Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my
3 year old 30 gallon water heater. I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
On Aug 6, 9:31�pm, "Jordan" wrote:
I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my 3 year old 30 gallon water heater. �I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? depends on your lifestyle, i would first add a water heater insulation blanket and remember if you live where it gets cold the standby losses help heat your home. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
"Jordan" wrote in message . .. I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my 3 year old 30 gallon water heater. I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? You use water heater timers with large tank water heaters, where the utility company has electric meters with timers in them, and charge a lower amount during off peak times, which is usually in the middle of the night. Personally, I doubt there is much savings at all, unless you wind up taking lots of cold showers |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
On Aug 6, 8:31*pm, "Jordan" wrote:
I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my 3 year old 30 gallon water heater. *I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? Nobody is getting 40 back, My total bill for the electric tank was under 40 a month, I know because that is how much it went down when I switched to Ng. Do a test, my tank still had warm water in it after 5 days when I would leave and turn off the power. See how much it drops overnight, you will be just reheating it and may save nothing. Insulate pipes and the tank, that will save money, turn down the temp so you only need hot water for a shower, that will save alot. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
On Aug 7, 9:47*am, ransley wrote:
On Aug 6, 8:31*pm, "Jordan" wrote: I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my 3 year old 30 gallon water heater. *I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? Nobody is getting 40 back, My total bill for the electric tank was under 40 a month, I know because that is how much it went down when I switched to Ng. Do a test, my tank still had warm water in it after 5 days when I would leave and turn off the power. See how much it drops overnight, you will be just reheating it and may save nothing. Of course it has to be reheated, but once again, that DOES NOT TRANSLATE INTO SAVING NOTHING. In fact, the more it has to be reheated, the MORE he saves. You do have one good point here, and that is to measure the water temp one night just before turning it off, then measure again in the AM before turing it back on. The smaller the temp drop, the less energy will be saved. That should give a good indication of how practical it would be. Could it be so small that it's not worth it? Sure. But that is different than saying it doesn't actually save any energy at all. Insulate pipes and the tank, that will save money, turn down the temp so you only need hot water for a shower, that will save alot. |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
|
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
On Aug 8, 12:46*pm, Smitty Two wrote:
In article , wrote: On Aug 7, 9:47*am, ransley Mark wrote: On Aug 6, 8:31*pm, "Jordan" wrote: I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my 3 year old 30 gallon water heater. *I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? Nobody is getting 40 back, My total bill for the electric tank was under 40 a month, I know because that is how much it went down when I switched to Ng. Do a test, my tank still had warm water in it after 5 days when I would leave and turn off the power. See how much it drops overnight, you will be just reheating it and may save nothing. Of course it has to be reheated, but once again, that DOES NOT TRANSLATE INTO SAVING NOTHING. * In fact, the more it has to be reheated, the MORE he saves. Sorry, not true. It's the change in *rate* of heat loss that determines the savings. The rate slows, slightly, as the temperature difference between the water in the tank and the surrounding air decreases. But that difference is essentially negligible. IOW, looking at a loss of 20 degrees in 10 hours overnight: if it loses 10 degrees in the first five hours and another 10 in the second five hours, there is absolutely *zero* savings. However, if it loses 10.1 degrees in the first five hours and 9.9 degrees in the second five hours, then you'll save by turning it off overnight. How much? Maybe a penny. Likely not even that. *You do have one good point here, and that is to measure the water temp one night just before turning it off, then measure again in the AM before turing it back on. *The smaller the temp drop, the less energy will be saved. *That should give a good indication of how practical it would be. *Could it be so small that it's not worth it? * Sure. * But that is different than saying it doesn't actually save any energy at all. Insulate pipes and the tank, that will save money, turn down the temp so you only need hot water for a shower, that will save alot.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
On Aug 8, 12:46*pm, Smitty Two wrote:
In article , wrote: On Aug 7, 9:47*am, ransley Mark wrote: On Aug 6, 8:31*pm, "Jordan" wrote: I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my 3 year old 30 gallon water heater. *I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? Nobody is getting 40 back, My total bill for the electric tank was under 40 a month, I know because that is how much it went down when I switched to Ng. Do a test, my tank still had warm water in it after 5 days when I would leave and turn off the power. See how much it drops overnight, you will be just reheating it and may save nothing. Of course it has to be reheated, but once again, that DOES NOT TRANSLATE INTO SAVING NOTHING. * In fact, the more it has to be reheated, the MORE he saves. Sorry, not true. Exactly what is not true? This is what you stated: "See how much it drops overnight, you will be just reheating it and may save nothing. ' That is what is not true and doesn't make any sense. Of course it has to be reheated the next morning. The point, once again, is that it takes less energy to then reheat it in the morning than it does to maintain it at the normal set temp all night. This is exactly the same concept and simple physics as turning back a thermostat overnight on a home heating system. Are you going to tell us that doesn't save energy too? And again, let me state the disclaimer, I'm not saying he's going to save a lot of energy. I'm not saying it's worth it to install a timer. Maybe it is, maybe it isn't depending on exactly how much energy he can save. But that is a totally different argument than saying turning off the water heater doesn't save any energy because it has to be reheated. It's the change in *rate* of heat loss that determines the savings. The rate slows, slightly, as the temperature difference between the water in the tank and the surrounding air decreases. But that difference is essentially negligible. IOW, looking at a loss of 20 degrees in 10 hours overnight: if it loses 10 degrees in the first five hours and another 10 in the second five hours, there is absolutely *zero* savings. Let's look at the previous example you gave he Let's say your HW is at 130 degrees, and it cools to 110 overnight in the tank with the heater off. Do you *really* think that the slope of temp over time isn't close enough to linear to disregard its shallowing in this *real world* consideration? The rate of heat loss is proportional to the temp difference. Let's assume it's in a basement at 60 degrees. At 130 degrees, the temp differential is 130-60, or 70 degrees. At 110, it's 110-60 or 50 degrees. So the temperature differential has gone from 70 to 50, or about a 30% difference at the end of the period. It's a decaying exponential so more of that 30% benefit occurs in the earlier period than in the later. But even if you assumed it was linear and went from 0 decrease to 30% at the end of the period, the tank would have an average of about 15% less heat loss over say 6 hours. That isn't zero and it's not negligible either. Again, whether it makes it worthwhile to install a timer is a completely different discussion. However, if it loses 10.1 degrees in the first five hours and 9.9 degrees in the second five hours, then you'll save by turning it off overnight. How much? Maybe a penny. Likely not even that. Clearly that can't happen. because the rate of heat loss is proportional to the temp difference and it's a natural log decaying function, which according to physics and math isn't close to being linear. In other words, it's going to lose much less in the second five hours. |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
|
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
On Aug 6, 8:31*pm, "Jordan" wrote:
I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my 3 year old 30 gallon water heater. *I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? What kind of timer, what does it consume 24x7, thats an extra charge. I have some commercial timers that consume maybe 4-5$ a month themselves. You might save 2-4$ on the tank and pay 5$ to run the timer. |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
"Jordan" wrote in message . .. I just started thinking about getting an electric water heater timer for my 3 year old 30 gallon water heater. I checked some of the reviews for the Intermatic timers and it looks like everybody loves them and they say they practically get their $40 bucks back each month. Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? I tried the timer, elec bill went UP. The water was cooling too much in the off cycles, then the WH had to run like hell to catch back up. |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Are electric WH timers worth it
Jordan wrote:
Are timers all they seem to be cracked up to be and will turning off the water heater from 10 PM to 8 AM really save a family of 4 a big chunk of change each month? Only if electricity costs less at night. Nick |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Talking about timers | UK diy | |||
News about timers | Home Repair | |||
OT and poser for old timers | Metalworking | |||
Security timers? | Electronics Repair | |||
Plug-in timers. | UK diy |