Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Electronics Repair (sci.electronics.repair) Discussion of repairing electronic equipment. Topics include requests for assistance, where to obtain servicing information and parts, techniques for diagnosis and repair, and annecdotes about success, failures and problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
Hi,
I am going to be vague for this first post.Please excuse me. A number of folks have very recently purchased defective AV receivers from a certain well known manufacturer. Since the manufacturer does not publicly disclose the cause of the symptoms owners are experiencing, much speculation has occurred as to the cause. The speculation I refer to is on a thread in a forum for AV enthusiasts. Since the repair involves a 40 pin ribbon cable and its associated connectors, one poster claims to have inside information as to the cause of the failure of these components. His claim is that there was an acidic gel applied to the PCB and connectors that corrodes the cable and connectors. Not knowing of any gel that could be left on a finished product's PCBs, especially in the area of a connector, I question this claim. So, my question is, does anyone have any explanation as to how or why or what this gel might be? And is it a feasible claim that there was such a gel? To me, the claim is extraordinary and leaves me with more questions than answers. Thanx in advance. Any help would be much appreciated. |
#2
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
On Sun, 10 Jul 2011 05:50:34 -0700 (PDT), Braunbear
wrote: Hi, I am going to be vague for this first post.Please excuse me. A number of folks have very recently purchased defective AV receivers from a certain well known manufacturer. Since the manufacturer does not publicly disclose the cause of the symptoms owners are experiencing, much speculation has occurred as to the cause. The speculation I refer to is on a thread in a forum for AV enthusiasts. Since the repair involves a 40 pin ribbon cable and its associated connectors, one poster claims to have inside information as to the cause of the failure of these components. His claim is that there was an acidic gel applied to the PCB and connectors that corrodes the cable and connectors. Not knowing of any gel that could be left on a finished product's PCBs, especially in the area of a connector, I question this claim. So, my question is, does anyone have any explanation as to how or why or what this gel might be? And is it a feasible claim that there was such a gel? To me, the claim is extraordinary and leaves me with more questions than answers. Thanx in advance. Any help would be much appreciated. Flux residue? -- Rich Webb Norfolk, VA |
#3
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
Braunbear wrote in message
... Hi, I am going to be vague for this first post.Please excuse me. A number of folks have very recently purchased defective AV receivers from a certain well known manufacturer. Since the manufacturer does not publicly disclose the cause of the symptoms owners are experiencing, much speculation has occurred as to the cause. The speculation I refer to is on a thread in a forum for AV enthusiasts. Since the repair involves a 40 pin ribbon cable and its associated connectors, one poster claims to have inside information as to the cause of the failure of these components. His claim is that there was an acidic gel applied to the PCB and connectors that corrodes the cable and connectors. Not knowing of any gel that could be left on a finished product's PCBs, especially in the area of a connector, I question this claim. So, my question is, does anyone have any explanation as to how or why or what this gel might be? And is it a feasible claim that there was such a gel? To me, the claim is extraordinary and leaves me with more questions than answers. Thanx in advance. Any help would be much appreciated. Flux associated with PbF is my guess |
#4
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
"Braunbear" I am going to be vague for this first post. ** Unsupported claims made on the net should be automatically treated as bull****. Unsupported claims from anonymous persons should automatically be treated as lies. The onus of proof always lies with the person making any claim - not on others to disprove. Liars thrive on anonymity, ambiguity and that no-one calls their bluff. Take this to heart and it will utterly change your life. ..... Phil |
#5
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
On Jul 10, 10:21*am, "N_Cook" wrote:
Braunbear wrote in message ... Hi, I am going to be vague for this first post.Please excuse me. A number of folks have very recently purchased defective AV receivers from a certain well known manufacturer. Since the manufacturer does not publicly disclose the cause of the symptoms owners are experiencing, much speculation has occurred as to the cause. The speculation I refer to is on a thread in a forum for AV enthusiasts. Since the repair involves a 40 pin ribbon cable and its associated connectors, one poster claims to have inside information as to the cause of the failure of these components. His claim is that there was an acidic gel applied to the PCB and connectors that corrodes the cable and connectors. Not knowing of any gel that could be left on a finished product's PCBs, especially in the area of a connector, I question this claim. So, my question is, does anyone have any explanation as to how or why or what this gel might be? And is it a feasible claim that there was such a gel? To me, the claim is extraordinary and leaves me with more questions than answers. Thanx in advance. Any help would be much appreciated. Flux associated with PbF is my guess Wouldn't the flux have been washed off by the time the board had been assembled in the finished product. Certainly before the conformal coating. no? Have you seen flux residue before in such situations? |
