Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
I see several posts asking for the plans to build whatever. I rarely build
using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. When someone wants something made, all I really want is a few photos of what they want and I'll design/build it based loosely on what they had in mind. I make several mistakes this way but it's part of the learning process. I love the challenge. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave -- Today's mighty oak is just yesterday's nut that held its ground. |
#2
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of
your pants. Dave Both. A few recent projects as examples: My recent mission style bed project was built pretty closely to a set of plans (August Home/Woodsmith), though I tweaked the dimensions a little and came up with my own bed rail fastening system. The spice rack I built was entirely my own design, based on the sizes of the spice jars that were in our cupboard. I did google around to look at photos of others' designs, but didn't base my design on any in particular. My router table is entirely my own design - designed around the scraps I had on hand, and made to fit in my B&D Workmate. Thus it's swapable with my stationary belt-disc sander etc. The rocking chair I'm working on is based very loosely on a plan (American Furniture Design), but I basically used that for some of the dimensions and angles. This plan contains very few of the pictures/tips/jigs I found useful in the August Home plan, and the CAD drawings that came with the rocking chair plan are poorly done and inconsistent with the single photo of the original chair. So again, I found all the pictures of mission style rockers I could, measured all the chairs I could find, picked elements of each that I liked or didn't like, and sketched up my own diagram that I'm building from. I'm thinking that it would probably be beneficial to teach myself how to use Google Sketchup or some basic CAD program, but I just haven't motivated myself to spend a few hours in front of a computer when I could spend a few hours with some wood instead. The only problems I've had with my own sketches/plans have occurred when I didn't look at them often enough. Andy |
#3
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
Teamcasa wrote:
Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. I usually work from a plan and cutlist, but in the vast majority of cases, _I_ created the plan and cutlist. If the project is based on an existing item, the plan is created from photos and descriptions of the item. The "plan" is usually nothing more than an 11"x17" pencil line drawing, with notes jotted down as to specific details that I don't want to forget. My cutlists are usually simple Excel printouts. Each project gets a clipboard, and parts are stretch-wrapped together and labeled, as I usually have more than one project going at a time. Shop projects, etc... usually don't warrant a plan. I've occasionally used commercial plans, not for an entire project, but for a detailed explanation of how a specific idea is executed. Sometimes, there's no point in reinventing the wheel. Personally, I've found the most difficult and mistake-prone way to work is to modify a plan on the fly that I didn't create. |
#4
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
In article , "Teamcasa" wrote:
I see several posts asking for the plans to build whatever. I rarely build using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. When someone wants something made, all I really want is a few photos of what they want and I'll design/build it based loosely on what they had in mind. I make several mistakes this way but it's part of the learning process. I love the challenge. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. I always build from plans. Sometimes, they're other people's plans, either purchased or free downloads. Usually, they're my own plans -- which are frequently just sketches with dimensions, and a picture in in my head. But I always, always, always build from some kind of plan. -- Regards, Doug Miller (alphageek at milmac dot com) It's time to throw all their damned tea in the harbor again. |
#5
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
|
#6
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
Andy wrote:
Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. I might make a rough sketch from the idea in my head if the project is complicated enough. As far as using plans from other sources, I only look at them to get different ideas of how something might go together. To me, woodworking is a process that begins with an idea and ends with the finished product. Building something according to an existing plan cuts out an integral (and fun) part of that process. |
#7
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
On Thu, 12 Oct 2006 09:13:35 -0700, "Teamcasa"
wrote: Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. I generally have an outline as to what, but serenidipty strikes more often than does Murphy. But frustrating Murphy rather than me always makes me happy. Mark (sixoneeight) = 618 |
#8
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
I'm a recent requester of plans for sideboard -- more for generating
some ideas rather than producing a piece. In this case, the sideboard is a gift for my son and daughter-in-law and I just wanted a few plans/pix to make sure what I produce is what they really want. Teamcasa wrote: I see several posts asking for the plans to build whatever. I rarely build using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. When someone wants something made, all I really want is a few photos of what they want and I'll design/build it based loosely on what they had in mind. I make several mistakes this way but it's part of the learning process. I love the challenge. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave |
#9
