DIYbanter

DIYbanter (https://www.diybanter.com/)
-   Woodworking (https://www.diybanter.com/woodworking/)
-   -   Florida bookcase tragedy (https://www.diybanter.com/woodworking/183909-florida-bookcase-tragedy.html)

Tim W November 26th 06 08:09 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm



[email protected] November 26th 06 09:01 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
bloody hell. Thats one of the maddest things i've heard in a long
time.

Theres probably a lesson to be learnt, but i've no idea what!

Barry
www.woodworking.wizkids.co.uk


Pete C. November 26th 06 09:06 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
" wrote:

bloody hell. Thats one of the maddest things i've heard in a long
time.

Theres probably a lesson to be learnt, but i've no idea what!

Barry
www.woodworking.wizkids.co.uk


Well, if it happened in the UK there would probably be an uproar to ban
bookcases. Never heard anywhere else insane enough to even talk about
banning kitchen knives. Damn, those 15" razor sharp planer knives must
be banned already, better hide them...

J T November 26th 06 09:30 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 8:09pm (EST+5)
(Tim*W) did post a story:

Sounds like BS - or a troll - to me. When's the last time you've
seen a bookcase out from the wall, unless someone's moved it? They
called in the cops, and the cops didn't even look in her room - or
notice the small - or notice the foot sticking out? IF there actually
was a body behind a bookcase, and I was a cop on the case, I'd be
wondering if someone had stuffed her back there.



JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


WoodButcher November 26th 06 09:51 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
11 days with a dead body in the house and nobody smelled it???
Smells like bull**** to me.

Art

"Tim W" wrote
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm





Pete C. November 26th 06 10:30 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
J T wrote:

Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 8:09pm (EST+5)
(Tim W) did post a story:

Sounds like BS - or a troll - to me. When's the last time you've
seen a bookcase out from the wall, unless someone's moved it? They
called in the cops, and the cops didn't even look in her room - or
notice the small - or notice the foot sticking out? IF there actually
was a body behind a bookcase, and I was a cop on the case, I'd be
wondering if someone had stuffed her back there.

JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


It's on CNN as well:

http://www.cnn.com/2006/US/11/25/boo....ap/index.html

It's out of season for April Fools jokes too.

Pete C.

Joe Bemier November 26th 06 10:48 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On Sun, 26 Nov 2006 21:06:09 GMT, "Pete C."
wrote:

Well, if it happened in the UK there would probably be an uproar to ban
bookcases.


No....wait....**BookCaseStop**....!
This is not just fingers, this device would save lives
Come on - lets get behind this.

Leon November 26th 06 11:12 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 

"J T" wrote in message
...
Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 8:09pm (EST+5)
(Tim W) did post a story:

Sounds like BS - or a troll - to me. When's the last time you've
seen a bookcase out from the wall, unless someone's moved it? They
called in the cops, and the cops didn't even look in her room - or
notice the small - or notice the foot sticking out? IF there actually
was a body behind a bookcase, and I was a cop on the case, I'd be
wondering if someone had stuffed her back there.


I agree.. If she could not get out, why did she not scream for help?
Probably the parents felt that after 38 years it was time that she moved out
one way or the other.



CW November 26th 06 11:24 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Read the atrticle again, slowly.

"WoodButcher" wrote in message
. ..
11 days with a dead body in the house and nobody smelled it???
Smells like bull**** to me.

Art

"Tim W" wrote
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm







George E. Cawthon November 26th 06 11:38 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Leon wrote:
"J T" wrote in message
...
Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 8:09pm (EST+5)
(Tim W) did post a story:

Sounds like BS - or a troll - to me. When's the last time you've
seen a bookcase out from the wall, unless someone's moved it? They
called in the cops, and the cops didn't even look in her room - or
notice the small - or notice the foot sticking out? IF there actually
was a body behind a bookcase, and I was a cop on the case, I'd be
wondering if someone had stuffed her back there.