#6
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
In article ,
Rich Webb wrote: On Sun, 10 Jul 2011 05:50:34 -0700 (PDT), Braunbear wrote: Hi, I am going to be vague for this first post.Please excuse me. A number of folks have very recently purchased defective AV receivers from a certain well known manufacturer. Since the manufacturer does not publicly disclose the cause of the symptoms owners are experiencing, much speculation has occurred as to the cause. The speculation I refer to is on a thread in a forum for AV enthusiasts. Since the repair involves a 40 pin ribbon cable and its associated connectors, one poster claims to have inside information as to the cause of the failure of these components. His claim is that there was an acidic gel applied to the PCB and connectors that corrodes the cable and connectors. Not knowing of any gel that could be left on a finished product's PCBs, especially in the area of a connector, I question this claim. So, my question is, does anyone have any explanation as to how or why or what this gel might be? And is it a feasible claim that there was such a gel? To me, the claim is extraordinary and leaves me with more questions than answers. Thanx in advance. Any help would be much appreciated. Flux residue? Could be, water-soluble flux is corrosive, and many manufacturers switched to it when CFCs were banned. Board populated, soldered, washed, then connectors added by hand and not washed. |
#7
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
On Jul 10, 12:06*pm, Smitty Two wrote:
In article , *Rich Webb wrote: On Sun, 10 Jul 2011 05:50:34 -0700 (PDT), Braunbear wrote: Hi, I am going to be vague for this first post.Please excuse me. A number of folks have very recently purchased defective AV receivers from a certain well known manufacturer. Since the manufacturer does not publicly disclose the cause of the symptoms owners are experiencing, much speculation has occurred as to the cause. The speculation I refer to is on a thread in a forum for AV enthusiasts. Since the repair involves a 40 pin ribbon cable and its associated connectors, one poster claims to have inside information as to the cause of the failure of these components. His claim is that there was an acidic gel applied to the PCB and connectors that corrodes the cable and connectors. Not knowing of any gel that could be left on a finished product's PCBs, especially in the area of a connector, I question this claim. So, my question is, does anyone have any explanation as to how or why or what this gel might be? And is it a feasible claim that there was such a gel? To me, the claim is extraordinary and leaves me with more questions than answers. Thanx in advance. Any help would be much appreciated. Flux residue? Could be, water-soluble flux is corrosive, and many manufacturers switched to it when CFCs were banned. Board populated, soldered, washed, then connectors added by hand and not washed. Thanx everyone for the quick responses. I appreciate the effort. Well, i learned that there is no gel, other than possible flux residue. I opened my unit and discovered no gel or residue, but I do have the symptoms of the defect. I just wish the manufacturer would be more forthcoming and let us know what went wrong as the symptoms are intermittent and the fix did not work for me. My cable and connectors were replaced. Not to mention, this happened to so many units across the entire model lineup that its hard to imagine they were all not washed properly. Thanx again. |
#8
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
On Sun, 10 Jul 2011 09:20:03 -0700 (PDT), Braunbear
wrote: On Jul 10, 12:06*pm, Smitty Two wrote: In article , *Rich Webb wrote: On Sun, 10 Jul 2011 05:50:34 -0700 (PDT), Braunbear wrote: Hi, I am going to be vague for this first post.Please excuse me. A number of folks have very recently purchased defective AV receivers from a certain well known manufacturer. Since the manufacturer does not publicly disclose the cause of the symptoms owners are experiencing, much speculation has occurred as to the cause. The speculation I refer to is on a thread in a forum for AV enthusiasts. Since the repair involves a 40 pin ribbon cable and its associated connectors, one poster claims to have inside information as to the cause of the failure of these components. His claim is that there was an acidic gel applied to the PCB and connectors that corrodes the cable and connectors. Not knowing of any gel that could be left on a finished product's PCBs, especially in the area of a connector, I question this claim. So, my question is, does anyone have any explanation as to how or why or what this gel might be? And is it a feasible claim that there was such a gel? To me, the claim is extraordinary and leaves me with more questions than answers. Thanx in advance. Any help would be much appreciated. Flux residue? Could be, water-soluble flux is