Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Electronics Repair (sci.electronics.repair) Discussion of repairing electronic equipment. Topics include requests for assistance, where to obtain servicing information and parts, techniques for diagnosis and repair, and annecdotes about success, failures and problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
Hi,
Since I created a NiMH battery pack using recently bought NiMH "C" batteries, I am in search of knowledge for the best way to slow charge these 1500 MAH "C" cells in series. I prefer using a timer and a constant current charger (I made) that supplies a constant 150MA. There is a lot of information on the web, but one site says one thing, and another says something else. www.batteryprice.com/batterycareguide.aspx provided the kind of information I was looking for: (Battery Capacity in MHA/Charge Rate) X 1.4 = Time to charge (slow charge). Note: Batteries "fully discharged" to 1V each cell. In my case, 1500/150 = 10 X 1.4 = 14 hours. This seems logical to me, but I wonder if anyone sees a flaw. Thank You in advance, John |
#3
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On Sun, 23 Dec 2012 16:53:34 -0500, wrote:
Hi, Since I created a NiMH battery pack using recently bought NiMH "C" batteries, I am in search of knowledge for the best way to slow charge these 1500 MAH "C" cells in series. I prefer using a timer and a constant current charger (I made) that supplies a constant 150MA. There is a lot of information on the web, but one site says one thing, and another says something else. www.batteryprice.com/batterycareguide.aspx provided the kind of information I was looking for: (Battery Capacity in MHA/Charge Rate) X 1.4 = Time to charge (slow charge). Note: Batteries "fully discharged" to 1V each cell. In my case, 1500/150 = 10 X 1.4 = 14 hours. This seems logical to me, but I wonder if anyone sees a flaw. Thank You in advance, John In the dark ages, I've charged NiCd and NiMH batteries with a timer. It's a good way *IF* you know the capacity of the battery and the state of charge. Capacity is easy as it's in the spec sheet. However, a given battery can have radically different capacity values at different charge/discharge rates. To make the numbers look huge, manufacturers use a slow discharge rate. The battery also has a charging efficiency, where it takes more coulombs to charge the battery, than it can deliver. I use 75% for most batteries. Once you know all that, and the state of charge, you can calculate how long you need to charge the battery. If the battery gets warm at the end, you're overcharging and have probably killed the battery. The catch is that if you forget to discharge to a known setpoint (i.e. 1V) you could easily overcharge the battery. Also, if you use a timer, and the power fails during the charge, you could also charge for longer than anticipated. Rather than go through this ordeal, technology exists to detect the end of charge. You can get the chips and make your own, or just buy a commercial NiMH charger. More detail: http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/charging_nickel_metal_hydride Note the comments on difficulties with trickle charging NiMH batteries. http://www.buchmann.ca/article18-page1.asp (Note: Isador Buchmann is the founder of Cadex and author of the BatteryUniversity.com web site). -- Jeff Liebermann 150 Felker St #D http://www.LearnByDestroying.com Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558 |
#4
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
In the dark ages, I've charged NiCd and NiMH batteries with a timer.
It's a good way *IF* you know the capacity of the battery and the state of charge. Capacity is easy as it's in the spec sheet. However, a given battery can have radically different capacity values at different charge/discharge rates. To make the numbers look huge, manufacturers use a slow discharge rate. The battery also has a charging efficiency, where it takes more coulombs to charge the battery, than it can deliver. I use 75% for most batteries. Once you know all that, and the state of charge, you can calculate how long you need to charge the battery. If the battery gets warm at the end, you're overcharging and have probably killed the battery. This is one of those rare cases where I have to disagree with Mr Lieberman. How warm is warm? "Getting warm" is an indication that charging is complete, or near-complete. Many NiMH manufacturers claim their cells need to be "slammed" to get maximum charge. I'm reluctant to do this. However, I've charged NiMH cells in those "15-minute" chargers, and though the cells got hot, they were not destroyed. (I no longer do this. I have about 20 cells of 2500mAh and higher capacity, so I never need a quick charge.) The best way to charge batteries is with a charger that lets you set the charge rate, and watches for the signs that indicate the cell is charged, such as the MAHA C9000. I generally charge at 0.3C or 0.4C, which is considered on the low side for NiMH cells. Contrary to what Battery University claims, I've never had problems with the cells overheating, or the charger failing to halt at around 1.42 to 1.45 volts. (Note that his gripes are principally directed at "consumer" chargers.) The C9000 displays the battery voltage, so I can choose to stop charger at whatever voltage I feel comfortable with. I'm not stupid enough to let any charger operate without checking it occasionally. If you like, stick a timer on the charger to shut it off. |
