Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Buying A Table Saw
I have about $
I have about $500. to $600. to blow on a table saw I was at the local HD and saw a RIDGID 10 In. Cast Iron Table Saw Model TS3650 did some research on the web sounds like a nice unit. I was woundering if you all know of a better one for the money. It will be in a stationary place. Thanks |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
The Patt's wrote:
I have about $ I have one. It depends on what you need. The table with iron wings is very nice. The 36" fence is great for a mid price contractor saw. The herculift works well. The motor is adequate. It cuts well enough. The downside: A 2.5" dust port, not a 4", ligher trunions, service and parts issues are not very good, the fence is quite light (will it survive a decade of heavy use?), 3rd party add ons are harder to find, etc. All in all, for $550 or so it is a fine saw if you are not a heavy user and can live with the minor problems. I am not sure that there are "better" ones. The Jet has advantages, as does the Delta but they cost more and have shorter fences. Griz is nice as well and a bargain. My prediction: If you but it you will probable be satisfied but will not really love it. I have about $500. to $600. to blow on a table saw I was at the local HD and saw a RIDGID 10 In. Cast Iron Table Saw Model TS3650 did some research on the web sounds like a nice unit. I was woundering if you all know of a better one for the money. It will be in a stationary place. Thanks |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
On Sun, 19 Dec 2004 18:27:56 -0500, "The Patt's"
wrote: I have about $500. to $600. to blow on a table saw I was at the local HD and saw a RIDGID 10 In. Cast Iron Table Saw Model TS3650 did some research on Personally, I'd see if I could find a deal on a Delta Contractors saw. I think you will find it to be a little more beefy and while the fence could be better you can always add a better fence at a later date. You should be able to get very close to the $ 600 figure. Mike |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
The Patt's wrote:
I have about $500. to $600. to blow on a table saw I was at the local HD and saw a RIDGID 10 In. Cast Iron Table Saw Model TS3650 did some research on the web sounds like a nice unit. I was woundering if you all know of a better one for the money. It will be in a stationary place. Thanks Lowe's has the Jet JWTS-10JF for $598, less 20% for a pre-tax price of $478. Factor in the $100 Lowe's gift card rebate on top of the 20% discount and you're under $400. I don't know how it compares to the RIGID but the price sounds good to me. Al |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
You guys go on and on about the "RIDGID" CRAP!!! I advise anyone
wanting to purchase ANY tool to do their homework first. Ridgid has a forum on thier website. READ THE REVIEWS!!! Most people outside the powertool industry don't realize that Ridgid "powertools" are NOT owned or operated by the Ridgid pipe tool company. Ridgid powertools are imported (from the lowest bidder in CHINA) by a company by the name of TTI. TTI leases the Ridgid name from the pipe tool company. Check out the local service. This thing is a piece of machinery just like a car. It will eventually fail. When it does, where will you get it fixed and how long will it take to get it fixed? The last thing you need is to be in the middle of a job and have your tool crap out on you and the repair guy tells you it's going to be a MINIMUM of 3 MONTHS before he even looks at it. This is the case here in New Orleans where there is only one repair shop for everything south of Baton Rouge. He's in no hurry to get your tool done because Home Depot only reimburses warranty claims to authorized service centers ONCE A YEAR!!! All that aside, Ridgid and Ryobi are HOME DEPOT ONLY TOOLS!!! Home Depot has an exclusive market for these tools. You can't go to the local tool house and compair prices....THEY DON'T HAVE THE TOOL!!! Home Depot sells the "select" tools from the major manufacturers i.e. DeWalt, Makita, Milwaukee, Porter Cable using a 6% markup. This I know because I sell tools and I see the price lists. NO BUSINESS CAN OPERATE ON A 6% MARKUP!! Where do you think they make their money? On the Ridgid, Ryobi, Work-Force tools, the $6.82 3/4" shackels, the $1.26 O-rings for your faucets. Do what you want with your money, but be advised, Home Depot and Lowes and all the "Big Box" stores aren't there for you to save money. They're there to make money. And, they're making it hand over fist at the expense of the un-educated and uninformed public. On Sun, 19 Dec 2004 18:27:56 -0500, "The Patt's" wrote: I have about $ I have about $500. to $600. to blow on a table saw I was at the local HD and saw a RIDGID 10 In. Cast Iron Table Saw Model TS3650 did some research on the web sounds like a nice unit. I was woundering if you all know of a better one for the money. It will be in a stationary place. Thanks |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