I agree.. If she could not get out, why did she not scream for help?
Probably the parents felt that after 38 years it was time that she moved out
one way or the other.



It is in the paper today, so it is not a troll.
The article in our paper says that she probably
fell back there trying to adjust an electric plug.
If she fell down and depending on the
dimensions, she could easily have been compressed
enough to eliminate any yelling and quickly suffocate.

I also, can't figure out why nobody checked the
room completely or noticed the foot? But, many
people are completely unaware of most things about
them. And, stupidity knows no bounds!


Tim W November 26th 06 11:45 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 

"J T" wrote in message
...
Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 8:09pm (EST+5)
(Tim W) did post a story:

Sounds like BS - or a troll - to me.

It's the BBC, not known for BS and if you want you can trace the original
report from the Local paper - St Petersburg Chronicle or something.

tim W



Leon November 26th 06 11:51 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 

"George E. Cawthon" wrote in message
...



It is in the paper today, so it is not a troll. The article in our paper
says that she probably fell back there trying to adjust an electric plug.
If she fell down and depending on the dimensions, she could easily have
been compressed enough to eliminate any yelling and quickly suffocate.


Yeah I actually feel that she probably knocker herself out and never
regained consciousness.


I also, can't figure out why nobody checked the room completely or noticed
the foot? But, many people are completely unaware of most things about
them. And, stupidity knows no bounds!


Yup. I do more thorough looks for less significant objects.



Pete C. November 27th 06 12:04 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Leon wrote:

"George E. Cawthon" wrote in message
...



It is in the paper today, so it is not a troll. The article in our paper
says that she probably fell back there trying to adjust an electric plug.
If she fell down and depending on the dimensions, she could easily have
been compressed enough to eliminate any yelling and quickly suffocate.


Yeah I actually feel that she probably knocker herself out and never
regained consciousness.


I also, can't figure out why nobody checked the room completely or noticed
the foot? But, many people are completely unaware of most things about
them. And, stupidity knows no bounds!


Yup. I do more thorough looks for less significant objects.


Also even for more aware folks, when you are looking for a large object
i.e. person, you tend not to look in small places as you would for lost
keys.

Pete C.

George Max November 27th 06 12:19 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On Sun, 26 Nov 2006 20:09:02 GMT, "Tim W"
wrote:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm


Wow.

This is another feature to add to my next project. A hidden drawer, a
flip out shelf, an old lady trap. ;)
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
Sorry to be so flip. If true, the womans family is very sad at this
time.

WoodButcher November 27th 06 12:28 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Doh!

"CW" wrote in message
ink.net...
Read the atrticle again, slowly.

"WoodButcher" wrote in message
. ..
11 days with a dead body in the house and nobody smelled it???
Smells like bull**** to me.

Art

"Tim W" wrote
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm









J T November 27th 06 01:22 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 10:30pm (EST+5) (Pete*C.) doth
sayeth:
It's on CNN as well: snip

Which only proves that CNN picked up the story also.

However, it is quite interesting that CNN has some thingls not
included in the other story, and which do absolutely nothing to make me
less suspicious. If she was that damn tiny, why not just reach behind
the bookcase while standing on the floor, rather than standing on a
bureau and reaching over? In my experience, it would be pretty easy to
tip over a bookcase, especially with the leverage being against a wall
would give you, even someone that small. And, if I walked into a room,
and saw a bookcase that far from a wall, I'd go look behind it,
especially with a "rat" smell coming from "somewhere"; because, if for
nothing else, I'd be looking for a place to set some rat traps and/or
dead rat.