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave Build from plans when you don't have one. Then run around getting the material called for in the plan. Or mess around with the plan, substitute material and dimensions, and likely mess up the project. Or get a plan in your head from other plans or pictures, mull it around a bit, sketch it out for the joints and build it with the material you have. At least your not building what someone else has built before you. Call it original design if that makes you happy. I get the idea and work out the details in my mind, sketching where I need to, Lay out my material, write all over it, sand it off, do it again, revise the plan because the material doesn't fit, down/up size the plan, get more material if I really feel I need it. This takes a month. Start cutting to size, need a jig - build one (jig takes 2 days, cutting takes 10 min), dry fit, cut some more material, more dry fit, change plans because I got a better idea, complete all the cutting and final dry fit. Begin glue up, take back down because I got ahead of myself in the glue up sequence, curse the glue squeeze out, fix that, recut the piece that doesn't fit, complete the assembly. This takes a week or so, depending on project size and complexity - your time may vary. Grab a coffee, have a smoke and watch the glue dry. Sand the snot out of it with progressively finer papers, make a great show of being fussy, damp wipe the project down to raise the grain and find missed spots to resand, lighly sand again. Grab more coffee and a smoke and watch the wood dry while looking for areas that need more sanding. This takes about 2-3 days. Give it a first coat of oil/stain and curse your blindness for missing that obvious sanding swirl that didn't show up when damp wiping, resand and curse some more. Complete the finishing, sanding out the damn fruit flies that came out of no where and landed in the last wet coat, wax it. Grab another cuppa and a smoke, sit down and finally see all the stupid mistakes you made, and curse some more. Plan the next project. If this hasn't happened to you, you don't enjoy working with wood and need a new pastime like bottle cap collecting. Pete |
#11
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
"Teamcasa" wrote in message
Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. I've never built from someone else's plans, but when I get an idea of something I want to build, I usually draw my own detailed plans. |
#12
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
On Thu, 12 Oct 2006 09:13:35 -0700, "Teamcasa"
wrote: I see several posts asking for the plans to build whatever. I rarely build using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. When someone wants something made, all I really want is a few photos of what they want and I'll design/build it based loosely on what they had in mind. I make several mistakes this way but it's part of the learning process. I love the challenge. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Seat of my pants, now- but when I was starting out making "real" furniture (as opposed to sawhorses and nailed-together 2x4 benches) I used plans until I got a good idea of what joints were availible, when they were appropriate, what approaches I did and didn't like, and glue-up procedures. Without that initial education via plans, I think my current projects would be suffering. I don't bother with cutlists, either- I've got a lathe, and do little projects as well, so I just get a couple more planks than I think I need, and keep the extra in the shop for some future project. I might plan out buying hardwood ply, but I don't use that much. |
#13
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
"Upscale" wrote in message ... "Teamcasa" wrote in message Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. I've never built from someone else's plans, but when I get an idea of something I want to build, I usually draw my own detailed plans. That's mostly what I do as well. Sometimes I'll detail out a particulair connection just to get a better idea on what order to make the cuts or should I mortise first, shape later or shape first, mortise later. Oh the sweet delima. I also agree with Pete's statement "If this ... (put togeather - take apart) hasn't happened to you, you don't enjoy working with wood and need a new pastime like bottle cap collecting." Dave |
#14
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
Teamcasa wrote: ... I rarely build using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. I'm really fond of the planning process; there's always a plan. The making of an esthetic whole out of materials, processes, and techniques is my definition of a satisfying craft (or craft hobby). There's three stages of a project (bookshelf, room moulding, room rearrangement... whatever). First you identify the goal; bookshelf for books this size, in this quantity, in this location in the house. Second, you put together a plausible scheme to reach the goal (shelf boards this width, of softwood, vertical supports blind-sliding-halfdovetailed in plywood, finished before cutting, and a cutting plan based on standard lumber sizes). Third, you make the trip to the lumberyard and transition those boards from raw wood to furniture-plus-sawdust. Sometimes it pays off big; sometimes you have happy accidents on the way and the plan changes. I ran into a sample-size display of stains while shopping for lumber, and my playing with different stains and woods soaked up an extra weekend. Sometimes you hit a hitch and have to re-plan or accept the uneven staining as a gift of the wood... And years of enjoyment of the project can be had if the plan is sound, while months of dissatisfaction can result if the wood finish sticks to your books. The plan DID call for finishing applied weeks ahead of final assembly, I'm happy to say. |
#15
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
Teamcasa wrote: I see several posts asking for the plans to build whatever. I rarely build using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. When someone wants something made, all I really want is a few photos of what they want and I'll design/build it based loosely on what they had in mind. I make several mistakes this way but it's part of the learning process. I love the challenge. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave I rarely have the luxury to work so loosely. I design in the laptop for most of my clients, generally on site with a tape measure in hand. I take it home and detail it out from there. I usually have a complete cutlist and drawings of plan and elevation views complete before I buy any wood. |
#16
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
LMAO, sounds familiar....