#5
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On Mon, 24 Dec 2012 04:32:24 -0800, "William Sommerwerck"
wrote: In the dark ages, I've charged NiCd and NiMH batteries with a timer. It's a good way *IF* you know the capacity of the battery and the state of charge. Capacity is easy as it's in the spec sheet. However, a given battery can have radically different capacity values at different charge/discharge rates. To make the numbers look huge, manufacturers use a slow discharge rate. The battery also has a charging efficiency, where it takes more coulombs to charge the battery, than it can deliver. I use 75% for most batteries. Once you know all that, and the state of charge, you can calculate how long you need to charge the battery. If the battery gets warm at the end, you're overcharging and have probably killed the battery. This is one of those rare cases where I have to disagree with Mr Lieberman. How warm is warm? "Getting warm" is an indication that charging is complete, or near-complete. That's easy. This is Figure 1: http://www.buchmann.ca/Article18_files/Figure1.gif from this article: http://www.buchmann.ca/article18-page1.asp The graph is for NiCd but NiMH is similar. I've also created my own temperature curves for my experiments in extremely rapid NiCd charging. Not that the temperature starts to rise at about 75% of full charge and has risen 45C (113F) above ambient at 100%. That's more than "getting warm". That's hot. Many NiMH manufacturers claim their cells need to be "slammed" to get maximum charge. I believe I demonstrated this in the past. See: http://802.11junk.com/jeffl/NiMH/ It seems that you have to charge cycle a NiMH battery about 3 times before it will deliver full capacity. However, the difference is small. For example: http://802.11junk.com/jeffl/NiMH/Duracelll-NiMH-2050.jpg shows that the first charge cycle results in a 1180mA-hr capacity, while the third charge cycle increased it to 1360mA-hr or about 15% increase. Is that what you mean by "slammed"? I'm reluctant to do this. However, I've charged NiMH cells in those "15-minute" chargers, and though the cells got hot, they were not destroyed. My favorite NiMH charger is a Radio Shack 23-1305 30 minute NiMH charger. The cells get warm at the end of charge. I haven't bothered to measure the temperature. Again, if you look at the previous article showing the temperature graph, the cell should be 113F at full charge. Hopefully, the charger slows down the rate of charge before reaching 100% or it probably will get that hot. (I no longer do this. I have about 20 cells of 2500mAh and higher capacity, so I never need a quick charge.) I've noticed that my NiMH battery collection (flashlights, cameras, GPS, radios, etc) spent much of their time in the charger simply recovering from self discharge. So, I invested in some Sanyo Eneloop batteries, which have a much lower self discharge rate. I took some photos yesterday with a camera that has been bouncing around my car for about 5 months. That battery indicator showed about 3/4 charge. Had this been the older batteries, they would have been almost totally discharged. The best way to charge batteries is with a charger that lets you set the charge rate, and watches for the signs that indicate the cell is charged, such as the MAHA C9000. I generally charge at 0.3C or 0.4C, which is considered on the low side for NiMH cells. Contrary to what Battery University claims, I've never had problems with the cells overheating, or the charger failing to halt at around 1.42 to 1.45 volts. (Note that his gripes are principally directed at "consumer" chargers.) http://www.mahaenergy.com/mh-c9000/ Nice charger/analyzer. I dunno the break-in and battery-forming features. Stressing the battery doesn't seem like a good way to increase battery life though it might produce rated capacity earlier. However, it's a much better charger than the common consumer junk chargers, and would probably be a good charger for the OP. The C9000 displays the battery voltage, so I can choose to stop charger at whatever voltage I feel comfortable with. I'm not stupid enough to let any charger operate without checking it occasionally. If you like, stick a timer on the charger to shut it off. Have you tested your battery for rated capacity after one of your charge cycles? The MH-C9000 will run a discharge mode test and display battery capacity. -- Jeff Liebermann 150 Felker St #D http://www.LearnByDestroying.com Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558 |
#6
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
http://802.11junk.com/jeffl/NiMH/Duracelll-NiMH-2050.jpg
shows that the first charge cycle results in a 1180mA-hr capacity, while the third charge cycle increased it to 1360mA-hr or about 15% increase. Is that what you mean by "slammed"? No. It means hitting it hard with a high charge current. I've noticed that my NiMH battery collection (flashlights, cameras, GPS, radios, etc) spent much of their time in the charger simply recovering from self discharge. I've never had that problem -- as far as I can tell. I've had cells that sat around for the better part of year deliver 20 or 30 flashes, with rapid recycling. Most of my cells have been close to rated capacity. In one case, a cell was about 20% low, and MAHA replaced it. http://www.mahaenergy.com/mh-c9000/ Nice charger/analyzer. I dunno the break-in and battery-forming features. Stressing the battery doesn't seem like a good way to increase battery life though it might produce rated capacity earlier. However, it's a much better charger than the common consumer junk chargers, and would probably be a good charger for the OP. Agreed. Thomas sometimes sold the C9000 for ~ $40, but those days seem over. I have two, so I don't have to wait if a lot of cells need charging. |
