Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that
it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. The unit is about 6 years old I opened up the wiring box and everything is still well-attached Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? Thanks, Steve |
#2
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"C & S" wrote:
My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. Sounds like it may be a bad start capacitor. (It's located on the side of the motor under that little hump cover.) Open cover and look at cap for leaks and rating. Grainger, McMaster-Carr, local motor shop, good hardware store, etc, should have replacement. Lew |
#3
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"C & S" wrote in message ... My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. The unit is about 6 years old I opened up the wiring box and everything is still well-attached Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? Thanks, Steve You may have bad bearings especially if the armature is hard to turn with no power. One cause of a hum with no start condition is a bad capacitor. Lots of places sell bearings. Motor shops should have capacitors in stock. I suspect that you could buy both bearings and capacitor for less than $199. However, a motor shop might charge you more than $199 to fix your motor. Jim |
#4
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
C & S wrote:
My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. The unit is about 6 years old I opened up the wiring box and everything is still well-attached Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? Thanks, Steve I agree with the other posters that the most likely case is the start capacitor. If you have another stationary tool with a motor in the 1.5 range try swapping the capacitor to see if it's the problem. For the test the capacitor doesn't have to be an exact replacement, as long as it's close to the 400 - 480 MFD range and rated for 120V. A new capacitor will run about $10 - $15. -- Jack Novak Buffalo, NY - USA |
#5
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
Nova wrote:
C & S wrote: My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. The unit is about 6 years old I opened up the wiring box and everything is still well-attached Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? Thanks, Steve I agree with the other posters that the most likely case is the start capacitor. If you have another stationary tool with a motor in the 1.5 range try swapping the capacitor to see if it's the problem. For the test the capacitor doesn't have to be an exact replacement, as long as it's close to the 400 - 480 MFD range and rated for 120V. A new capacitor will run about $10 - $15. CORRECTION - make that 400 - 480 MFD rated for 250V. -- Jack Novak Buffalo, NY - USA |
#6
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
On Mon, 23 Mar 2009 16:55:33 -0400, "C & S"
wrote: The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. If by "wobbles back and forth" you mean the shaft moves laterally relative to the motor case, then your bearing are long gone. If you mean a rotational wobble, then I'll echo the other responses. Take the capacitor and a $10 bill to a local motor shop and get a replacement. Tom Veatch Wichita, KS USA |
#7
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"Jim" wrote in message I suspect that you could buy both bearings and capacitor for less than $199. However, a motor shop might charge you more than $199 to fix your motor. A repair shop is unlikely to charge more than a new motor might cost since they wouldn't get much business. It's not going to hurt to take the motor in and get an estimate. My 1 hp tablesaw motor bearings went a few years ago. I knew they were going from the sound but resisted taking the motor in until I sold the saw to a close friend. Estimate was $86 with a six month warranty. A new motor would have cost me $200 ca with a two year warranty. Had the motor repaired and it's run fine for the past twelve years. |
#8
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"C & S" wrote in message Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? What is the problem with a 30 mile ride? Take the wife to breakfast and stop at the motor shop. Chances are, it can be fixed for cheap if it is just a capacitor or such. |
#9
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
On Tue, 24 Mar 2009 07:33:10 -0400, "StephenM"
wrote: Good link. What's MFD anyway? It appears to be a unit of capacity (no pun intended). I assume that I need to match the physical dimmensions, the voltage and just come pretty close on the MFD. The capacitor for this motor is 125V 300MFD. Thanks, Steve Being a novice in electrical, here's what I did when my vintage Delta's drill motor stopped working, I removed the motor from the mounting and applied power, It will not rotate. With the power still on, I manually rotate the pulley, it continues to rotate and speed up to full rpm. When I switched the power off, it stopped rotating. I repeat the test a few times to be sure. I concluded that the capacitor had failed as the capacitor main function is to start the motor. However, if the motor cannot rotate manually without power on, than it could be the bearings, or if it rotates and make a sound it maybe the carbon brushes or other problems. If you have a millimeter and know how to test the motor winding do it, otherwise go 30 miles and have someone test it for you, rather than replacing the motor like I did. To continue the story... I tried to resizing both pulleys to get the RPM I need for my new motor, I found it's impossible as the pulley size will be too big to fit the constrained space. Anyone looking for a new unused Baldor motor? Make me an offer that I cannot refuse. I am in CA. I believe the capacitor you need is 7245K111. http://www.mcmaster.com/#7245k111/=14vfi5 If the spec and the size fit your motor click "1" on the "EACH" at the lower left side... and you got a new capacitor. Good luck, please tell us the result :-) BTW, C.H. Wilke Inc. no longer sell Yorkcraft and I still using the Yorkcraft 15" planner. |
