Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
![]() |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Happened upon this school website
http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oodworking.htm Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? Check out all the router table action with no push blocks or sticks, hands inches from the bit. |
#2
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos?
Bruce Johnson's alma mater? -- www.e-woodshop.net Last update: 11/06/04 |
#3
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Swingman" wrote in message ... Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? Bruce Johnson's alma mater? Is he still on TV or did OSHA require the DIY channel to remove him? ;~) |
#4
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Leon" wrote in message
"Swingman" wrote in message Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? Bruce Johnson's alma mater? Is he still on TV or did OSHA require the DIY channel to remove him? ;~) Well, he does still have all his fingers, but I wonder if the bookies in the UK are taking bets yet? He scares SWMBO and she doesn't know a router from a table saw. I don't know why I continue to record his show as I just FF over the first few minutes and erase it almost immediately. Once, I did see him build a nice little oak bookshelf, with very nice lines, that was put together correctly, but most of his stuff is cheesy DIY to the max, IMO. But he must be doing something more or less pleasing to the powers that be .... he's on TV and we're not (although I am convinced there is a real woodworker hiding somewhere off camera). ;) -- www.e-woodshop.net Last update: 11/06/04 |
#5
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Swingman" wrote in message ... Snip But he must be doing something more or less pleasing to the powers that be ... he's on TV and we're not (although I am convinced there is a real woodworker hiding somewhere off camera). ;) Yeah he has to know something... I guess he rushes through the projects to show more of what can be done. I was thinking I might swing by and see you some time next week, Wednesdayish. Will be be around? -- www.e-woodshop.net Last update: 11/06/04 |
#6
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Leon" wrote in message "Swingman" wrote in message But he must be doing something more or less pleasing to the powers that be ... he's on TV and we're not (although I am convinced there is a real woodworker hiding somewhere off camera). ;) Yeah he has to know something... I guess he rushes through the projects to show more of what can be done. I was thinking I might swing by and see you some time next week, Wednesdayish. Will be be around? I'll make a point of it. Give me a holler e-mail. -- www.e-woodshop.net Last update: 11/06/04 |
#7
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Tue, 21 Dec 2004 09:15:12 -0600, "Swingman" wrote:
Well, he does still have all his fingers, This one doesn't appear to http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Trellis/Mortising%20-trellis(Ryan&Tars).JPG Nasty kickback risk on this one, even with that riving knife. http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...SAWING%202.jpg The inverted sander isn't good practice http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Plaques%20and%20frames/Pix%20frames%20ll%20(Ryan).jpg although the worst hazard is clearly the terrible electrical fault - look at what it's done to his hair ! This should have a push board to feed the board through - can't see if there is one. http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/ww%205th%20hour%20class/R.Meridith(Bread%20board-sanding).JPG I'd like to see more earmuffs too. -- Smert' spamionam |
#8
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Andy Dingley" wrote in message ... On Tue, 21 Dec 2004 09:15:12 -0600, "Swingman" wrote: Well, he does still have all his fingers, This one doesn't appear to http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...sing%20-trelli s(Ryan&Tars).JPG Or... is his finger bent - like the second finger is? Nasty kickback risk on this one, even with that riving knife. http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...SAWING%202.jpg Oh please. You're stretching on this one Andy. Is there any cut on a table saw that the kickback police don't nail as a kickback hazard? That is a perfectly reasonable cut to make on a table saw. The inverted sander isn't good practice http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...%20frames/Pix% 20frames%20ll%20(Ryan).jpg Now that one is... shall we say... novel. Not a horrible safety risk since it's just a vibrating sander, but I can't imagine how wobbly that must have been. This should have a push board to feed the board through - can't see if there is one. http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/ww%205th%20hour%20class/R.Meridith(Bread%20board-sanding).JPG I'd really be concerned if there was a push stick in the picture. Note that the board is not yet past the edge of the bed. You'd suggest a push stick on a board that is not fully secured on the bed? It's time to quit looking for boogy men in everything on this site. His hands aren't near the business end of the machine and his hands offer far better control than a push stick. So - what is the safety advantage of a push stick? -- -Mike- |
#9
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Andy Dingley" wrote in message ... On Tue, 21 Dec 2004 09:15:12 -0600, "Swingman" wrote: Well, he does still have all his fingers, This one doesn't appear to http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Trellis/Mortising%20-trellis(Ryan&Tars).JPG I guess he had that finger reattached for this picture http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...ner%20Tars.jpg Frank |
#11
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#12
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() wrote in message ups.com... Happened upon this school website http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oodworking.htm Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? Check out all the router table action with no push blocks or sticks, hands inches from the bit. You scare me Larry. I didn't see a picture there where they were doing anything unsafe. Push sticks on a router table is not one of the best ideas I've ever heard. Hands inches from the bit? Yeah - it's called woodworking. It requires control in order to be safe. Look at what they are routing and suggest a safer alternative. -- -Mike- |
