Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
UK diy (uk.d-i-y) For the discussion of all topics related to diy (do-it-yourself) in the UK. All levels of experience and proficency are welcome to join in to ask questions or offer solutions. |
Reply |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
I want the smallest possible radiator. Are there any almost silent fan assisted designs available?
I have room for wall mounted radiators but I really don't want to give
away wall space to some big white thing. Are there any small radiator designs that contain discreet tangential fans to enhance their output? And a quite separate question. Why are radiators white, or even chrome? Surely matt black would make them more efficient, so they could be smaller? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Peter wrote:
I have room for wall mounted radiators but I really don't want to give away wall space to some big white thing. Are there any small radiator designs that contain discreet tangential fans to enhance their output? And a quite separate question. Why are radiators white, or even chrome? Surely matt black would make them more efficient, so they could be smaller? I think Myson have traditionally dominated this sector, but their units were neither compact nor pretty last I saw - but that was a fair while ago. You can diy your own with a normal rad + several pc fans on reduced V Presumably you could also put rad + fan under the floor if you wanted, with filtered vents. But the best option (that Ive never tried) appears to be to put a bunch of microbore inside partition walls. Raising the whole wall to quite modest temps would deliver the same heat. I calculated it once, and it looked like it would work well. Anyone else considered this? NT |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
In an earlier contribution to this discussion,
Peter wrote: I have room for wall mounted radiators but I really don't want to give away wall space to some big white thing. Are there any small radiator designs that contain discreet tangential fans to enhance their output? Maybe not quite what you want, but Myson do 'Kickspace' fan-blown radiators which fit under kitchen units in otherwise dead space. And a quite separate question. Why are radiators white, or even chrome? Surely matt black would make them more efficient, so they could be smaller? The word 'radiator' is a misnomer in this context. Most of the heat transfer is by convection with only a small amount being radiated. Making them matt black would increase the radiated heat a bit - but wouldn't have a dramatic effect on overall heat output - and would be considered less aesthetically acceptable by most! -- Cheers, Set Square ______ Please reply to newsgroup. Reply address is invalid. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Set Square wrote:
Maybe not quite what you want, but Myson do 'Kickspace' fan-blown radiators which fit under kitchen units in otherwise dead space. but all the ones I've seen are noisy and not very effective - they have the fan heater problem of warming the room up quickly but then allowing it to cool down just as fast - there's no thermal mass. -- Spamtrap in use To email replace 127.0.0.1 with blueyonder dot co dot uk |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
but all the ones I've seen are noisy and not very effective - they have
the fan heater problem of warming the room up quickly but then allowing it to cool down just as fast - there's no thermal mass. Hmm, yes. This is what concerns me, I definitely do not want the noise a fan heater, nor the draught, but I can't help feeling that a 2 metre long tangential fan rotating at a pretty slow speed could be quite inaudible, yet seriously increase the airflow throw a radiator. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 05 Oct 2005 19:19:32 +0100, Peter
wrote: but all the ones I've seen are noisy and not very effective - they have the fan heater problem of warming the room up quickly but then allowing it to cool down just as fast - there's no thermal mass. Hmm, yes. This is what concerns me, I definitely do not want the noise a fan heater, nor the draught, but I can't help feeling that a 2 metre long tangential fan rotating at a pretty slow speed could be quite inaudible, yet seriously increase the airflow throw a radiator. The myson ones work but become noisy. A slow or variable speed tangential fan as you suggest would be alot better if available. You could fit a few 60mm fans between the 2 parts of a small double convector rad , easy to control and run them from a plugin low volatge adaptor. Robert royall at which net |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
