Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
UK diy (uk.d-i-y) For the discussion of all topics related to diy (do-it-yourself) in the UK. All levels of experience and proficency are welcome to join in to ask questions or offer solutions. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Computer work area
I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a
counter for computer use. The corner is only 4 foot and 3/4 inch by 1foot 6 inches. Current thinking is to allow the counter to protrude along the shortest wall to a width of 2 foot 4 inches. I'm assuming I can fasten softwood battens to the wall to support the counter. Would I also need a supporting leg at each extremity. I've drawn a diagram of the straight lines outlined above, but I'm not sure how to plan the curve I want at the front of the counter. Are there any websites that could help with this, or does anyone have any advice. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Andy Hall wrote:
I think that the main issue you will need to think about is weight of any monitor that you put on there if it's a CRT one unless a 15" type. In that case, I would put a supporting leg at each front corner. With an LCD monitor and putting the PC base unit on the floor, you could get away with wall battens only. The other issue is the depth of a CRT monitor. If you put it on a shallow shelf, the screen will be very much in-your-face. I have a very similar situation here, and even with a forward extension shelf for the keyboard[*] I couldn't use anything larger than a 15in CRT. All the 17in CRTs available at the time would have put the screen too far inside my comfortable focusing distance. Changing to a 17in LCD allowed the screen to be pushed a lot further back, which left a lot more room for papers and saved me having to buy a new pair of glasses. [*] A keyboard shelf below the desk level would be a good idea anyway, because the keyboard should be at a lower level than the desktop and the screen. All you need are a few bits of wood and a pair of kitchen drawer runners. -- Ian White |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Paul S wrote:
I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. See http://tinyurl.com/dqm8d (or http://groups.google.co.uk/group/uk.d-i-y/msg/169036c7dba763c6?hl=en&) for how I built mine David |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Sun, 7 Aug 2005 11:52:53 +0100, Ian White
wrote: Andy Hall wrote: I think that the main issue you will need to think about is weight of any monitor that you put on there if it's a CRT one unless a 15" type. In that case, I would put a supporting leg at each front corner. With an LCD monitor and putting the PC base unit on the floor, you could get away with wall battens only. The other issue is the depth of a CRT monitor. If you put it on a shallow shelf, the screen will be very much in-your-face. I have a very similar situation here, and even with a forward extension shelf for the keyboard[*] I couldn't use anything larger than a 15in CRT. All the 17in CRTs available at the time would have put the screen too far inside my comfortable focusing distance. Changing to a 17in LCD allowed the screen to be pushed a lot further back, which left a lot more room for papers and saved me having to buy a new pair of glasses. [*] A keyboard shelf below the desk level would be a good idea anyway, because the keyboard should be at a lower level than the desktop and the screen. All you need are a few bits of wood and a pair of kitchen drawer runners. Good point, Ian. The only trouble with underslung keyboard shelves is that although you can position the forearm as it should be (horiontally) and have a neat solution; it doesn't easily provide wrist or forearm rest places. It's not that important that the keyboard should be below the desktop - the key things are rest positions and angle for the keyboard and having the monitor at a range of angles relative to the eye line of the user. The factors are the desk, monitor height and seat position in relation to the user. -- ..andy To email, substitute .nospam with .gl |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Andy Hall wrote:
I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. I think that the main issue you will need to think about is weight of any monitor that you put on there if it's a CRT one unless a 15" type. In that case, I would put a supporting leg at each front corner. With an LCD monitor and putting the PC base unit on the floor, you could get away with wall battens only. As 17" monitors are under £200 and 17" monitors with inbuilt televisions (or televisions with PC input) under £300 I think LCD is the way to go. Depending on the purpose of the PC and the layout of the bedroom, a wireless keyboard with trackpad might mean that a counter isn't needed at all. Owain |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Paul S wrote: I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. The corner is only 4 foot and 3/4 inch by 1foot 6 inches. Current thinking is to allow the counter to protrude along the shortest wall to a width of 2 foot 4 inches. I'm assuming I can fasten softwood battens to the wall to support the counter. Would I also need a supporting leg at each extremity. I've drawn a diagram of the straight lines outlined above, but I'm not sure how to plan the curve I want at the front of the counter. Are there any websites that could help with this, or does anyone have any advice. Not answering question, and not DIY (typically of me), but ... Would you not consider one of those things on castors they call 'workstations'. I have one (Homebase? many years ago) in nice solidish timber (~2" strips that look like glued together -- but very solid). Has taken loads of abuse over six years. Otherwise look for a metal frame. 