#7
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On Mon, 24 Dec 2012 11:28:48 -0800, "William Sommerwerck"
wrote: http://802.11junk.com/jeffl/NiMH/Duracelll-NiMH-2050.jpg shows that the first charge cycle results in a 1180mA-hr capacity, while the third charge cycle increased it to 1360mA-hr or about 15% increase. Is that what you mean by "slammed"? No. It means hitting it hard with a high charge current. Yuck. Why would I want to do that? If there were dendrites in NiMH batteries like in NiCd, then perhaps it would make sense. Besides if such a high current blast was necessary to produce a proper battery, or to produce bigger numbers on the data sheet, the manufacturers would already be doing it. Where did you see this recommendation? I couldn't find anything with Google under "NiMH slamming" variations, except under National Institute of Mental Health. I did find this blurb that recommends against the practice: http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/post/25581821 I've noticed that my NiMH battery collection (flashlights, cameras, GPS, radios, etc) spent much of their time in the charger simply recovering from self discharge. I've never had that problem -- as far as I can tell. I've had cells that sat around for the better part of year deliver 20 or 30 flashes, with rapid recycling. Perhaps my cameras and GPS require a higher minimum state of charge than your flash? When I used to leave my conventional NiMH batteries in the camera for a few months, it would usually be good for one or two photos before complaining. I always kept a spare set of charged NiMH with the camera in case I run out. They were also only good for a few shots. http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/sanyo_eneloop.html Scroll down to the two pink graphs near the bottom of the article. The conventional battery is down to half capacity in 75 days, and 1/4 capacity in 150 days. Incidentally, this article: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/using_nimh.html covers quite a bit of ground on dealing with NiMH batteries, including trickle charging, and a home made NiMH computah controlled charger: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/battman2.html and a simplified USB powered charger: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/usb_charger.html I'm tempted... Most of my cells have been close to rated capacity. In one case, a cell was about 20% low, and MAHA replaced it. I didn't know that Maha made batteries: http://www.mahaenergy.com/batteries/ $4.25/ea for AA in a 4 pack is not cheap. Somewhat more expensive than Sanyo Eneloop. I dunno. There are other low self discharge NiMH batteries available. Duracell Pre Charged http://www.duracell.com/en-US/product/rechargeable-staycharged-batteries.jspx Rayovac Hybrid or Platinum: http://www.rayovac.com/Products/Rechargeable-Batteries-and-Chargers/Everyday-Use-best-battery-charger.aspx Kodak Pre-Charged http://store.kodak.com/store/ekconsus/en_US/pd/ThemeID.3925700/Ni-MH_Pre-Charged_Rechargeable_Batteries_AA/productID.158853000 http://www.mahaenergy.com/mh-c9000/ Nice charger/analyzer. I dunno the break-in and battery-forming features. Stressing the battery doesn't seem like a good way to increase battery life though it might produce rated capacity earlier. However, it's a much better charger than the common consumer junk chargers, and would probably be a good charger for the OP. Agreed. Thomas sometimes sold the C9000 for ~ $40, but those days seem over. I have two, so I don't have to wait if a lot of cells need charging. I'm finding prices from $50 to $140 (including tax and shipping). http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=maha%20mh-c9000&_sop=15 -- Jeff Liebermann 150 Felker St #D http://www.LearnByDestroying.com Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558 |
#8
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
"Jeff Liebermann" wrote in message
... On Mon, 24 Dec 2012 11:28:48 -0800, "William Sommerwerck" wrote: http://802.11junk.com/jeffl/NiMH/Duracelll-NiMH-2050.jpg shows that the first charge cycle results in a 1180mA-hr capacity, while the third charge cycle increased it to 1360mA-hr or about 15% increase. Is that what you mean by "slammed"? No. It means hitting it hard with a high charge current. Yuck. Why would I want to do that? If there were dendrites in NiMH batteries like in NiCd, then perhaps it would make sense. Besides if such a high current blast was necessary to produce a proper battery, or to produce bigger numbers on the data sheet, the manufacturers would already be doing it. Where did you see this recommendation? I couldn't find anything with Google under "NiMH slamming" variations, except under National Institute of Mental Health. I did find this blurb that recommends against the practice: http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/post/25581821 "Slam" is my choice of words. I can't give you any references, but I've repeatedly seen in the documentation for NiMH cells, that hitting them hard is necessary