Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
router table or shaper
I have been using a Delta shaper/router for several years and it has
served me well. I now need to upgrade since I have started to use a lot of 6/4 and 8/4 materials and the Delta is only a 1/2 HP. I use router bits exclusively now and doubt that I will need shaper heads in the future. Which ever I get I will also get a power feeder for it. The router or shaper will be installed in the right side of my TS which has a 50" fence and uses a 1.5 HP dust collector. I am looking at the Grizzly 1 1/2 HP shaper or getting another ( my fourth) Hitachi 12V router, 3 1/4 HP, variable speed, soft start etc. and if I go with the router it will be used exclusively on the table. I run a one man shop and weekly average use of shaper/router will be about 1 hour Grizzly pros no time spent building table cons $200 more than a router and materials but I won't spend several days building table. 1 1/2 HP as opposed to 3 1/4HP Comments or suggestions. TIA -- Art Ransom Lancaster , Texas www.turningaround.org |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
If you aren't going to use a large (5") panel raiser, the router is a fine
deal. It's better on small stuff.. I love the big panel raiser, but it really needs 3 HP.. The wider raiser lends considerable class to doors, but you may be able to accomplish the same with vertical panel raising bits. Wilson "Art Ransom" wrote in message ... I have been using a Delta shaper/router for several years and it has served me well. I now need to upgrade since I have started to use a lot of 6/4 and 8/4 materials and the Delta is only a 1/2 HP. I use router bits exclusively now and doubt that I will need shaper heads in the future. Which ever I get I will also get a power feeder for it. The router or shaper will be installed in the right side of my TS which has a 50" fence and uses a 1.5 HP dust collector. I am looking at the Grizzly 1 1/2 HP shaper or getting another ( my fourth) Hitachi 12V router, 3 1/4 HP, variable speed, soft start etc. and if I go with the router it will be used exclusively on the table. I run a one man shop and weekly average use of shaper/router will be about 1 hour Grizzly pros no time spent building table cons $200 more than a router and materials but I won't spend several days building table. 1 1/2 HP as opposed to 3 1/4HP Comments or suggestions. TIA -- Art Ransom Lancaster , Texas www.turningaround.org |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Art,
I have the Griz 1.5 HP shaper for about 5 years. I got it mainly because I figured it would cost the same or more for a good router table. IIRC I paid around $400. Got the extension wing and the router spindle attachment at the same time - so I can use any router bit with the shaper. The only disadvantage is that the shaper has only 2 speeds (12K & 9K I think). Sometimes that's a little slow for a router bit. It is great for raised panels using one of those 3/4 bore 3 wing bits (I use an MLCS for around $70). Another nice feature is the raise/lower handle & lock - similar to a TS. Also, it is pretty hefty and seems to have plenty of power for my needs. OTOH, I have also been toying with the idea of mounting an extra router that I don't use much on my TS too. Just to have it available for smaller jobs or when I don't want to have to switch out the shaper spindle for the router spindle. A downside to shaper bits is their cost. I only have about a half dozen shaper bits - the cope/stick & panel bits are used most of the time. I would definitely buy it again if I were making the same decision today. Lou In article , Art Ransom wrote: I have been using a Delta shaper/router for several years and it has served me well. I now need to upgrade since I have started to use a lot of 6/4 and 8/4 materials and the Delta is only a 1/2 HP. I use router bits exclusively now and doubt that I will need shaper heads in the future. Which ever I get I will also get a power feeder for it. The router or shaper will be installed in the right side of my TS which has a 50" fence and uses a 1.5 HP dust collector. I am looking at the Grizzly 1 1/2 HP shaper or getting another ( my fourth) Hitachi 12V router, 3 1/4 HP, variable speed, soft start etc. and if I go with the router it will be used exclusively on the table. I run a one man shop and weekly average use of shaper/router will be about 1 hour Grizzly pros no time spent building table cons $200 more than a router and materials but I won't spend several days building table. 1 1/2 HP as opposed to 3 1/4HP Comments or suggestions. TIA |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
"Art Ransom" wrote: [snipperized for brevity] Grizzly pros no time spent building table cons $200 more than a router and materials but I won't spend several days building table. 1 1/2 HP as opposed to 3 1/4HP Comments or suggestions. TIA Apples and oranges. 1 1/2 HP of induction motor vs 3 1/4 HP for a universal motor...at 10.000 RPM with a large panel raising cutter..the shaper will seem so much stronger than 1-1/2HP. The shaper will work its butt off all day. The Hitachi (I own a couple) will be working its ballbearings off. The shaper heads/cutters cost a lot more money if you're talking carbide. The shaper set-up is a lot more complex/involved. The shaper speed change usually involves re-tightening of the belt(s). The shaper is much quieter. I don't know about the Grizzly, but a lot of shapers can take a chuck for 1/2" router bits, so the investment you have won't go to waste. But... if you're going to lean into it with a hunk of 8/4 oak... a 1-1/2 HP shaper may not be adequate either. A router table is a cheap and dirty but will not do a shaper's job over the long haul. IMHO |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Router table - Bench dog or Rockler? | Woodworking | |||
Help with router table | Woodworking | |||
Plunge or non-plunge router better under table? | Woodworking | |||
General International Table Saw Dimensions | Woodworking | |||
Just finished my new router table | Woodworking |