Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
My house has cpvc water pipes - the person who owned it before me re-plumbed
the house and this is what he used. Is this superior to copper? Is one preferred over the other? |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
Zootal wrote: My house has cpvc water pipes - the person who owned it before me re-plumbed the house and this is what he used. Is this superior to copper? Is one preferred over the other? For durability, I doubt there is much difference. Copper will corode and CPVC won't but... For ease of maintenance and making changes, it is CPVC hands down. Harry K |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
"Harry K" wrote in message ups.com... Zootal wrote: My house has cpvc water pipes - the person who owned it before me re-plumbed the house and this is what he used. Is this superior to copper? Is one preferred over the other? For durability, I doubt there is much difference. Copper will corode and CPVC won't but... For ease of maintenance and making changes, it is CPVC hands down. Harry K I've always used copper. Very durable and strong. If I have to change something, I solder them together, ready to go, no waiting for glue to dry. However, gluing is admittedly faster and easier then soldering, and modern pvc glues dry in full strength in a few hours. How strong is cpvc? I'm afraid I'll accidently hit the pipe and break it, or twisting it when I thread a fitting on and break it. I keep thinking of PVC, which is relatively brittle. |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
Well plastic wouldnt get ripped off!
My dad used to rent homes in phoenix, he had to go all plastic since tenants would steal the copper pipes and everything else of value out of the homes.... with todays high copper prices people are finding their gutters downspouts and other copper stuff has grown feet and left the building Plastic is safe at least for now |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
The blue stuff is ready in a minute or so. Hmmm...learn something new every day. Full pressure in a few minutes? Again, only if it has been out in the sun a long time. People build lawn furniture out of PVC I've seen PVC chairs collapse. But it didn't break - it was just too thin, and could not hold the weight. |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
"Zootal" wrote in message news My house has cpvc water pipes - the person who owned it before me re-plumbed the house and this is what he used. Is this superior to copper? Is one preferred over the other? PVC gets brittle in time especially in sun light ( you should always paint it) definitely never use it for air lines regardless of what any body says. Now CPVC I have never used for water but have used it for chemical lines, I'm not sure if it gets brittle over time. Myself I'll stick with copper but there are situations plastic is better ( pools, chemical lines, waste from soda machines ) This is pretty interesting http://www.ppfahome.org/cpvc/faqcpvc.html |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
"Zootal" wrote in message ... I've always used copper. Very durable and strong. If I have to change something, I solder them together, ready to go, no waiting for glue to dry. However, gluing is admittedly faster and easier then soldering, and modern pvc glues dry in full strength in a few hours. How strong is cpvc? I'm afraid I'll accidently hit the pipe and break it, or twisting it when I thread a fitting on and break it. I keep thinking of PVC, which is relatively brittle. I've always used copper as well. In saying that however, I just had to re-route water lines and install and aerator etc.... I found the selection of copper fittings to be rather poor and the prices were outrageous. Have you priced a 10' stick of 3/4 Type L recently? $34! And the fittings are all running a few bucks on up (each). So I could definitely see the advantages of CPVC given what appeared to be a better selection of fittings and much, much cheaper. For the odd bit I do, I'll prolly stick with Cu but if I were outfitting a whole house, I'd sure be looking at plastic! Cheers, cc ps. I prolly just like copper cause of the torch and such.....just don't get the same effect with a little stick with glue on it |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
I've been planning to re-plumb most of an old house we bought in my
home town for vacations, using pex products. My investigation so far hasn't revealed much in the way of negatives about pex pipe. The Lowes around here are stocking a good selection of Zurn brand pex pipe, fittings and tools. BTW, Zurn now has a new tool, and new crimp rings, so one needs only the one (expensive) tool to do 4 sizes of tubing. The new tool is the kind that pinches an ear on the crimp ring, as opposed to the tools that surround and squeeze the entire ring. That means that it can be a bit smaller, and thus fit into some tighter spaces. Ease of installation, resistance to freezing, and manifold type of installation seem to be pluses to me. If anyone has had bad luck with pex, I'm probably not the only one who would like to hear of it. I'm getting ready to puchase the tools and supplies pretty soon. Home Depot seems completely unaware of pex plumbing, and Menards home centers do carry pex (Durapex), but perhaps not as complete a set as that of Lowes. Thanks for any input. Bates |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
