Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
David
 
Posts: n/a
Default Thinnest material for torsion box?

Space limitations doesn't permit me to build a large FLAT assembly
table. What I use now is my portable outfeed table (actually a heavy
metal cabinet on casters with leveling legs), but it isn't quite wide
enough to assemble many of my projects. I'm considering building a
removable top (torsion box) that can be placed on top to increase it's
size AND be as flat as possible. When not in use it will be stored
against a wall. I can't leave the box on top of the cabinet to do
double duty as an outfeed table because the cabinet is too high for a
torsion box to be level with the TS.

Will 1/4" MDF or 1/4" hardboard be thick enough to maintain a rigid
structure? I want it as thin as possible so the height of table isn't
increased any more than necessary when the torsion box is in place, so
what should be a minimum height of the grid? I'm guessing that if the
grid is too short it won't provide good rigidity?? The torsion box will
be 4'x6' and will be supported by a base table of 26"x45" so there will
be 48-26=22/2=11 inches of overhang on the width (each side) and
72-45=27/2=13.5" overhang in length on each end. The heaviest object
I'd expect to be built on the table would be under 100 lbs.

Requirements: light as possible since it's movable, and thin as possible
yet sturdy.

Dave





Dave
  #3   Report Post  
Patriarch
 
Posts: n/a
Default

David wrote in :

Space limitations doesn't permit me to build a large FLAT assembly
table.


I've used a salvaged hollow core door for such purposes. At about 34"x
80"ish, it's been adequate for that.

Cheap, too.

Patriarch
  #4   Report Post  
David
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Good tip, Pat. Alas, I gotta go with a 48 width for the assy table.

Dave

Patriarch wrote:

David wrote in :


Space limitations doesn't permit me to build a large FLAT assembly
table.



I've used a salvaged hollow core door for such purposes. At about 34"x
80"ish, it's been adequate for that.

Cheap, too.

Patriarch

  #5   Report Post  
Robatoy
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article ,
David wrote:

[snipped for brevity]

Requirements: light as possible since it's movable, and thin as possible
yet sturdy.


I am often faced with situation like this: thin and strong.
I the solid surface business, the unsupported overhang for a breakfast
bar is limited to 6". To go beyond that, I am either looking at brackets
(NOT elegant) or another type of support: Torsion box.
I have built and used many of the following type: 1/4" MDF skins and 1"
wide x3/4" maple for the ribs. I glue the whole thing together with WEST.
I have also used PB and MDF for the ribs..needless to say, accuracy is
paramount.


  #6   Report Post  
jo4hn
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I built full size doors for a 6' high x 4' cabinet using 1x 3 members
and 1/8" hard board for the skins. works fine with no sags so far. You
will have different requirements for an horizontal table.
mahalo,
jo4hn
  #7   Report Post  
BobS
 
Posts: n/a
Default

David,

I built one using 3/4"x2-1/4" pine and 1/8" hardboard for a top. Overall
size is 4' x 6'. The top is screwed down so it's replaceable if it gets
damaged. I had some 1x6's laying around so I ripped them down - hence the
odd ball size (2-1/4"). It's nice and sturdy and has held everything I've
thrown at it weight wise but I think the most I've had on it was about
100lbs.

When not needed, it's up against a wall. The top was waxed with several
coats of Johnson's paste wax so glue and paints don't stick.

Bob S.


"David" wrote in message
...
Space limitations doesn't permit me to build a large FLAT assembly table.
What I use now is my portable outfeed table (actually a heavy metal
cabinet on casters with leveling legs), but it isn't quite wide enough to
assemble many of my projects. I'm considering building a removable top
(torsion box) that can be placed on top to increase it's size AND be as
flat as possible. When not in use it will be stored against a wall. I
can't leave the box on top of the cabinet to do double duty as an outfeed
table because the cabinet is too high for a torsion box to be level with
the TS.

Will 1/4" MDF or 1/4" hardboard be thick enough to maintain a rigid
structure? I want it as thin as possible so the height of table isn't
increased any more than necessary when the torsion box is in place, so
what should be a minimum height of the grid? I'm guessing that if the grid
is too short it won't provide good rigidity?? The torsion box will be
4'x6' and will be supported by a base table of 26"x45" so there will be
48-26=22/2=11 inches of overhang on the width (each side) and
72-45=27/2=13.5" overhang in length on each end. The heaviest object I'd
expect to be built on the table would be under 100 lbs.

