I am building a 52" x 18" x 2" (actual dimensions) white oak bench for
a small alcove that is surrounded on 3 sides by walls.

To support the bench, I am thinking of using white oak cleats along the 3
supporting sides and screwing up through the cleats into the bench so
that there are no (obviousy) visible fasteners

Would a running 3/4" x 2" cleat along 3 sides of the bench be
sufficient to support the bench under easonable use? (say maximum of
3 adults or 4 children sitting on it).

Assume that the cleats will be screwed into the studs every 16 inches
using a 3 1/2" deck screw. Assume also that 3" deck screws will be
used to screw up through the cleat into the bench.

Thanks

On Jan 17, 10:20*am, blueman wrote:
I am building a 52" x 18" x 2" (actual dimensions) white oak bench for
a small alcove that is surrounded on 3 sides by walls.

To support the bench, I am thinking of using white oak cleats along the 3
supporting sides and screwing up through the cleats into the bench so
that there are no (obviousy) visible fasteners

Would a running 3/4" x 2" cleat along 3 sides of the bench be
sufficient to support the bench under easonable use? (say maximum of
3 adults or 4 children sitting on it).

Assume that the cleats will be screwed into the studs every 16 inches
using a 3 1/2" deck screw. Assume also that 3" deck screws will be
used to screw up through the cleat into the bench.

Thanks

It should easliy hold the weight but *may* sag slightly.

http://www.woodbin.com/calcs/sagulator.htm

I think the sagulator only accounts for shelves supported on the ends
not across the length on one side as you propose.

Running a 3/4 ledger under the bench is a fine idea. No problem with
strength as you describe. Personally I would use small lag bolts into
the studs maybe 5/16" or 3/8". Screw pull-out would be your only
concern here so the lags give more bite. The deck screws won't likely
pull out but a commercial grade approach would use lags.

As far as attachment up to the bench, I would probably use table irons
or other typical attachments like used for a table top. Across the 18"
width you will get some expansion and need to account for that in a
sliding attachment. Plus is seems difficult to screw up through a 3/4
wide board and that puts your screw at the very end and edge of the
bench slab.

You could use pocket screws but that puts the screws even farther
toward the end and edge.

Finally, you only need a little grab into the bench top, just enough
to keep it from sliding or coming loose. Also, I don't think this
would ever sag and in fact I would probably just put a ledger at each
end but having it along the back will make it a littloe more stable.

On Jan 17, 7:20*am, blueman wrote:
I am building a 52" x 18" x 2" (actual dimensions) white oak bench for
a small alcove that is surrounded on 3 sides by walls.

To support the bench, I am thinking of using white oak cleats along the 3
supporting sides and screwing up through the cleats into the bench so
that there are no (obviousy) visible fasteners

Would a running 3/4" x 2" cleat along 3 sides of the bench be
sufficient to support the bench under easonable use? (say maximum of
3 adults or 4 children sitting on it).

Assume that the cleats will be screwed into the studs every 16 inches
using a 3 1/2" deck screw. Assume also that 3" deck screws will be
used to screw up through the cleat into the bench.

Thanks

RayV writes:

On Jan 17, 10:20*am, blueman wrote:
I am building a 52" x 18" x 2" (actual dimensions) white oak bench for
a small alcove that is surrounded on 3 sides by walls.

To support the bench, I am thinking of using white oak cleats along the 3
supporting sides and screwing up through the cleats into the bench so
that there are no (obviousy) visible fasteners

Would a running 3/4" x 2" cleat along 3 sides of the bench be
sufficient to support the bench under easonable use? (say maximum of
3 adults or 4 children sitting on it).

Assume that the cleats will be screwed into the studs every 16 inches
using a 3 1/2" deck screw. Assume also that 3" deck screws will be
used to screw up through the cleat into the bench.

Thanks

It should easliy hold the weight but *may* sag slightly.

http://www.woodbin.com/calcs/sagulator.htm

I think the sagulator only accounts for shelves supported on the ends
not across the length on one side as you propose.

I have used the sagulator before but I don't really know how to use it
when there is support on 3 sides. I would have thought that given that
the bench is only 18" wide and that it is made of 2" thick White Oak
that the sag would be really minimal.

"SonomaProducts.com" writes:
Running a 3/4 ledger under the bench is a fine idea. No problem with
strength as you describe. Personally I would use small lag bolts into
the studs maybe 5/16" or 3/8". Screw pull-out would be your only
concern here so the lags give more bite. The deck screws won't likely
pull out but a commercial grade approach would use lags.

I like that suggestion but my only concern would be whether I could
still countersink the heads given that I have only 3/4" of depth.

As far as attachment up to the bench, I would probably use table irons
or other typical attachments like used for a table top. Across the 18"
width you will get some expansion and need to account for that in a
sliding attachment. Plus is seems difficult to screw up through a 3/4
wide board and that puts your screw at the very end and edge of the
bench slab.

Good point about allowing for expansion and about screwing up through
a 3/4" board.

I am not familiar with the term "table irons" -- I tried googling but
kept getting things like ironing boards and periodic table elements
Can you describe what they are or give me another term that I could
search on?

