Right now I use a shop vac attached to most tools. Most of the posters
here seem to be true woodworkers with planers and lathes that generate
much dust and chips. I do mostly home improvement projects around my
house. I use a table saw, band saw, mitre saw and a spindle sander. Is
a dust collector going to be much advantage for my basement shop? Is
there a problem short cycling a dust collector because sometimes I just
need to to cut a 2x4 or some 1 by lumber.

Thanks

Rocky

Rocky,

Your question is sure to generate a lot of answers since it's been discussed
and cussed by many for such a long time. You can Google it till the cows
come home and get lots of answers but the short answer to your question is -

1. Yes it will be of some value but how much depends on a number of factors.

2. Short-cycling should not be a big factor if you purchase a collector that
has a decent motor and the wiring (typically 220VAC) is done correctly.

Now I'll let the rest of the group provide the long versions..........

Bob S.


"Rocky" wrote in message
oups.com...
Right now I use a shop vac attached to most tools. Most of the posters
here seem to be true woodworkers with planers and lathes that generate
much dust and chips. I do mostly home improvement projects around my
house. I use a table saw, band saw, mitre saw and a spindle sander. Is
a dust collector going to be much advantage for my basement shop? Is
there a problem short cycling a dust collector because sometimes I just
need to to cut a 2x4 or some 1 by lumber.

Thanks

Rocky

Stick with the shop vac. Add a jointer, stick with the shop vac. If
you ever add a planer, then go for a dust collector.

Dust collection is ineffective on miter saws, table saws and spindle
sanders. (I use a friends band saw when I need one and he has a shop vac on
it. It does a pretty good job; a DC would be better, but not by much.)

DCs are great on jointers, planers, and router tables. You don't have any
of them; so it would really be a waste of money. Okay?

Sorry to go off on a tangent here, but I've noticed that my DC (IIRC, older
1HP delta canister w/ a bag that hangs off the side) does pretty much
nothing when connected to my bandsaw. Anybody have any tips on improving
dust collection with a bandsaw?

Would weather stripping the doors a bit be a good idea? Some sort of
enclosure around the lower guides, maybe?

-John

Cut a 4" circular hole in the door and hook up a 4" dust hose using a toilet
flange (4"). It sucks most of the dust up fine. Works a lot better than the
little 2" they put in the front.

Tim

"John Girouard" wrote in message
...
Sorry to go off on a tangent here, but I've noticed that my DC (IIRC,
older 1HP delta canister w/ a bag that hangs off the side) does pretty
much nothing when connected to my bandsaw. Anybody have any tips on
improving dust collection with a bandsaw?

Would weather stripping the doors a bit be a good idea? Some sort of
enclosure around the lower guides, maybe?

-John

On Wed, 19 Oct 2005 19:49:51 -0400, "tdup2" wrote:

Cut a 4" circular hole in the door and hook up a 4" dust hose using a toilet
flange (4"). It sucks most of the dust up fine. Works a lot better than the
little 2" they put in the front.

Tim

snip
Tim... I'm going to do just that on my 14" Ridgid, very soon...

To prevent me from re-inventing the wheel, what/how did you use to cut the 4"
hole?


mac

Please remove splinters before emailing

I put a piece of wood behind the door and drilled some holes then took tin
snips and cut my circle. If your careful there will not be to much filing to
do.

Tim

"mac davis" wrote in message
...
On Wed, 19 Oct 2005 19:49:51 -0400, "tdup2" wrote:

Cut a 4" circular hole in the door and hook up a 4" dust hose using a
toilet
flange (4"). It sucks most of the dust up fine. Works a lot better than
the
little 2" they put in the front.

Tim

snip
Tim... I'm going to do just that on my 14" Ridgid, very soon...

To prevent me from re-inventing the wheel, what/how did you use to cut the
4"
hole?


mac

Please remove splinters before emailing

Not true.

"Toller" wrote in message
...
Dust collection is ineffective on miter saws, table saws and spindle
sanders.

I had the same question. I've been researching a DC selection myself
but like the other poster pointed out there's abundance of material of
past postings for me to find "which" DC, but whether to even use one is
a question I hadn't thought of. I do have a planer though, and man
does it throw out the shavings. Right now I just take the planer onto
the deck to use.

wrote in message
oups.com...
I had the same question. I've been researching a DC selection myself
but like the other poster pointed out there's abundance of material of
past postings for me to find "which" DC, but whether to even use one is
a question I hadn't thought of. I do have a planer though, and man
does it throw out the shavings. Right now I just take the planer onto
the deck to use.

89% of the participants in this conference agree that a DC +planer is a very
good combination. The other 11% just like to argue.

Bob

Rocky wrote:
Right now I use a shop vac attached to most tools. Most of the posters
here seem to be true woodworkers with planers and lathes that generate
much dust and chips. I do mostly home improvement projects around my
house. I use a table saw, band saw, mitre saw and a spindle sander. Is
a dust collector going to be much advantage for my basement shop? Is
there a problem short cycling a dust collector because sometimes I just
need to to cut a 2x4 or some 1 by lumber.

Thanks

Rocky

It would be hard to beat putting a diaper on your tablesaw. If you
have access to a sewing machine or know someone who can sew, you can
make one for under $20. I have got to make a new one for my Ridgid TS.
I put one on my old craftsman over a year ago and it would great. If
you want details on one just let me know.

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg...#more-pictures