I have an Inca 10" joiner planer with a Tersa cutting head (3 disposable
blades) but Inca is no longer made and the blades are quite expensive per
reversible set at $90. And I have to run the dust collection system to
collect the shavings I make my own lumber for use so I work the
joiner/planer overtime. I thought I would limit the Inca to joining and
the deWalt 735 for planing to dimension.

I would be interested in comments by anyone who uses the DeWalt 735 13"
planer with the chip collector?
Are the extension table a must?
How noisy and how effective is the chip collector that goes with it?
Can this chip collector be used with other tools like bandsaws and table
saws that are normally attached to a large dust collection system?

Thanks

On Thu, 2 Mar 2006 03:18:58 -0600, Ron Koshoshek wrote:
I would be interested in comments by anyone who uses the DeWalt 735 13"
planer with the chip collector? Are the extension table a must? How noisy
and how effective is the chip collector that goes with it? Can this chip
collector be used with other tools like bandsaws and table saws that are
normally attached to a large dust collection system?

I have the DW735. I like it alot. The blade indexing system is nice. Good
thing, the blades seem to nick pretty easily. With blades in good condition,
the finish is excellent. I've had little to no snipe, without the infeed and
outfeed tables. But it is necessary to support the stock. For short pieces,
I've just done that by hand, and used roller stands for longer stock.

This isn't a _truly_ portable planer. I weighs near 100 pounds! I've been
moving it from stowage to my bench and back. I'll build or buy a rolling stand
for it before long.

The planer has an internal blower that does a very good job of ejecting the
chips. The chip collector offered by DeWalt is a passive device, dependent
upon the planer's blower to provide the airflow. It would not be suitable for
use with other machines. I connect my 735 to my central dust collection
system.

--
Art

the chip collector works well connected to a central DC system ( I have an
oneida 3HP) - nothing escapes. HOWEVER: the blades absolutely suck. they're
about %40 a pop to replace, and no matter what you do, they chip and nick
faster than you'll beleive. even soft stuff (like clear pine) will nick the
blades.

I would definitely not consider buying one - theblade situation is that bad.
I'm actually thining about replacing mine 9afer only about 4 months of use
I'm on my 4th or 5th set of blades in a one man shop, with moderate use.
I've heard other folks have had similar problems, and the local tool shop
actually admits that its a design flaw. No help from Dewalt....

My old delta 12" planer (when it died I replaced it with the dewalt) used to
run blades for 6-8 months without a problem, so I'm pretty sure its not my
technique that is killing the blades.....

--YMMV
--JD

I have a 735 and like it. The chip collector is more of a chip extractor and
with out a hose of some type it will send chips across the room with ease. I
don't think it can be changed to support any other device either. The blade are
very easy to change but do seem to dull fast but this is my first planer. You
can't take large cuts out of a wide board so many passes are needed sometimes.
The finish leaving the planer is very good. I don't use the higher CPI much and
find the faster CPI works very good for my needs. The input and output tables
are needed if you don't use Dewalts then you will need something or you will get
snipe. I lift the board slightly going in the raise the board slightly again on
the exit. I don't have any snipe use this method. I have the Dewalts stand and
like it for moving the planner around the shop for longer boards. For my needs
it works fine for now. I may move up to a planner with more HP then the 735 but
for now I can do everything I want now.


"Ron Koshoshek" wrote:

I have an Inca 10" joiner planer with a Tersa cutting head (3 disposable
blades) but Inca is no longer made and the blades are quite expensive per
reversible set at $90. And I have to run the dust collection system to
collect the shavings I make my own lumber for use so I work the
joiner/planer overtime. I thought I would limit the Inca to joining and
the deWalt 735 for planing to dimension.

I would be interested in comments by anyone who uses the DeWalt 735 13"
planer with the chip collector?
Are the extension table a must?
How noisy and how effective is the chip collector that goes with it?
Can this chip collector be used with other tools like bandsaws and table
saws that are normally attached to a large dust collection system?

Thanks

"Ron Koshoshek" wrote in message
...
I have an Inca 10" joiner planer with a Tersa cutting head (3 disposable
blades) but Inca is no longer made and the blades are quite expensive per
reversible set at $90. And I have to run the dust collection system to
collect the shavings I make my own lumber for use so I work the
joiner/planer overtime. I thought I would limit the Inca to joining and
the deWalt 735 for planing to dimension.