Reporters have lied before; could be the case here, or someone
stuffed her behind there. Or, she was actually that stupid, and died
from it. I'm not a cop on the scene, so don't know. What I do know is,
the information that I do have makes me suspicious that one way or
another this is BS.

quote Family members scoured her room for clues but found nothing,
although they did notice a strange smell.
On Nov. 9, Weber's sister went into her bedroom and looked behind a
bookcase, where she saw the woman's foot. Using a flashlight, the family
saw Weber was wedged upside-down behind the unit.
"I'm sleeping in the same house as her for 11 days, looking for her,"
her mother, Connie Weber, told the St. Petersburg Times. "And she's
right in the bedroom."
Both Weber and her sister previously had adjusted the television plug by
standing on a bureau next to the shelf and leaning over the top. Her
family believes Weber, who was 5-foot-3 and barely 100 pounds, may have
fallen headfirst into the space.
"She's a little thing," her mother said. "And the bookcase is 6 feet
tall and solid. And she couldn't get out." end quote



JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


John November 27th 06 01:38 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
O.K. GOAT, how about you give us the full story on the O.J. thing.
You're sooo smart, it should be easy for you.


Mark & Juanita November 27th 06 05:41 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On Sun, 26 Nov 2006 22:30:02 GMT, "Pete C." wrote:

J T wrote:

Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 8:09pm (EST+5)
(Tim W) did post a story:

Sounds like BS - or a troll - to me. When's the last time you've
seen a bookcase out from the wall, unless someone's moved it? They
called in the cops, and the cops didn't even look in her room - or
notice the small - or notice the foot sticking out? IF there actually
was a body behind a bookcase, and I was a cop on the case, I'd be
wondering if someone had stuffed her back there.

JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


It's on CNN as well:


Oh, well, if CNN says it, it must be true.

[yeah, right]

Agree with others here, this just doesn't pass the smell test (no pun
intended).



+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

If you're gonna be dumb, you better be tough

+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Bill in Detroit November 27th 06 05:58 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Joe Bemier wrote:
On Sun, 26 Nov 2006 21:06:09 GMT, "Pete C."
wrote:

Well, if it happened in the UK there would probably be an uproar to ban
bookcases.


No....wait....**BookCaseStop**....!
This is not just fingers, this device would save lives
Come on - lets get behind this.


As of today, any bookcase I design will have an escape hatch.

LRod November 27th 06 11:51 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On Sun, 26 Nov 2006 23:45:51 GMT, "Tim W"
wrote:

It's the BBC, not known for BS and if you want you can trace the original
report from the Local paper - St Petersburg Chronicle or something.


St. Petersburg Times.

I read the article and the obit. I feel there is something that isn't
being told. And not that it lessens the heartache for the family, but
it might help explain how it happened. 38 years old, living at home,
physically quite small, extremely menial job by the sound of it. I
wonder if this woman had "special needs." Especially as the suspected
scenario was an abduction.

But the smell part bothers me. I've had dead things in the house on
two occasions. It's not a smell you can ignore. Granted, it's not
always easy to track down (never did find the carcasses in either
case), especially if it's a rodent, but if you have a missing person
AND an odor, it seems to me it's time to tear the house apart.

--
LRod

Master Woodbutcher and seasoned termite

Shamelessly whoring my website since 1999

http://www.woodbutcher.net

Proud participant of rec.woodworking since February, 1997

email addy de-spam-ified due to 1,000 spams per month.
If you can't figure out how to use it, I probably wouldn't
care to correspond with you anyway.

Joe Bemier November 27th 06 01:01 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On Mon, 27 Nov 2006 11:51:09 +0000, LRod
wrote:

On Sun, 26 Nov 2006 23:45:51 GMT, "Tim W"
wrote:

It's the BBC, not known for BS and if you want you can trace the original
report from the Local paper - St Petersburg Chronicle or something.


St. Petersburg Times.

I read the article and the obit. I feel there is something that isn't
being told. And not that it lessens the heartache for the family, but
it might help explain how it happened. 38 years old, living at home,
physically quite small, extremely menial job by the sound of it. I
wonder if this woman had "special needs." Especially as the suspected
scenario was an abduction.

But the smell part bothers me. I've had dead things in the house on
two occasions. It's not a smell you can ignore. Granted, it's not
always easy to track down (never did find the carcasses in either
case), especially if it's a rodent, but if you have a missing person
AND an odor, it seems to me it's time to tear the house apart.



