I am looking at flooring to go over an UFH system and have come across a
lot of sites selling "engineered oak" as suitable for this purpose. The
description of these floors however sound to me more like laminate i.e.
a sub layer (be it of oak or ply) covered by a top layer of oak of
varying thicknesses.

I thought that engineered oak was made by taking pieces of oak and
gluing together to form a piece less likely to warp. This is certainly
how the "oak" patio doors I have installed is made.

Cheers

Martin
--
Martin Carroll

AIUI "engineered wood" means "wood machined to exact dimensions",
whilst your doors I would describe as "laminated wood" or "glulam".

Martin Carroll wrote:
I am looking at flooring to go over an UFH system and have come across a
lot of sites selling "engineered oak" as suitable for this purpose. The
description of these floors however sound to me more like laminate i.e.
a sub layer (be it of oak or ply) covered by a top layer of oak of
varying thicknesses.

I thought that engineered oak was made by taking pieces of oak and
gluing together to form a piece less likely to warp. This is certainly
how the "oak" patio doors I have installed is made.

Cheers

Martin
Usually would refer to laminated wood as you describe but tends to be a
much abused term where some sort of process is applied to virtual
firewood to turn it into a manufactured product that is just about fit
for purpose.
The only way to be sure is to ask for the specification backed up with a
sample.

Bob

Martin Carroll wrote:
I am looking at flooring to go over an UFH system and have come across a
lot of sites selling "engineered oak" as suitable for this purpose. The
description of these floors however sound to me more like laminate i.e.
a sub layer (be it of oak or ply) covered by a top layer of oak of
varying thicknesses.

I thought that engineered oak was made by taking pieces of oak and
gluing together to form a piece less likely to warp. This is certainly
how the "oak" patio doors I have installed is made.

Cheers

Martin
Usually would refer to laminated wood as you describe but tends to be a
much abused term where some sort of process is applied to virtual
firewood to turn it into a manufactured product that is just about fit
for purpose.
The only way to be sure is to ask for the specification backed up with a
sample.

Bob

On 1 July, 21:46, Martin Carroll wrote:
I am looking at flooring to go over an UFH system and have come across a
lot of sites selling "engineered oak" as suitable for this purpose. *The
description of these floors however sound to me more like laminate i.e.
a sub layer (be it of oak or ply) covered by a top layer of oak of
varying thicknesses.

I thought that engineered oak was made by taking pieces of oak and
gluing together to form a piece less likely to warp. *This is certainly
how the "oak" patio doors I have installed is made.

Cheers

Martin
--
Martin Carroll

Engineered flooring has a surface layer of real wood on a man-made
board substrate (typically, plywood). It is laminated, but it is not
'laminate' in the sense of laminate flooring (which has more in common
with a high pressure plastic laminate like formica - layers of resin
and paper).

The real wood surface thickness in engineered flooring can vary from a
cheap veneer to a 6mm or so layer. In the latter case, the only
difference from solid wood is in the mind and in any snob value that
remains in saying you have a 'solid wood' floor. Once you've sanded
down a solid t&g floor by 6mm you've ****ed it anyway, as the tongues
will be showing (or at least the top overlap on the grooved side will
be so thin it will be splintering).

Because of the cross-ply layers in the substrate, they are much more
stable, which is why they are recommended for over UFH.

Martin Carroll wrote:
I am looking at flooring to go over an UFH system and have come across a
lot of sites selling "engineered oak" as suitable for this purpose. The
description of these floors however sound to me more like laminate i.e.
a sub layer (be it of oak or ply) covered by a top layer of oak of
varying thicknesses.

I thought that engineered oak was made by taking pieces of oak and
gluing together to form a piece less likely to warp. This is certainly
how the "oak" patio doors I have installed is made.

IME the phrase usually means a man made base - ply / mdf etc, with real
wood surface. Said surface usually being thick enough to accommodate a
number of sandings. It should be less likely to warp than solid oak as
well and generally be more dimensionally stable.

--
Cheers,

John.

/================================================== ===============\
| Internode Ltd - http://www.internode.co.uk |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------|
| John Rumm - john(at)internode(dot)co(dot)uk |
\================================================= ================/