duh
"Usenet" wrote in message ... Y ou guys go on and on about the "RIDGID" CRAP!!! I advise anyone wanting to purchase ANY tool to do their homework first. Ridgid has a forum on thier website. READ THE REVIEWS!!! Most people outside the powertool industry don't realize that Ridgid "powertools" are NOT owned or operated by the Ridgid pipe tool company. Ridgid powertools are imported (from the lowest bidder in CHINA) by a company by the name of TTI. TTI leases the Ridgid name from the pipe tool company. Check out the local service. This thing is a piece of machinery just like a car. It will eventually fail. When it does, where will you get it fixed and how long will it take to get it fixed? The last thing you need is to be in the middle of a job and have your tool crap out on you and the repair guy tells you it's going to be a MINIMUM of 3 MONTHS before he even looks at it. This is the case here in New Orleans where there is only one repair shop for everything south of Baton Rouge. He's in no hurry to get your tool done because Home Depot only reimburses warranty claims to authorized service centers ONCE A YEAR!!! All that aside, Ridgid and Ryobi are HOME DEPOT ONLY TOOLS!!! Home Depot has an exclusive market for these tools. You can't go to the local tool house and compair prices....THEY DON'T HAVE THE TOOL!!! Home Depot sells the "select" tools from the major manufacturers i.e. DeWalt, Makita, Milwaukee, Porter Cable using a 6% markup. This I know because I sell tools and I see the price lists. NO BUSINESS CAN OPERATE ON A 6% MARKUP!! Where do you think they make their money? On the Ridgid, Ryobi, Work-Force tools, the $6.82 3/4" shackels, the $1.26 O-rings for your faucets. Do what you want with your money, but be advised, Home Depot and Lowes and all the "Big Box" stores aren't there for you to save money. They're there to make money. And, they're making it hand over fist at the expense of the un-educated and uninformed public. On Sun, 19 Dec 2004 18:27:56 -0500, "The Patt's" wrote: I have about $ I have about $500. to $600. to blow on a table saw I was at the local HD and saw a RIDGID 10 In. Cast Iron Table Saw Model TS3650 did some research on the web sounds like a nice unit. I was woundering if you all know of a better one for the money. It will be in a stationary place. Thanks |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
On Sun, 19 Dec 2004 18:27:56 -0500, "The Patt's"
vaguely proposed a theory .......and in reply I say!: remove ns from my header address to reply via email He leaps! Is this your first table saw? If so, do you really need one? Serious question. There are a few people here who started to post agreement. I have about $500. to $600. to blow on a table saw I was at the local HD and saw a RIDGID 10 In. Cast Iron Table Saw Model TS3650 did some research on the web sounds like a nice unit. I was woundering if you all know of a better one for the money. It will be in a stationary place. Thanks |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Usenet babbles:
snip of lotsa nearly accurate stuff. You can't go to the local tool house and compair prices....THEY DON'T HAVE THE TOOL!!! Home Depot sells the "select" tools from the major manufacturers i.e. DeWalt, Makita, Milwaukee, Porter Cable using a 6% markup. This I know because I sell tools and I see the price lists. Yeah. You see YOUR price lists and think they're the be-all and end-all. o what you want with your money, but be advised, Home Depot and Lowes and all the "Big Box" stores aren't there for you to save money. They're there to make money. And, they're making it hand over fist at the expense of the un-educated and uninformed public. But you're there JUST to save the public money? No business is going to last if it doesn't make money. Even little one man stores have to feed, clothe and house the owner, so there to make money. Charlie Self "One of the common denominators I have found is that expectations rise above that which is expected." George W. Bush |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Usenet wrote:
Home Depot sells the "select" tools from the major manufacturers i.e. DeWalt, Makita, Milwaukee, Porter Cable using a 6% markup. This I know because I sell tools and I see the price lists. How come the two little guys I shop at beat HD on this stuff every day? Do these store owners live in tents, out back? Are they registered as a 501(C) charity? Do the store employees donate time? No! G You need a new price list. Barry |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Barry,
I never said that Home Depot sells everything at a 6% markup. As for the two tool houses you frequent, no, their employees (the few they have) don't donate their time. The owners don't live in tents. And they are not charities. I never implied that they were. I do, however, have a few questions for you. Where do you do your comparison shopping on Ridgid and Ryobi? What advantage would any company have in selling their product to only one distributor? If Home Depot is the only retailer of Ridgid and Ryobi what would be the purpose in selling those brands at a 6% markup? Are you a contractor? Do you sell tools? Do you work for Home Depot? Do you work for TTI? Do you work for Ridgid, Ryobi, or Milwaukee? How many different models of the major manufacturers do your 2 little guys have? How many tools do your 2 little guys have that Home Depot doesn't have? What other services do your 2 little guys offer that Home Depot Doesn't offer? Look, people, I'm not here trying to get you to buy any particular brand of tool. Ridgid, Ryobi, Craftsman, Chicago Electric, Emmerson, and any of these other cheaply made power tools have their place. That is, in the hands of homeowners and not in the hands of contractors and serious woodworkers. I really believe that Home Depot doesn't care one bit how much they rip off the american public. I know (and the knowledge is out there) these lesser, cheaply made tools (ESPECIALLY Ridgid) are in some cases being posed as equal in if not superior in quality to the tools put out by the major manufacturers. Ridgid power tools are of the same caliber as CHEAP Black and Decker tools with one exception.... Black and Decker knows their $39.00 circular saw is a $39.00 circular saw and they sell it as such. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
|
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Usenet wrote:
Where do you do your comparison shopping on Ridgid and Ryobi? I don't. I compare them on a tool by tool basis to other brands. So far I've bought one tool, a Ridgid jointer. The jointer served we well, and I sold to another person here on the 'wreck, after buying a DJ-20 from on of my "little guys" for $1099. What advantage would any company have in selling their product to only one distributor? Why would I care? If Home Depot is the only retailer of Ridgid and Ryobi what would be the purpose in selling those brands at a 6% markup? There isn't any. I understood your post to say that HD was selling DeWalt, PC, etc... at a 6% markup. How many different models of the major manufacturers do your 2 little guys have? Many! See for yourself: http://www.coastaltool.com/ http://www.toolsplus.com/ In store prices are often lower than those on the sites. I'm not the only 'wrecker who patronizes these guys. FWIW, both are across the street from HD stores. How many tools do your 2 little guys have that Home Depot doesn't have? Also many! What other services do your 2 little guys offer that Home Depot Doesn't offer? Only web service and direction to a tool repair shop for out of warranty repairs. I really believe that Home Depot doesn't care one bit how much they rip off the american public. I know (and the knowledge is out there) these lesser, cheaply made tools (ESPECIALLY Ridgid) are in some cases being posed as equal in if not superior in quality to the tools put out by the major manufacturers. Smart users do homework before they buy, no? I snipped some of your other questions for brevity. Barry |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
On Fri, 14 Jan 2005 20:36:22 GMT, B a r r y
wrote: Usenet wrote: Where do you do your comparison shopping on Ridgid and Ryobi? I don't. I compare them on a tool by tool basis to other brands. So far I've bought one tool, a Ridgid jointer. The jointer served we well, and I sold to another person here on the 'wreck, after buying a DJ-20 from on of my "little guys" for $1099. What advantage would any company have in selling their product to only one distributor? Why would I care? If Home Depot is the only retailer of Ridgid and Ryobi what would be the purpose in selling those brands at a 6% markup? There isn't any. I understood your post to say that HD was selling DeWalt, PC, etc... at a 6% markup. How many different models of the major