I replaced most of my old rusty galvanized pipes under the crawl space
with oversized copper pipe when prices for copper hit rock bottom just a few years back. But, I also used pex tubing for my radiant floor system around the same date, due to concerns about concrete/copper chemical reactions. Pex won't collect so much calcium/magnesium on the interior of the pipe I understand either, so for long term plumbing like the radiant floor, I had no choice. I found the pex to be relatively easy to work with because fewer joints are required. The tubing can bend around wide corners, and squeaking is a thing of the past with this material. Be careful not to pinch the hose when bending, or a weak spot will develop. If necessary, a little heat will make the Pex rebound to new though. I used stainless steel hose clamps and brass fitings for connections with the pex and haven't found any problems. Heat the Pex slightly, and it will fit over the barbed fitings, and then when cool fits pretty tight anyway. The new fittings probably are better, but it's not a big deal. The only problem with Pex that I've heard of is under very high temperature situations. If your solar water flows through at temperatures above 180F, I'd be worried about a meltdown, but I run 140F through my system all the time without concern. Copper won't face this high temp problem, so I'd probably use copper for solar panel and hot water heater connections. As for using PVC or anything related to that inside the house, I wouldn't do it. Outside, for irrigation lines, and maybe even for the main water line leading to the house, yes, but a burst water pipe in the wrong place is a real expensive nightmare to be avoided at almost any cost. PVC degrades much faster in sunlight, but it does dry out even in the dark, and becomes brittle over time regardless, and so shouldn't be used inside the house. I still used soft copper tubing for a recent water main to house connection. Even though it's buried two feet down, I still worry that seismic or shovel action could crack PVC. If you can afford copper it, get oversized type L pipes though. I ran type L 1-1/2" copper cold water and 3/4" hot water copper pipes under my crawl space. The mainfold for the radiant floor system was 2" pipe. I don't like water softeners, and I don't want calcium build-up to be a problem in my lifetime in the main lines of the house system. It also helps reduce water hammer and other strange sounds...But, given copper prices today, PEX is the way to go most everywhere, except the garden. Bates wrote: I've been planning to re-plumb most of an old house we bought in my home town for vacations, using pex products. My investigation so far hasn't revealed much in the way of negatives about pex pipe. The Lowes around here are stocking a good selection of Zurn brand pex pipe, fittings and tools. BTW, Zurn now has a new tool, and new crimp rings, so one needs only the one (expensive) tool to do 4 sizes of tubing. The new tool is the kind that pinches an ear on the crimp ring, as opposed to the tools that surround and squeeze the entire ring. That means that it can be a bit smaller, and thus fit into some tighter spaces. Ease of installation, resistance to freezing, and manifold type of installation seem to be pluses to me. If anyone has had bad luck with pex, I'm probably not the only one who would like to hear of it. I'm getting ready to puchase the tools and supplies pretty soon. Home Depot seems completely unaware of pex plumbing, and Menards home centers do carry pex (Durapex), but perhaps not as complete a set as that of Lowes. Thanks for any input. Bates |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
I forgot to add--No, copper will not corrode. There are some houses
with copper lines that are over a hundred years old and still working fine. The Gothic cathedrals of Europe have copper roofs that are nearly a thousand years old. It does however allow for build-up of mineral deposits inside the hot water tubing, that can be a nuisance in maybe 50 years or so, depending upon how bad your local water supply is. Use plastic, copper hangers with brass screws, or wrap electrical tape around the pipe if steel straps are used, as copper will produce electrolysis and corrode other metals when in direct contact with them. For durability, I doubt there is much difference. Copper will corode and CPVC won't but... For ease of maintenance and making changes, it is CPVC hands down. |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
"Alan" wrote in message ps.com... I forgot to add--No, copper will not corrode. There are some houses with copper lines that are over a hundred years old and still working fine. The Gothic cathedrals of Europe have copper roofs that are nearly a thousand years old. Certain water supplies have had a corrosive effect on copper. This is mostly in the south western states. People have had problems after 20 years. |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
Seen the price of copper, lately?