"Peter" wrote in message ... I have room for wall mounted radiators but I really don't want to give away wall space to some big white thing. Are there any small radiator designs that contain discreet tangential fans to enhance their output? And a quite separate question. Why are radiators white, or even chrome? Surely matt black would make them more efficient, so they could be smaller? ================== You might possibly be a suitable candidate for skirting radiators. They don't suit everybody or every location but they're worth a look if you're determined to avoid standard panel radiators. You might be able to combine skirting rads and tangential fans to achieve a bespoke system, but I doubt if it will be cheap. Try a 'google' for 'skirting radiators'. Cic. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 05 Oct 2005 14:37:04 +0100, Set Square wrote:
The word 'radiator' is a misnomer in this context. Most of the heat transfer is by convection with only a small amount being radiated. Making them matt black would increase the radiated heat a bit - but wouldn't have a dramatic effect on overall heat output - and would be considered less aesthetically acceptable by most! AIUI the heat transfer is about 30% by radiation but much less when they are being run cooler using TRVs and/or condensing boilers. The emissivity of the white enamel is not far of the perfect matt black (about 90% as good). In fact most surfaces have emissivities around this figure the only ones which don't are shiny metal ones. If you play about with an IR thermometer you'll soon see which ones have low emissivities. -- Ed Sirett - Property maintainer and registered gas fitter. The FAQ for uk.diy is at http://www.diyfaq.org.uk Gas fitting FAQ http://www.makewrite.demon.co.uk/GasFitting.html Sealed CH FAQ http://www.makewrite.demon.co.uk/SealedCH.html |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
Cicero wrote: "Peter" wrote in message ... I have room for wall mounted radiators but I really don't want to give away wall space to some big white thing. Are there any small radiator designs that contain discreet tangential fans to enhance their output? And a quite separate question. Why are radiators white, or even chrome? Surely matt black would make them more efficient, so they could be smaller? ================== You might possibly be a suitable candidate for skirting radiators. They don't suit everybody or every location but they're worth a look if you're determined to avoid standard panel radiators. You might be able to combine skirting rads and tangential fans to achieve a bespoke system, but I doubt if it will be cheap. Try a 'google' for 'skirting radiators'. Or look at vertical radiators that only take up a small length of wall and can be sufficiently decorative to take the place of a piece of modern art that you might have there instead. -- John Cartmell john@ followed by finnybank.com 0845 006 8822 Qercus magazine FAX +44 (0)8700-519-527 www.finnybank.com Qercus - the best guide to RISC OS computing |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
|
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Peter wrote: Hmm, yes. This is what concerns me, I definitely do not want the noise a fan heater, nor the draught, but I can't help feeling that a 2 metre long tangential fan rotating at a pretty slow speed could be quite inaudible, yet seriously increase the airflow throw a radiator. It won't work. CH radiators work by radiation and convection. Fan heaters work by convection and the surface area needs to be vastly increased to achieve the required heat transfer. An example would be a car radiator which dissipates heat by forced convection. The surface area is made vast by the use of lots of sheet metal fins to transfer the heat to the airstream. If you want a fan heater you'd have to use one of the Myson jobs or obtain an air heater battery and go about fabricating a small air handler. There are commercial fan coil units for heating and/or cooling, similar to the indoor ceiling cassettes on split system AC units. The cheap and nasty fans usually start giving trouble after a few years. |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Aidan wrote:
Peter wrote: Hmm, yes. This is what concerns me, I definitely do not want the noise a fan heater, nor the draught, but I can't help feeling that a 2 metre long tangential fan rotating at a pretty slow speed could be quite inaudible, yet seriously increase the airflow throw a radiator. It won't work. CH radiators work by radiation and convection. Fan heaters work by convection and the surface area needs to be vastly increased to achieve the required heat transfer. It works very well in fact. I know because I've done it as a temporary measure. Its the same principle as fan cooling a heatsink in tronic goods. Think your CPU wont get hotter if the fan fails? The only problem is getting or making a long thin fan. I guess in principle one could make a tangential thing and spin it at low rpm, sounds a fair bit of work tho. Practically pc fans are all I've come up with, anything else is too large. Now how to diy a 5' tangential fan... NT |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