manufacturers do your 2 little guys have? Many! See for yourself: http://www.coastaltool.com/ http://www.toolsplus.com/ In store prices are often lower than those on the sites. I'm not the only 'wrecker who patronizes these guys. FWIW, both are across the street from HD stores. How many tools do your 2 little guys have that Home Depot doesn't have? Also many! What other services do your 2 little guys offer that Home Depot Doesn't offer? Only web service and direction to a tool repair shop for out of warranty repairs. I really believe that Home Depot doesn't care one bit how much they rip off the american public. I know (and the knowledge is out there) these lesser, cheaply made tools (ESPECIALLY Ridgid) are in some cases being posed as equal in if not superior in quality to the tools put out by the major manufacturers. Smart users do homework before they buy, no? I snipped some of your other questions for brevity. Barry Thanks Barry for proving my point!!! The other guys don't live in tents or work for free or own a charity. Because they have the other tools and services that HD doesn't. By the way I did notice that you completely avoided my last paragraph in my reply. The HD brand tools (Ridgid and Ryobi) ARE NOT UP TO SNUFF with the major manufacturers. I'm sorry you feel the need to get so defensive about spending your hard earned money on something a REAL tool person thinks is crap. I'm sure you also get defensive when you throw a bar-b-que and have Wal-mart brand pickels that you paid Vlassic prices for and your brother-in-law (who happens to be a chef) picks on you for your ignorance and arrogance. |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
On Fri, 14 Jan 2005 16:48:41 -0600, Usenet
wrote: Thanks Barry for proving my point!!! Unfortunately, I'm totally confused what your point actually is. By the way I did notice that you completely avoided my last paragraph in my reply. Probably because I didn't feel it was relevant in my reply. The HD brand tools (Ridgid and Ryobi) ARE NOT UP TO SNUFF with the major manufacturers. At certain price points, they certainly are, at others they're not. When I bought my one Ridgid tool, a 6" jointer, I felt the $379 price was an decent value. I still do. Ridgid's new 5" ROS is a good looking tool at it's price point. I've never bought a Ryobi tool, as one has yet to fit into my plan. I'm sorry you feel the need to get so defensive about spending your hard earned money on something a REAL tool person thinks is crap. My General 650, DJ-20, X5 band saw, Veritas & Lie Nielsen planes, collection of Bosch and PC routers, PC & Makita sanders, Makita and DeWalt drills, Senco nail guns, Hirsch chisels, Starrett measuring and marking tools, etc... are all crap? You're right, _I DID NOT_ know that. I appreciate the education. Thanks again! Barry |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
On Fri, 14 Jan 2005 23:19:45 GMT, Ba r r y
wrote: On Fri, 14 Jan 2005 16:48:41 -0600, Usenet wrote: Thanks Barry for proving my point!!! Unfortunately, I'm totally confused what your point actually is. By the way I did notice that you completely avoided my last paragraph in my reply. Probably because I didn't feel it was relevant in my reply. The HD brand tools (Ridgid and Ryobi) ARE NOT UP TO SNUFF with the major manufacturers. At certain price points, they certainly are, at others they're not. When I bought my one Ridgid tool, a 6" jointer, I felt the $379 price was an decent value. I still do. Ridgid's new 5" ROS is a good looking tool at it's price point. I've never bought a Ryobi tool, as one has yet to fit into my plan. I'm sorry you feel the need to get so defensive about spending your hard earned money on something a REAL tool person thinks is crap. My General 650, DJ-20, X5 band saw, Veritas & Lie Nielsen planes, collection of Bosch and PC routers, PC & Makita sanders, Makita and DeWalt drills, Senco nail guns, Hirsch chisels, Starrett measuring and marking tools, etc... are all crap? You're right, _I DID NOT_ know that. I appreciate the education. Thanks again! Barry Barry, As a tech. for the past 14 years working for both DeWalt and Makita and repairing ALL major manufacturers tools, and as a professional woodworker, and now as a salesman and repair tech. for a local distributor in the New Orleans area, I think I may have a little more expertise in the power tool industry than you. And again, maybe you shouldn't be so arrogant and so pompas. END OF DISCUSSION!!! |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
"Usenet" wrote in message