#10
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"Ed Pawlowski" wrote in message ... "C & S" wrote in message Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? What is the problem with a 30 mile ride? Take the wife to breakfast and stop at the motor shop. Chances are, it can be fixed for cheap if it is just a capacitor or such. The problem with a 3o mile ride is the possibility that I have to drop it off so that they can look at it later meaning 2 trips and a not so nominal charge to declair it "not worth fixing" ... that's why I asked here to get a feel for what might be wrong. -steve |
#11
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"WD" wrote in message ... On Mon, 23 Mar 2009 16:55:33 -0400, "C & S" wrote: Yeah, you are lucky. My similar Yorkcraft's motor quit after 2 years, than I was pretty dumb. I ordered a new Baldor motor (about $250) after installing it, I found I have the wrong RPM. I have a quick sale in craigslist for $250 without the new Baldor motor. The buyer insist that I gave him the old motor. After I moved out of State and bought a used Delta DJ20, I realized that I could have repaired it by replacing the capacitor for less than $15. Go to McMaster Carr type in exactly the specifications: http://www.mcmaster.com/#capacitors/=14jbq7 Good link. What's MFD anyway? It appears to be a unit of capacity (no pun intended). I assume that I need to match the physical dimmensions, the voltage and just come pretty close on the MFD. The capacitor for this motor is 125V 300MFD. Thanks, Steve |
#13
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
In article , "StephenM" wrote:
What's MFD anyway? It appears to be a unit of capacity (no pun intended). Capacitance, actually -- a measure of the capacitor's ability to hold electric charge. MFD = microfarads. This is also sometimes shown as the Greek letter mu (which looks like a lower-case u with a tail) followed by the letter f. I assume that I need to match the physical dimmensions, the voltage and just come pretty close on the MFD. The capacitor for this motor is 125V 300MFD. There's really no need at all to match the physical dimensions. The new capacitor doesn't have to be mounted in the same orientation, or even in the same place, as the old one. It just needs to have the same electrical connections. You don't need an exact match on the voltage; anything rated between 115V and 125V will match up with about anything else rated in the same range. The capacitance needs to be a fairly close match, I'd guess +/- five or ten percent. Exact match of course is better. |
#14
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
On Mar 23, 1:55*pm, "C & S" wrote:
My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. The unit is about 6 years old I opened up the wiring box and everything is still well-attached Others have suggested 'bad start capacitor'. In addition to the start capacitor, there's a switch that connects the capacitor at startup and disconnects it during motor run. Don't be so sure you need to buy parts; I've fixed motors by cleaning sawdust from those switches. It's usually inside the bell housing of the motor, near the centrifugal arms (at speed, these weights pull a spring back and the switch opens up). |
#15
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"StephenM" wrote in message The problem with a 3o mile ride is the possibility that I have to drop it off so that they can look at it later meaning 2 trips and a not so nominal charge to declair it "not worth fixing" ... that's why I asked here to get a feel for what might be wrong. -steve The motor shops I've dealt with have never made a charge if it could not be fixed. In my case, that would only be one trip since we have a telephone. Of course, I'll drive 30 miles just to get a loaf of good bread. |
#16
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"Ed Pawlowski" wrote: Of course, I'll drive 30 miles just to get a loaf of good bread. And here I thought that was something only done in SoCalgrin Assume "good bread" includes good deli rye, something that is almost impossible to find in Socal. Lew |
#17
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
On Tue, 24 Mar 2009 22:44:46 +0000, Lew Hodgett wrote:
Assume "good bread" includes good deli rye, something that is almost impossible to find in Socal. It's pretty difficult to find in Eastern WA as well :-(. -- Intelligence is an experiment that failed - G. B. Shaw |
#18
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"Lew Hodgett" wrote in message ... "Ed Pawlowski" wrote: Of course, I'll drive 30 miles just to get a loaf of good bread. And here I thought that was something only done in SoCalgrin Assume "good bread" includes good deli rye, something that is almost impossible to find in Socal. Lew That is exactly what I mean. Widoff's Bakery in Worcester MA had a great sourdough Jewish rye, just like the old days. Just don't go the day before Christmas or Easter unless you can wait in line for a half hour at 7 AM. Same thing at Golemo's for the kielbasa. There are a few very good ethnic stores in the area. |