to get a "full" charge. You are repeatedly warned NOT to charge them below 0.3C, and higher values are preferable. I've noticed that my NiMH battery collection (flashlights, cameras, GPS, radios, etc) spent much of their time in the charger simply recovering from self discharge. I've never had that problem -- as far as I can tell. I've had cells that sat around for the better part of year deliver 20 or 30 flashes, with rapid recycling. Perhaps my cameras and GPS require a higher minimum state of charge than your flash? When I used to leave my conventional NiMH batteries in the camera for a few months, it would usually be good for one or two photos before complaining. I always kept a spare set of charged NiMH with the camera in case I run out. They were also only good for a few shots. Most of my flashes are 500-series Canons, which are hardly wimpy li'l critters. http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/sanyo_eneloop.html Scroll down to the two pink graphs near the bottom of the article. The conventional battery is down to half capacity in 75 days, and 1/4 capacity in 150 days. That's not what I would consider "rapid" self-discharge -- other than, perhaps, compared to a lead-acid battery. Incidentally, this article: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/using_nimh.html covers quite a bit of ground on dealing with NiMH batteries, including trickle charging, and a home made NiMH computah controlled charger: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/battman2.html and a simplified USB powered charger: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/usb_charger.html I'm tempted... Most of my cells have been close to rated capacity. In one case, a cell was about 20% low, and MAHA replaced it. I didn't know that Maha made batteries: http://www.mahaenergy.com/batteries/ I don't know if they make them, but they definitely sell them under the PowerEx brand. Thomas sells four for about $12. Considering that a charged 2500mAh cell gives about as much runtime as an alkaline cell, it doesn't take long to amortize the cost. Thomas sometimes sold the C9000 for ~ $40, but those days seem over. I have two, so I don't have to wait if a lot of cells need charging. I'm finding prices from $50 to $140 (including tax and shipping). http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=maha%20mh-c9000&_sop=15 The eBay prices are nuts. I was wrong. Thomas's holiday deal is the charger, a generic carrying case, four Immedion AA cells and a plastic case for the latter, for about $52. Given the cost of the "accessories", the charger nets at $40. This would be a very good time to grab a C9000 from Thomas Distributing. |
#9
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On Mon, 24 Dec 2012 14:39:56 -0800, "William Sommerwerck"
wrote: "Slam" is my choice of words. I can't give you any references, but I've repeatedly seen in the documentation for NiMH cells, that hitting them hard is necessary to get a "full" charge. You are repeatedly warned NOT to charge them below 0.3C, and higher values are preferable. I think I've decoded the effect. It's a cure for "voltage depression", where the NiMH battery decides to operate fairly normally, but at a somewhat lower voltage. The usual culprit is over charging. I've had it happen to me and almost tossed a set of good batteries. The recommended fix is to cycle charge the batteries a few times and it should recover. However, the not so graceful fix is to discharge the battery, and then to a radical quick charge, being careful not to overcharge it again. Allegedly, this avoids having to cycle charge the battery several times, probably at the expense of battery life. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memory_effect#Voltage_depression_due_to_long-term_over-charging See voltage depression section near the bottom of the page: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/using_nimh.html http://www.greenbatteries.com/nibafa.html#NiMH%20memory Most of my flashes are 500-series Canons, which are hardly wimpy li'l critters. I'm not familiar with the flash, but I suspect is does not have the continuous high current load of a camera with it's focus and aperture motors grinding away for many minutes. http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/sanyo_eneloop.html Scroll down to the two pink graphs near the bottom of the article. The conventional battery is down to half capacity in 75 days, and 1/4 capacity in 150 days. That's not what I would consider "rapid" self-discharge -- other than, perhaps, compared to a lead-acid battery. Well, it's rapid enough that I was recharging almost everything I owned every 3 months or so. If it were only one device, I wouldn't complain, but it was a mix of GPS, flashlights, cameras, phones, walkie-talkies, FRS radios, clocks, etc. I don't know if they make them, but they definitely sell them under the PowerEx brand. Thomas sells four for about $12. Considering that a charged 2500mAh cell gives about as much runtime as an alkaline cell, it doesn't take long to amortize the cost. Well, the plan was to save money by using rechargeable batteries. I usually buy Costco Kirland AA batteries: http://www2.costco.com/Browse/Product.aspx?prodid=11285539&whse=BD_115&topnav=bd off&cat=21810&hierPath=68474*91765*&lang=en-US at about $0.30 each. Sanyo Eneloop NiMH batteries are costing me about $3.00 each. So, if the NiMH battery lasts 10 charge cycles, I break even. So