END OF DISCUSSION!!! Naaaah ... you just think it is. Question: On your informed crap-o-meter, please rank, in best to worst, the following: B&D, Ridgid, Ryobi power hand tools ... which seem to be favorite the choices of the yuppie housewife in her DIY mode. Reason I ask is that someone fitting that description is asking me, and I don't generally buy those brands (except my older Ridgid planer, which I basically stole, and is still going strong (knock, knock)) Thanks for the public service, cher. ;) -- www.e-woodshop.net Last update: 11/06/04 |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
To the question of margin, Usenet clearly does not understand the
dynamics of a competitive marketplace. Let us assume that Ryobi has no sustainable cost advantage over other manufacturers. The price (margin) that can be charged at retail, therefore, is constrained by the retail prices (margins) of competitive product. Having the exclusive ability to sell a product does allow one to set prices freely without fear of price-shopping on any exact model. Selling that product into a competitive market against more widely-available lines means that unless there is a premium value to the brandname, unlikely in the case of Ryobi, then the profit-maximizing price will be the same as if the product was not sold exclusively by a single retailer. |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Usenet wrote:
As a tech. for the past 14 years working for both DeWalt and Makita and repairing ALL major manufacturers tools, and as a professional woodworker, and now as a salesman and repair tech. for a local distributor in the New Orleans area, I think I may have a little more expertise in the power tool industry than you. I'm sure you do. Therefore, please explain to me how my "little" suppliers, such as Coastal and Tools Plus, are selling ALL Makita, Porter Cable, DeWalt, Delta, Bosch, etc... for lower prices than Home Depot and Lowes, if the big boxes are selling said tools at a 6" markup? You wrote this a few days back: "Home Depot sells the "select" tools from the major manufacturers i.e. DeWalt, Makita, Milwaukee, Porter Cable using a 6% markup. This I know because I sell tools and I see the price lists. NO BUSINESS CAN OPERATE ON A 6% MARKUP!! " Thanks, Barry |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
John Grossbohlin wrote:
.... ... Troy Built filed for bankruptcy reorganization a few years ago because they gave such big price concessions to Home Depot that they were cutting their own throat. What they didn't understand was that not all business is worth having... .... Another example is Rubbermaid which was forced into bankruptcy by their deal w/ WalMart...when WM went to China, Rubbermaid couldn't match price and lost the shelf space--then they could no longer support the ramped-up manufacturing space and there they went... Buy WalMart (and other boxeers) and support the Communist Capitalist Chinese... |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
wrote in message oups.com... To the question of margin, Usenet clearly does not understand the dynamics of a competitive marketplace. Let us assume that Ryobi has no sustainable cost advantage over other manufacturers. The price (margin) that can be charged at retail, therefore, is constrained by the retail prices (margins) of competitive product. Having the exclusive ability to sell a product does allow one to set prices freely without fear of price-shopping on any exact model. Selling that product into a competitive market against more widely-available lines means that unless there is a premium value to the brandname, unlikely in the case of Ryobi, then the profit-maximizing price will be the same as if the product was not sold exclusively by a single retailer. Another issue related to this discussion is the price pressure the big boxes can exert on the manufacturers. While the spread between the big box's retail price and other sellers cost may appear to be trivial (e.g., 5-10%) it is likely the big box extracted price concessions from the manufactuers that yields them a spread of 20% or more. Home Depot and WalMart are two widely cited companies who exert this kind of pressure. One example I'm familiar with due to geographic proximity press and knowing one of the former executives is Troy Built garden equipment. Troy Built filed for bankruptcy reorganization a few years ago because they gave such big price concessions to Home Depot that they were cutting their own throat. What they didn't understand was that not all business is worth having... they were far better off selling through their traditional channels and doing lower volume. As I understand it, doing the higher volume to meet the HD contract demands raised their marginal costs and made them unprofitable. John |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