#13
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Mike Marlow" wrote in message ink.net... wrote in message ups.com... Happened upon this school website http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oodworking.htm Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? You scare me Larry. I didn't see a picture there where they were doing anything unsafe. Push sticks on a router table is not one of the best ideas I've ever heard. Hands inches from the bit? Yeah - it's called woodworking. It requires control in order to be safe. Look at what they are routing and suggest a safer alternative. I too don't see any glaring safety hazards. Some of the kids in the background(s) didn't have their safety glasses on...but I'm sure they've been told umteen times. Table saw guards and spliters in place. No long sleeves or long hair evident. I noticed some have hearing aides but one might wonder why they don't wear the muffs to preserve what little hearing they might still have. Larry(...not the original poster) |
#14
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Tue, 21 Dec 2004 14:27:40 GMT, "Lawrence L'Hote"
wrote: "Mike Marlow" wrote in message link.net... wrote in message ups.com... Happened upon this school website http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oodworking.htm Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? You scare me Larry. I didn't see a picture there where they were doing anything unsafe. Push sticks on a router table is not one of the best ideas I've ever heard. Hands inches from the bit? Yeah - it's called woodworking. It requires control in order to be safe. Look at what they are routing and suggest a safer alternative. I too don't see any glaring safety hazards. Some of the kids in the background(s) didn't have their safety glasses on...but I'm sure they've been told umteen times. Table saw guards and spliters in place. No long sleeves or long hair evident. I noticed some have hearing aides but one might wonder why they don't wear the muffs to preserve what little hearing they might still have. I suspect the power tools have a lower noise level than the cars-turned-into-boom-boxes in which they drive around. :-( Larry(...not the original poster) |
#15
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Chetandra sanding her yo-yo" is one caption which might have been
reconsidered. ![]() FoggyTown "Cut to shape . . . pound to fit." |
#16
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On 21 Dec 2004 11:01:10 -0800, "foggytown" wrote:
"Chetandra sanding her yo-yo" is one caption which might have been reconsidered. ![]() "Ryan using a vibrator..." I have to agree with others here, other than the photographer running around doing flash photography while the kids are in the middle of operations I don't see anything to get in a twist about. I hope they warned them a flash was coming before they fired up the machine. -Leuf |
#17
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() Mike Marlow wrote: wrote in message ups.com... Happened upon this school website http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oodworking.htm Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? Check out all the router table action with no push blocks or sticks, hands inches from the bit. You scare me Larry. I didn't see a picture there where they were doing anything unsafe. Push sticks on a router table is not one of the best ideas I've ever heard. Hands inches from the bit? Yeah - it's called woodworking. It requires control in order to be safe. Look at what they are routing and suggest a safer alternative. You guys serious? I'd shake your hand if you had any fingers left. You don't think this is a problem? http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...in%20Dylan.jpg http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Plaques%20and%20frames/plaque%20(Tabitha).JPG ?? |
#18
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() wrote in message ups.com... Mike Marlow wrote: wrote in message ups.com... Happened upon this school website http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oodworking.htm Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? Check out all the router table action with no push blocks or sticks, hands inches from the bit. You scare me Larry. I didn't see a picture there where they were doing anything unsafe. Push sticks on a router table is not one of the best ideas I've ever heard. Hands inches from the bit? Yeah - it's called woodworking. It requires control in order to be safe. Look at what they are routing and suggest a safer alternative. You guys serious? I'd shake your hand if you had any fingers left. You don't think this is a problem? http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...in%20Dylan.jpg http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Plaques%20and%20frames/plaque%20(Tabitha).JPG ?? No, and no. I prefer the safety and control of my hands on a piece of wood than the instability of a push stick used for the wrong task. Yes, I have all of my fingers and I've been woodworking for over 35 years. Maybe you have also, and I don't suggest you abandon procedures that make you comfortable, but the level of pure asinine safety talk here is absurd. Most of it is nothing more than people repeating things they've heard or read and it becomes mantra, rather than being based on anything substantial. There are too many people here who do nothing more than look for what they can point out as a safety issue, just for the sake of passing wind. As to the photos, neither you nor I know what number 44 is shaping. He has a solid hold on his stock and that mitigates more potential problems than anything you're going to do with a push stick. If he's just doing edge work on that shaper his hands are perfectly safe where they are. What are you seeing that is such a concern? The young lady, likewise has a good hold on her stock and her hands are well clear of the cutter. She has control. What are you seeing wrong with her picture? -- -Mike- |
#19
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
As to the photos, neither you nor I know what number 44 is shaping.