far, that's been the case, so for cost savings, rechargeable wins. However, that has NOT been the case for convenience. I can leave an alkaline AA battery in my various devices for many months, and not have a self discharge problem. I find myself carrying spare alkaline batteries for these devices just in case the battery decides to discharge itself. Extra points for devices that suck power when turned off. Therefore, for convenience, conventional rechargeable NiMH is a problem. The low self discharge batteries are a big improvement and may just solve the problem. I'm not keeping score, but I'm definitely not recharging anywhere near as often as when I was using conventional NiMH batteries. I was wrong. Thomas's holiday deal is the charger, a generic carrying case, four Immedion AA cells and a plastic case for the latter, for about $52. Given the cost of the "accessories", the charger nets at $40. This would be a very good time to grab a C9000 from Thomas Distributing. Good price, but the web pile is back to $52 (including shipping) and without the AA cells and plastic case: http://www.ecrater.com/p/11476696/maha-powerex-c9000-aa-aaa -- Jeff Liebermann 150 Felker St #D http://www.LearnByDestroying.com Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558 |
#10
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On 12/24/2012 2:10 PM, Jeff Liebermann wrote:
On Mon, 24 Dec 2012 11:28:48 -0800, "William Sommerwerck" wrote: http://802.11junk.com/jeffl/NiMH/Duracelll-NiMH-2050.jpg shows that the first charge cycle results in a 1180mA-hr capacity, while the third charge cycle increased it to 1360mA-hr or about 15% increase. Is that what you mean by "slammed"? No. It means hitting it hard with a high charge current. Yuck. Why would I want to do that? If there were dendrites in NiMH batteries like in NiCd, then perhaps it would make sense. Besides if such a high current blast was necessary to produce a proper battery, or to produce bigger numbers on the data sheet, the manufacturers would already be doing it. Where did you see this recommendation? I couldn't find anything with Google under "NiMH slamming" variations, except under National Institute of Mental Health. I did find this blurb that recommends against the practice: http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/post/25581821 I've noticed that my NiMH battery collection (flashlights, cameras, GPS, radios, etc) spent much of their time in the charger simply recovering from self discharge. I've never had that problem -- as far as I can tell. I've had cells that sat around for the better part of year deliver 20 or 30 flashes, with rapid recycling. Perhaps my cameras and GPS require a higher minimum state of charge than your flash? When I used to leave my conventional NiMH batteries in the camera for a few months, it would usually be good for one or two photos before complaining. I always kept a spare set of charged NiMH with the camera in case I run out. They were also only good for a few shots. http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/sanyo_eneloop.html Scroll down to the two pink graphs near the bottom of the article. The conventional battery is down to half capacity in 75 days, and 1/4 capacity in 150 days. Incidentally, this article: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/using_nimh.html covers quite a bit of ground on dealing with NiMH batteries, including trickle charging, and a home made NiMH computah controlled charger: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/battman2.html and a simplified USB powered charger: http://www.stefanv.com/electronics/usb_charger.html I'm tempted... Most of my cells have been close to rated capacity. In one case, a cell was about 20% low, and MAHA replaced it. I didn't know that Maha made batteries: http://www.mahaenergy.com/batteries/ $4.25/ea for AA in a 4 pack is not cheap. Somewhat more expensive than Sanyo Eneloop. I dunno. There are other low self discharge NiMH batteries available. Duracell Pre Charged http://www.duracell.com/en-US/product/rechargeable-staycharged-batteries.jspx Rayovac Hybrid or Platinum: http://www.rayovac.com/Products/Rechargeable-Batteries-and-Chargers/Everyday-Use-best-battery-charger.aspx Kodak Pre-Charged http://store.kodak.com/store/ekconsus/en_US/pd/ThemeID.3925700/Ni-MH_Pre-Charged_Rechargeable_Batteries_AA/productID.158853000 http://www.mahaenergy.com/mh-c9000/ Nice charger/analyzer. I dunno the break-in and battery-forming features. Stressing the battery doesn't seem like a good way to increase battery life though it might produce rated capacity earlier. However, it's a much better charger than the common consumer junk chargers, and would probably be a good charger for the OP. Agreed. Thomas sometimes sold the C9000 for ~ $40, but those days seem over. I have two, so I don't have to wait if a lot of cells need charging. I'm finding prices from $50 to $140 (including tax and shipping). http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=maha%20mh-c9000&_sop=15 +1 on the c9000 I've had good results with the older Enloop charger...the one with the single led that can charge an odd number of cells. There are two categories of dendrites. Dendrites that have already shorted need to be vaporized with short-duration high-current. That clears the short and blasts a bigger hole in the separator. Causes higher self-discharge and faster dendrite regrowth. Back in the day when NiCds were expensive and