Hey all,

I have a kitchen and living room separated by a load bearing wall that has 3
ducts and 1 cold air return running thru it.
I'd like to remove the wall and put in a beam. The new beam and the wall
removal I can deal with, but,
moving duct work is going to be a new challenge.

Currently there are 3 ducts coming off the main trunk line (in the
unfinished basement ) at separate spots in intervals of 16 inches (so the
lines fit up the wall cavities) they run west @ 6 feet off of the trunk line
before they turn up thru the wall I want to remove.
I'd like to take out the ducts, and run 1 large line off the main trunk
line. this new line would exit the main trunk line 1 foot north of where
last of the 3 current ducts located. (trunk line runs N/S)
I'd then remove the majority of the existing wall, then this new line will
run 6 feet from the trunk line then turn up next to the "stub" of the
remaining wall. Then when the new line reaches the ceiling turn it back
south in a ceiling bulkhead to rejoin the remaining duct work that runs
thru the floor of the second floor. The current ducts all open into the
same room which currently gets too much air with all the vents open.

I understand that running angles at 90' will really cut down on air flow
but, I don't think I have much of an other option.
My question is, If I remove the 3 lines and consolidate them, should the sq
footage of a cross section of the new square duct be larger / smaller or the
same size as the sum of the 3 existing ducts.

ie. given 3 pipes at 6 inch round then (6*6 / 2) *3 = 54 inches so new
square line off the trunk line should be 6x9 or so.


thanks in advance for any advice.

Dave

zephyr wrote:
Hey all,

I have a kitchen and living room separated by a load bearing wall
that has 3 ducts and 1 cold air return running thru it.
I'd like to remove the wall and put in a beam. The new beam and the
wall removal I can deal with, but,
moving duct work is going to be a new challenge.


Pardon me for asking, but I am only trying to keep someone out of
trouble and I don't know your qualifications.

You seem unsure of moving ducts, but feel good about removing a load
bearing wall. Do you have experience as an engineer? Guessing on this job
is not a good thing.

I am not sure what others will recommend here, but I suggest employing a
HVAC professional that will do the math for you and make sure your ducts as
planed and air handling capacity you have will handle it. No getting it
right now, can be very expensive later to correct. Almost as expensive as
the damage caused by making a mistake on the load bearing wall.

--
Joseph Meehan

Dia duit

He definetely needs a pro, and likely changes to his furnace and AC
like a bigger blower motor, if its even possible. he might have to
upgrade to a high speed small diameter duct system, whatever the
changes are going to cost big bucks

"Joseph Meehan" wrote in message
news
zephyr wrote:
Hey all,

I have a kitchen and living room separated by a load bearing wall
that has 3 ducts and 1 cold air return running thru it.
I'd like to remove the wall and put in a beam. The new beam and the
wall removal I can deal with, but,
moving duct work is going to be a new challenge.


Pardon me for asking, but I am only trying to keep someone out of
trouble and I don't know your qualifications.

You seem unsure of moving ducts, but feel good about removing a load
bearing wall. Do you have experience as an engineer? Guessing on this
job is not a good thing.

I am not sure what others will recommend here, but I suggest employing
a HVAC professional that will do the math for you and make sure your ducts
as planed and air handling capacity you have will handle it. No getting
it right now, can be very expensive later to correct. Almost as expensive
as the damage caused by making a mistake on the load bearing wall.


Gentlemen,

I appreciate your concearn for my safety and well being,
I do not have experience as an engineer, however, I do have a good friend
who is an architect and he should be able to come up with the correct size
beam for me.
I do have experience as a framer, so, the wall portion of the job is not
going to be difficult. (just plain old hard work)
however, I'd love to know if I should over size the extension to the trunk
line, or not in order to get sufficient air to the upstairs bedroom.


For those interested in the bearing wall part of my project, it is an 11
foot wall with a doorway currently in at the south end of the wall (wall
runs n/s) , I want to expand the "doorway" to be 8+ feet wide.
regardless I will be pulling permits, so whatever mistakes I make *should*
be caught by an experienced pro. I'm just hoping to skip having to redo /
repair any work.