-- Christopher A. Young You can't shout down a troll. You have to starve them. .. "Harry K" wrote in message ups.com... Zootal wrote: My house has cpvc water pipes - the person who owned it before me re-plumbed the house and this is what he used. Is this superior to copper? Is one preferred over the other? For durability, I doubt there is much difference. Copper will corode and CPVC won't but... For ease of maintenance and making changes, it is CPVC hands down. Harry K |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
I have seen corroded copper.
If copper doesn't corrode, why do we have to sandscreen and wirebrush it before we sweat? -- Christopher A. Young You can't shout down a troll. You have to starve them. .. "Alan" wrote in message ps.com... I forgot to add--No, copper will not corrode. |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
My house has cpvc water pipes - the person who owned it before me
re-plumbed the house and this is what he used. Is this superior to copper? Is one preferred over the other? I chose CPVC piping when I plumbed our house a couple of years ago. I decided against copper because we have acidic water that can cause pinhole leaks in the pipe over time. It also takes a bit of skill and practice to solder copper fittings, and there's always a small risk of starting a house fire with the torch. Copper pipe is also rather expensive these days. PEX was my second choice, but very few stores in my area stocked it. If I needed to make an emergency repair or small addition, I may not be able to find the pipe or fittings nearby. PEX also required a special crimping tool that was rather expensive at the time. In the end, I chose CPVC pipe. It won't corrode like copper, and doesn't require any special tools to install. It's inexpensive, and widely available at any home center or local hardware store. It's quick to install, and very easy to work with. Anthony |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
The builders use that plastic stuff because it's cheaper, and even a
Mexican can install it. Other than that, it has no real advantage over copper. The slight flexability of copper may make it advantageous in some circumstances. Both are fairly reliable, but I have my doubts about threads on anything plastic. Obviously copper will cost more. I would probably not mix the two types in a house. |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
On 9 Aug 2006 18:48:46 -0700, "Harry K"
wrote: Zootal wrote: My house has cpvc water pipes - the person who owned it before me re-plumbed the house and this is what he used. Is this superior to copper? Is one preferred over the other? For durability, I doubt there is much difference. Copper will corode and CPVC won't but... But copper wont crack when someone bumps into it, CPVC will. Copper wont sag between the hangers, CPVC does. Copper dont shatter when a screw on fitting is over tightened, CPVC does. Copper dont make the hot water taste like plastic, CPVC does. For ease of maintenance and making changes, it is CPVC hands down. I dont consider waiting hours for the glue to dry to be "ease of maintenance". Soldering is more work, but the pipes can be used a few minutes after soldering. CPVC needs hours to dry securely and until them, No Water". Harry K |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
Zootal wrote: The blue stuff is ready in a minute or so. Hmmm...learn something new every day. Full pressure in a few minutes? Yes, and not just the blue stuff. A big advantage of PVC/CPVC is the ease of repair and modification. It is flexible enough that given a few feet either side of the patch it can be cut and a new fitting inserted. Can't do that with copper (easily). Again, only if it has been out in the sun a long time. People build lawn furniture out of PVC I've seen PVC chairs collapse. But it didn't break - it was just too thin, and could not hold the weight. They were using the wrong schedule PVC then. Harry K |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
" wrote in news:1155177742.860452.12310
@q16g2000cwq.googlegroups.com: Well plastic wouldnt get ripped off! My dad used to rent homes in phoenix, he had to go all plastic since tenants would steal the copper pipes and everything else of value out of the homes.... Yeah, and the liberal judges overlook it, because all landlords are evil!! with todays high copper prices people are finding their gutters downspouts and other copper stuff has grown feet and left the building Plastic is safe at least for now |
#19
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