He has a solid hold on his stock and that mitigates more potential problems than anything you're going to do with a push stick. If he's just doing edge work on that shaper his hands are perfectly safe where they are. What are you seeing that is such a concern? The young lady, likewise has a good hold on her stock and her hands are well clear of the cutter. She has control. What are you seeing wrong with her picture? The problem isn't when the person has control of their stock, it's what happens to their body if they lose control of their stock. Kickback has happened to all of us at one time or another, and the girl trying to control that short piece is asking for an accident. A push block like ones used in a jointer would make that operation much more safe, IMO. |
#21
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On 21 Dec 2004 18:28:34 -0800, "
wrote: As to the photos, neither you nor I know what number 44 is shaping. He has a solid hold on his stock and that mitigates more potential problems than anything you're going to do with a push stick. If he's just doing edge work on that shaper his hands are perfectly safe where they are. What are you seeing that is such a concern? The young lady, likewise has a good hold on her stock and her hands are well clear of the cutter. She has control. What are you seeing wrong with her picture? The problem isn't when the person has control of their stock, it's what happens to their body if they lose control of their stock. Kickback has happened to all of us at one time or another, and the girl trying to control that short piece is asking for an accident. A push block like ones used in a jointer would make that operation much more safe, IMO. I don't know if she's safe or not, but I'm a devout coward... I use a slide jig that holds the work against the fence and makes it really, really hard to get my fingers in the way.. |
#22
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() wrote in message oups.com... The problem isn't when the person has control of their stock, it's what happens to their body if they lose control of their stock. Kickback has happened to all of us at one time or another, and the girl trying to control that short piece is asking for an accident. A push block like ones used in a jointer would make that operation much more safe, IMO. That's where we disagree Larry. The push block or push stick put your hands more in the clear is something does go wrong or they keep your hands more in the clear in the case of tight cuts like up against the rip fence, but they do not offer more stability to the work. They can remove control. They are an extension to your hand and as such they are a somewhat flexible extension. I do use them and I do not want to sound like I don't advocate them, but every tool in its place. Likewise, do not critique a perfectly safe procedure simply because you can. To use a push block on a piece the size she is using is going to result in less control, and probably an increase in likelihood of kickback. How is that possibly safer? -- -Mike- |
#23
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On 21 Dec 2004 13:28:20 -0800, "
wrote: Mike Marlow wrote: wrote in message ups.com... Happened upon this school website http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oodworking.htm Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? Check out all the router table action with no push blocks or sticks, hands inches from the bit. You scare me Larry. I didn't see a picture there where they were doing anything unsafe. Push sticks on a router table is not one of the best ideas I've ever heard. Hands inches from the bit? Yeah - it's called woodworking. It requires control in order to be safe. Look at what they are routing and suggest a safer alternative. You guys serious? I'd shake your hand if you had any fingers left. You don't think this is a problem? http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...in%20Dylan.jpg He's standing clear of any kickback, from the look of the workpiece, it appears the operation is a simple roundover, the stock is sufficiently large that his hand is not near the roundover bit as it moves the stock, what is your concern? http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Plaques%20and%20frames/plaque%20(Tabitha).JPG ?? No hearing protection -- not a good idea. Router bit in fence -- seems OK. It's a short piece that she is working, use of a push stick would appear to me to be more dangerous than the operation as she is performing it. If something grabs, she is out the the way of any kickback, there is noone behind her. Her fingers are again well clear of the bit, her eyes and attention appear to be firmly on the work. I would probably have clamped a guard board over the exposed portion of the bit at board height. A push block, particularly with an edged surface would have the potential for tipping the workpiece. |
#24
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On 21 Dec 2004 13:28:20 -0800, "
wrote: You don't think this is a problem? http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...in%20Dylan.jpg http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Plaques%20and%20frames/plaque%20(Tabitha).JPG I hadn't noticed those two yet - nasty. The first machine is probably illegal to operate in the UK in a commercial workshop and is _certainly_ so in a school workshop. In fact the first one just isn't something _I'd_ do. That's the most common table-mounted router accident requiring a hospital visit (according to the HSE's figures) - a blind emerging cut, where the pushing hand goes straight into the unseen cutter. The second picture is one I'd cheerfully do, but I'd never let kids do it. _I_ have some idea of where my fingers are, where the bit is, and how far to separate them. Kids can't reliably do that. |