|
#22
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 17 Jan 2005 19:25:44 GMT, B a r r y
wrote: Usenet wrote: As a tech. for the past 14 years working for both DeWalt and Makita and repairing ALL major manufacturers tools, and as a professional woodworker, and now as a salesman and repair tech. for a local distributor in the New Orleans area, I think I may have a little more expertise in the power tool industry than you. I'm sure you do. Therefore, please explain to me how my "little" suppliers, such as Coastal and Tools Plus, are selling ALL Makita, Porter Cable, DeWalt, Delta, Bosch, etc... for lower prices than Home Depot and Lowes, if the big boxes are selling said tools at a 6" markup? You wrote this a few days back: "Home Depot sells the "select" tools from the major manufacturers i.e. DeWalt, Makita, Milwaukee, Porter Cable using a 6% markup. This I know because I sell tools and I see the price lists. NO BUSINESS CAN OPERATE ON A 6% MARKUP!! " Thanks, Barry Barry, Two old sayings come to mind when it comes to you: 1) You can lead a horse to water but, you can't make him drink. 2) A fool and his money are soon parted. Buy your Ridgid. Your money, not mine. Have fun!! Your friend, USENET |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
Usenet states:
Again, prices are not the issue. The issue here is: WHICH IS THE BETTER BUY? $500.00 SPENT IN RIDGID TOOLS OR $500.00 SPENT (ON EQUAL FUNCTIONING TOOLS) IN TOOLS BY MAKITA, DEWALT OR PORTER CABLE? Well, actually, maybe. The OP was looking for a table saw, something DeWalt and Makita and PC make, but not necessarily in a type the OP wants. And if he does want a job site saw, the Ridgid is actually at least as good as, and in many respects better than, the ones turned out by the above three. Quality is similar. There are more features. It is somewhat easier to use. Price is sensible. When it comes to heavier saws, the DeWalt hybrid is a good one, and comes, stripped, for nearly $900. The complete Ridgid TS3650 is a contractor's saw with a built in mobile base that comes complete for a shade under $600. It is about as good as any contractor's saw out there right now. Are RIDGID and RYOBI comperable tools? RIDGID in price? YES. In quality? NO. I'm not sure what you're stating here. OK. They're comparable in price. Except they're not. And certainly the Ridgid line of table saws differs from the Ryobi line, so one wouldn't expect too great price similarities. Are you stating that Ridgid is lesser in quality than Ryobi? Charlie Self "One of the common denominators I have found is that expectations rise above that which is expected." George W. Bush |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
|
#25
|
|||
|
|||
RIDGID does not have a sustainable COST advantage over the other
manufacturers. RYOBI does I would love to know how Ryobi has a cost advantage over its competitors. I think they sell a lesser product for a lower price. For many, the product works fine and offeres good value, for others it does not. Again, prices are not the issue....$500.00 SPENT... If prices are not the issue, then why is it the key component of your argument? You have presupposed your conclusion in the above statement - ie. the tools are "EQUAL FUNCTIONING" (no need to shout, by the way), and they cost the same, so buy the brandname. The better buy depends on the tool in question - not every Dewalt is a whizbang. Most people outside the powertool industry don't realize that Ridgid "powertools" are NOT owned or operated by the Ridgid pipe tool company. I do not think the general public is even aware of Ridgid as a plumbing toolmaker, and they only see the tool at HD, so they are well aware that it is a housebrand. In fact, this may lead to some cross-branding synergies resulting in a cost advantage, since HD promotes Ridgid and vice versa. One might argue that a company like Delta, which contracts out manufacturing to plants all over, is less and less a brand name that can be relied on as a badge of quality. Plus the fact that Black & Decker has rolled it up, suggests that brand name will mean less and less in the tool market. READ THE REVIEWS!!! Ridgid does well in Fine Woodworking reviews, often garnering the "Best Buy" slot, with the jointer, the bandsaw, and the sander all doing well. Home Depot and Lowes and all the "Big Box" stores (are) making (money) hand over fist at the expense of the un-educated and uninformed public. HD and Lowes have overall profit margins in the 6-7% range, which seems decent, but does not reach the "hand over fist" threshold, IMO. Remember that they constrain one another - they compete head to head, unless you believe that they collude to dupe the foolish masses... .... |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
