I'm about to try my hand at raise paneled wainscoting in my dining room.

I've read a number of books on the subjects and have most of my
questions answered, but still have a few more.

The wainscoting will be painted white like the rest of the trim. In the
books I've been reading, they suggest that MDF works well for the
panels, but still use poplar for the rails & stiles. Is there any reason
I can't use MDF for the rails and stiles as well? This would keep
movement to essentially zero.

Secondly, what's the proper way to size the panels? The books have
suggested selecting a rail/stile width the same as the window/door trim
in the room. Given this, how do I establish a "standard" width for the
panels? There was an example in one of the books about the "golden mean"
for the rectangles, but I will still have to adjust some widths to get
them to fit in the walls. Obviously, I'll have to adjust some panel
heights to fit under the windows.

Thanks for any help.

~Mark.

"Mark Ohlund" wrote in message
news
The wainscoting will be painted white like the rest of the trim. In the
books I've been reading, they suggest that MDF works well for the
panels, but still use poplar for the rails & stiles. Is there any reason
I can't use MDF for the rails and stiles as well? This would keep
movement to essentially zero.

MDF is murder on router bits. Perhaps that's a reason to use poplar,
assuming you'll use the router for the rails and stiles. The panels can be
cut on the table saw unless you want a fancy ogee profile, but even so you
can start on the saw so you're removing less material with the router.
Personally, though, for a wainscot I'd stick with either a cove or a bevel
profile, both of which you can produce at the TS.... But i digress. I did
my family room and used MDF throughout.

The wainscoting will be painted white like the rest of the trim. In the
books I've been reading, they suggest that MDF works well for the
panels, but still use poplar for the rails & stiles. Is there any reason
I can't use MDF for the rails and stiles as well? This would keep
movement to essentially zero.

Maybe because the rails and stiles are more likely to suffer dings and
dents, and in this respect MDF doesn't hold up very well.

"mp" wrote in message ...
The wainscoting will be painted white like the rest of the trim. In the
books I've been reading, they suggest that MDF works well for the
panels, but still use poplar for the rails & stiles. Is there any reason
I can't use MDF for the rails and stiles as well? This would keep
movement to essentially zero.

Maybe because the rails and stiles are more likely to suffer dings and
dents, and in this respect MDF doesn't hold up very well.



I have used MDF for panels in the past but not for stiles and rails .the
reason, it is homogenious and has low bending strength, [breaks easily]
relative to wood which has a higher directional strength...mjh

Sorry I thought you wanted it to look like the real thing ,as it were made
of wood . So as the wainscote will not get any active use just be nailed to
the wall and if it is not abused on its way to the final destination it
should be fine .

As far as the door goes, just dont slam it .......mjh

"B a r r y" wrote in message
...
On Sat, 13 Mar 2004 08:30:53 GMT, "Mike Hide"
wrote:


I have used MDF for panels in the past but not for stiles and rails .the
reason, it is homogenious and has low bending strength, [breaks easily]
relative to wood which has a higher directional strength...mjh


I've used MDF for the entire door on several occasions.

The reason I'm not worried about stile and rail strength is that the
panel can be glued in place. When the entire door is made of a
composite material, there's very little movement, so there no reason
for the panel to float.

The only reason I used built up construction is that I don't like the
curved corners left by "MDF Door" bits. These are the bits that
simply rout a fake panel on the face of the door.

Barry