I would be interested in comments by anyone who uses the DeWalt 735 13"
planer with the chip collector?
Are the extension table a must?
How noisy and how effective is the chip collector that goes with it?
Can this chip collector be used with other tools like bandsaws and table
saws that are normally attached to a large dust collection system?

Thanks

I think you would, at best, be making a lateral move, If you work you
planer overtime I suspect that you will wear the planer out much sooner than
later, and that is not even taking into consideration the disposable knives.
My recommendation is to step up to a stationary planer with rechargeable
knives.
BTY, MiniMax-USA.com sells Tersa Knives for as little as $15 each in 12"
lengths. Might be worth a try to cut 2" off.

I've had mine now for about 3 months. I've run soft maple, pine,
cedar, and red oak through it with no discernable wear or nicks to the
knives. I know three other guys who claim to have run hundreds of
board feet through before fliping the knives. As for chip ejection -
look out. It pushes harder than your average shop vac pulls. That is
why they have the chip collector bag but the best bet is a 600 cfm or
dust collector. I have noticed a lot of people who have problems with
it eg. chiped knives, binding, broken belts, are not using the machine
properly. I had the machine bind on me once when I didn't see a 1/8"
crown on a piece of 8/4 maple. No one could expect any machine of this
size to take a 3/16" cut. When the machine bound I imediatly switched
it off (the belt will give to save the machine - a good thing) to save
the belt. Reset the depth and with a few extra passes it had done a
beautiful job.

"BD" wrote in message
oups.com...
I've had mine now for about 3 months. I've run soft maple, pine,
cedar, and red oak through it with no discernable wear or nicks to the
knives. I know three other guys who claim to have run hundreds of
board feet through before fliping the knives. As for chip ejection -
look out. It pushes harder than your average shop vac pulls. That is
why they have the chip collector bag but the best bet is a 600 cfm or
dust collector. I have noticed a lot of people who have problems with
it eg. chiped knives, binding, broken belts, are not using the machine
properly. I had the machine bind on me once when I didn't see a 1/8"
crown on a piece of 8/4 maple. No one could expect any machine of this
size to take a 3/16" cut. When the machine bound I imediatly switched
it off (the belt will give to save the machine - a good thing) to save
the belt. Reset the depth and with a few extra passes it had done a
beautiful job.

I had been using a 16 year old Ryobi portable planer until recently. It has
worked just fine for many years but after running only 6 of 45 nine foot
long 6 to 11" wide rough cut Oak boards through I realized that I needed a
bigger planer.
As the OP indicated, he is running the planer overtime. I strongly suspect
that the portables are going to be slow and tedious for rough cut lumber in
large quantities.

Leon wrote:


I think you would, at best, be making a lateral move, If you work you
planer overtime I suspect that you will wear the planer out much sooner than
later, and that is not even taking into consideration the disposable knives.

Reusable, easily replaced knives are the exact reason I'm running my
DW733 into the ground.

I so wish the newer "portables" stayed with them. While I have no
delusions of my 733 being a "production" machine, It's served me well
for years, and I don't have the space for a stationary planer.

For $15 or so a resharpening, I can have a better edge than new, and
keep a back-beveled set handy for difficult jobs. Some of my blades are
on the 4th go-around.

Maybe by the time my 733 bites it, a new version without disposables
will be available.

Barry

"B a r r y" wrote in message
. com...
Leon wrote:


I think you would, at best, be making a lateral move, If you work you
planer overtime I suspect that you will wear the planer out much sooner
than later, and that is not even taking into consideration the disposable
knives.

Reusable, easily replaced knives are the exact reason I'm running my DW733
into the ground.

I so wish the newer "portables" stayed with them. While I have no
delusions of my 733 being a "production" machine, It's served me well for
years, and I don't have the space for a stationary planer.

For $15 or so a resharpening, I can have a better edge than new, and keep
a back-beveled set handy for difficult jobs. Some of my blades are on the
4th go-around.

Maybe by the time my 733 bites it, a new version without disposables will
be available.

By comparison to their bigger brothers, cheaper planers and cheaper ink jet
printers are very much the same from a manufacturers point of view. Sell
affordable planers/ink jet printers at low profit then sell lots and lots
of expensive high profit blades/ink cartridges that cost next to nothing to
manufacture. I doubt the portables will go back to a blade that lasts.

On the flip side of that coin, $15 to resharpen, $30 to buy new double edged
sided blades. Or that was about the ratio the last time I checked. Either
way I resharpen with my Tormek.

Because of the disposable blades that now come in portable planers I was
ready when I went stationary.