I agree with you.

This is a quote from the Chicago Tribune....
"A spokesman for the Pasco County Sheriff's Office said Mariesa
Weber's death was not suspicious."

I would be interested to know how they came to that conclusion.

George November 27th 06 01:34 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 

"Tim W" wrote in message
...

"J T" wrote in message
...
Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 8:09pm (EST+5)
(Tim W) did post a story:

Sounds like BS - or a troll - to me.

It's the BBC, not known for BS and if you want you can trace the original
report from the Local paper - St Petersburg Chronicle or something.


BBC _not_ known for BS? Yeah, right. Neither is the NYT.

Nonetheless, having been on more than enough DRTLW calls, humans smell just
like dead rats, only larger, therefore longer. If no one was home during
the brief time she might have been able to yell before the presumably full
and therefore heavy bookcase and the weight of her internal organs
suffocated her, then it's certainly not suspicious. Lividity would let them
know if the body had remained in any other position very long, even if there
were no other injuries besides the small hemorrhages known in cases of
suffocation.

Police seldom look at the home of a missing adult, even if the occupants
grant them entrance. Not to mention that adults are considered to have the
right to go wherever they want and stay as long as they care to.


DonkeyHody November 27th 06 01:39 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 


I also, can't figure out why nobody checked the
room completely or noticed the foot? But, many
people are completely unaware of most things about
them. And, stupidity knows no bounds!


About a year ago, in a small town near me, a man who lived alone was
reported missing by his family. The cops searched for him for two
weeks until a family member noticed a strange smell in his bedroom. He
was lying in his own bed "under a pile of clothes".

DonkeyHody
"If your only tool is a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a
nail." - Abraham Maslow


Pete C. November 27th 06 02:45 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Mark & Juanita wrote:

On Sun, 26 Nov 2006 22:30:02 GMT, "Pete C." wrote:

J T wrote:

Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 8:09pm (EST+5)
(Tim W) did post a story:

Sounds like BS - or a troll - to me. When's the last time you've
seen a bookcase out from the wall, unless someone's moved it? They
called in the cops, and the cops didn't even look in her room - or
notice the small - or notice the foot sticking out? IF there actually
was a body behind a bookcase, and I was a cop on the case, I'd be
wondering if someone had stuffed her back there.

JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


It's on CNN as well:


Oh, well, if CNN says it, it must be true.

[yeah, right]

Agree with others here, this just doesn't pass the smell test (no pun
intended).

+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

If you're gonna be dumb, you better be tough

+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------+


That wasn't my point. While the details of the case may or not be
suspicious, the fact that so many news services have picked up the story
certainly clears it of the BS / Troll claim.

Pete C.

J T November 27th 06 04:08 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 7:38pm (EST-1) From: (John) doth now
burble:
O.K. GOAT, how about you give us the full story on the O.J. thing.
You're sooo smart, it should be easy for you.

Yeah, I can tell you. No prob. He had a trial. He was found not
guilty. That's all you need to know.



JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


Bill in Detroit November 27th 06 05:19 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
J T wrote:
Sun, Nov 26, 2006, 7:38pm (EST-1) From: (John) doth now
burble:
O.K. GOAT, how about you give us the full story on the O.J. thing.
You're sooo smart, it should be easy for you.

Yeah, I can tell you. No prob. He had a trial. He was found not
guilty. That's all you need to know.



JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.

"In for a dime, in for a dollar ..." Tell the whole story.

He had a second trial under civil law. He was found guilty and ordered
to pay a huge fine. He has not, to this day, paid a cent.

criminal trial required "beyond the shadow of doubt"
civil trial required "preponderance of evidence"

Bill

J. Clarke November 27th 06 05:30 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On Mon, 27 Nov 2006 00:58:54 -0500, Bill in Detroit wrote:

Joe Bemier wrote:
On Sun, 26 Nov 2006 21:06:09 GMT, "Pete C."
wrote:

Well, if it happened in the UK there would probably be an uproar to ban
bookcases.