#25
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Wed, 22 Dec 2004 00:42:01 +0000, Andy Dingley
wrote: On 21 Dec 2004 13:28:20 -0800, " wrote: You don't think this is a problem? http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...in%20Dylan.jpg http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Plaques%20and%20frames/plaque%20(Tabitha).JPG I hadn't noticed those two yet - nasty. The first machine is probably illegal to operate in the UK in a commercial workshop and is _certainly_ so in a school workshop. In fact the first one just isn't something _I'd_ do. That's the most common table-mounted router accident requiring a hospital visit (according to the HSE's figures) - a blind emerging cut, where the pushing hand goes straight into the unseen cutter. A blind emerging cut 1/4" high with a 3 1/2" high workpiece is considered hazardous? Just how would one make such a roundover in the UK? Surely a hand-held router would be considered even more dangerous (free-spinning unguarded bit along with chance for router kickback if the person forgets the proper feed direction -- see your comment below regarding kids). The second picture is one I'd cheerfully do, but I'd never let kids do it. _I_ have some idea of where my fingers are, where the bit is, and how far to separate them. Kids can't reliably do that. I think you are underestimating young teens. I know that when my dad taught me how to use power tools, the single most important comment he made was, "that blade doesn't know the difference between your finger and a piece of wood -- know where it is at all times. Seeing how that girl's concentration as she is making the cut, it appears she has been similarly admonished. |
#26
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Tue, 21 Dec 2004 18:15:26 -0700, Mark & Juanita
wrote: A blind emerging cut 1/4" high with a 3 1/2" high workpiece is considered hazardous? I can't see how big the workpiece is from that picture. Maybe it's not really that hazardous. It's certainly _considered_ hazardous - the HSE are having a real thing about emerging cuts. Looking at the actual stats for hand injuries, they seem to have a point. We might all just be careless drunks working with our eyes shut, but that's when the injuries are happening. http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/wis18.pdf http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/woodindx.htm Just how would one make such a roundover in the UK? Same way as in the picture - but not feeding it with your fingers. For a commercial workshop there's a strong pressure to fit tunnel guards for this find of work To be honest, you're going to find no (UK) school workshops and very few colleges with spindle moulders. Surely a hand-held router would be considered even more dangerous Depends on circumstances. There's a good working principle in PUWER which says that works should be done on the least-risk machine - which means the fixed vertical spindle, if you have one. However spindle moulders have a bad reputation in the UK and many people avoid having one altogether - leaving them with the free router. I think you are underestimating young teens. I'm probably underestimating that one, but deliberately so. You have to plan around the worst behaved and least attentive of the group. This is also the one most likely to whine "But _Siirr_, you let Sammy Maloof use the bandsaw!" If you can filter the group, perhaps a woodworking club, then you can achieve a lot more. Your best pupils are still the same, but you don't have to account for the less able or committed to the same extent. -- Smert' spamionam |
#27
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Andy Dingley" wrote in message ... On 21 Dec 2004 13:28:20 -0800, " wrote: You don't think this is a problem? http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oors%20plain%2 0Dylan.jpg http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...%20frames/plaq ue%20(Tabitha).JPG I hadn't noticed those two yet - nasty. The first machine is probably illegal to operate in the UK in a commercial workshop and is _certainly_ so in a school workshop. In fact the first one just isn't something _I'd_ do. That's the most common table-mounted router accident requiring a hospital visit (according to the HSE's figures) - a blind emerging cut, where the pushing hand goes straight into the unseen cutter. Through 3" of wood? I think not. The second picture is one I'd cheerfully do, but I'd never let kids do it. _I_ have some idea of where my fingers are, where the bit is, and how far to separate them. Kids can't reliably do that. I have to respectfully disagree Andy. My own kids are proof of that and I've had a few other kids that were either neighborhood kids or the kids of friends, who over the years I've taught a bit of wood working to, or have for one reason or another, have done wood working in my garage. I assure you - not all and even *most* kids that are interested in this stuff are not the absent minded air heads you typically find in the shopping malls. There's a world of bright, attentive kids out there. If you haven't crossed paths with them, then that's truly a shame, because it does your heart good to work with them. They can indeed reliably function in a wood working shop. I've read more stuff here that concerns me than what I've seen and experienced with the attentiveness and capability of the kids I've worked with. -- -Mike- |
