There are several on-line suppliers offering kitchen units with solid wood carcasses. They seem to cost about the same (or less) than the usual chipboard ones from the big names. The wood is typically 18mm thick and made from panels 'assembled' from smaller planks.

They also seem to be made in factories in the UK which is nice.

Are there any things to worry about with cabinets made like this? Why would anyoen buy chipboard in preference?

Examples of suppliers:
http://www.discountkitchenfactory.co.uk/
http://www.solidwoodkitchencabinets.co.uk/
http://www.solidwoodkitchen.co.uk/

thanks for any comments,

Robert
laws at bcs.org.uk

On 28/09/2012 16:24, RobertL wrote:
There are several on-line suppliers offering kitchen units with solid wood carcasses. They seem to cost about the same (or less) than the usual chipboard ones from the big names. The wood is typically 18mm thick and made from panels 'assembled' from smaller planks.

They also seem to be made in factories in the UK which is nice.

Are there any things to worry about with cabinets made like this? Why would anyoen buy chipboard in preference?

Examples of suppliers:
http://www.discountkitchenfactory.co.uk/
http://www.solidwoodkitchencabinets.co.uk/
http://www.solidwoodkitchen.co.uk/

thanks for any comments,

Robert
laws at bcs.org.uk


I can't see how they would compete on price with (say) B&Q carcases.
Their profit is in the doors, drawers, and worktops.

Chipboard was a PITA before the adjustable plastic pillars were invented
because it inevitably got damp at the bottom and decayed from there.
These days, I don't see any problem with it unless you are particularly
Essex. YMMV if you were renovating a classy old property.

On 28/09/2012 16:24, RobertL wrote:
There are several on-line suppliers offering kitchen units with solid wood carcasses. They seem to cost about the same (or less) than the usual chipboard ones from the big names. The wood is typically 18mm thick and made from panels 'assembled' from smaller planks.

They also seem to be made in factories in the UK which is nice.

Are there any things to worry about with cabinets made like this? Why would anyoen buy chipboard in preference?


It's melamine faced, so easy to maintain. It's almost certainly more
stable than wood. Unless your kitchen is prone to flooding, I can't see
the advantages of wooden carcasses

newshound wrote:
Chipboard was a PITA before the adjustable plastic pillars were invented

I hate those plastic pillars. As you attempt to slide the base
unit into place the damn things snap off. Proper continuous
panel all the way to the floor lets you adjust the position
infinitely, and spreads the weight across two long lengths
instead of four spot pressure points.

JGH

On 28/09/2012 18:18, wrote:
newshound wrote:
Chipboard was a PITA before the adjustable plastic pillars were invented

I hate those plastic pillars. As you attempt to slide the base
unit into place the damn things snap off. Proper continuous
panel all the way to the floor lets you adjust the position
infinitely, and spreads the weight across two long lengths
instead of four spot pressure points.

JGH


You don't slide them into place, at least not with any force. You screw
them up before you insert the unit, lift it into place, *then* adjust
the feet.

"RobertL" wrote in message
...
- There are several on-line suppliers offering kitchen units with
- solid wood carcasses. They - seem to cost about the same (or less)
- than the usual chipboard ones from the big names. The wood is
- typically 18mm thick and made from panels 'assembled' from smaller planks.

- They also seem to be made in factories in the UK which is nice.

- Are there any things to worry about with cabinets made like this?
- Why would anyoen buy chipboard in preference?


Apart from the door and drawer fronts, which can be solid oak
or any other timber if you so choose, the only part visible part
aside from the end panels will be the insides of the cupboards
and drawers. Here white melamine is preferable, both from a
visibilty aspect and in terms of keeping it clean. Its a whole
lot easier to see what's at the back of a cupboard if the interior
is white, and its also easier to see if its been properly cleaned.

Apart from this, the reason chipbpoard and MDF are so popular is
because they're more stable in a kitchen environment, by design,
than is natural timber.

Quite what benefit there can be, in having the sides and maybe even
the backs of cabinets, which will never actually be seen - i.e all
but the end panels - made from solid timber is something only the
suppliers could possibly answer.


michael adams

....


Examples of suppliers:
http://www.discountkitchenfactory.co.uk/
http://www.solidwoodkitchencabinets.co.uk/
http://www.solidwoodkitchen.co.uk/

thanks for any comments,

Robert
laws at bcs.org.uk

On Friday, September 28, 2012 6:42:32 PM UTC+1, michael adams wrote:
"RobertL" robertmlaws wrote in message

...

- There are several on-line suppliers offering kitchen units with

- solid wood carcasses. They - seem to cost about the same (or less)

- than the usual chipboard ones from the big names. The wood is

- typically 18mm thick and made from panels 'assembled' from smaller planks.



- They also seem to be made in factories in the UK which is nice.



- Are there any things to worry about with cabinets made like this?

- Why would anyoen buy chipboard in preference?





Apart from the door and drawer fronts, which can be solid oak

or any other timber if you so choose, the only part visible part

aside from the end panels will be the insides of the cupboards

and drawers. Here white melamine is preferable, both from a

visibilty aspect and in terms of keeping it clean. Its a whole

lot easier to see what's at the back of a cupboard if the interior

is white, and its also easier to see if its been properly cleaned.



Apart from this, the reason chipbpoard and MDF are so popular is

because they're more stable in a kitchen environment, by design,

than is natural timber.



Quite what benefit there can be, in having the sides and maybe even

the backs of cabinets, which will never actually be seen - i.e all

but the end panels - made from solid timber is something only the

suppliers could possibly answer.





michael adams



...