2 ft by 1 ft 7, with keyboard 'drawer'; I wouln't want much smaller. Can extend workspace temporarily with a wide shelf (fixed down with screws as necessary). Can just about fit (along with chair with me in) in a 3 ft 10 landing. Nice shelf for computer and loads of peripherals. 17" CRT fits easily; but hardly 19" -- which, in any case, should be banned as a (physical body) health hazard. Incidentally, bedrooms appear to be particularly dusty. Advice on dust protection or countermeasures may be worth seeking. Best regards, Jon C. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
On 07 Aug 2005, wrote
Paul S wrote: I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. The corner is only 4 foot and 3/4 inch by 1foot 6 inches. Current thinking is to allow the counter to protrude along the shortest wall to a width of 2 foot 4 inches. I'm assuming I can fasten softwood battens to the wall to support the counter. Would I also need a supporting leg at each extremity. I've drawn a diagram of the straight lines outlined above, but I'm not sure how to plan the curve I want at the front of the counter. Are there any websites that could help with this, or does anyone have any advice. Not answering question, and not DIY (typically of me), but ... Would you not consider one of those things on castors they call 'workstations'. I have one (Homebase? many years ago) in nice solidish timber (~2" strips that look like glued together -- but very solid). Has taken loads of abuse over six years. Otherwise look for a metal frame. I'll second that one should look at that route first. About 3 years ago I'd planned on replacing the hotch-potch of tables and junk in my office with a good corner unit; cost wasn't a huge factor -- I work from home, and can justify it -- but getting a workable unit was important, and I was happy to spend a few pounds to get it right. I worked out a design and costed the materials at around £100 (sheet materials, legs, shelving, paint, varnish, etc.). At the time, Homebase was doing a large corner unit for £80; I bought it on one of those 10% off days, so it came in at £72. (Aren't my sums good? I did that without a calculator....) It put together in a day - - a bit complex: lots of bits -- and does exactly what I wanted, for about £30 less than materials would've cost and for *lot* less time and effort. -- Cheers, Harvey |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Owain wrote:
Andy Hall wrote: I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. I think that the main issue you will need to think about is weight of any monitor that you put on there if it's a CRT one unless a 15" type. In that case, I would put a supporting leg at each front corner. With an LCD monitor and putting the PC base unit on the floor, you could get away with wall battens only. As 17" monitors are under ?200 and 17" monitors with inbuilt televisions (or televisions with PC input) under ?300 I think LCD is the way to go. Depending on the purpose of the PC and the layout of the bedroom, a wireless keyboard with trackpad might mean that a counter isn't needed at all. Also depending on the layout, it might be nice if the monitor was able to rotate through 90 degrees, for convienent use when in bed. Personally, I find using a keyboard least stressful when it's on my lap. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Andy Hall wrote:
[*] A keyboard shelf below the desk level would be a good idea anyway, because the keyboard should be at a lower level than the desktop and the screen. All you need are a few bits of wood and a pair of kitchen drawer runners. Good point, Ian. The only trouble with underslung keyboard shelves is that although you can position the forearm as it should be (horiontally) and have a neat solution; it doesn't easily provide wrist or forearm rest places. It's not that important that the keyboard should be below the desktop - the key things are rest positions and angle for the keyboard and having the monitor at a range of angles relative to the eye line of the user. The factors are the desk, monitor height and seat position in relation to the user. I strongly agree... but when you apply those basic principles, it almost invariably means that the keyboard should be below the standard desktop height. There is a danger of getting into Holy Wars about this, but IMO a wrist rest is a bad solution. The problem isn't lack of wrist support - what makes people's wrists ache is bad computer furniture that forces the arms to reach forwards and upwards to get to the keyboard, with the wrists cranked unnaturally downwards. And then they're expecting us to waggle our fingers, without it hurting? There's stacks of information on the web, but the basic recommendation is that the upper arms should be able to hang vertically in a neutral position, with the forearms roughly (but not rigidly) horizontal, and the wrists roughly (but not rigidly) straight. In other words, it's a lot like the piano-playing