You could use pocket screws but that puts the screws even farther
toward the end and edge.

Finally, you only need a little grab into the bench top, just enough
to keep it from sliding or coming loose.

I guess my overall preference would be to have the fasteners as hidden
as possible which is why I was initiatlly considering screwing up
through the ledger board (note I can't use anything really thicker
than 3/4" or else it will stand proud of the surrounding door trim).

So given your point that "you only need a little grab", are there
other alternatives to providing a little grab (with room for
expansion/contraction) while being minimally visible?

Thanks,
Jeff

Also, I don't think this
would ever sag and in fact I would probably just put a ledger at each
end but having it along the back will make it a littloe more stable.

That was my hope, but wanted to confirm before I spent the $$$ and
time on building it.

On Jan 17, 7:20*am, blueman wrote:
I am building a 52" x 18" x 2" (actual dimensions) white oak bench for
a small alcove that is surrounded on 3 sides by walls.

To support the bench, I am thinking of using white oak cleats along the 3
supporting sides and screwing up through the cleats into the bench so
that there are no (obviousy) visible fasteners

Would a running 3/4" x 2" cleat along 3 sides of the bench be
sufficient to support the bench under easonable use? (say maximum of
3 adults or 4 children sitting on it).

Assume that the cleats will be screwed into the studs every 16 inches
using a 3 1/2" deck screw. Assume also that 3" deck screws will be
used to screw up through the cleat into the bench.

Thanks

Well with a lag you could do a 1/4" counter bore and the head would
then sit under the surface and still have 1/2 of grab. That's plenty,
but two deck screws at each stud will be just as good I suppose.

Here is a link to what I call table irons. Its an old term from
original Stickley days, maybe outdated now. http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?Offerings_ID=786.
They have an info sheet on how to install. I use a Forstner bit and
make a round rabbit that hangs partly off the side of the table apron
(or ledger in your case). But you can use a squared cut-out just as
well.

If you are worried about sag, the sagulator says that a 500 lb center
load will deflect (sag) 1/16 of an inch.

On Jan 17, 1:01*pm, blueman wrote:
"SonomaProducts.com" writes:
Running a 3/4 ledger under the bench is a fine idea. No problem with
strength as you describe. Personally I would use small lag bolts into
the studs maybe 5/16" or 3/8". Screw pull-out would be your only
concern here so the lags give more bite. The deck screws won't likely
pull out but a commercial grade approach would use lags.

I like that suggestion but my only concern would be whether I could
still countersink the heads given that I have only 3/4" of depth.



As far as attachment up to the bench, I would probably use table irons
or other typical attachments like used for a table top. Across the 18"
width you will get some expansion and need to account for that in a
sliding attachment. Plus is seems difficult to screw up through a 3/4
wide board and that puts your screw at the very end and edge of the
bench slab.

Good point about allowing for expansion and about screwing up through
a 3/4" board.

I am not familiar with the term "table irons" -- I tried googling but
kept getting things like ironing boards and periodic table elements
Can you describe what they are or give me another term that I could
search on?

You could use pocket screws but that puts the screws even farther
toward the end and edge.

Finally, you only need a little grab into the bench top, just enough
to keep it from sliding or coming loose.

I guess my overall preference would be to have the fasteners as hidden
as possible which is why I was initiatlly considering screwing up
through the ledger board (note I can't use anything really thicker
than 3/4" or else it will stand proud of the surrounding door trim).

So given your point that "you only need a little grab", are there
other alternatives to providing a little grab (with room for
expansion/contraction) while being minimally visible?

Thanks,
Jeff

Also, I don't think this
would ever sag and in fact I would probably just put a ledger at each
end but having it along the back will make it a littloe more stable.

That was my hope, but wanted to confirm before I spent the $$$ and
time on building it.



On Jan 17, 7:20*am, blueman wrote:
I am building a 52" x 18" x 2" (actual dimensions) white oak bench for
a small alcove that is surrounded on 3 sides by walls.

To support the bench, I am thinking of using white oak cleats along the 3
supporting sides and screwing up through the cleats into the bench so
that there are no (obviousy) visible fasteners

Would a running 3/4" x 2" cleat along 3 sides of the bench be
sufficient to support the bench under easonable use? (say maximum of
3 adults or 4 children sitting on it).

Assume that the cleats will be screwed into the studs every 16 inches
using a 3 1/2" deck screw. Assume also that 3" deck screws will be
used to screw up through the cleat into the bench.

Thanks- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

"SonomaProducts.com" writes:

Well with a lag you could do a 1/4" counter bore and the head would
then sit under the surface and still have 1/2 of grab. That's plenty,
but two deck screws at each stud will be just as good I suppose.

Here is a link to what I call table irons. Its an old term from
original Stickley days, maybe outdated now. http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?Offerings_ID=786.
They have an info sheet on how to install. I use a Forstner bit and
make a round rabbit that hangs partly off the side of the table apron
(or ledger in your case). But you can use a squared cut-out just as
well.

If you are worried about sag, the sagulator says that a 500 lb center
load will deflect (sag) 1/16 of an inch.


And I believe that is without even taking into account the cleat on
the back wall which should significantly reduce the effective span.