No....wait....**BookCaseStop**....!
This is not just fingers, this device would save lives
Come on - lets get behind this.


As of today, any bookcase I design will have an escape hatch.


Just as an engineering exercise, it might be interesting to figure out how
to design a bookcase that prevented this risk while not standing a
ludicrous distance from the wall or presenting a tipping hazard.

--
--John
to email, dial "usenet" and validate
(was jclarke at eye bee em dot net)

Bill in Detroit November 27th 06 08:18 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
J. Clarke wrote:

Just as an engineering exercise, it might be interesting to figure out how
to design a bookcase that prevented this risk while not standing a
ludicrous distance from the wall or presenting a tipping hazard.

Attach it to the wall with screws driven behind the shelving or French
cleats?

It sounds like it must already have been several inches from the wall
because 1) the object she was fishing out fell behind it and 2) when she
fell behind it, it did not tip.

How is it that an entire human being could get wedged back there and NOT
tip it? The only possibility that comes to mind is that the bookshelf
was fairly deep.

I still think that this one deserves close scrutiny by the coroner.

J T November 27th 06 11:07 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Mon, Nov 27, 2006, 3:18pm (Bill*in*Detroit) doth
sayeth:
snip I still think that this one deserves close scrutiny by the
coroner.

I find it hard to imagine that any size bookcase 6' tall couldn't
be pretty easily tipped.

This "adjusting the TV plug" sticks in my mind. If the electrical
plug is what's meant I've never seen any plug higher off the floor then
a foot or so, at least not in a bedroom or other living space anyway.

I agree.



JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


Brian Henderson November 28th 06 12:03 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On Mon, 27 Nov 2006 12:19:13 -0500, Bill in Detroit
wrote:

He had a second trial under civil law. He was found guilty and ordered
to pay a huge fine. He has not, to this day, paid a cent.


Not only that, but he has pointedly said he will *NEVER* pay and has
purposely hidden all of his assets in order to avoid paying anything.
This whole book deal was specifically brokered so that he's never
actually receive any money in his own name, it would go to someone
else and be safe from confiscation under the law.

RicodJour November 28th 06 04:01 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Tim W wrote:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm


Amazing the amount of judgments and assumptions made so far. Maybe a
more complete report will help answer some questions and lay suspicions
to rest.
http://www.bradenton.com/mld/bradent...l/16099174.htm

R


LRod November 28th 06 05:10 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On 27 Nov 2006 20:01:43 -0800, "RicodJour"
wrote:

Tim W wrote:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm


Amazing the amount of judgments and assumptions made so far. Maybe a
more complete report will help answer some questions and lay suspicions
to rest.
http://www.bradenton.com/mld/bradent...l/16099174.htm


I believe (based on the St. Petersburg Times byline) that this is the
same article as published in the St. Petersburg Times. I had already
read it. The questions I raised in my post above, which were based on
my reading of the article, remain unresolved.

--
LRod

Master Woodbutcher and seasoned termite

Shamelessly whoring my website since 1999

http://www.woodbutcher.net

Proud participant of rec.woodworking since February, 1997

email addy de-spam-ified due to 1,000 spams per month.
If you can't figure out how to use it, I probably wouldn't
care to correspond with you anyway.

Bill in Detroit November 28th 06 09:09 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
RicodJour wrote:
Tim W wrote:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm


Amazing the amount of judgments and assumptions made so far. Maybe a
more complete report will help answer some questions and lay suspicions
to rest.
http://www.bradenton.com/mld/bradent...l/16099174.htm

R


Nope ... just arouses more.