|
#15
|
|||
|
|||
It increases the proportion of heat emitted by convection. It reduces
the radiator surface temperature and reduces the proportion of heat emitted by radiation. Well, yes, but it should take heat from the radiator by design, I am actually trying to tale the most from the radiator. Either way, if the control system and the boiler is correctly specified it should keep the radiator piping hot at the maximum level of air flow forced through the radiator; again, by design. Ed Sirret, said above that very little energy is emitted from a 'radiator' by way of radiation anyway. The overall effect approximates to naff all, in respect for the effort involved. If he wants forced convection, he'd be best advised to buy a heater battery which is designed for this purpose. Or some of those finned tube heaters. I'm not familiar with 'finned tube' though I think I know those you mean. But it's space I am trying to save. I would love to have a very flat skirting board radiator of 2m length, which is capable of maintaining an already warm room, but which has a fan mode to boost its capacity when the room is being heated from cold. This is why car radiators and heater matrices are the distinctive shape that they are. You could bolt on a couple of double-panel Mysons when your car radiator next fails, but I doubt that it would achieve the required heat transfer rate. Yes, but car radiators are cooling pretty inefficient 90kW (or thereabouts) motors. Their design owes a lot to the much greater cooling they must provide, much like the complexity we see in the heatsinks used in power electronics. If they weren't so ugly it might be fun to try an automotive radiator in a CH system. Though perhaps its fan motor could be replaced with something a little less energetic. Anyway, in the meantime I think I would like to track down a manufacturer of tangential fans and call them to ask what the longest design they make is. It should be quite a simple experiment. |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
In an earlier contribution to this discussion,
Aidan wrote: wrote: It works very well in fact. I know because I've done it as a temporary measure. It increases the proportion of heat emitted by convection. It reduces the radiator surface temperature and reduces the proportion of heat emitted by radiation. Not necessarily! Provided the water flow rate is increased to replenish the heat at the same rate as it is being removed, the surface of the rad will stay at the same temperature as before - thus giving increased convection and the same radiation. -- Cheers, Set Square ______ Please reply to newsgroup. Reply address is invalid. |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 05 Oct 2005 00:09:18 +0100, Peter
wrote: I have room for wall mounted radiators but I really don't want to give away wall space to some big white thing. Are there any small radiator designs that contain discreet tangential fans to enhance their output? And a quite separate question. Why are radiators white, or even chrome? Surely matt black would make them more efficient, so they could be smaller? How much time/money do you want to spend? cheers, Pete. |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
How much time/money do you want to spend?
Hard to say but under a thousand for sure. |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Peter wrote:
How much time/money do you want to spend? Hard to say but under a thousand for sure. achievable with rows of computer fans on standard but smaller rads. NT |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Aidan wrote:
wrote: It works very well in fact. I know because I've done it as a temporary measure. It increases the proportion of heat emitted by convection. It reduces the radiator surface temperature and reduces the proportion of heat emitted by radiation. The overall effect approximates to naff all, in respect for the effort involved. If he wants forced convection, he'd be best advised to buy a heater battery which is designed for this purpose. Or some of those finned tube heaters. This is why car radiators and heater matrices are the distinctive shape that they are. You could bolt on a couple of double-panel Mysons when your car radiator next fails, but I doubt that it would achieve the required heat transfer rate. Its the same principle as fan cooling a heatsink in tronic goods. Think your CPU wont get hotter if the fan fails? The heatsink usually has extended fins to shift a few watts; I have no idea of typical CPU heat output. To shift a 1 or 2 kW, you need lots of fins, or a large acreage of panel radiators. I know what Im talking about. NT |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Peter wrote: Well, yes, but it should take heat from the radiator by design, I am actually trying to tale the most from the radiator. Either way, if the control system and the boiler is correctly specified it should keep the radiator piping hot at the maximum level of air flow forced through the radiator; again, by design. It won't. Ed Sirret, said above that very little energy is emitted from a 'radiator' by way of radiation anyway. If they weren't so ugly it might be fun to try an automotive radiator in a CH system. Though perhaps its fan motor could be replaced with something a little less energetic. You could get the fan and heater matrix from a car. The heater matrix is copper pipes expanded into ali fins. The fins are so closely packed on some that, at first glance, they look like a block of grooved aluminium. At a flying guess, I'd think you'd get 1 kW from a heater battery 200mm square, depending on the fin density, but much smaller than a rad, with or without fans. Anyway, in the meantime I think I would like to track down a manufacturer of tangential fans and call them to ask what the longest design they make is. It should be quite a simple experiment. Centrifugal fans. The options are axial flow (Vent-Axias), centrifugal or mixed flow. The impellers in fan convectors are centrifugal but are forward curved. Real, efficient, commercial fans have backward curved blades (or is that the other way round?), but look very different to the injection moulded forward curved jobs. Try Ziehl if you want to make something fancy with speed controls. Quality, but much =A3s. Rads are frequently run off variable temperature systems, modulating boilers or weather compensated. Convectors should be run from a constant temperature system; it will still put out some heat but a variable temperature system would play havoc with any accurate control systems. |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
|
#24
|
|||
|
|||
"Aidan" wrote:
snip It hasn't been seen since. So it was really fast then? :-) -- |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
Matt wrote: "Aidan" wrote: So it was really fast then? :-) Good for sprints :-)) |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
On Thu, 6 Oct 2005 12:34:14 +0100, "Set Square"
wrote: In an earlier contribution to this discussion, Aidan wrote: wrote: It works very well in fact. I know because I've done it as a temporary measure. It increases the proportion of heat emitted by convection. It reduces the radiator surface temperature and reduces the proportion of heat emitted by radiation. Not necessarily! Provided the water flow rate is increased to replenish the heat at the same rate as it is being removed, the surface of the rad will stay at the same temperature as before - thus giving increased convection and the same radiation. I agree, with forced convection the rate of cooling is faster than with natural convection (for the same temperature difference) So as long as you increase the flowrate thro' rad you will get more heat output. The heat output to size ratio can be optimised by design as in car rads or fan convectors, just as the design of a normal convector rad attempts to maximse the heat output by natural convection in a design acceptable for domestic use. Robert royall at which net |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
In an earlier contribution to this discussion,
Anna Kettle wrote: achievable with rows of computer fans on standard but smaller rads. But is it art? Anna Does it have to be? g -- Cheers, Set Square ______ Please reply to newsgroup. Reply address is invalid. |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
|
#30
|
|||
|
|||
On Thu, 6 Oct 2005 16:15:54 +0100, Anna Kettle
wrote: In article . com, says... Peter wrote: How much time/money do you want to spend? Hard to say but under a thousand for sure. achievable with rows of computer fans on standard but smaller rads. But is it art? Some fans with LEDs could look nice, more k3wl than arty maybe... Anyway, the OP should have better luck looking for a cross flow fan (AKA tangential fan): http://www.casetech.co.uk/CoolerMaster-300mm-Cross-Flow-Fan-p-17326.html http://www.review-displays.co.uk/Products/motors/orix.htm http://www.ebmpapst.co.uk/pages/content.asp?s_16,p_2 http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&safe=off&client=opera&rls=en&q=si te%3A.co.uk+cross+flow+fan&btnG=Search ...etc One of the coolermaster ones with a car heater matrix would form a nice 'mini Myson'. I'd try a row of 80mm PC case fans first, they are pretty quiet on 5v and 3-7v 2A wall wart could run a whole load of them. eBuyer have a pretty good range. cheers, Pete. |
#31
|
|||
|
|||
|
#32
|
|||
|
|||
Anna Kettle wrote:
In article . com, says... Peter wrote: How much time/money do you want to spend? Hard to say but under a thousand for sure. achievable with rows of computer fans on standard but smaller rads. But is it art? Anna To some people, anything is art! The idea is to put the fans out of sight at the bottom behind the rad. They need to be run on reduced voltage to keep them quiet. Unfanned airlfow is so slow that even modest air movement can triple output. NT |
#33
|
|||
|
|||
|
#34
|
|||
|
|||
I don't think that's right. The fin design on all radiators I've seen
is pretty basic - no more than a thin sheet of steel made into a wavy shape and spot welded to the panel. The transfer of heat from the panel to the fins is limited by the design and I think that you'd find that with a powerful fan you could get the fin temperature down quite low but the panel temperature would remain high simply because of the poor thermal transfer characteristic. Next time your heating is on try feeling the temperature on the panel, on the fins near the panel and on the end of the fins furthest from the panel. I've often toyed with the idea of boosting certain rads in this way and I suspect it would work to some degree if I could be bothered. Wet fan heaters such as Mysons plinth heaters use a longitudinal fan and one of the features of all such fans is that over time they "sag". Once that happens they become unbalanced and start to get noisy. I know, I've got one :-( For that reason I wouldn't bother with a longitudinal fan below a panel radiator. If I was playing with such a design I'd go for small electronics fans running very slowly. |
#35
|
|||
|
|||
On 6 Oct 2005 13:03:47 -0700, "Aidan" wrote:
wrote: I agree, with forced convection the rate of cooling is faster than with natural convection (for the same temperature difference) So as long as you increase the flowrate thro' rad you will get more heat output. Do you not think that the rate of heat transfer from the fluid to the inside surface of the radiator might be dependent on & limited by the surface area? I would agree that there are many factors which affect the total heat output and without detailed modelling or actual measurements determining exactly how much each factor affects the output is difficult. However I have noticed that in myson fan convectors and skirting board convectors the fins are attached to a simple pipe, whose internal surface area is much smaller than that of a normal rad. Therefore I would assume that transfer of heat from the water to the rad is not normally a problem. My advise would be to attach a few computer fans to a double convector rad, let the rad get to a stable temperature - measure the inlet to outlet temp diff , switch fans on and see if the temp diff increases significantly. Robert royall at which net |
#36
|
|||
|
|||
|
#37
|
|||
|
|||
Calvin wrote: I don't think that's right. The fin design on all radiators I've seen is pretty basic - no more than a thin sheet of steel made into a wavy shape and spot welded to the panel. There is one corrugated fin, spot welded on at about 15mm intervals. Let us say there's two fins per inch. On proper heater batteries, the copper pipes are passed through ali or copper sheet fins which have holes punched in them. 12 or 18 fins per inch is not unusual. The pipes are hydraulically expanded to ensure a wide contact area between the pipe and the fin metal. Now, why do you think they'd do all that? Do you think it might be possible that the amount of heat transferred is somehow related to the surface area of the heated metal? Next time your heating is on try feeling the temperature on the panel, on the fins near the panel and on the end of the fins furthest from the panel. Granny. Eggs. Suck |
#38
|
|||
|
|||
Aidan wrote:
wrote: Its not worth getting into, you dont understand basic thermodynamics. Ooooh, Hissssssy, Hissy! no, just getting real. Strangely, the one book that was on my desk when I read that comment was 'Applied Thermodynamics for Engineering Technologists' sounds like you ought to know better then NT |
#39
|
|||
|
|||
I want the smallest possible radiator. Are there any almost silentfan assisted designs available?
Peter wrote:
I have room for wall mounted radiators but I really don't want to give away wall space to some big white thing. Are there any small radiator designs that contain discreet tangential fans to enhance their output? And a quite separate question. Why are radiators white, or even chrome? Surely matt black would make them more efficient, so they could be smaller? Yes. fan blown 'wet' heaters. Mine have 'smiths' on them About 1.5KW output. About 500mm square, fit in 4" depth. |
#40
|
|||
|
|||
I want the smallest possible radiator. Are there any almost silent fan assisted designs available?
|
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Smallest vans that can carry 8' x 4' sheets of MDF/plasterboard inside? | UK diy | |||
Finding smallest circle that fits over a trapezoid | Metalworking | |||
Smallest water softeners? | UK diy |