Allen wrote in message ... Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave Build from plans when you don't have one. Then run around getting the material called for in the plan. Or mess around with the plan, substitute material and dimensions, and likely mess up the project. Or get a plan in your head from other plans or pictures, mull it around a bit, sketch it out for the joints and build it with the material you have. At least your not building what someone else has built before you. Call it original design if that makes you happy. I get the idea and work out the details in my mind, sketching where I need to, Lay out my material, write all over it, sand it off, do it again, revise the plan because the material doesn't fit, down/up size the plan, get more material if I really feel I need it. This takes a month. Start cutting to size, need a jig - build one (jig takes 2 days, cutting takes 10 min), dry fit, cut some more material, more dry fit, change plans because I got a better idea, complete all the cutting and final dry fit. Begin glue up, take back down because I got ahead of myself in the glue up sequence, curse the glue squeeze out, fix that, recut the piece that doesn't fit, complete the assembly. This takes a week or so, depending on project size and complexity - your time may vary. Grab a coffee, have a smoke and watch the glue dry. Sand the snot out of it with progressively finer papers, make a great show of being fussy, damp wipe the project down to raise the grain and find missed spots to resand, lighly sand again. Grab more coffee and a smoke and watch the wood dry while looking for areas that need more sanding. This takes about 2-3 days. Give it a first coat of oil/stain and curse your blindness for missing that obvious sanding swirl that didn't show up when damp wiping, resand and curse some more. Complete the finishing, sanding out the damn fruit flies that came out of no where and landed in the last wet coat, wax it. Grab another cuppa and a smoke, sit down and finally see all the stupid mistakes you made, and curse some more. Plan the next project. If this hasn't happened to you, you don't enjoy working with wood and need a new pastime like bottle cap collecting. Pete |
#17
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
|
#18
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
wrote in message oups.com... Teamcasa wrote: I see several posts asking for the plans to build whatever. I rarely build using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. When someone wants something made, all I really want is a few photos of what they want and I'll design/build it based loosely on what they had in mind. I make several mistakes this way but it's part of the learning process. I love the challenge. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave I rarely have the luxury to work so loosely. I design in the laptop for most of my clients, generally on site with a tape measure in hand. I take it home and detail it out from there. I usually have a complete cutlist and drawings of plan and elevation views complete before I buy any wood. If woodworking was my profession, I too would carefully design, plan and purchase with care. As a hobby, I am relieved of that responsibility. If this hobby ever became work, I'd go back to playing golf, welding or diving. Dave |
#19
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
J T wrote: Thu, Oct 12, 2006, 9:13am (EDT-3) (Teamcasa) doth queryeth: snip Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Plans? Plans? Don' need no steenkin' plans! JOAT It's not hard, if you get your mind right. - Granny Weatherwax The problem with using plans is that it is so hard to find them. Now, if there were some way to find plans with a quick and easy search.... |
#20
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
"Mike" wrote in
ps.com: J T wrote: Thu, Oct 12, 2006, 9:13am (EDT-3) (Teamcasa) doth queryeth: snip Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Plans? Plans? Don' need no steenkin' plans! JOAT It's not hard, if you get your mind right. - Granny Weatherwax The problem with using plans is that it is so hard to find them. Now, if there were some way to find plans with a quick and easy search.... Searching's too hard. I want someone to post links to plans right in front of me. ;-) Puckdropper -- Wise is the man who attempts to answer his question before asking it. To email me directly, send a message to puckdropper (at) fastmail.fm |
#21
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
On Thu, 12 Oct 2006 09:13:35 -0700, "Teamcasa" wrote:
I see several posts asking for the plans to build whatever. I rarely build using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. When someone wants something made, all I really want is a few photos of what they want and I'll design/build it based loosely on what they had in mind. I make several mistakes this way but it's part of the learning process. I love the challenge. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave I've tried working with plans and hit 2 problems: Not having a planer, the thickness on plans usually isn't possible... if it calls for 5/8" 11/16" thickness I have to use 3/4" stock and change all the other measurements or it throws everything off... I just don't have the patience required... Once the bug hits me I want to picture it in my head, draw enough of a sketch to get sizes and stuff and just go with it... Also, I have a really bad habit of my projects evolving as I progress, with improvements and changes that I usually like in the end.. Mac https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis/wood_stuff.htm |
#22
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
On Fri, 13 Oct 2006 02:48:40 GMT, "Teamcasa" wrote:
If woodworking was my profession, I too would carefully design, plan and purchase with care. As a hobby, I am relieved of that responsibility. If this hobby ever became work, I'd go back to playing golf, welding or diving. Dave My older brother drives me crazy when we do a project together.... His background is in airframe, and he plans EVERYTHING... I have to say that his finished work is much better than mine, but he'll take hours and sometimes days designing in CAD and revising material and cut lists, dimensions, etc. until I've either built it myself or gone home and done another project.. *g* I'm pretty sure that my work would be better if I was more like him, but my hobby is making saw dust and his is 50/50 planning and building.. Mac https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis/wood_stuff.htm |