A freestanding 72" book case is unlikely to have been more than about
60" wide and far more likely to have been about 48" wide. (Golden Mean
would call for it to be ~44.5") And yes, that IS an assumption. And it
also makes it hard to conceive of a way that the entire body (5' 3")
could have been hidden from view. Or a reason why she would have gone
over the top of it to deal with an electrical plug (her Dad says he
found her inverted ... not horizontal). Or, having been able to tip it
out enough to fall in behind it she was not able to tip it out enough to
free herself. Or how, if she didn't have to tip it outward to fall
behind it, it still managed to pin her immobile.

The family was just getting ready to sit down to dinner. No one in the
house could hear her? Dad, Mom, Sister? Nobody heard? If she was trying
to adjust the plug for the tv in her room, apparently the tv wasn't
working. So it didn't cover her cries. According to her Mom she was
speaking lucidly and audibly immediately before entering the bedroom.

Age 38, no children, scrawny*, punker tattoo on her ankle, living with
her parents, working in a minor job.

There is a LOT between the lines here.

Yeah ... I suppose it's possible that this was some sort of freak
accident. I suppose it's possible that I'll find a winning Powerball
ticket on my front porch tomorrow.

Bill

* BMI of well under 18
http://www.bariatricedge.com/dtcf/pa...calculator.htm
** name of a guy who either committed suicide or botched a one-man orgy
and who died in 1997
http://www.findadeath.com/Deceased/h...Hutchence.html
--
Life is like playing a violin in public and learning the instrument as
one goes on.
Samuel Butler (1835 - 1902)

J. Clarke November 28th 06 01:00 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
On Mon, 27 Nov 2006 15:18:30 -0500, Bill in Detroit wrote:

J. Clarke wrote:

Just as an engineering exercise, it might be interesting to figure out how
to design a bookcase that prevented this risk while not standing a
ludicrous distance from the wall or presenting a tipping hazard.

Attach it to the wall with screws driven behind the shelving or French
cleats?


How do you reach the plug behind it?

It sounds like it must already have been several inches from the wall
because 1) the object she was fishing out fell behind it


She wasn't "fishing out an object", she was plugging something in or
unplugging something.

and 2) when she
fell behind it, it did not tip.


The main point is that it was far enough from the wall to accommodate an
electrical plug. This would be one of the design criteria for the
exercise, that there be some provision for dealing with electrical outlets
behind the bookcase.

How is it that an entire human being could get wedged back there and NOT
tip it? The only possibility that comes to mind is that the bookshelf
was fairly deep.

I still think that this one deserves close scrutiny by the coroner.


--
--John
to email, dial "usenet" and validate
(was jclarke at eye bee em dot net)

RicodJour November 28th 06 01:35 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 

Bill in Detroit wrote:
RicodJour wrote:
Tim W wrote:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/6185854.stm


Amazing the amount of judgments and assumptions made so far. Maybe a
more complete report will help answer some questions and lay suspicions
to rest.
http://www.bradenton.com/mld/bradent...l/16099174.htm

R


Nope ... just arouses more.


More assumptions it seems.

A freestanding 72" book case is unlikely to have been more than about
60" wide and far more likely to have been about 48" wide. (Golden Mean
would call for it to be ~44.5") And yes, that IS an assumption. And it
also makes it hard to conceive of a way that the entire body (5' 3")
could have been hidden from view. Or a reason why she would have gone
over the top of it to deal with an electrical plug (her Dad says he
found her inverted ... not horizontal). Or, having been able to tip it
out enough to fall in behind it she was not able to tip it out enough to
free herself. Or how, if she didn't have to tip it outward to fall
behind it, it still managed to pin her immobile.

The family was just getting ready to sit down to dinner. No one in the
house could hear her? Dad, Mom, Sister? Nobody heard? If she was trying
to adjust the plug for the tv in her room, apparently the tv wasn't
working. So it didn't cover her cries. According to her Mom she was
speaking lucidly and audibly immediately before entering the bedroom.

Age 38, no children, scrawny*, punker tattoo on her ankle, living with
her parents, working in a minor job.

There is a LOT between the lines here.