#19
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
"Ed Pawlowski" wrote: Same thing at Golemo's for the kielbasa. You want good fresh kielbasa or Italian sausage, ya gotta make your own. Still got my hand grinder and sausage stuffer snout at the ready. Lew |
#20
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Jointer motor failure
Try this to see where the problem is: remove the belt. Disconnect the
capacitor and jumper the two leads together that went to the capacitor. Try to start the motor. It should start, but it may start slowly and without a lot of torque. If it starts, then the internal switch and mechanism are good and you have a bad starting capacitor. If it still won't start, then the internal switch is either bad or has sawdust in between the contacts. Starting capacitors on dual voltage motors are generally rated at around 125 V (because the starting winding will only see 125 V regardless of the voltage that the motor is connected for). A ballpark for MFD rating is approx. 200 MFD per horsepower for a 3450 rpm motor. Doug "C & S" wrote in message ... My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. The unit is about 6 years old I opened up the wiring box and everything is still well-attached Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? Thanks, Steve |
#21
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Motor failure - Update/resolution
Update
I found a motor place a little closer by ... more like 20 miles. My wife brought him the capacitor and he tested it... sadly, it was good. I schlepped down there at yesterday with the rest of the motor. He opened it put right then an did quickie diagnosis. He short, he got it working in about five minutes by cleaning up the contacts on the centrifugal switch and adjusting it's tension. He said that we pull it apart and clean it up before returning it. He had it for all of 1:45 before I gat the call that I could have it back. I don't know what the bill will be but it can't be all that bad. Thanks all for the help, Steve "C & S" wrote in message ... My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. The unit is about 6 years old I opened up the wiring box and everything is still well-attached Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? Thanks, Steve |
#22
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Motor failure - Update/resolution
StephenM wrote:
Update I found a motor place a little closer by ... more like 20 miles. My wife brought him the capacitor and he tested it... sadly, it was good. I schlepped down there at yesterday with the rest of the motor. He opened it put right then an did quickie diagnosis. He short, he got it working in about five minutes by cleaning up the contacts on the centrifugal switch and adjusting it's tension. He said that we pull it apart and clean it up before returning it. He had it for all of 1:45 before I gat the call that I could have it back. I don't know what the bill will be but it can't be all that bad. Thanks all for the help, Steve "C & S" wrote in message ... My jointer, (Yorrcraft YC-8) motor quit this afternoon. The symptom is that it hums and the shaft wobbles back and forth. If I turn it manually it groans and lumbers forward. The unit is about 6 years old I opened up the wiring box and everything is still well-attached Wilke will sell me a replacement for $199 (it's a 1.5hp 110/220 TFEC motor). The one motor repair shop In the area is about 30 miles away. Do you think there is any merit to attempting to fix it or should just pry open my wallet? Thanks, Steve I had thought of that when you originally posted but did not post since it sounded like you had the motor apart, and I assumed that it had been cleaned. Exactly the same thing happened to me several years ago. I was using the saw and it stopped dead. After shopping around, I decided to have it fixed, and took the motor and my checkbook to the repair shop. It took him about the same time to fix my motor. As I remember he charged a couple of bucks for the cleaning. The good thing he showed me some places that I had not been cleaning and a couple of oil ports that I did not know exist. One point. Be caused you were trying to get the motor started you may check the wiring in the cord and off-on switch. I just discovered recently that some wires got hot and melted the insulation. I have taped them and am looking for a replacement switch for my 40 year old Craftsman table saw. Yes I know their reputation, but am not about to change as everything works perfectly and everything is in alignment. With its cast iron top it will probably passed on to my grandson and be used for another 40 years. |
#23
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Motor failure - Update/resolution
On Thu, 26 Mar 2009 08:59:16 -0400, Keith Nuttle wrote:
I have taped them and am looking for a replacement switch for my 40 year old Craftsman table saw. Yes I know their reputation, but am not about to change as everything works perfectly and everything is in alignment. With its cast iron top it will probably passed on to my grandson and be used for another 40 years. Their reputation 40 years ago was pretty darn good! I suspect you've got a keeper there. -- Intelligence is an experiment that failed - G. B. Shaw |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Synchron motor failure | UK diy | |||
what rpm motor for a jointer? | Woodworking | |||
Blower Motor Failure | Home Repair | |||
Capacitor-Run or Cap-Start motor for a Jointer? | Woodworking | |||
Failure mode of a small PM motor | Electronics Repair |