wrote in message ups.com... The builders use that plastic stuff because it's cheaper, and even a Mexican can install it. Other than that, it has no real advantage over copper. The slight flexability of copper may make it advantageous in some circumstances. Both are fairly reliable, but I have my doubts about threads on anything plastic. Obviously copper will cost more. I would probably not mix the two types in a house. The garden hose piping or also called PEX. is exactly as you said I'll leave out the Mex. stuff , it's nothing but low end crap a money maker for the contractor no real; skill to install it just drill a go. |
#20
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
"Zootal" wrote in message news My house has cpvc water pipes - the person who owned it before me re-plumbed the house and this is what he used. Is this superior to copper? Is one preferred over the other? As far as drain lines go, nothing's better than plastic. (other than the need to provide more support than you would for copper/iron). |
#21
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
wrote in message ... On Thu, 10 Aug 2006 12:13:15 -0500, wrote: U/V damaged white PVC gerts brittle but that is usually after about 10 years in the Florida sun. People use PVC pipe for guides on boat trailers and boat lifts here in South Florida. If it was as brittle as you say it would snap off the fist time the wind caught your boat. That is not what happens. I have to smile. Here in NM, PVC lasts about 8-12 months exposed! |
#22
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
The garden hose isn't the same material as PEX. Use Google to find the
PEX vendors and learn about the stuff, it's not a third-world product, but is extensively used in radiant floor heating and in Europe. It is what is used in many new houses now, not that this recommends its use elsewhere. I'm curious about the CVPVC. I wouldn't use PVC inside my house though, that's for sure. I realize that people put plastic everywhere these days, but the long term outlook for lots of it doesn't look good to me. As for the pinhole problems in copper, I can see from comments posted that certain water conditions apparently are a problem, but fortunately this isn't the case in my area. But, a lot of type M copper is simply too thin, and I would not be surprised if the grade of copper is the real problem in some of the cases mentioned. I dug up recently a length of 1" copper in my garden, a part of a 40 year old irrigation system for pumping water from the San Joaquin River, was found to be in such excellent condition, that I may put it back into service. If it had been plastic, my shovel would have cracked it during removal. As for the pipe sizing issue, I'll agree that delivery pressure and volume issues have to be considered and tested for the job to be done right. Sacramento Dave wrote: wrote in message ups.com... The builders use that plastic stuff because it's cheaper, and even a Mexican can install it. Other than that, it has no real advantage over copper. The slight flexability of copper may make it advantageous in some circumstances. Both are fairly reliable, but I have my doubts about threads on anything plastic. Obviously copper will cost more. I would probably not mix the two types in a house. The garden hose piping or also called PEX. is exactly as you said I'll leave out the Mex. stuff , it's nothing but low end crap a money maker for the contractor no real; skill to install it just drill a go. |
#23
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
"James "Cubby" Culbertson" wrote in message news wrote in message ... On Thu, 10 Aug 2006 12:13:15 -0500, wrote: U/V damaged white PVC gerts brittle but that is usually after about 10 years in the Florida sun. People use PVC pipe for guides on boat trailers and boat lifts here in South Florida. If it was as brittle as you say it would snap off the fist time the wind caught your boat. That is not what happens. I have to smile. Here in NM, PVC lasts about 8-12 months exposed! I lived in Las Vegas for 15 years. PVC would last about 1 summer in the sun, and then that was it. |
#24
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
wrote in message ... On Thu, 10 Aug 2006 21:16:33 -0600, "James \"Cubby\" Culbertson" wrote: I have to smile. Here in NM, PVC lasts about 8-12 months exposed! How do they plumb swimming pools? Beats me. Never looked. Most pools are below ground so I'd imagine the piping is below ground. I'm really going from my own experience of where I've left a couple sticks of the stuff outside in the weather and within 10 months or so, it was pretty brown (from white). |
#25
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