position, with the keyboard quite low down and quite close in to the belly. For most people, that position doesn't need any wrist support at all. If any support is needed, it is from chair arms a few inches forward of the elbows. The ideal situation is to start with a decent chair, with adjustable dimensions to suit the individual. Then the objective of the computer desk is to position the keyboard where the fingers need it to be, and the screen where the eyes and neck want it. Never the other way round. (IMO, anyway. This workstation is designed on those principles, and I've been using it full-time as a technical writer for over 16 years with absolutely no sign of wrist, arm or shoulder aches... much less any clinical problems. But at a client's site where the keyboard is perched up on a desk, I quickly notice that it's much harder work.) -- Ian White |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Ian White wrote:
(IMO, anyway. This workstation is designed on those principles, and I've been using it full-time as a technical writer for over 16 years with absolutely no sign of wrist, arm or shoulder aches... much less any clinical problems. But at a client's site where the keyboard is perched up on a desk, I quickly notice that it's much harder work.) I suppose it depends on what you're used to. When I started typing (cira age five, and my little fingers used to get squashed between the keys), it was a manual typewriter on the coffee-table, then I grew big enough to be able to reach the kitchen table. I am still not used to soft spongy keyboards. In t'olden days we used to do speed tests on manuals because you could whack the carriage over faster than the electrics did. And daisywheels were particularly sluggish, type a line and then wait for them to catch up. Owain |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
In message , Owain
writes Andy Hall wrote: I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. I think that the main issue you will need to think about is weight of any monitor that you put on there if it's a CRT one unless a 15" type. In that case, I would put a supporting leg at each front corner. With an LCD monitor and putting the PC base unit on the floor, you could get away with wall battens only. As 17" monitors are under £200 and 17" monitors with inbuilt televisions (or televisions with PC input) under £300 I think LCD is the way to go. I bought two 19" Acer TFT monitors for £180 each 6 months ago -- geoff |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
raden wrote:
In message , Owain writes Andy Hall wrote: I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. I think that the main issue you will need to think about is weight of any monitor that you put on there if it's a CRT one unless a 15" type. In that case, I would put a supporting leg at each front corner. With an LCD monitor and putting the PC base unit on the floor, you could get away with wall battens only. As 17" monitors are under £200 and 17" monitors with inbuilt televisions (or televisions with PC input) under £300 I think LCD is the way to go. I bought two 19" Acer TFT monitors for £180 each 6 months ago The price has dropped like a stone recently due to gluts in the market. Current low end prices for TFT monitors (no TV tuner, inc. VAT but not P+P, from EBuyer): 15" £125 17" £135 19" £175 17" is the current sweet spot in the market... |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
Owain writes: As 17" monitors are under £200 They were around £150 at Christmas, and have come down in price since then. I think I've seen them at around £125 at computer fairs, but not been keeping an eye out for them recently. -- Andrew Gabriel |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Wow! Thanks everyone. Did'nt expect that many replies. Even the TFT posts
were useful, as I might buy one soon (currently have 15" CRT). Are they as cheap as they're likely to get now ? From what some have said, it seems that I should have a look at corner units in places like Homebase, MFI, Staples etc. Anywhere else ? Ian W, I've always been in favour of resting wrists on the desk, and for that reason, thought I would'nt get anything with a keyboard draw, but your saying that thinking is wrong, and I should'nt need to rest my wrists at all! If so, I'll have to have a re-think. Any recommended sites to read about this ? I've now realised I really need a printer shelf as well, so it looks like a corner unit might be a better idea than a counter. Also now realise that I need more depth than I thought (unless I go and buy the TFT now) which would have meant the counter needed supports at the front. |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Paul S wrote:
Wow! Thanks everyone. Did'nt expect that many replies. Even the TFT posts were useful, as I might buy one soon (currently have 15" CRT). Are they as cheap as they're likely to get now ? 15" probably are, the glut has pretty much gone and they are dropping off the bottom end of the market. 17" may go down a bit more but not much. 19" should keep coming down, if you want to wait.. and wait.. Like all IT things, you'll always get a better one for less money in a few months! From what some have said, it seems that I should have a look at corner units in places like Homebase, MFI, Staples etc. Anywhere else ? Ian W, I've always been in favour of resting wrists on the desk, and for that reason, thought I would'nt get anything with a keyboard draw, but your saying that thinking is wrong, and I should'nt need to rest my wrists at all! If so, I'll have to have a re-think. Any recommended sites to read about this ? The desk I'm at now has a drawer which is long enough that I can have the keyboard 4" from the edge and rest my wrists if I want to anyway.. I've now realised I really need a printer shelf as well, so it looks like a corner unit might be a better idea than a counter. Also now realise that I need more depth than I thought (unless I go and buy the TFT now) which would have meant the counter needed supports at the front. TFTs are a lot lighter than CRTs too ;-) Difficult to sit your fluffy toys on top though.. 8^D |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
|
#18
|
|||
|
|||
In message , Paul
S writes Wow! Thanks everyone. Did'nt expect that many replies. Even the TFT posts were useful, as I might buy one soon (currently have 15" CRT). Are they as cheap as they're likely to get now ? Prolly not, but you have to jump in somewhere Try a 17" and you'll never go back to a 15" again You don't need the printer right by the computer, you can put it somewhere else in the room From what some have said, it seems that I should have a look at corner units in places like Homebase, MFI, Staples etc. Anywhere else ? Ian W, I've always been in favour of resting wrists on the desk, and for that reason, thought I would'nt get anything with a keyboard draw, but your saying that thinking is wrong, and I should'nt need to rest my wrists at all! If so, I'll have to have a re-think. Any recommended sites to read about this ? I've now realised I really need a printer shelf as well, so it looks like a corner unit might be a better idea than a counter. Also now realise that I need more depth than I thought (unless I go and buy the TFT now) which would have meant the counter needed supports at the front. -- geoff |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
On Sun, 7 Aug 2005 17:05:40 UTC, "PC Paul" wrote:
15" £125 17" £135 19" £175 CPC are doing 15" ones for under 100. They have 17" ones for 125, and Belinea ones for 135. All excluding VAT, but free delivery. |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
raden wrote:
I bought two 19" Acer TFT monitors for £180 each 6 months ago I bought an LG Flatron 17" for £199 (reduced from £299) 8 months ago. Them prices is dropping faster than a hoor's knickers in a dockyard when the ship comes in. Owain |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
In message , Bob Eager
writes On Sun, 7 Aug 2005 17:05:40 UTC, "PC Paul" wrote: 15" £125 17" £135 19" £175 CPC are doing 15" ones for under 100. They have 17" ones for 125, and Belinea ones for 135. One thing to look out for with TFT monitors is dead pixels Apparently they can be very annoying (like that little job you didn't get quite right, which nobody else notices but you - because you know it's there) -- geoff |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
On Sun, 7 Aug 2005 16:40:32 +0100, Ian White
wrote: Andy Hall wrote: [*] A keyboard shelf below the desk level would be a good idea anyway, because the keyboard should be at a lower level than the desktop and the screen. All you need are a few bits of wood and a pair of kitchen drawer runners. Good point, Ian. The only trouble with underslung keyboard shelves is that although you can position the forearm as it should be (horiontally) and have a neat solution; it doesn't easily provide wrist or forearm rest places. It's not that important that the keyboard should be below the desktop - the key things are rest positions and angle for the keyboard and having the monitor at a range of angles relative to the eye line of the user. The factors are the desk, monitor height and seat position in relation to the user. I strongly agree... but when you apply those basic principles, it almost invariably means that the keyboard should be below the standard desktop height. There is a danger of getting into Holy Wars about this, but IMO a wrist rest is a bad solution. The problem isn't lack of wrist support - what makes people's wrists ache is bad computer furniture that forces the arms to reach forwards and upwards to get to the keyboard, with the wrists cranked unnaturally downwards. And then they're expecting us to waggle our fingers, without it hurting? There's stacks of information on the web, but the basic recommendation is that the upper arms should be able to hang vertically in a neutral position, with the forearms roughly (but not rigidly) horizontal, and the wrists roughly (but not rigidly) straight. In other words, it's a lot like the piano-playing position, with the keyboard quite low down and quite close in to the belly. For most people, that position doesn't need any wrist support at all. If any support is needed, it is from chair arms a few inches forward of the elbows. The ideal situation is to start with a decent chair, with adjustable dimensions to suit the individual. Then the objective of the computer desk is to position the keyboard where the fingers need it to be, and the screen where the eyes and neck want it. Never the other way round. (IMO, anyway. This workstation is designed on those principles, and I've been using it full-time as a technical writer for over 16 years with absolutely no sign of wrist, arm or shoulder aches... much less any clinical problems. But at a client's site where the keyboard is perched up on a desk, I quickly notice that it's much harder work.) Agreed. To me, the chair is the key issue. You ca fix most other issues after that -- ..andy To email, substitute .nospam with .gl |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