#28
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I personally don't see a problem in any of these pics. At least the
operator appears to be concentrating on the task at hand. In fact, the only time i ever use a push stick is for ripping narrow pieces with a TS. I would rather guide things with my hands if possible, but i run WW machinery for a living, and am comfortable with that. I DO pay careful attention to where my fingers are in relation to the danger areas.BTW, I still have all my fingers attached and intact! --dave wrote in message ups.com... Mike Marlow wrote: wrote in message ups.com... Happened upon this school website http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...oodworking.htm Can YOU pick out all the safety hazards in these photos? Check out all the router table action with no push blocks or sticks, hands inches from the bit. You scare me Larry. I didn't see a picture there where they were doing anything unsafe. Push sticks on a router table is not one of the best ideas I've ever heard. Hands inches from the bit? Yeah - it's called woodworking. It requires control in order to be safe. Look at what they are routing and suggest a safer alternative. You guys serious? I'd shake your hand if you had any fingers left. You don't think this is a problem? http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/...in%20Dylan.jpg http://www.msd.k12.mo.us/vocational/woodworking/Plaques%20and%20frames/plaque%20(Tabitha).JPG ?? |
#29
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I guess I am missing the reason for alarm. Yeah, I see a couple of pics
that make me a little nervous but snapshots don't always catch the action. If the router example is the young lady in Orange, I can't imagine controlling that block she is routing with a push stick - she has her hands in a defensive position and unengaged fingers raised. The young fellow using the shaper does bother me but I don't know if the right hand crossed over the knife path or he just put it there. It is easy to pick a shop class apart from a few pics. If you look at all of them there appear to be some pretty well-trained hands and eyes among that group. |
#31
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Tue, 21 Dec 2004 08:49:47 -0600, "RonB" wrote:
BTW - Did anyone notice the PROJECTS these kids were building? Pretty impressive. I'm impressed that they even have a SHOP, or a class for it.. They haven't had shop classes in Calif. forbears, that I know of.. Kids hear you talking about high school shop class and think you're talking about training mall rats.. |
#32
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Shaper was the only one that really bothered me, too. I'm a stick and
featherboard guy. Overarm router should have a pin underneath to follow the pattern, limiting the danger. I really like the middleschoolers' stuff. They've got a lot of enthusiasm at that age, and they really like a quick project. Always a challenge to get some sort of result quickly. I liked box-jointed boxes for the first one. Teaches square and same size pieces, about a third of any woodworking project. "RonB" wrote in message news:xGWxd.19418$F25.18692@okepread07... I guess I am missing the reason for alarm. Yeah, I see a couple of pics that make me a little nervous but snapshots don't always catch the action. If the router example is the young lady in Orange, I can't imagine controlling that block she is routing with a push stick - she has her hands in a defensive position and unengaged fingers raised. The young fellow using the shaper does bother me but I don't know if the right hand crossed over the knife path or he just put it there. It is easy to pick a shop class apart from a few pics. If you look at all of them there appear to be some pretty well-trained hands and eyes among that group. |
#33
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"RonB" wrote in message
I guess I am missing the reason for alarm. Yeah, I see a couple of pics that make me a little nervous but snapshots don't always catch the action. "Dylan" on the shaper, and "Tabatha" routing that small piece, were the only ones that really made me want to say "be careful there". But the pictures certainly may not give a proper perspective. Pretty impressive work, though. -- www.e-woodshop.net Last update: 11/06/04 |
#35
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() |
#36
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "J T" wrote in message ... Tue, Dec 21, 2004, 5:11am (EST-3) says: Happened upon this school website snip I suspect none of the machines were turned on when the pictures were taken. Some were - you can see the wood chips flying. -- -Mike- |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Nice write up about LEDs | Metalworking | |||
Risk Management/Shop Safety and Advice (long) | Woodworking | |||
2- vs. 3-prong outlets | Home Repair | |||
Am I grounded? Electrically speaking. | Home Repair | |||
Safety spectacles, why so difficult? | UK diy |