shorted ones were free, it made a lot of sense for hobby projects. The second class is those that have not yet pierced the separator. For those, I'm a fan of burp charging. Same process you'd use for plating when you want a smooth surface. I did some experiments, but I had nowhere enough data to draw a conclusion. And I concluded that the cost of powering the computer and the programmable power supply and load probably exceeded the benefit. The biggest problem with charging batteries is determining when to stop. I had a friend who did radio repair for the city. Back in the day, police radios were terminated by a thermal switch. That worked surprisingly well, but only because the battery was predictably depleted during the shift. If you stuck a charged radio into the charger, you did some damage. He had a lot of failed batteries from people who left the radio off all day and stuck it back in the charger. There's so much variability in temperature, thermal time constant, voltage gradient, etc. that it's best to measure change than absolute value. I'm a fan of 0deltaV termination with timer and temperature fail-safe for NiMH cells. |
#11
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
Most of my flashes are 500-series Canons, which are hardly
wimpy li'l critters. I'm not familiar with the flash, but I suspect is does not have the continuous high current load of a camera with it's focus and aperture motors grinding away for many minutes. Most DSLRs use lithium-ion batteries. I've never measured the current drain, but I doubt it approaches what's required to charge an electronic flash from a dead start. And unless you're using the focus-track feature, auto-focus operation is intermittent. -- discussion of rechargeable versus disposable batteries snipped -- I use rechargeables on any device where I can easily swap the batteries. Disposables are okay for certain kinds of toys and LED flashlights. (Most take AAA cells, and I have a huge box of Polaroid AAA alkalines I got cheap.) |
#12
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On Mon, 24 Dec 2012 17:20:32 -0800, mike wrote:
+1 on the c9000 Sigh. I've got an itchy mouse finger hovering over the "buy" button. There are two categories of dendrites. Dendrites that have already shorted need to be vaporized with short-duration high-current. That clears the short and blasts a bigger hole in the separator. Causes higher self-discharge and faster dendrite regrowth. Back in the day when NiCds were expensive and shorted ones were free, it made a lot of sense for hobby projects. I've done my share of NiCd cells directly across a 12v car battery for a few fractions of a second. No explosions, and a rather minimal success rate. The ones that worked didn't last very long. The second class is those that have not yet pierced the separator. For those, I'm a fan of burp charging. Same process you'd use for plating when you want a smooth surface. I did some experiments, but I had nowhere enough data to draw a conclusion. And I concluded that the cost of powering the computer and the programmable power supply and load probably exceeded the benefit. Also known as "negative pulse charging" or "reflex charging". There are commercial chargers that do this. Pulse-Power: http://www.fm2way.com/batterycharger/technica.htm "Negative Pulse Charging Myths and Facts" http://www.powerdesigners.com/pdf/Tech%20Brief%20Negative%20Pulse%20Charging%20Techn iques%20Myths%20&%20Facts%20-%20Final.pdf I'm not convinced, but then I haven't tried one of these chargers. The biggest problem with charging batteries is determining when to stop. Yep. Kinda like filling the gas tank with no gas gauge or automatic pump shutoff. I had a friend who did radio repair for the city. Back in the day, police radios were terminated by a thermal switch. That worked surprisingly well, but only because the battery was predictably depleted during the shift. If you stuck a charged radio into the charger, you did some damage. He had a lot of failed batteries from people who left the radio off all day and stuck it back in the charger. I know it well. The Motorola HT600 and similar "brick" radios. As an added bonus, Motorola may have designed the charger to destroy the battery packs. http://www.repeater-builder.com/motorola/genesis/ht600-charger-mod.html They also have to be modified to work with NiMH packs: http://www.repeater-builder.com/motorola/genesis/nimh-charger-mod.html However, my favorite was a Kenwood something HT, that had small a red plastic window in the bottom of the battery pack. The charger had a corresponding window with a IR photo transistor in the charger base. This was suppose to measure the cell temperature and stop charging when it became warm. Unfortunately, a little dirt on either window turned the charger into a battery overcharger. There's so much variability in temperature, thermal time constant, voltage gradient, etc. that it's best to measure change than absolute value. I'm a fan of 0deltaV termination with timer and temperature fail-safe for NiMH cells. For NiMH, that's a problem. Trickle charging an NiMH battery makes the drop in terminal voltage very difficult to see. It's in the low millivolt region. I think (not sure) that Maha recommends something like 0.5C charge on their Eneloop just so that deltaV can be detected. Here's a hint, without detail: http://www.flickr.com/groups/strobist/discuss/72157625332323687/ "manufacturers recommend 0.5C to 1C to (1A