Owain wrote:
raden wrote: I bought two 19" Acer TFT monitors for ?180 each 6 months ago I bought an LG Flatron 17" for ?199 (reduced from ?299) 8 months ago. Them prices is dropping faster than a hoor's knickers in a dockyard when the ship comes in. At the current price, it's also a good idea to look at power consumption. Looking at some monitor specs, I saw a variance of 30W between monitors of similar brightness. 30W, 8 hours/day = 240Wh/day = 2p/day. In the first year, that'll cost you 6 quid. |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
Paul S wrote:
I've now realised I really need a printer shelf as well, so it looks like a corner unit might be a better idea than a counter. Also now realise that I need more depth than I thought (unless I go and buy the TFT now) which would have meant the counter needed supports at the front. It is possible to mount TFTs on the wall, there is standard for the mounting plate at the back than enables it to be taken off the desk stand and fixed to a wall bracket. I know Dell TFTs do this and I assume others. -- David Clark $message_body_include ="PLES RING IF AN RNSR IS REQIRD" |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
Paul S wrote:
Ian W, I've always been in favour of resting wrists on the desk, and for that reason, thought I would'nt get anything with a keyboard draw, but your saying that thinking is wrong, and I should'nt need to rest my wrists at all! If so, I'll have to have a re-think. Any recommended sites to read about this ? There are thousands! http://www.ergonomics4schools.com/lzone/office.htm Good explanation with diagrams http://office-ergo.com/alternat.htm Basic principles The HSE guidelines: http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg36.pdf Review and critique of national guidelines: http://www.hazards.org/workstations/ -- Ian White |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
"PC Paul" wrote in message .uk... raden wrote: In message , Owain writes Andy Hall wrote: I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. I think that the main issue you will need to think about is weight of any monitor that you put on there if it's a CRT one unless a 15" type. In that case, I would put a supporting leg at each front corner. With an LCD monitor and putting the PC base unit on the floor, you could get away with wall battens only. As 17" monitors are under £200 and 17" monitors with inbuilt televisions (or televisions with PC input) under £300 I think LCD is the way to go. I bought two 19" Acer TFT monitors for £180 each 6 months ago The price has dropped like a stone recently due to gluts in the market. Current low end prices for TFT monitors (no TV tuner, inc. VAT but not P+P, from EBuyer): 15" £125 17" £135 19" £175 17" is the current sweet spot in the market... Who is selling at those prices? |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
On 08 Aug 2005, Doctor Drivel wrote
"PC Paul" wrote in message .uk... The price has dropped like a stone recently due to gluts in the market. Current low end prices for TFT monitors (no TV tuner, inc. VAT but not P+P, from EBuyer): 15" £125 17" £135 19" £175 17" is the current sweet spot in the market... Who is selling at those prices? As he mentioned, ebuyer is: they've got a 17" one in there for £141 including VAT and with free delivery (this will wrap badly): http://www.ebuyer.com/customer/produ...=c2hvd19wcm9kd WN0X292ZXJ2aWV3&product_uid=91803 -- Cheers, Harvey |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
Doctor Drivel wrote:
"PC Paul" wrote in message .uk... raden wrote: In message , Owain writes Andy Hall wrote: I have a small corner space in my bedroom, to which I want to fit a counter for computer use. I think that the main issue you will need to think about is weight of any monitor that you put on there if it's a CRT one unless a 15" type. In that case, I would put a supporting leg at each front corner. With an LCD monitor and putting the PC base unit on the floor, you could get away with wall battens only. As 17" monitors are under £200 and 17" monitors with inbuilt televisions (or televisions with PC input) under £300 I think LCD is the way to go. I bought two 19" Acer TFT monitors for £180 each 6 months ago The price has dropped like a stone recently due to gluts in the market. Current low end prices for TFT monitors (no TV tuner, inc. VAT but not P+P, from EBuyer): 15" £125 17" £135 19" £175 17" is the current sweet spot in the market... Who is selling at those prices? "Current low end prices for TFT monitors (no TV tuner, inc. VAT but not P+P, *from EBuyer*):" Subtle I know, but the 'from Ebuyer' was meant as a clue. http://www.ebuyer.co.uk |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
How can I get a contractor to FINISH?!?!? | Home Ownership | |||
Newbie: starting a small computer repair business... | Electronics Repair | |||
Kelton Balancer Review Draft--long | Woodturning | |||
For Sale, Delta planer, craftsman bandsaw,103.0103 , Work bench top in pittsburgh Area | Woodworking |