#23
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
"mac davis" wrote in message ... On Fri, 13 Oct 2006 02:48:40 GMT, "Teamcasa" wrote: If woodworking was my profession, I too would carefully design, plan and purchase with care. As a hobby, I am relieved of that responsibility. If this hobby ever became work, I'd go back to playing golf, welding or diving. Dave My older brother drives me crazy when we do a project together.... His background is in airframe, and he plans EVERYTHING... I have to say that his finished work is much better than mine, but he'll take hours and sometimes days designing in CAD and revising material and cut lists, dimensions, etc. until I've either built it myself or gone home and done another project.. *g* I'm pretty sure that my work would be better if I was more like him, but my hobby is making saw dust and his is 50/50 planning and building.. Mac I too like planning- up until I make a mistake or I don't like the way a plan does something. From then on, its on to improvisational work. Mac, Mexico soon? I'm turning a bowl from walnut with a big knot in it. Its a test of my patients. Dave |
#24
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
"Teamcasa" wrote I too like planning- up until I make a mistake or I don't like the way a plan does something. From then on, its on to improvisational work. Mac, Mexico soon? I'm turning a bowl from walnut with a big knot in it. Its a test of my patients. I have this strong visual of David turning a bowl while his patients sit in a waiting/lathe room full of wood shavings. |
#25
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
"mac davis" wrote in message My older brother drives me crazy when we do a project together.... His background is in airframe, and he plans EVERYTHING... I have to say that his finished work is much better than mine, but he'll take hours and sometimes days designing in CAD and revising material and cut lists, dimensions, etc. until I've either built it myself or gone home and done another project.. *g* I like to do some planning. Most times, it is a sketch made while sitting in front of the TV. I make a rough cut list so I don't have to go back to get more wood, but it is subject to change, as are the plans once things get going. I've built a couple of projects from bought or free plans though. If I see something I like, I'd just as well spend a few $$ and have the work done for me and it can be a good learning experience to find out how others would do a joint. I also have limited artistic skills so for designs like the Tudor bench I built from American Furniture Design was money well spent. |
#26
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
mac davis wrote in
: On Thu, 12 Oct 2006 09:13:35 -0700, "Teamcasa" wrote: I see several posts asking for the plans to build whatever. I rarely build using plans other than a basic sketch to insure correct dimensions. When someone wants something made, all I really want is a few photos of what they want and I'll design/build it based loosely on what they had in mind. I make several mistakes this way but it's part of the learning process. I love the challenge. Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave I've tried working with plans and hit 2 problems: Not having a planer, the thickness on plans usually isn't possible... if it calls for 5/8" 11/16" thickness I have to use 3/4" stock and change all the other measurements or it throws everything off... I just don't have the patience required... Once the bug hits me I want to picture it in my head, draw enough of a sketch to get sizes and stuff and just go with it... Also, I have a really bad habit of my projects evolving as I progress, with improvements and changes that I usually like in the end.. Mac https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis https://home.comcast.net/~mac.davis/wood_stuff.htm I never use plans. I look at my lumber supply and then at whatever tools or machinery catch my fancy. I then start cutting or milling or planing or carving or turning and then sanding or scraping and shellacing or oiling or varnishing or polyurathaning or painting. I never know what it is going to be. Even when it's completed I'm not sure what it is, but it's been cut, milled, planed, carved, sanded or scraped (or sanded and scraped) shellaced, oiled, varnished, painted, polyurathaned or left natural. Never know what it is, but I love the workmanship. "Don't need no steenken plans" (JOAT 2006). Hank sining or varnishing or |
#27
Posted to rec.woodworking
|
|||
|
|||
Build with plans - Or not
On Fri, 13 Oct 2006 09:16:27 -0700, mac davis wrote:
Are you a must have a plan person or do you just build it by the seat of your pants. Dave Summa both. Some times I'll start with plans then, as the project progresses, depart from them. I just completed the DP table from ShopNotes #57. Very good plans. However, I made no drawer and increased the top dims to 39" x 17" x 1 1/4". And changed the table material to a 3 part mdf / cdx / mdf sandwich. Then I shellacked it. And added a corrugated plastic baffle to the dust box to get rid of the corners and smooth the flow. And used 3/4 inch square tubing (which I had laying around) in place of their flimsy-looking angle brackets (which I would have had to buy). And a shop-built collar for the vacuum hose entry that is exactly right. The hose just slides in but once the shop vac starts, it's downright tough to pull it out. And I made the slots in the back stop by a different method. Come to think of it ... I could patent this! ;-) Yeah ... I use plans. Like a fighter jet uses a catapault. Bill |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
My Plans Postings | Woodworking | |||
Looking for fun- easy to build - toddler bed plans | Woodworking | |||
Teaching kids how to build skateboards using Vacuum Bagging technique | Woodworking | |||
Plans | Woodworking | |||
Please help recommend joints for dresser/armoire plans! | Woodworking |