On 18 Jan 2005 10:32:53 -0800, wrote:
RIDGID does not have a sustainable COST advantage over the other manufacturers. RYOBI does I would love to know how Ryobi has a cost advantage over its competitors. I think they sell a lesser product for a lower price. For many, the product works fine and offeres good value, for others it does not. Again, prices are not the issue....$500.00 SPENT... If prices are not the issue, then why is it the key component of your argument? You have presupposed your conclusion in the above statement - ie. the tools are "EQUAL FUNCTIONING" (no need to shout, by the way), and they cost the same, so buy the brandname. The better buy depends on the tool in question - not every Dewalt is a whizbang. Most people outside the powertool industry don't realize that Ridgid "powertools" are NOT owned or operated by the Ridgid pipe tool company. I do not think the general public is even aware of Ridgid as a plumbing toolmaker, and they only see the tool at HD, so they are well aware that it is a housebrand. In fact, this may lead to some cross-branding synergies resulting in a cost advantage, since HD promotes Ridgid and vice versa. One might argue that a company like Delta, which contracts out manufacturing to plants all over, is less and less a brand name that can be relied on as a badge of quality. Plus the fact that Black & Decker has rolled it up, suggests that brand name will mean less and less in the tool market. READ THE REVIEWS!!! Ridgid does well in Fine Woodworking reviews, often garnering the "Best Buy" slot, with the jointer, the bandsaw, and the sander all doing well. Home Depot and Lowes and all the "Big Box" stores (are) making (money) hand over fist at the expense of the un-educated and uninformed public. HD and Lowes have overall profit margins in the 6-7% range, which seems decent, but does not reach the "hand over fist" threshold, IMO. Remember that they constrain one another - they compete head to head, unless you believe that they collude to dupe the foolish masses... ... Example of a $39.00 circular saw that sells at HD for $119.00 http://www.ridgid.com/CatalogDocs/R3200_301_RSHEET.pdf Example of a $160.00 that HD whores out at $109.00 http://www.makita.com/res_tools/pdf/...wns/5007NB.pdf Please note on each of these the type of bearing on the output shaft. If this is the type of corners that Ridgid is willing to cut on a circular saw, what will they do on a $600.00+ table saw? Again, all you bozos obviously know ecconomics, tool operation, tool sales, tool manufacturers, tool quailty, etc., etc., etc. better than I. You know it so well that you obviously know a GREAT deal when you see one. As I've stated before, your money not mine!!! |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
On Tue, 18 Jan 2005 17:32:15 -0600, Usenet
wrote: On 18 Jan 2005 10:32:53 -0800, wrote: RIDGID does not have a sustainable COST advantage over the other manufacturers. RYOBI does I would love to know how Ryobi has a cost advantage over its competitors. I think they sell a lesser product for a lower price. For many, the product works fine and offeres good value, for others it does not. Again, prices are not the issue....$500.00 SPENT... If prices are not the issue, then why is it the key component of your argument? You have presupposed your conclusion in the above statement - ie. the tools are "EQUAL FUNCTIONING" (no need to shout, by the way), and they cost the same, so buy the brandname. The better buy depends on the tool in question - not every Dewalt is a whizbang. Most people outside the powertool industry don't realize that Ridgid "powertools" are NOT owned or operated by the Ridgid pipe tool company. I do not think the general public is even aware of Ridgid as a plumbing toolmaker, and they only see the tool at HD, so they are well aware that it is a housebrand. In fact, this may lead to some cross-branding synergies resulting in a cost advantage, since HD promotes Ridgid and vice versa. One might argue that a company like Delta, which contracts out manufacturing to plants all over, is less and less a brand name that can be relied on as a badge of quality. Plus the fact that Black & Decker has rolled it up, suggests that brand name will mean less and less in the tool market. READ THE REVIEWS!!! Ridgid does well in Fine Woodworking reviews, often