Yeah ... I suppose it's possible that this was some sort of freak
accident. I suppose it's possible that I'll find a winning Powerball
ticket on my front porch tomorrow.


Everything you wrote is an assumption.
Google the Darwin awards - strange things kill people all of the time.
People win the lottery all of the time
Exactly how big is a 5'3" 100 pound woman supposed to be to prevent
being called scrawny by an armchair quarterback?
If she were married, would she not be scrawny, not have the tattoo or
not be dead?
There was a plug strip. That's like an extension cord. Usually those
are used in areas where you need more outlets and/or in a more
convenient location. The more convenient location is not always the
most convenient location.
Maybe the bookcase was on the diagonal in a corner. That's a
possibility, not an assumption.
You neglected to assume what was on the bookcase besides the TV, how
much the stuff weighed and the distribution of that weight. From there
you can make calculated assumptions (you know, more assumptions) about
the force required to overturn the bookcase in your assumed location.
Show all work.
There apparently were sections of the article dealing with inverted
suffocation that you didn't read. Perhaps you should read them.

Other than that, good post.

R


George November 28th 06 03:29 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 

"J. Clarke" wrote in message
...
On Mon, 27 Nov 2006 15:18:30 -0500, Bill in Detroit wrote:

J. Clarke wrote:

Just as an engineering exercise, it might be interesting to figure out
how
to design a bookcase that prevented this risk while not standing a
ludicrous distance from the wall or presenting a tipping hazard.

Attach it to the wall with screws driven behind the shelving or French
cleats?


How do you reach the plug behind it?


Remove the _Life of Thomas Edison_ and reveal the direct path to the plug?

I've got one where the plug is behind Clay Blair's excellent work on US
submarines in WWII, _Silent Victory_.

Doesn't take a lot of forethought if you're building the case yourself, sort
of like building in the path for the cold air return underneath the grille
you attached in the kick.


Locutus November 28th 06 09:34 PM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 

"DonkeyHody" wrote in message
ups.com...


I also, can't figure out why nobody checked the
room completely or noticed the foot? But, many
people are completely unaware of most things about
them. And, stupidity knows no bounds!


About a year ago, in a small town near me, a man who lived alone was
reported missing by his family. The cops searched for him for two
weeks until a family member noticed a strange smell in his bedroom. He
was lying in his own bed "under a pile of clothes".

DonkeyHody
"If your only tool is a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a
nail." - Abraham Maslow


How did the clothes get on top of him?



J T November 29th 06 01:06 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
Tue, Nov 28, 2006, 4:34pm (Locutus) asked:
How did the clothes get on top of him?

I wondered about that too. Also wondered how the girl would have
gotten on top of the bureau? Step up on a chair? If so the chair
should've still been there.



JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


Pete C. November 29th 06 03:28 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 
J T wrote:

Tue, Nov 28, 2006, 4:34pm (Locutus) asked:
How did the clothes get on top of him?

I wondered about that too. Also wondered how the girl would have
gotten on top of the bureau? Step up on a chair? If so the chair
should've still been there.

JOAT
Democratic justice. One man, one rock.


Under a pile of clothes is easy, try making your bed, then dump a pile
of laundry on top, now crawl into bed under the mess. If it was someone
poor who couldn't afford to heat the place properly it's more insulation
too, not just a mess.

Pete C.

RicodJour November 29th 06 05:17 AM

Florida bookcase tragedy
 

J T wrote:
Tue, Nov 28, 2006, 4:34pm (Locutus) asked:
How did the clothes get on top of him?

I wondered about that too. Also wondered how the girl would have
gotten on top of the bureau? Step up on a chair? If so the chair
should've still been there.


Second article link:
"Mariesa's television was plugged into a power strip that ran to an
outlet behind a tall wooden bookshelf with a solid back. Whenever
something went wrong with a plug, she or Gina stood on a bureau next to
the shelf and leaned over the top to make an adjustment. Maybe this
time she leaned too far and pitched headfirst over the edge."

R



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:53 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 DIYbanter