Examples of suppliers:

http://www.discountkitchenfactory.co.uk/

http://www.solidwoodkitchencabinets.co.uk/

http://www.solidwoodkitchen.co.uk/



thanks for any comments,



Robert

laws at bcs.org.uk


Chip doesn't last well. Timber does.


NT

wrote in message
...
On Friday, September 28, 2012 6:42:32 PM UTC+1, michael adams wrote:
"RobertL" robertmlaws wrote in message

...

- There are several on-line suppliers offering kitchen units with

- solid wood carcasses. They - seem to cost about the same (or less)

- than the usual chipboard ones from the big names. The wood is

- typically 18mm thick and made from panels 'assembled' from smaller planks.



- They also seem to be made in factories in the UK which is nice.



- Are there any things to worry about with cabinets made like this?

- Why would anyoen buy chipboard in preference?





Apart from the door and drawer fronts, which can be solid oak

or any other timber if you so choose, the only part visible part

aside from the end panels will be the insides of the cupboards

and drawers. Here white melamine is preferable, both from a

visibilty aspect and in terms of keeping it clean. Its a whole

lot easier to see what's at the back of a cupboard if the interior

is white, and its also easier to see if its been properly cleaned.



Apart from this, the reason chipbpoard and MDF are so popular is

because they're more stable in a kitchen environment, by design,

than is natural timber.



Quite what benefit there can be, in having the sides and maybe even

the backs of cabinets, which will never actually be seen - i.e all

but the end panels - made from solid timber is something only the

suppliers could possibly answer.





michael adams



...





Examples of suppliers:

http://www.discountkitchenfactory.co.uk/

http://www.solidwoodkitchencabinets.co.uk/

http://www.solidwoodkitchen.co.uk/



thanks for any comments,



Robert

laws at bcs.org.uk


Chip doesn't last well.

It usually lasts long enough to fulfil its intended purpose.

Up to 40 years and more, in some cases

Timber does.

Often too long for a kitchen which will often be replaced within
30 years if not sooner.


michael adams

....







NT

On Friday, September 28, 2012 9:35:50 PM UTC+1, michael adams wrote:
meow2222 wrote in message

...

On Friday, September 28, 2012 6:42:32 PM UTC+1, michael adams wrote:

"RobertL" robertmlaws wrote in message



...



- There are several on-line suppliers offering kitchen units with



- solid wood carcasses. They - seem to cost about the same (or less)



- than the usual chipboard ones from the big names. The wood is



- typically 18mm thick and made from panels 'assembled' from smaller planks.







- They also seem to be made in factories in the UK which is nice.







- Are there any things to worry about with cabinets made like this?



- Why would anyoen buy chipboard in preference?











Apart from the door and drawer fronts, which can be solid oak



or any other timber if you so choose, the only part visible part



aside from the end panels will be the insides of the cupboards



and drawers. Here white melamine is preferable, both from a



visibilty aspect and in terms of keeping it clean. Its a whole



lot easier to see what's at the back of a cupboard if the interior



is white, and its also easier to see if its been properly cleaned.







Apart from this, the reason chipbpoard and MDF are so popular is



because they're more stable in a kitchen environment, by design,



than is natural timber.







Quite what benefit there can be, in having the sides and maybe even



the backs of cabinets, which will never actually be seen - i.e all



but the end panels - made from solid timber is something only the



suppliers could possibly answer.











michael adams







...











Examples of suppliers:



http://www.discountkitchenfactory.co.uk/



http://www.solidwoodkitchencabinets.co.uk/



http://www.solidwoodkitchen.co.uk/







thanks for any comments,







Robert



laws at bcs.org.uk





Chip doesn't last well.



It usually lasts long enough to fulfil its intended purpose.

I plan to use my kitchen for the rest of my life, then pass it on.

Up to 40 years and more, in some cases

That is very optimistic for chip. I do however know a real wood kitchen still in use that looks over a century old.


Timber does.



Often too long for a kitchen which will often be replaced within

30 years if not sooner.

Often because of deteriorated chipboard
Even more often because of dodgy melamine/chipboard styling. Wood tends to be more conservative, and not look so outdated.


NT

wrote:
newshound wrote:
Chipboard was a PITA before the adjustable plastic pillars were invented

I hate those plastic pillars. As you attempt to slide the base
unit into place the damn things snap off. Proper continuous
panel all the way to the floor lets you adjust the position
infinitely, and spreads the weight across two long lengths
instead of four spot pressure points.

But of your floor isn't level you're in trouble!

--
Chris Green

wrote:

Chip doesn't last well. Timber does.

Thin sheets of oak, in particular, don't last well at all - at least
not in the sense of staying flat and smooth.

--
Chris Green

In article ,
RobertL writes
There are several on-line suppliers offering kitchen units with solid wood carcasses.
They seem to cost about the same (or less) than the usual chipboard ones from
the big names. The wood is typically 18mm thick and made from panels
'assembled' from smaller planks.

They also seem to be made in factories in the UK which is nice.

Are there any things to worry about with cabinets made like this? Why would
anyoen buy chipboard in preference?

Examples of suppliers:
http://www.discountkitchenfactory.co.uk/
http://www.solidwoodkitchencabinets.co.uk/
http://www.solidwoodkitchen.co.uk/

There are some pretty much waterproof mdf boards with smooth cladding
that get used in commercial and industrial installations. I'd love to
see them used for kitchen cabinets but no joy yet, the market seems
happy with cheap ****. Real wood might work looks wise but it's not for
me, I want bright wipe down surfaces that don't care about a bit of
damp.
--
fred
it's a ba-na-na . . . .