garnering the "Best Buy" slot, with the jointer, the bandsaw, and the sander all doing well. Home Depot and Lowes and all the "Big Box" stores (are) making (money) hand over fist at the expense of the un-educated and uninformed public. HD and Lowes have overall profit margins in the 6-7% range, which seems decent, but does not reach the "hand over fist" threshold, IMO. Remember that they constrain one another - they compete head to head, unless you believe that they collude to dupe the foolish masses... ... Example of a $39.00 circular saw that sells at HD for $119.00 http://www.ridgid.com/CatalogDocs/R3200_301_RSHEET.pdf Example of a $160.00 that HD whores out at $109.00 http://www.makita.com/res_tools/pdf/...wns/5007NB.pdf Please note on each of these the type of bearing on the output shaft. If this is the type of corners that Ridgid is willing to cut on a circular saw, what will they do on a $600.00+ table saw? Again, all you bozos obviously know ecconomics, tool operation, tool sales, tool manufacturers, tool quailty, etc., etc., etc. better than I. You know it so well that you obviously know a GREAT deal when you see one. As I've stated before, your money not mine!!! Also note, there is no parts breakdown on the table saw!! As a repair tech...that tells me something. |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
|
#30
|
|||
|
|||
bozos? BOZOS? Sir, I challenge you to a duel!
The arguments I have made here are not personal, please do not resort to attacks when making your points, address the logic and facts of the argument. Personally I own a range of equipment, from most of the major manufacturers including Festool and Ryobi, each a good value for the purposes to which I shall put them. I was merely addressing factual and logical deficiencies in your missives, not advocating the blind purchase of any particular brand. BTW, you clearly cherry picked a negative thread off the Ridgid site, which looks suspiciously like one you wrote. A cursory scan shows many positive reviews, as well. |
#31
|
|||
|
|||
|
#32
|
|||
|
|||
Usenet writes:
Now, I don't know, but, is there the possibility that somewhere up the corporate chain, one of the parent companies of Home Depot is also the parent company of Ridgid? You got that right. You don't know. My dad always told me not to put all my eggs into one basket. Yet, it's awefully funny that Home Depot is the only distributor of Ridgid and Ryobi tools. One BIG egg. One BIG basket. That's a business decision for Ryobi's parent company, and they seem to like it, so far. Charlie Self "One of the common denominators I have found is that expectations rise above that which is expected." George W. Bush |
#33
|
|||
|
|||
On 18 Jan 2005 16:50:11 -0800,
wrote: bozos? BOZOS? Sir, I challenge you to a duel! Dualing Bozos? Floppy shoes at twenty paces? |
#34
|
|||
|
|||
"Glenna Rose" wrote in message
Watch it there, Buddy! g There's a lot of us "housewives" out there who use woodworking tools (and do it quite successfully). Witness that you left out the "yuppie" part ... a big difference, and the existence of whom can not be denied. It's been my experience that those "housewives" are more discriminating as a whole than are their male counterparts. Most us ladies tend to buy tools, of any kind, more carefully being very aware they will last us for a long, long time. We, more than men, tend to keep the same ol' reliables around for decades so choose more carefully in the beginning. Men, as a rule, tend to want bigger and better to keep up with their buddies. Nothing wrong with that because they buy and manufacturers come up with better (hopefully!) to sell to them and we all benefit. I'm thinking you've perhpas been watching way too many TV commercials. Granted "doofus americanus" (you know, the guy with the constipated look on his face, shaking his fist in the air, forcefully exclaiming "YEAH! whenever some over paid sports figure scores) does exist and is rightly portrayed in many of them these days .. but I seriously doubt the species buys that many tools, and you will find about as many of them here as "yuppie housewifes". There are, of course, exceptions to that, but looking at the wide spectrum, that is the way it is. For an alternate take, Google the countless tool buyng threads wRec down through the years, most of them dripping with "discrmination". -- www.e-woodshop.net Last update: 11/06/04 |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Thinking of buying a Ryobi BTK3100 table saw - any advice out there. | Woodworking | |||
Table saw reviews?? | Woodworking | |||
Building an extension table. | Woodworking |