corrosive, and many manufacturers switched to it when CFCs were banned. Board populated, soldered, washed, then connectors added by hand and not washed. Thanx everyone for the quick responses. I appreciate the effort. Well, i learned that there is no gel, other than possible flux residue. I opened my unit and discovered no gel or residue, but I do have the symptoms of the defect. I just wish the manufacturer would be more forthcoming and let us know what went wrong as the symptoms are intermittent and the fix did not work for me. My cable and connectors were replaced. Not to mention, this happened to so many units across the entire model lineup that its hard to imagine they were all not washed properly. Thanx again. What I've gleaned is that the switch to Pb-free lead (no pun intended) manufacturers to trying several different solder formulations and then more permutations on top of that to find a workable flux. I'd imagine that some of the attempts worked out less well than others. I'm keeping my tub of Kester 44. ;-) -- Rich Webb Norfolk, VA |
#9
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
Braunbear wrote: On Jul 10, 12:06 pm, Smitty Two wrote: In article , Rich Webb wrote: On Sun, 10 Jul 2011 05:50:34 -0700 (PDT), Braunbear wrote: Hi, I am going to be vague for this first post.Please excuse me. A number of folks have very recently purchased defective AV receivers from a certain well known manufacturer. Since the manufacturer does not publicly disclose the cause of the symptoms owners are experiencing, much speculation has occurred as to the cause. The speculation I refer to is on a thread in a forum for AV enthusiasts. Since the repair involves a 40 pin ribbon cable and its associated connectors, one poster claims to have inside information as to the cause of the failure of these components. His claim is that there was an acidic gel applied to the PCB and connectors that corrodes the cable and connectors. Not knowing of any gel that could be left on a finished product's PCBs, especially in the area of a connector, I question this claim. So, my question is, does anyone have any explanation as to how or why or what this gel might be? And is it a feasible claim that there was such a gel? To me, the claim is extraordinary and leaves me with more questions than answers. Thanx in advance. Any help would be much appreciated. Flux residue? Could be, water-soluble flux is corrosive, and many manufacturers switched to it when CFCs were banned. Board populated, soldered, washed, then connectors added by hand and not washed. Thanx everyone for the quick responses. I appreciate the effort. Well, i learned that there is no gel, other than possible flux residue. I opened my unit and discovered no gel or residue, but I do have the symptoms of the defect. I just wish the manufacturer would be more forthcoming and let us know what went wrong as the symptoms are intermittent and the fix did not work for me. My cable and connectors were replaced. Not to mention, this happened to so many units across the entire model lineup that its hard to imagine they were all not washed properly. Thanx again. Actually, they may have missed that step on the entire product run, which is why they don't want to say anything. Cleaning a PCB cost money, and slows production. The bean counters cut every corner they can, and some they can't. It sounds like it's time for a 'Class Action Lawsuit'. -- It's easy to think outside the box, when you have a cutting torch. |
#10
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
That's not true.
-- Cheers, WB .............. "Phil Allison" wrote in message ... ** Unsupported claims made on the net should be automatically treated as bull****. Unsupported claims from anonymous persons should automatically be treated as lies. The onus of proof always lies with the person making any claim - not on others to disprove. Liars thrive on anonymity, ambiguity and that no-one calls their bluff. Take this to heart and it will utterly change your life. .... Phil |
#11
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
In article ,
Rich Webb wrote: What I've gleaned is that the switch to Pb-free lead (no pun intended) manufacturers to ... Homonyms messing with you again? Led to another typo? Damn that English language. |
#12
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Gel on finished PCB?
"Braunbear" wrote in message ... Thanx everyone for the quick responses. I appreciate the effort. Well, i learned that there is no gel, other than possible flux residue. I opened my unit and discovered no gel or residue, but I do have the symptoms of the defect. I just wish the manufacturer would be more forthcoming and let us know what went wrong as the symptoms are intermittent and the fix did not work for me. My cable and connectors were replaced. Not to mention, this happened to so many units across the entire model lineup that its hard to imagine they were all not washed properly. Thanx again. Well since the 'well known manufacture' is a secret, how do you expect to get a valid answer? Get serious, what make and model are you talking about? |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Finished something... | Metalworking | |||
How Do You Know When It's Finished | Woodworking | |||
It's finished | Woodworking Plans and Photos | |||
Finished! | UK diy | |||
New shop open, my first workbench is finished, just not finished... | Woodworking |