours put out 35kBTU/hr, which is enough to heat the house if we lose electricity. We use heat pumps for our primary heat, so this is a big advantage. When we lived in Vermont we had a wood stove for backup and for those nights when it was -25F. Fortunately we don't get those here in Alabama. ;-) My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. *Not* a good idea. Heat and electronics don't go well together. Also, mantles tend to be too high for TVs anyway. It may look good in a magazine but it doesn't work. The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. So I don't know if weight would be a factor. I think I could get this done for less then 5k. It was close to $1500 just for our logs, installed. The fireplace was already there and plumbed outside. Any advice on this idea? Things I might run into as roadblocks? What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Shouldn't be any major roadblocks. |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
"jtpr" wrote My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. They work well and are very efficient. I use one in my shop and it has been very good. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. Leave it as a fantasy. That is too high for a screen and you'll regret it after while. There as some guides as to screen size and mounting height for best viewing so check them out. Saw the picture. Nice house. Looks well kept. |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
On Jun 28, 11:45*am, jtpr wrote:
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. *Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. *My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. *The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. *So I don't know if weight would be a factor. *I think I could get this done for less then 5k. Any advice on this idea? *Things I might run into as roadblocks? *What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Thanks, Jim I'm not a fan of ventless. Basically you're breathing the conbustion products. How well do you trust that you gas is 100% gas and nothing else slips in? You can install a vented fireplace that vents directly out a rear wall. It does not have to go up. I have one at our lake house. The vent is on the outside wall behind it. Funny thing is they built a fake chimney above it. For curb appeal I guess. It also has a tv space above it. It is a bit high but it's not too bad. Helps if you have the fireplace directly at the floor level rather than up on a hearth. |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
On Mon, 28 Jun 2010 12:36:24 -0700 (PDT), jtpr wrote:
As for the danger, keep in mind this is an occasional aesthetic use thing, not really a heat source. It would never be left on overnight or unattended. Aside from all else that's been said, assuming that attending the fire mitigates the CO danger is dangerous. Often the first symptom of CO poisoning is passing out. At that point it's hard to do anything about it. I'll defer to others as to the actual CO danger from a ventless heater, but if you're in the least concerned about CO, being in attendance will not protect you. In such a case you should use a CO detector or eliminate the potential source. Edward |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
"jtpr" wrote in message ... We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. So I don't know if weight would be a factor. I think I could get this done for less then 5k. Any advice on this idea? Things I might run into as roadblocks? What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Thanks, Jim For me, the issue is safety. The only CO monitor to buy is one that has a constant digital readout. This will tell you if you have 5 parts or 205 parts. The screamers only scream when they reach threshold levels. With the constant display models, you can fine tune a bit by opening a window, or making a draft. A dumb thing to do when you are trying to heat, but some fireplaces are just not very good at venting. I have seen fireplace pipes where there are two pipes, one inside another. One brings in fresh air, the other takes out combusted air. I don't believe they give off a lot of radiant heat, but some do have blowers that catch some of it. Do your homework so you aren't installing a safety hazard, or something that is going to cost 3x to yank and fix right. Do it once, do it right. Steve visit my blog at http://cabgbypasssurgery.com watch for the book A fool shows his annoyance at once, but a prudent man overlooks an insult. |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gas fireplace advice
On Jun 28, 10:45*am, jtpr wrote:
We live in coastal NH and renovated out house a couple of years ago. The one thing we miss from our old house is the fireplace and wood stove. *Without going into the difficulties of putting in a real fireplace/chiminey in this house I have come to the conclusion that a nice solution might be a gas fireplace. My undertanding is that these are, or can be, ventless so I would not have to worry about an external chimney. *My fantasy would be to build a stone wall in the middle of the wall with the fireplace in it and hang the LCD screen above the mantle. *The house was originally a 1920's bungalow and this is the original part of it, thus it has only 2x4 walls. *So I don't know if weight would be a factor. *I think I could get this done for less then 5k. Any advice on this idea? *Things I might run into as roadblocks? *What should I look for when looking at gas fireplaces? Thanks, Jim If your house is real tight and you have condensation on the windows now in winter it will get worse since Gas releases alot of moisture. In a tight house you can make air unhealthy from combustion byproducts. In some areas of Canada unvented heaters are outlawed and thats what you will have , an unvented heater. I would get a stove that can run gas and wood and vent it, and forget the LCD its a dumb idea , you will cook the tv to an early death, and its to high for proper viewing. Tvs should be eye level in the middle of screen where you sit, not 6-7 ft up where you strain your head to see it. You are thinking all about looks, not practicality and useage. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Advice on Purchasing a Wood Burning Fireplace Insert | Home Repair | |||
Fireplace Insert..Ideas on how to clean up fireplace area...Help...Ideas.... | Home Repair | |||
Fireplace insert. Advice? | Home Repair | |||
To fireplace or not to fireplace... (repair or remove) | Home Repair | |||
Advice needed re fireplace and room heater | UK diy |