to 2A on eneloop) to make negative delta voltage detection more "detectable"." I did some testing of temperature detections on individual NiCd cells when I was doing my ultra-rapid charging experiments. I stuck 8 thermistors on various parts of the cell, and proceeded to intentionally overcharge it. The mass of the cell was sufficiently high that the thermal lag was substantial. That won't make much difference for a slow charge, but can easily be catastrophic with ultra-rapid charge, where seconds count. The best sensor location appeared to be in the middle of the cell. Unfortunately, the plastic or paper wrap around the battery is a good thermal insulator. I had to scrape off the coating and connect directly to the metal case. -- Jeff Liebermann 150 Felker St #D http://www.LearnByDestroying.com Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558 |
#13
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
MAHA has told me it will never provide a C or D adapter for the C9000. Not
wanting to figure out how to reliably attach wires to the charger's terminals, I charge my C NiMH cells * in an Eveready charger with a NiCd / NiMH switch on it. I monitor the charge with my hand. When the cell gets a bit warm, I pull it. * I use C cells in a potato-masher flash and a classic Sony FM radio. Also known as "negative pulse charging" or "reflex charging". There are commercial chargers that do this. Pulse-Power: http://www.fm2way.com/batterycharger/technica.htm "Negative Pulse Charging Myths and Facts" http://www.powerdesigners.com/pdf/Tech%20Brief%20Negative%20Pulse%20Charging%20Techn iques%20Myths%20&%20Facts%20-%20Final.pdf I'm not convinced, but then I haven't tried one of these chargers. This principle isn't new. The basic system dates back to the late 60s. Motorola made a "pulse-discharge" charger for Honeywell flashes. The claim was not only that it could quickly recharge the power pack, but that it would often "heal" a badly performing or even "dead" pack. "Modern Photography" gave the system a rave review, confirming that it worked as claimed. Several years later I asked Burt Keppler what happened to the system. He said Honeywell pulled it because there were too many instances of the packs exploding. When I asked him why he never reported this in "Modern", he had no answer. |
#14
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On 12/25/2012 9:55 AM, Jeff Liebermann wrote:
On Mon, 24 Dec 2012 17:20:32 -0800, wrote: +1 on the c9000 Sigh. I've got an itchy mouse finger hovering over the "buy" button. There are two categories of dendrites. Dendrites that have already shorted need to be vaporized with short-duration high-current. That clears the short and blasts a bigger hole in the separator. Causes higher self-discharge and faster dendrite regrowth. Back in the day when NiCds were expensive and shorted ones were free, it made a lot of sense for hobby projects. I've done my share of NiCd cells directly across a 12v car battery for a few fractions of a second. No explosions, and a rather minimal success rate. The ones that worked didn't last very long. You need better control than that. I've had better luck discharging a big cap into the cell. The second class is those that have not yet pierced the separator. For those, I'm a fan of burp charging. Same process you'd use for plating when you want a smooth surface. I did some experiments, but I had nowhere enough data to draw a conclusion. And I concluded that the cost of powering the computer and the programmable power supply and load probably exceeded the benefit. Also known as "negative pulse charging" or "reflex charging". There are commercial chargers that do this. Pulse-Power: http://www.fm2way.com/batterycharger/technica.htm "Negative Pulse Charging Myths and Facts" http://www.powerdesigners.com/pdf/Tech%20Brief%20Negative%20Pulse%20Charging%20Techn iques%20Myths%20&%20Facts%20-%20Final.pdf I'm not convinced, but then I haven't tried one of these chargers. The biggest problem with charging batteries is determining when to stop. Yep. Kinda like filling the gas tank with no gas gauge or automatic pump shutoff. I had a friend who did radio repair for the city. Back in the day, police radios were terminated by a thermal switch. That worked surprisingly well, but only because the battery was predictably depleted during the shift. If you stuck a charged radio into the charger, you did some damage. He had a lot of failed batteries from people who left the radio off all day and stuck it back in the charger. I know it well. The Motorola HT600 and similar "brick" radios. As an added bonus, Motorola may have designed the charger to destroy the battery packs. http://www.repeater-builder.com/motorola/genesis/ht600-charger-mod.html They also have to be modified to work with NiMH packs: http://www.repeater-builder.com/motorola/genesis/nimh-charger-mod.html However, my favorite was a Kenwood something HT, that had small a red plastic window in the bottom of the battery pack. The charger had a corresponding window with a IR photo transistor in the charger base. This was suppose to measure the cell temperature and stop charging when it became warm. Unfortunately, a little dirt on either window turned the charger into a battery overcharger. There's so much variability in temperature, thermal time constant, voltage gradient, etc. that it's best to measure change than absolute value. I'm a fan of 0deltaV termination with timer and temperature