Requirements: light as possible since it's movable, and thin as possible
yet sturdy.

Dave





Dave



  #8   Report Post  
Badger
 
Posts: n/a
Default

David wrote:

Will 1/4" MDF or 1/4" hardboard be thick enough to maintain a rigid
structure? I want it as thin as possible so the height of table isn't
increased any more than necessary when the torsion box is in place, so
what should be a minimum height of the grid? I'm guessing that if the
grid is too short it won't provide good rigidity?? The torsion box will
be 4'x6' and will be supported by a base table of 26"x45" so there will
be 48-26=22/2=11 inches of overhang on the width (each side) and
72-45=27/2=13.5" overhang in length on each end. The heaviest object
I'd expect to be built on the table would be under 100 lbs.

Requirements: light as possible since it's movable, and thin as possible
yet sturdy.

Dave


Built a model railway layout board that way, 3/16 ply faces with 3/4 x
1+1/2 inner frame in a square/diamond/square/diamond etc style, put it
upsidedown on trestles and it makes a table for all sorts of uses, lives
on one edge in the conservatory.
As long as you point loadings aren't too high 1/4 sheeting should be fine.

Niel.
  #9   Report Post  
alexy
 
Posts: n/a
Default

David wrote:

Space limitations doesn't permit me to build a large FLAT assembly
table. What I use now is my portable outfeed table (actually a heavy
metal cabinet on casters with leveling legs), but it isn't quite wide
enough to assemble many of my projects. I'm considering building a
removable top (torsion box) that can be placed on top to increase it's
size AND be as flat as possible. When not in use it will be stored
against a wall. I can't leave the box on top of the cabinet to do
double duty as an outfeed table because the cabinet is too high for a
torsion box to be level with the TS.

Will 1/4" MDF or 1/4" hardboard be thick enough to maintain a rigid
structure? I want it as thin as possible so the height of table isn't
increased any more than necessary when the torsion box is in place, so
what should be a minimum height of the grid? I'm guessing that if the
grid is too short it won't provide good rigidity?? The torsion box will
be 4'x6' and will be supported by a base table of 26"x45" so there will
be 48-26=22/2=11 inches of overhang on the width (each side) and
72-45=27/2=13.5" overhang in length on each end. The heaviest object
I'd expect to be built on the table would be under 100 lbs.

Requirements: light as possible since it's movable, and thin as possible
yet sturdy.


Dave, to meet your requirements, you really need engineering help,
which I am NOT qualified to give. But some ideas:

1) How flat is your cabinet/outfeed table? If it provides good
support, you need very little stiffness in this part of your
structure. Shims on the underside of your table could take care of any
twist or other unevenness.

2) Make a thin torsion box the size of the cabinet, surrounded by a
thicker one that will overhang the cabinet.

3) Look at a plane's wing design, optimized for strength and weight,
and use some of their concepts, such as lightening holes in the web
and small stiffeners to give local rigidity to a thin skin. Doing that
right is well beyond my knowledge base, but I'd guess that making the
surrounding torsion box 4" thick with interior pieces of 1/8" ply
filled with 3" holes and attached to each other and the top and bottom
with 1/4"x1/4" glue block strips would be both stiffer and lighter
than a 2" thick box with 1/2" thick interior pieces.
--
Alex -- Replace "nospam" with "mail" to reply by email. Checked infrequently.
  #10   Report Post  
David
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I went across town to my primary wood supplier AFTER they said by phone
they had 1/4" hardboard. I get there and NO, then don't even CARRY it!
aaargh! Another retail clerk blows it--thank you very much!

I go to the next supplier about 4 blocks from the first one. yes, they
have 1/4" hardboard, but it's $22 a sheet. No thanks. I'll try HD near
home.