wrote in message ... I guess it's a good thing the sun doesn't shine in Florida because most people with a well have pipes outside and they are always white PVC. Explodig pipe is not a huge problem. Yeah, all the well pipes here are underground. It's the altitude for us that does it. At 5800 ft above sea level, the sun is pretty intense. That's why a number of folks refer to Albuquerque as the "skin cancer capital of the world". I've lived in a number of places, travelled to many others, and have never felt the sun more intense than it is here. With that comes extreme dryness as well so that may be playing a part in the plastic's demise as well. Cheers, cc |
#27
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
"James "Cubby" Culbertson" wrote in message ... wrote in message ... I guess it's a good thing the sun doesn't shine in Florida because most people with a well have pipes outside and they are always white PVC. Explodig pipe is not a huge problem. Yeah, all the well pipes here are underground. It's the altitude for us that does it. At 5800 ft above sea level, the sun is pretty intense. That's why a number of folks refer to Albuquerque as the "skin cancer capital of the world". I've lived in a number of places, travelled to many others, and have never felt the sun more intense than it is here. With that comes extreme dryness as well so that may be playing a part in the plastic's demise as well. Cheers, cc Naw, PVC is broken down by UV exposure. You are probably right, at 5800 feet the amount of UV reaching the pipe is much more than it is at sea level - anyone who mountain climbs knows this. I've got 2nd degree burns from not respecting how much more UV exposure you get at the top of even a moderately tall mountain. It's my limited understanding that the PVC is worn out by the UV radiation reacting with the chlorine in the pipe - something that CPVC as much of due to how it's processed. But I think all plastic is harmed by UV radiation, I know that PEX is, PVC certainly is, nylon not so much, and I'm sure a few others. |
#28
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
I think all plastic is harmed by UV radiation, I know that PEX is,
PVC certainly is, nylon not so much, and I'm sure a few others. The grey PVC pipe they make for electrical conduit has UV inhibitors. It is designed for outside use and holds up nicely. I guess the reason they don't bother putting the UV inhibitor in normal plumbing pipe, is because it usually doesn't sit out in the sun. Most of the time it's buried underground or under a floor in insulation. Anthony |
#29
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
On Fri, 11 Aug 2006 15:44:55 -0700, "Eigenvector"
wrote: "James "Cubby" Culbertson" wrote in message ... wrote in message ... I guess it's a good thing the sun doesn't shine in Florida because most people with a well have pipes outside and they are always white PVC. Explodig pipe is not a huge problem. Yeah, all the well pipes here are underground. It's the altitude for us that does it. At 5800 ft above sea level, the sun is pretty intense. That's why a number of folks refer to Albuquerque as the "skin cancer capital of the world". I've lived in a number of places, travelled to many others, and have never felt the sun more intense than it is here. With that comes extreme dryness as well so that may be playing a part in the plastic's demise as well. Cheers, cc Naw, PVC is broken down by UV exposure. You are probably right, at 5800 feet the amount of UV reaching the pipe is much more than it is at sea level - anyone who mountain climbs knows this. I've got 2nd degree burns from not respecting how much more UV exposure you get at the top of even a moderately tall mountain. It's my limited understanding that the PVC is worn out by the UV radiation reacting with the chlorine in the pipe - something that CPVC as much of due to how it's processed. But I think all plastic is harmed by UV radiation, I know that PEX is, PVC certainly is, nylon not so much, and I'm sure a few others. Simple solution. Put all plastic pipe inside of copper pipe, use the next size up in the copper. Like 1/2" cpvc inside 3/4" copper. Oh, wait a minute, soldering the copper would melt the cpvc. You have to use steel pipe instead. |
#31
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
copper or cpvc water pipes?
|
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Brown's gas?? | Metalworking | |||
NO MORE hot water problems | Home Repair | |||
Thankless or Tankless hot water heaters | Home Repair | |||
Flushing / Cleaning Hot Water Heater Help Needed | Home Repair | |||
hot water recirculator, instant hot water but not a water heating unit, saves water, gas, time, money | Home Repair |