fail-safe for NiMH cells. For NiMH, that's a problem. Trickle charging an NiMH battery makes the drop in terminal voltage very difficult to see. Agreed. Trickle charging is for sissies. ;-) And only makes sense when you have no reasonable termination system...and then, it still makes no sense. That's also my complaint about the C9000. If your cells have slightly high internal resistance, it refuses to charge them at rated current. If you crank the current down till they charge, you risk failure of charge termination. It's in the low millivolt region. I think (not sure) that Maha recommends something like 0.5C charge on their Eneloop just so that deltaV can be detected. Here's a hint, without detail: http://www.flickr.com/groups/strobist/discuss/72157625332323687/ "manufacturers recommend 0.5C to 1C to (1A to 2A on eneloop) to make negative delta voltage detection more "detectable"." I did some testing of temperature detections on individual NiCd cells when I was doing my ultra-rapid charging experiments. I stuck 8 thermistors on various parts of the cell, and proceeded to intentionally overcharge it. The mass of the cell was sufficiently high that the thermal lag was substantial. That won't make much difference for a slow charge, but can easily be catastrophic with ultra-rapid charge, where seconds count. The best sensor location appeared to be in the middle of the cell. Unfortunately, the plastic or paper wrap around the battery is a good thermal insulator. I had to scrape off the coating and connect directly to the metal case. |
#15
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
Jeff Liebermann wrote:
[...] http://www.buchmann.ca/article18-page1.asp [..] Overcharge could occur even though the NiMH battery feels cool to the touch." Where does the excess energy go if it doesn't finish up as heat in the battery? -- ~ Adrian Tuddenham ~ (Remove the ".invalid"s and add ".co.uk" to reply) www.poppyrecords.co.uk |
#16
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On 12/26/2012 3:27 AM, Adrian Tuddenham wrote:
Jeff wrote: [...] http://www.buchmann.ca/article18-page1.asp [..] Overcharge could occur even though the NiMH battery feels cool to the touch." Where does the excess energy go if it doesn't finish up as heat in the battery? Cool to the touch is not the same as exactly at ambient. |
#17
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Best Method to Slow Charge NiMH Batteries
On Wed, 26 Dec 2012 11:27:56 +0000,
lid (Adrian Tuddenham) wrote: Jeff Liebermann wrote: [...] http://www.buchmann.ca/article18-page1.asp [..] Overcharge could occur even though the NiMH battery feels cool to the touch." Where does the excess energy go if it doesn't finish up as heat in the battery? Thermal lag. It takes a while for the battery to become warm to the touch. If the -deltaV sensor says it's done at a conservative point, you'll never feel the heat (which is a good thing). With a fast charge, you could easily overcharge before the internal heating has time to make it to the surface. We're also not talking about much heat. 0.5C charge into 1.35V is only about 1.4 watts. Heating shouldn't be a problem with a slow charge, which might simply radiate the heat before it gets excessively too hot. Extra credit for manufacturers that include small fans in their chargers which insures that the temperature sensors don't work. However, I've never seen a cold and overcharged battery. With reasonably fast charging, the batteries I've played with all get warm or hot as they approach full charge. The battery manufacturers are making sure that the battery gets warm by playing with the ma-hr capacity number. For example, a 2300 ma-hr NiMH battery, may achieve the rated capacity at 0.1C discharge. However at 1C discharge, it's only good for 2000 ma-hr. Less for higher discharge rates. Old batteries also lose surface area, and therefore lose capacity. Trying to charge a moving target like with a fixed timer charger, is just not going to work. It will overcharge. Now, if you really want entertainment value, try putting a sealed zip-lock plastic bag over the charger and give it a nice hefty overcharge. The bag will inflate slightly with even a modest overcharge. Where does the gas come from? It's from blowing the vent seal on the battery and boiling off electrolyte. Note the pressure curve: http://www.buchmann.ca/Article18_files/Figure1.gif The safety vent opens at about 130 psi and stays open forever. The gas is mostly hydrogen, so you probably make a small bang. You can sometimes see condensed electrolyte on the bag surface. The potassium hydroxide can be detected with ph test strips. Do that a few times and there will be little electrolyte left in the battery. I "rejuvenated" at few NiCd cells by filing off a corner of the cell, and using a hypodermic to inject KOH back into the cell. I'm not certain how well it worked, because there may have been other damage inside, but it worked well enough to run an HT for a few months. I guess that's one advantage to 0.1C charging. It will never get hot enough to vent. -- Jeff Liebermann 150 Felker St #D http://www.LearnByDestroying.com Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558 |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
NiMh batteries | UK diy | |||
NiMH batteries in a 2-way radio | Electronics Repair | |||
AA NiMh batteries | UK diy | |||
bit OT but are NH batteries the same as NiMh ?? | UK diy | |||
NiMH batteries | UK diy |