I go back home and drop off what I DID find in the way of wood (in case
some miscreant decides he needs the walnut more than I do) and then
drive to my local HD for some 1/4" hardboard, which, last time I bought
some, was available at there. Walk 14 miles to the back of the store to
get it. hmmm.... 1/8"...3/16". no 1/4". Look at the smaller sizes like
2x4 and 4x4. Yup. 1/4". go find a clerk to get the phone number of
the next HD about 1.5 miles away. Call them. "Nope" NONE of the HD's
carry 1/4" hardboard in 4x8 size because "it gets broken". Gee, that
hasn't stopped them from carrying 1.6 million OTHER items that are
broken or missing parts!!! Screw it; I get three pieces of the 4x4
stuff for under $9 each and call it a day.

I live in a city of nearly a million people and all I wanted was a piece
of 1/4" thick hardboard 4'x8'. This isn't the only common item I've had
difficulty with. Does anyone share my pain?? Are you often amazed at
the lack of availability of common stuff in YOUR town?

Dave

David wrote:
Space limitations doesn't permit me to build a large FLAT assembly
table. What I use now is my portable outfeed table (actually a heavy
metal cabinet on casters with leveling legs), but it isn't quite wide
enough to assemble many of my projects. I'm considering building a
removable top (torsion box) that can be placed on top to increase it's
size AND be as flat as possible. When not in use it will be stored
against a wall. I can't leave the box on top of the cabinet to do
double duty as an outfeed table because the cabinet is too high for a
torsion box to be level with the TS.

Will 1/4" MDF or 1/4" hardboard be thick enough to maintain a rigid
structure? I want it as thin as possible so the height of table isn't
increased any more than necessary when the torsion box is in place, so
what should be a minimum height of the grid? I'm guessing that if the
grid is too short it won't provide good rigidity?? The torsion box will
be 4'x6' and will be supported by a base table of 26"x45" so there will
be 48-26=22/2=11 inches of overhang on the width (each side) and
72-45=27/2=13.5" overhang in length on each end. The heaviest object
I'd expect to be built on the table would be under 100 lbs.

Requirements: light as possible since it's movable, and thin as possible
yet sturdy.

Dave





Dave



  #11   Report Post  
Lee Michaels
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"David" wrote

I live in a city of nearly a million people and all I wanted was a piece
of 1/4" thick hardboard 4'x8'. This isn't the only common item I've had
difficulty with. Does anyone share my pain?? Are you often amazed at the
lack of availability of common stuff in YOUR town?

You can always try an old fashioned lumber yard.

There are not as many of them as there used to be. But in a town of that
size, there should be something.



  #12   Report Post  
David
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Lee, 2 of the suppliers were lumber yards. One didn't carry it and the
other charged more than I thought it should cost so I passed on it.

Dave

Lee Michaels wrote:
"David" wrote

I live in a city of nearly a million people and all I wanted was a piece
of 1/4" thick hardboard 4'x8'. This isn't the only common item I've had
difficulty with. Does anyone share my pain?? Are you often amazed at the
lack of availability of common stuff in YOUR town?


You can always try an old fashioned lumber yard.

There are not as many of them as there used to be. But in a town of that
size, there should be something.



  #13   Report Post  
CW
 
Posts: n/a
Default

They charge that because they know that no one else has got it.

"David" wrote in message
...
Lee, 2 of the suppliers were lumber yards. One didn't carry it and the
other charged more than I thought it should cost so I passed on it.



  #14   Report Post  
George
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Not to mention, it "breaks" so easily they lose quite a bit....

All the running would easily have paid for the expensive stuff.

"CW" wrote in message
k.net...
They charge that because they know that no one else has got it.

"David" wrote in message
...
Lee, 2 of the suppliers were lumber yards. One didn't carry it and the
other charged more than I thought it should cost so I passed on it.





  #15   Report Post  
BobS
 
Posts: n/a
Default

David,

1/8" hardboard will work just fine as I stated in my post.

Bob S.



Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Door sill material choice BobK207 Home Repair 3 January 29th 05 11:21 AM
Home plans and Material lists Dennis Woodworking 8 December 22nd 04 02:06 AM
Made map holder today from LEXAN! What a material! Daniel A. Mitchell Metalworking 16 May 16th 04 11:13 AM
Cover material for ceiling insulation _firstname_@lr _dot_ los-gatos _dot_ca.us Home Ownership 1 January 8th 04 03:10 PM
need suggestions on material thickness for case noel Metalworking 3 December 8th 03 03:40 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:44 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"