Dave





--
Joseph Meehan

Dia duit

I think most of us here dont want to see anyoone bring down a cieling
or worse Such sad events can and do occur

a good friend had a issue like yours, they opened the wall with a
couple pillars where the ducts ran from basement to upstairs and
installed a wall and counter about 3 feet tall.

IMHO you need to get a estimate from a heating contractor...

"zephyr" wrote in message
. ..
Hey all,

I have a kitchen and living room separated by a load bearing wall that has
3 ducts and 1 cold air return running thru it.
I'd like to remove the wall and put in a beam. The new beam and the wall
removal I can deal with, but,
moving duct work is going to be a new challenge.

Currently there are 3 ducts coming off the main trunk line (in the
unfinished basement ) at separate spots in intervals of 16 inches (so the
lines fit up the wall cavities) they run west @ 6 feet off of the trunk
line before they turn up thru the wall I want to remove.
I'd like to take out the ducts, and run 1 large line off the main trunk
line. this new line would exit the main trunk line 1 foot north of where
last of the 3 current ducts located. (trunk line runs N/S)
I'd then remove the majority of the existing wall, then this new line
will run 6 feet from the trunk line then turn up next to the "stub" of the
remaining wall. Then when the new line reaches the ceiling turn it back
south in a ceiling bulkhead to rejoin the remaining duct work that runs
thru the floor of the second floor. The current ducts all open into the
same room which currently gets too much air with all the vents open.

I understand that running angles at 90' will really cut down on air flow
but, I don't think I have much of an other option.
My question is, If I remove the 3 lines and consolidate them, should the
sq footage of a cross section of the new square duct be larger / smaller
or the same size as the sum of the 3 existing ducts.

ie. given 3 pipes at 6 inch round then (6*6 / 2) *3 = 54 inches so new
square line off the trunk line should be 6x9 or so.


thanks in advance for any advice.

Dave
Dave Area for circle is Pi x r squared 3.1416 x 9 x 3 pipes is 84.9.
Been out of school over 60 years so someone may correct this. WW

"Warren Weber" hiview68NO wrote in message
...

"zephyr" wrote in message
. ..
Hey all,

I have a kitchen and living room separated by a load bearing wall that
has 3 ducts and 1 cold air return running thru it.
I'd like to remove the wall and put in a beam. The new beam and the wall
removal I can deal with, but,
moving duct work is going to be a new challenge.

Currently there are 3 ducts coming off the main trunk line (in the
unfinished basement ) at separate spots in intervals of 16 inches (so the
lines fit up the wall cavities) they run west @ 6 feet off of the trunk
line before they turn up thru the wall I want to remove.
I'd like to take out the ducts, and run 1 large line off the main trunk
line. this new line would exit the main trunk line 1 foot north of where
last of the 3 current ducts located. (trunk line runs N/S)
I'd then remove the majority of the existing wall, then this new line
will run 6 feet from the trunk line then turn up next to the "stub" of
the remaining wall. Then when the new line reaches the ceiling turn it
back south in a ceiling bulkhead to rejoin the remaining duct work that
runs thru the floor of the second floor. The current ducts all open into
the same room which currently gets too much air with all the vents open.

I understand that running angles at 90' will really cut down on air flow
but, I don't think I have much of an other option.
My question is, If I remove the 3 lines and consolidate them, should the
sq footage of a cross section of the new square duct be larger / smaller
or the same size as the sum of the 3 existing ducts.

ie. given 3 pipes at 6 inch round then (6*6 / 2) *3 = 54 inches so new
square line off the trunk line should be 6x9 or so.


thanks in advance for any advice.

Dave
Dave Area for circle is Pi x r squared 3.1416 x 9 x 3 pipes is 84.9.
Been out of school over 60 years so someone may correct this. WW


Warren,

your right, thanks for the correction

Dave